News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by rayiner on Monday October 14, 2013 @09:19PM (#6550831)
Of all of the unconstitutional things Obama has been alleged of doing, blatantly disregarding the Constitution's allocation of the power of the purse to the House and unilaterally raising the debt ceiling to placate the "international financial community" would undoubtedly be the most egregious. It would effectively be a coup d'état and the right's hand-waving about Obama being a dictator will have become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by jbooth on Monday October 14, 2013 @10:11PM (#6551064)
So you're a lawyer, right? Politically I get what you're saying but legally, with the 14th amendment and all, he has to either illegally prioritize or illegally ignore the debt limit. Maybe ignoring the debt limit has more constitutional standing than reprioritizing the congressional budget. No idea on my end.

Personally, if we're prioritizing, I think he should do some math where they pay all treasury bonds, on time and 100%, and then just cut every other expenditure in half (or whichever % works out), across the board. Social security checks, contractor payments, gov't worker payments, etc. Anybody refuses to do work, send the half-paid national guard after them and order them, since we're in crazytown anyways. And tell them to write their congressman.

That's possibly the "least illegal" option, and certainly the most politically palatable, as far as respecting congress's self-contradictory legal orders in this mess.

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by rayiner on Monday October 14, 2013 @10:46PM (#6551190)
The fact that the 14th amendment prohibits reneging on the public debt does not mean that the President is empowered to ignore the other provisions of the Constitution in order to avert a Constitutional breach by Congress. Section V of the 14th amendment clearly gives Congress the power to enforce the other provisions of the amendment.

See: http://www.volokh.com/2013/10/03/14th-amendment-option-table.

As for the illegality of prioritizing payments, as far as I can tell, out of the mandatory expenditures only a small amount is Constitutionally required (specifically, judges' salaries). The rest is only statutorily mandatory. As you correctly perceive, it seems preferable to commit a statutory violation to avoid a Constitutional one.

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by waps on Monday October 14, 2013 @10:55PM (#6551219)
Believe it or not, lawyers deal with conflicting laws all the time. There's a few general principles, the most important "rule of thumb" is :

Constitution trumps amendments (but only in certain high-up courts), which trumps normal law, which trumps contracts (written "generally" before oral ones), which trumps common sense ("what a good house father would do"). The sum total of all these things form "the law" as viewed from the perspective of a person (so yes, you are legally obligated to "generally be good" even when the law doesn't explicitly require it (e.g. help people involved in accidents))

Basically since the government debt obligations are contracts, while the debt ceiling is a law, Obama has no choice in the matter : any lawful payments (like medicare, ...) have to be fulfilled before any contract is paid. So barring a new law (the "agreement" the news talks about), on Okt 17, the US should default. Maybe Obama can delay it a few days, but certainly no more.

Please note that congress is doing exactly what it was designed to do. Congress, whether you agree with it or not, represents the will of the people of the united states and Obama is ignoring it, refusing to do so much as negotiate (or so claims congress, and I see no reason to doubt their claims). He knew years in advance that this was coming and gambled. Every executive who has fought congress on this has failed, again something Obama is perfectly aware of (it featured prominently in his education for one thing, hell, it's one of the main forces that brought us democracy in the first place).

In case someone doesn't know this : Obama's a lawyer. Lawyers tend to be lawyers first, people second. And he has a history of this sort of thing : expect him to follow the law over common sense.

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by AlexMax on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @02:21AM (#6551791)
> Please note that congress is doing exactly what it was designed to do. Congress, whether you agree with it or not, represents the will of the people of the united states and Obama is ignoring it, refusing to do so much as negotiate (or so claims congress, and I see no reason to doubt their claims). He knew years in advance that this was coming and gambled. Every executive who has fought congress on this has failed, again something Obama is perfectly aware of (it featured prominently in his education for one thing, hell, it's one of the main forces that brought us democracy in the first place).

The Affordable Care Act was passed through normal legislative processes and defended by the judicial system. It has also survived an almost constant legislative assault since then.

Shutting down the government and threatening default over a piece of legislation you don't like is not part of the normal legislative process. It's radical. And you can even argue that with cute little last minute rule changes like HR 368 that it's borderline undemocratic as well. The American people may have mixed opinions on the Affordable Care Act, but I highly doubt they wanted the federal government shut down over it.

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by aboodman on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @02:44AM (#6551856)
Congress is not doing what it was 'designed' to do. The Hastert Rule (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hastert_Rule) was only introduced in the last 30 years or so, and has never been followed as dogmatically as Boehner is following it now.

By refusing to bring a bill to a vote unless a majority of his party openly supports it, Boehner is explicitly preventing compromise.

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by waps on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @04:18AM (#6552101)
That's not what I mean. Congress is refusing to finance a government whose actions it doesn't support. Which is exactly what it's supposed to do, and is in fact one of it's core functions.

The power of the purse is allocated to the house.

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by polymatter on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @08:34AM (#6552833)
Boehner is refusing to allow Congress a vote to finance the government. This is not the same as Congress refusing to finance the government.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by mkr-hn on Thursday October 17, 2013 @09:42AM (#6565253)
Days later, congress voted to finance the government. They collectively decided it would be easier to build a better government on an economy that isn't in a nosedive.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by dllthomas on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @09:05AM (#6552976)
Constitution trumps laws trump contracts, but this particular contract is specifically blessed ("shall not be questioned") in a way no other contracts or laws are.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by digikata on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @01:28AM (#6551660)
I'm thinking that looking at this Constitutional conflict is a lot like when you know you're about to execute latent untested paths in your production codebase. Except that, of course, you're not just crashing a webserver in this case...
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by dllthomas on Monday October 14, 2013 @10:48PM (#6551195)
Bullshit. Congress has been exercising the power of the purse all along, passing budgets with deficits. Congress does not have the power to default on our obligations. The executive taking corrective action is worse than the congress doing so, but it's the congresses fault for failing to do their jobs not any sort of power grab.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by rayiner on Monday October 14, 2013 @10:53PM (#6551206)
It might be unconstitutional for Congress to default on our obligations, under the 14th amendment. At the same time, by the terms of the 14th amendment itself, Congress is the one entrusted with enforcing that requirement. The Constitution does not require that for every possible violation by one branch, some other branch be able to cure that violation.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by dctoedt on Monday October 14, 2013 @11:04PM (#6551255)
> At the same time, by the terms of the 14th amendment itself, Congress is the one entrusted with enforcing that requirement.

Yeah, but Article II charges the President with taking care that the laws be faithfully executed. To quote Lincoln (in a different context, certainly), "are all the laws but one to go unexecuted and the Government itself go to pieces lest that one be violated?" Obama would be on solid legal ground in saying that he has to reconcile conflicting congressional mandates by ignoring the debt ceiling.

(On the other hand, I read today that any debt that was issued above the debt ceiling would be a lot more costly because buyers would insist on premium interest rates to compensate for the increased legal risk that the debt would be held invalid.)

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by dllthomas on Monday October 14, 2013 @10:57PM (#6551225)
Laws in violation of the Constitution are not laws. If the Congress sets up a situation where the only legal option is default some component of that setup is not law. The fact that Congress is granted powers to make laws that enforce the article doesn't mean the article only has effect through actions of Congress.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by jbigelow76 on Monday October 14, 2013 @09:52PM (#6550978)
It's not about "placating" anybody, it's about standing up and walking away from the table instead of playing Russian roulette with your crazy, drunk, suicidal uncle.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by sixothree on Monday October 14, 2013 @09:54PM (#6550985)
I like how you casually ignore the whole 14th amendment thingy.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by krapp on Monday October 14, 2013 @10:01PM (#6551019)
This isn't about reality, it's about politics.