News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by meowface on Friday October 11, 2013 @03:10AM (#6531820)
It is rather sleazy that they tried to portray Assange as a self-obsessed, egomaniacal cult leader of some kind. Claiming he was in a cult and bleaches his hair, etc. Quite an ad hominem (even if the movie is not intended to be a documentary or a polemic). People are going to watch the movie, see that, and go "oh, what a nut job" even though it's completely fictional.

Really leaves a bad taste in my mouth. Also the claims that Assange is responsible for the harm or death of Americans, or that they later leaked unredacted documents.

The Social Network's dramatization of Zuckerberg wasn't nearly that acrid, in comparison.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by mpyne on Friday October 11, 2013 @12:13PM (#6534021)
> It is rather sleazy that they tried to portray Assange as a self-obsessed, egomaniacal cult leader of some kind.

It is still sleazy if there's element of truth to that? Cult leader, maybe not, but his ego is visible from the ISS, and his narcissism is fairly hard to miss as well.

Likewise Assange is certainly intermingled with harm/death to Americans, if not directly involved. He claims there are higher reasons such as his effort to foist transparency on the U.S. government in particular, but you don't leak hundreds of thousands of diplomatic cables and still end up Doing No Harm.

Additionally it was Assange's mistakes that left the archive of unencrypted unredacted documents on a public web server in the first place. The Guardian journalist should have been just fine to publish the password years after the fact as the FTP share used to push the documents to the journalists doing the analysis was not required to be public for years! So again, although Assange is not "the sole gunman" here he does share in the responsibility.

And all of this now reaches back into why it might be appropriate to describe Assange with cult-like descriptives. You ask a U.S. Democrat and they'll probably be able to list at least 5 things they don't like about a prominent Democratic politician. Even a Republican would be able to list faults with their politicians.

But to hear people describe Assange, he is almost literally perfect, has never done something wrong, makes snap decisions that are revealed to have been 100% beneficial years later, and never suffers from normal human misunderstanding or flaws in decision-making. Where does this come from?? I screw up something at least twice before breakfast every day, but any fault people point out with Assange must be as part of a vast government and media conspiracy to discredit him? OK, sure...

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by belorn on Friday October 11, 2013 @01:19PM (#6534478)
> Likewise Assange is certainly intermingled with harm/death to Americans, if not directly involved.

Source? In what way has he directly been involved in any harm? Second, US Brig. Gen. Robert Carr vittnessed under oath that the armies investigation could not identify a single death. Do you know something that the second largest army in the world could not prove?

> So again, although Assange is not "the sole gunman" here he does share in the responsibility.

I guess the architect for the World Trade Center do share some responsibility when the two building crashed in 2001. Had he built them more secure, more like a bunker, then so many people would still be alive. so again, althrough Daniel Libeskind is not "the sole gunman" here he does share in the responsibility.

or maybe, just maybe I want to put the whole blame on Al-Qaeda.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by quesera on Friday October 11, 2013 @07:55PM (#6536567)
Libeskind is the new guy. The original was designed by Minoru Yamasaki

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minoru_Yamasaki

Or was that a joke? :)

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by belorn on Friday October 11, 2013 @09:42PM (#6536903)
I am sorry, you are totally right. I got the two designers mixed up. Thanks.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by wooter on Friday October 11, 2013 @01:01PM (#6534358)
To summarize your post: he has a big ego. he may have caused harm to someone. he made a mistake when handling blatant war crimes. you don't like that "some people" think hes literally perfect and want them to criticize him at least for the mistakes he makes before breakfast - not focus on the actual, real, concrete violations of law that he revealed.

Your entire post reads like you're trying to make mud stick. Give me a break. All of that is a far-cry from what the movie portrayed and is quite intellectually dishonest.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by aeturnum on Friday October 11, 2013 @01:19PM (#6534473)
>want them to criticize him at least for the mistakes he makes before breakfast - not focus on the actual, real, concrete violations of law that he revealed.

These are not mutually exclusive goals. I'm grateful for Assange's work and the changes it has affected on the world. However, I think if you were picking the front-man for Wikileaks, he would be a poor choice.

Thankfully, the ideal people rarely do anything interesting, and Assange is a very interesting character (in both senses of the word). I was actually surprised by how little of the memo took issue with the film. Almost all of it is tone, and much of that tone is open to interpretation (does the film mock Assange's feeling of being watched, or do the characters in the scene mock it? The scene includes thugs following Assange.). I'm also surprised the film adds a disclaim as to its sources at the end.

Wikileaks seems really upset, but it seems like the film makers could have done a lot worse. I'm sure the people in the US government have their own list of inaccuracies. What do you expect from a form of entertainment?

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by redthrowaway on Friday October 11, 2013 @02:31PM (#6534981)
>But to hear people describe Assange, he is almost literally perfect

That's a shameful straw man. I don't know of many people who think Assange the man is any sort of saint, but there are many of us who think the character assassination against him is an obvious attempt to distract from the true story, just as the news stories about Manning's psychological and emotional health were an attempt to cast her decision to release those documents as anything other than a principled and moral one.

I think a world without Wikileaks would be a measurably worse place, and a world without Assange would be a world without Wikileaks. Believing that requires no acts of deification or hagiography on my part. He's a flawed man doing important work.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by meowface on Friday October 11, 2013 @04:02PM (#6535597)
Original comment poster here.

He is definitely an arrogant kind of guy, but the movie literally portrays him as having been in some kind of cult wherein everyone bleaches their hair white. That kicks him down from "arrogant asshole" to "crazy, God complex cult leader" to people watching the movie.

And really, from what I can tell, he's not done anything particularly immoral. No evidence has come out that anything he leaked harmed any Americans. He sifts through all leaked material before just publishing it willy nilly.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by vilda on Friday October 11, 2013 @07:54AM (#6532520)
This won't be first or last movie that wrongly depicts history :)

Braveheart is one example: the section "Historical inaccuracy" takes good 1/3 of the whole Wikipedia article. Amadeus by Miloš Forman is another example. The Social Network...

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by d23 on Friday October 11, 2013 @09:18AM (#6532861)
Neither Braveheart nor Amadeus were about living people. It could be argued that Zuckerburg's well-being and entire mission doesn't hinge upon the public's perception of him either (plus, as meowface said, the image portrayed of him wasn't that bad).
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by klmr on Friday October 11, 2013 @09:11AM (#6532829)
Except that nobody cares whether Edward Longshanks was slandered, or that his political actions were misrepresented. For Wikileaks and Assange, this has consequences in the real world, and defamation in particular may lead to criminal prosecution.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by viat on Friday October 11, 2013 @09:29AM (#6532918)
Except that they do. Especially at a time of national referendum on Scottish independence. With that context Braveheart starts to look more and more like racist propaganda. The date of the referendum vote was even chosen for it's historical significance.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by jessaustin on Friday October 11, 2013 @01:34PM (#6534566)
Racist? Are you saying that English is a "race", that it's somehow the same "race" that existed 700 years ago, and that it is "racially" justified in ruling Scotland?

Those would be novel claims.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by RexRollman on Saturday October 12, 2013 @10:07PM (#6541192)
Braveheart is a good example but my favorite example is Remember The Titans, which went so far as to have a player get into a car accident before the championship game when, in fact, he played in that game and got into the accident after the season had ended.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by snowwrestler on Friday October 11, 2013 @02:24PM (#6534938)
I think it's important to separate our consideration of people from how we feel about some of the things they work on.

It's possible to support the work of Wikileaks while still acknowledging:

- The work and results of Wikileaks is not solely the result of Julian Assange.

- Julian Assange might be an egotistical narcissist.

- The work and results of Wikileaks may have contributed to harm as well as good.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by lake99 on Friday October 11, 2013 @05:05PM (#6535929)
> - Julian Assange might be an egotistical narcissist.

"might be"? Anyone "might" be! Do you have substantial reasons for suspecting that Assange is one?

> - The work and results of Wikileaks may have contributed to harm as well as good.

No one denies that Wikileaks has done harm. Not even Assange himself. Wikileaks has harmed the US image quite badly. For example, before Wikileaks, I had no idea the US military is run by the kind of people who would gun down innocents from a helicopter, so casually.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by snowwrestler on Friday October 11, 2013 @05:45PM (#6536102)
> Do you have substantial reasons for suspecting that Assange is one?

Some people have asserted as much, including people who have known him personally. Others have said that those assertions are false.

Since I don't have evidence either way, it "might" be true. Might. Might! I'm not saying it's true. I'm saying I can't prove it's not true.

I'm also saying, if that upsets you, think about why that might be. Is it because you know Mr. Assange personally and know it to be a false allegation? Or is it because you like Wikileaks and interpret any attack on Assange as an attack on Wikileaks?

"L'etat, c'est moi"? I don't believe that's true. I think we should be wary of cults of personality. Even if we don't think the "personality" is themselves creating it.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by lake99 on Friday October 11, 2013 @06:13PM (#6536204)
I know that you never said it's true. The problem with all these mights is that they can add to character assassination, without bringing anything substantial to the discussion. Obamacare? Obama might be an egotistical narcissist. Non-violence? Gandhi might have been an egotistical narcissist¹. See what I mean?

And no, it's not because I'm fond of Assange. I welcome information from everywhere.

¹ I hear many people in India say something to that effect these days.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by james3 on Saturday October 12, 2013 @05:44PM (#6540467)
I think personal characterizations have no place in the discussion of public characters, as these can only ever be opinions that are unable to be proven true or false. They only serve to derail a discussion when the argument turns away from one's favor, and is a very dishonest thing to do. Shame on you snowwrestler.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by SkyMarshal on Friday October 11, 2013 @03:16PM (#6535269)
>- Julian Assange <del>might be</del> is portrayed by the media as an egotistical narcissist.

FTFY. You have to be careful with such subjective characterizations of people you've only seen in the media and never actually met in real life, they're almost always inaccurate. Modern media is full of bias and fallacies.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by snowwrestler on Friday October 11, 2013 @04:49PM (#6535853)
You didn't fix anything; my phrasing and your phrasing are mutually compatible.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by gadders on Friday October 11, 2013 @04:55AM (#6532070)
Do they cover the (alleged) rapes that Assange was involved in?
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by nailer on Friday October 11, 2013 @05:39AM (#6532202)
If so, I hope they also show the excited tweets Ardin before/at the party she then attended with her alleged rapist.

http://radsoft.net/news/20101001,01.shtml

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by scott_karana on Friday October 11, 2013 @11:59AM (#6533939)
There's nothing unusual about someone being raped by someone close to them, who took advantage of their trust. The messages could have been deleted because she felt ashamed of her trust.

I'm not blaming Assange for anything. I'm just saying those messages mean very little.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by nailer on Friday October 11, 2013 @08:15PM (#6536634)
This trust was within 48 hours after (not before) Ardin was allegedly raped.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by Permit on Friday October 11, 2013 @12:23PM (#6534103)
How would that be in any way relevant?
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by nailer on Friday October 11, 2013 @08:02PM (#6536593)
I imagine it's fairly uncommon for someone to arrange seats to attend a crayfish party with their rapist immediately after they've been raped.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by steveklabnik on Friday October 11, 2013 @05:06AM (#6532110)
The article states that they claim Assange was charged with 'rape' in Sweden, and that Assange has never been charged with anything by anyone.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by gadders on Friday October 11, 2013 @10:28AM (#6533270)
Doesn't he need to go back to Sweden to be charged? TBH that's just semantics. He's wanted for rape, his extradition was appealed and still went through. He's hiding in the Ecuadorian embassy to avoid the rape "charges".
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by steveklabnik on Friday October 11, 2013 @12:43PM (#6534238)
I am not an expert on Swedish law. I'm just repeating the article.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by nemof on Friday October 11, 2013 @11:44AM (#6533839)
So, what of us people who actually see Assange in much the way you've described the fictive character?

Honestly, if anyone's sleazy it's Assange.