News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by snowwrestler on Friday October 11, 2013 @02:24PM (#6534938)
I think it's important to separate our consideration of people from how we feel about some of the things they work on.

It's possible to support the work of Wikileaks while still acknowledging:

- The work and results of Wikileaks is not solely the result of Julian Assange.

- Julian Assange might be an egotistical narcissist.

- The work and results of Wikileaks may have contributed to harm as well as good.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by lake99 on Friday October 11, 2013 @05:05PM (#6535929)
> - Julian Assange might be an egotistical narcissist.

"might be"? Anyone "might" be! Do you have substantial reasons for suspecting that Assange is one?

> - The work and results of Wikileaks may have contributed to harm as well as good.

No one denies that Wikileaks has done harm. Not even Assange himself. Wikileaks has harmed the US image quite badly. For example, before Wikileaks, I had no idea the US military is run by the kind of people who would gun down innocents from a helicopter, so casually.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by snowwrestler on Friday October 11, 2013 @05:45PM (#6536102)
> Do you have substantial reasons for suspecting that Assange is one?

Some people have asserted as much, including people who have known him personally. Others have said that those assertions are false.

Since I don't have evidence either way, it "might" be true. Might. Might! I'm not saying it's true. I'm saying I can't prove it's not true.

I'm also saying, if that upsets you, think about why that might be. Is it because you know Mr. Assange personally and know it to be a false allegation? Or is it because you like Wikileaks and interpret any attack on Assange as an attack on Wikileaks?

"L'etat, c'est moi"? I don't believe that's true. I think we should be wary of cults of personality. Even if we don't think the "personality" is themselves creating it.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by lake99 on Friday October 11, 2013 @06:13PM (#6536204)
I know that you never said it's true. The problem with all these mights is that they can add to character assassination, without bringing anything substantial to the discussion. Obamacare? Obama might be an egotistical narcissist. Non-violence? Gandhi might have been an egotistical narcissist¹. See what I mean?

And no, it's not because I'm fond of Assange. I welcome information from everywhere.

¹ I hear many people in India say something to that effect these days.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by james3 on Saturday October 12, 2013 @05:44PM (#6540467)
I think personal characterizations have no place in the discussion of public characters, as these can only ever be opinions that are unable to be proven true or false. They only serve to derail a discussion when the argument turns away from one's favor, and is a very dishonest thing to do. Shame on you snowwrestler.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by SkyMarshal on Friday October 11, 2013 @03:16PM (#6535269)
>- Julian Assange <del>might be</del> is portrayed by the media as an egotistical narcissist.

FTFY. You have to be careful with such subjective characterizations of people you've only seen in the media and never actually met in real life, they're almost always inaccurate. Modern media is full of bias and fallacies.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by snowwrestler on Friday October 11, 2013 @04:49PM (#6535853)
You didn't fix anything; my phrasing and your phrasing are mutually compatible.