News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by ruswick on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @10:45AM (#6515305)
Nest is very adept at charging large amounts of money for solutions to small problems. Dealing with the shortcomings of modern smoke detectors is a minor annoyance at best, and (at least for me) isn't worth anything even remotely approaching what Nest is charging. Keep in mind that this detector provides no increase in safety, and if anything is a regression because it postpones alerting the user to prevent the annoyance of false positives. You are paying only for convenience.

Adequate smoke detectors can be purchased for $20. Is the minor increase in convenience really worth shelling out over 6 times that amount, possibly at the expense of safety?

(EDIT: as others have pointed out, this also serves as a carbon monoxide detector. The implication from the product page is that this product is designed to be placed on the ceiling. What could possibly go wrong?)

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by WillyF on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @10:57AM (#6515372)
I was going to agree with you, and then I remembered the night that the smoke detector in my rental started chirping every few minutes. It was around 3 AM. We had really high ceilings, so if I stood on a chair, I could almost reach the smoke detector to disable it. It took a solid 15 minutes of my standing on my tippy toes trying to figure out what would make the chirping stop. I don't remember exactly how I did it, but I was mere minutes away from using a baseball bat.

It turns out it was the smoke detector's "self-destruct" chirp. A new battery wouldn't even do the job. Had to buy a new smoke detector because the old one had reached its age limit.

That night if you had asked me to pay $100 so that I could go back to sleep and not have to worry about THAT CHIRP, I would have whipped out my wallet so fast.

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by drbawb on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:34AM (#6515638)
We just moved into a condo which had a very old [Nov 1999] BRINK's home security installation that we didn't intend to use.

When we first moved in all the keypads said: "CALL 1-800-<WHATEVER> FOR SERVICE. NOT READY." We were not interested in a home-alarm service, so we simply left them alone and went about our move.

Fast forward 3 months: these alarm pads would start beeping in the middle of the night. We had a friend watching our house during the day: they'd _never_ beep during the day, not once. Around 1AM though they'd go off and starting chirping in 15 second intervals.

The first night: we were able to silence it by hitting "CANCEL" on the keypad. On subsequent nights we could silence it for [what seemed like] a random period of time between 15 minutes and several hours.

Perhaps it was just the sleep deprivation, but I swear by the fourth night you couldn't shut it up for more than 5 minutes at a time.

Fed up with the alarm: I headed downstairs, pajama-clad, with my multi-tool and a flash light.

---

Turns out: this is the "low battery alarm" -- we cut open the strongbox and disconnected a sealed lead acid battery and shut off the breaker. (Which coincidentally takes out our CO alarms, but it was worth it for the peaceful slumber.)

The battery did test bad so I disposed of it. (Shame: I wanted to repurpose it.)

It seems that these sorts of "self-destruct" alarms are DESIGNED to (A) go off when you're likely to be home (night-time hours) and (B) they are hard to ignore (e.g: exhibit some kind of non-deterministic pattern.)

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by WillyF on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:38AM (#6515687)
Because the alarms are so annoying, people often end up disabling the alarms and never replacing them. That's dangerous in the long run. In the short run it's dangerous to try to disable an alarm in the middle of the night. I wonder if anyone has ever died from a fall while attempting to stop the chirping in a sleep-deprived state.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by drbawb on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @02:27PM (#6516860)
That's the thing: we still haven't replaced our CO alarm.

Given how integrated it is into the BRINKs panel: it's doubtful the CO alarms would've even worked while the BRINKs panel was powered but unactivated.

Now we are left with keypads [we don't want] and deactivated CO alarms bolted in to our freshly painted walls. sigh

I'm not particularly annoyed by the behavior itself: false alarms don't bother me, and a low battery alert is definitely a useful "error code."

What bugs me is that it should be easy to dismiss the "low battery warning" for _at least_ 8 to 12 hour windows. Long enough that you can actually get some rest and deal with it in the morning / after your shift.

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by lallysingh on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @02:34AM (#6519731)
If the walls are freshly painted, you can remove the alarms, patch the holes, and paint over. The new paint will match the paint around it.

It costs maybe $20 for enough materials (not counting paint).

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by drharris on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @12:51PM (#6516161)
It's likely because late night/early morning is cooler temperature, and this drops the battery voltage enough to trigger the sensor.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by drbawb on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @02:11PM (#6516727)
Might make sense for fire alarms: but this home alarm system had a battery that was in a sealed strong-box in a midwestern US basement.

tl;dr: the battery, in this case, was in a room that is continuously controlled for humidity, temperature, and in this case: light.

--

The system usage should also be pretty static: as our house guest was home and presumably tripping the motion sensors all day. (Yes: even though the system was unarmed _and unactivated_, our motion sensors still appeared to be _sensing._ -- It's purely coincidence, but this ordeal started right around when the Internet was in an uproar over PRISM & the NSA.)

Retiring to our unprotected bedroom dwellings for the evening would've only _decreased_ the system's draw, if it had any impact at all.

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by yock on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:14AM (#6515501)
That night if you had asked me to pay $100 so that I could go back to sleep and not have to worry about THAT CHIRP, I would have whipped out my wallet so fast.

See, you say that, but it isn't just one smoke detector. It's ALL of them. My small house alone has no fewer than 4 plus a CO detector. That's $500, real money to save me from an occasional hour of lost sleep or, at worst, an extremely rare night? The value proposition just isn't there.

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by carrigan on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:39AM (#6515694)
The Nest Protect adds several hardware components that a traditional smoke detector doesn't have, including an ambient light sensor, a distance/motion sensor, a multicolor LED, and WiFi. If your only problem with the current smoke detectors out there is the chirp, then it can be solved by adding just the light sensor and LED, which is not a large cost addition. The additional cost of adding networking hardware, creating a protocol for these to talk to each other as well as the thermostat, and creating a mobile app just to configure the nightlight is what really drives the price so high here.

Hopefully the innovative ideas that they are using for conveying that a battery is low or stopping the alarm from going off when cooking make it into other designs. Quite frankly I don't see the benefit added from networking my smoke detectors.

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by rsync on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @04:05PM (#6517479)
Exactly. I have no interest in adding any more computer networks or nodes to my home, nor do I wish to provide Internet services on public IPs, etc. I don't need the complexity in my life, nor do I need the attack surface (nor the trade of legacy annoyances for modern annoyances).

BUT, I do need a smoke detector that doesn't make me want to kill myself every time I interact with it - I already have printers for that. Here's hoping there's an easy way to completely disable all networking on these devices...

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by X-Istence on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @04:28PM (#6517616)
Don't set it up on Wifi ... the devices will talk to each other over ZigBee as far as I can tell.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by telephonetemp on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @06:52PM (#6518376)
Is there anyone out there trying to give printers the Nest treatment?
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by ruswick on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:01AM (#6515415)
I understand that conventional smoke detectors can be irritating, but I still don't see how an experience like that is worth an extra $110. I suppose the calculus is different for people with far more money, but for most people, I don't think that smoke detectors pose a large enough annoyance to warrant buying the Nest.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by Terretta on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:53AM (#6515788)
If you want to know, remotely, if your house is burning down, you can spend $450 a year for a monitoring service and who knows how much for a system that dials them in case of alerts, or you can buy Nest.

I see this as priced against monitoring services and systems that phone them.

Compared to those, this is cheap.

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by caseyf7 on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @08:38PM (#6518807)
The problem is Nest doesn't connect to a central monitoring center (as far as I can tell) and many insurance companies require central monitoring. I would love to have these, but I won't buy them if the insurance company won't sign off on them.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by pionar on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @03:16PM (#6517181)
Well, if your house is burning down, and you're not in it, there's not anything you can do anyway, and you finding out before you get home doesn't change anything, so that's not that useful.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by joshstrange on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @03:50PM (#6517380)
Not true, you can call the fire department.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by dm2 on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:41AM (#6515707)
Consider that it happens regularly every couple of years, especially when you have multiple smoke alarms.

Then if you have high-ceilings it makes it much more difficult (have to go get a ladder in the middle of the night).

It will freak kids out, they're not fun to get back to bed.

The elderly or disabled might not be able to remove the battery or remove the alarm.

I'd say it's definitely a step in the right direction and in-line with Nests other product (probably much of the same hardware).

What's next for Nest? Lighting? Door locks? Security system?

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by tanzam75 on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @12:01PM (#6515837)
We're long past the point where you should be replacing smoke alarm batteries at all.

Put in a lithium battery. The lithium battery will last for the entire 10-year life of the smoke alarm. Thus, you should only replace smoke alarms -- not the battery.

In fact, these days, they're selling smoke alarms with sealed non-replaceable lithium batteries. This prevents people from attempting to use an alarm past end-of-life, and thus getting a false sense of security.

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by VLM on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @12:17PM (#6515949)
Oh whatever LOL. It'll be marketed as lasting a decade and value engineered to only last a year. You don't increase profits by making things last longer. By being sealed and making it chirp you'll force people to buy another instead of simply unpluging the battery.

The problem with a nanny state is eventually people rebel. The future of smoke detection is high profits for mfgrs and residents will spend an hour their first day in new premises disabling and disconnecting the devices. The overall effect on safety will be a profound net decrease, although theoretically on paper we'll never be safer.

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by nknighthb on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @01:29PM (#6516424)
I seem to recall seeing my first lithium battery smoke detector back in the 90s. I certainly haven't bought a non-hardwired detector that wasn't one of the 10-year lithium battery type in the past decade. (You'd have to ask my electrician what he just installed in my renovated house, I haven't looked too closely at them yet.)

Haven't given me any problems. Haven't heard about them giving anyone else any problems. You seem to be dismissing something that already has a proven track record. Why is that?

[deleted]
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by nknighthb on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @02:52PM (#6517024)
I think you either replied to the wrong comment, or badly misread mine. I wasn't making any remark about the Nest alarm at all.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by ZoFreX on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @04:31PM (#6517628)
They last much longer than a year. My dad has them in his house and he's had them a while now - the fire department in the area fit them for free.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by JohnTHaller on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:09AM (#6515476)
How much did the loss of sleep last night cost the above poster in their job the next day? It isn't about how much money you have, it's about how valuable your time is.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by WillyF on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:16AM (#6515513)
My wife lost just as much sleep, and she makes more than I do.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by cjrp on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:32AM (#6515628)
Unless you're a freelancer/contractor, the loss of efficiency probably costs you nothing. It costs your employer, so maybe they should be funding your smoke detector?
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by untog on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:24AM (#6515556)
This reminds me of the HN post I saw a few days ago for a wake up call service - someone suggested "$20-$30 a year" for it. For an alarm. To wake you up.

While I don't doubt that people out there will pay for both, let's not kid ourselves that it will be a mass-market product. The value proposition is way off.

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by foobarian on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:24AM (#6515558)
I would have used a baseball bat. 5 minutes and $20 to replace. (Which you had to do anyway).
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by kgermino on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:29AM (#6515606)
Agreed. I actually did (well, a hammer)

Incidentally, if nothing else this announcement reminded my to order a replacement.

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by mcantelon on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @01:26PM (#6516406)
Earplugs are cheaper than $100.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by pit on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @04:04PM (#6517474)
Plus, you'll sleep right through the alarm!
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by mcantelon on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @04:22PM (#6517574)
It depends on your alarm (I can hear mine with earplugs in).
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by nate on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:11AM (#6515486)
Smoke/Carbon Monoxide detectors have been an enormous issue for me.

Many of the detectors that use a 9V battery backup have a poorly designed chamber holding the battery. Often the battery doesn't make good contact with the metal contacts inside the detector. This results in constant false positives that the battery is low. When it actually does run low, I'm forced to start this cycle over and over again of: find "new" battery, alarm still chirping, is the "new" battery really low or is it the battery chamber misaligned again, etc.

The dog loses another 3 months of her life from stress whenever this happens. I've never seen an animal so scared of a constant chirp.

So when these things start chirping at 2am, and I can't tell if the batteries in the drawer are brand new, instead of dealing with a scared dog, and possibly buying yet more new batteries, the detector comes off the ceiling and ends up in a drawer of blankets to dampen the noise as the chirping takes awhile to die after the detector is removed from power and battery removed.

Additionally, I help with many things around our condo association. I'm constantly changing batteries in these detectors. But first I need to find them. You hear a chirp that the battery is low, and now you have to find it somewhere. Maybe it's in the common hallways of 3 floors of units, or maybe it's a unit owner's. This involves me walking around the building trying to catch one in action of chirping.

I've been a loud detractor of Nest in the past because of their use of Facebook ads spamming my friend list, but I welcome an intelligently designed detector and am going to gladly spend the money to buy at least two of these and will hopefully get the condo association on these. The dog is going to be very happy. :)

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by kbutler on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @02:48PM (#6517001)
> the detector comes off the ceiling and ends up in a drawer of blankets to dampen the noise as the chirping takes awhile to die after the detector is removed from power and battery removed.

You can generally hold down the test button to quickly drain the internal capacitance (sometimes with interesting audio effects).

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by foobarian on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:45AM (#6515730)
I bet there are CYA reasons that current smoke detectors are as annoying as they are. Smoke detector or not, it is inevitable that there is going to be a fire, and people will get hurt, and nobody wants to be the maker of a smoke detector that wasn't as annoying as possible about signaling for battery replacement.

With the nest and the text message, I would worry about the text number/account credentials getting stale/lost over time, and then when someone gets hurt in a fire there will be liability shenanigans.

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by WillyF on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:52AM (#6515783)
I wonder if they could use the motion sensor to alert people of a low battery. I'd much rather hear a chirp every time that I walk by than while I'm half way through a good night's sleep.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by jtbigwoo on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @04:23PM (#6517585)
>> Often the battery doesn't make good contact with the metal contacts inside the detector. This results in constant false positives that the battery is low.

This is probably not bad design. The smoke detector is trying to tell you something.

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by tene on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @05:52PM (#6518066)
Why do you keep dead batteries, especially somewhere you could confuse them with good batteries?
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by timdorr on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @10:52AM (#6515335)
It can hook into an existing Nest thermostat and turn off the HVAC, which could be a source of fire or CO. It also can serve as a low level light at night that's motion activated, so you can find your way down the hall without turning on the full set of lights.

Yeah, it's a bit pricey, but it's definitely better than the Thermostat for value and more within the price range I'd expect for a Nest device.

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by blktiger on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @12:08PM (#6515895)
That's a nice safety feature. The other nice feature that most of the commenters here seem to have missed is that these devices are designed to improve your Nest's auto thermostat feature by knowing where people are in your house. You are basically putting an extra sensor for the nest in every room.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by FireBeyond on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @10:55PM (#6519172)
Actually, that might be the deal /maker/ for me. I am away from home for a day at a time, then when I work from home I'm nowhere near the thermostat, so the whole "sensor" thing doesn't really work - which, to their credit, they told me, before I purchased.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by ubercore on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @01:05PM (#6516258)
As a homeowner, it's way in the other direction for me. The thermostat does an excellent job of saving us money through our heating bills. And compared to other thermostats that can talk to a phone app or web app, it's cheap.

This however, will cost more than a comparable sensor for our simplisafe security system. It doesn't call into a central monitoring station, so I can't get the same insurance discount I do now. Nightlights are, imo, more or less of a solved problem, so I don't see that as really adding value.

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by Terretta on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:56AM (#6515813)
I noted this deeper, but will post it up here:

I don't see this as priced against a $20 smoke alarm. I see this as priced against a smoke system that phones a monitoring service so your home is protected while you are away. These systems are easily $60 - $100 per unit plus the base station plus a recurring fee ($45/month in my area).

Nest pricing is far cheaper than the combination of these, while giving you active remote monitoring peace of mind.

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by mynameisvlad on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @10:48AM (#6515316)
Have you ever had your smoke detector do the low battery chirp? Because I will easily pay 6 times more to never hear that godawful sound ever again.

Especially when you have high ceilings, and the detector is the 120V AC kind and has no overly visible slot for a battery.

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by arethuza on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @10:52AM (#6515339)
I don't mind the chirps but I do often have huge problems finding out which fire alarm has a low battery - as some of our ceilings are (I think) 14ft going up and down a ladder multiple times isn't a lot of fun...

[A few years back our neighbouring apartment had a nasty fire - so I went out and bought a lot of fire alarms, fire blankets etc. - we weren't at much risk as our walls are about 1m thick sandstone. However, it did mean I ended up replacing all of the batteries in the "new" alarms at roughly the same time.]

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by bcl on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:25AM (#6515566)
My solution is to just go an replace them all. Much faster than trying to track down the one, especially in a 2 story house where the chirp echos and isn't repeated very often.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by arethuza on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:39AM (#6515691)
LOL Clearly I am not sensible enough to think of that elegant solution!
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by tanzam75 on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @12:05PM (#6515869)
> Have you ever had your smoke detector do the low battery chirp? Because I will easily pay 6 times more to never hear that godawful sound ever again.

Or, you can pay $5 for a lithium battery that will last the life of the alarm. If it chirps, time to replace the smoke alarm.

(You did realize that smoke alarms should be replaced every ten years, right?)

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by the_cat_kittles on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @12:46PM (#6516132)
whoa- any particular battery brand that works the best?
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by tanzam75 on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @01:29PM (#6516423)
I don't know that one brand is that much better than another. But for something like a smoke detector, you'd probably feel better buying one of the big brands.

Just make sure they're lithium, non-rechargeable batteries, with an expiration date about 8 years in the future.

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by Shivetya on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @10:59AM (#6515399)
At their price point that is a pretty damn expensive convenience? How are they any different in requiring batter changes? At 129 I will just laugh it off as another appeals to people want others to think of them differently.

Nest is trying to market the same way as Apple does, they appeal to Vanity through different directions. Expecting people in the market segment to feed off each other.

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by mynameisvlad on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:05AM (#6515441)
The article says it pretty well. There are no horrible chirps, it'll alert you in a humane way that hey, your battery is low and you need to change it.

They've clearly found a problem (current alarms suck) and have made a solution. Just because you don't see the convenience doesn't mean other people don't, as is clear from the comments here. Once you get burned by regular smoke detectors in the middle of the night, you would pay good money for a product that actually fixes some of these issues.

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by DanBC on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @12:04PM (#6515857)
> Have you ever had your smoke detector do the low battery chirp?

No. I change the batteries once a year.

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by highace on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:28AM (#6515601)
My smoke alarm is connected to the mains electricity. No need for new batteries ever. Just a simple extension from the power outlets in the attic and down through the ceiling.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by joeshaw on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:40AM (#6515705)
In the US, current fire codes require that hardwired smoke detectors also have a battery backup.

http://artisanelectric.net/blog/the-big-picture/how-old-are-...

http://www.nfpa.org/codes-and-standards/document-information...

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by zwily on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:35AM (#6515654)
They should still have a battery backup.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by ruswick on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @10:50AM (#6515329)
I have. I identify the detector and the batteries. It's not particularly hard.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by mynameisvlad on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @10:53AM (#6515348)
As I said, some of them have no overly obvious battery compartment. Either it's on the backside, or internally and you have to unscrew it open. Not all have an obvious battery compartment.

And it's incredibly annoying when you have to climb onto a chair/table/whathaveyou because your ceilings are so high you can't naturally reach it.

The one in my last apartment even had a big button in the middle. I thought I might be able to press it in order to turn off the alarm temporarily. That was not a good idea.

[deleted]
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by mynameisvlad on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:03AM (#6515427)
The one in my last apartment was electric, but I believe still had a backup battery. And still chirps like the devil if that goes out, but you can't even just remove it, because then it'll chirp at you for not having a backup battery in place. And there's no way that I know to turn that chirp off.

See how that might be annoying in the middle of the night with high ceilings in the first place, and no replacement battery available?

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by zyb09 on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:47AM (#6515742)
To be honest they also look kind of cool, while average smoke detectors don't. I imagine this being a big factor, since you're going to have one of these on the ceiling in every room.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by smackfu on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @01:49PM (#6516552)
There are a whole lot of product types where an adequate one from Walmart costs $20, but plenty of people spend $100+ on better ones. For instance, anything you can put in a kitchen. Not sure why so many objections to this product even existing.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by Gipetto on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:20AM (#6515532)
This is also about those of us with means helping to mainstream the technology. As we buy and help work out the bugs the technology will (hopefully) become cheaper and more widespread. When this happens we'll find low cost and intelligent devices become more accessible and hopefully become standard fare in new homes. It has practically happened already for the smartphone. Who says it can't, and shouldn't, happen here?
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by tommorris on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @12:50PM (#6522347)
Ah, but look at the marketing.

"Cares for your family as much as you do."

Appeal to parental guilt is a pretty powerful marketing tool.

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by tonylemesmer on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:26AM (#6515574)
You are correct in all your statements, however this will be a successful product, so everyone's happy :)