Re:8pen + Leap Motion
by alexhawdon on Thursday October 03, 2013 @09:16AM
(#6488643)
Reminds me of Palm's 'Graffiti', both in execution and scope: it's a stop-gap solution, possibly to a problem that no longer exists.
IMO, their three suggested use-cases are quite flimsy.
"...enable surgeons to take notes during an operation without removing their gloves" - They already can, it's called dictation which is subsequently transcribed by a medical secretary whose time is far less expensive.
"check recipes while cooking without spilling flour on the keyboard" - touchless navigation of a pre-chosen recipe, maybe. Actually stopping cooking to search for a recipe/technique that you're unsure about? I would rather quickly wash my hands and use a more traditional input method to find what I want.
"search for TV programs without leaving their couch" - Given the range of the Leap device this really doesn't make sense - are they envisaging a wireless version you take with you to the couch/coffee table. Some sort of device that can 'remotely control' your television...
I still think Leap Motion is great technology, but still missing a decent application.
Re:8pen + Leap Motion
by djkz on Thursday October 03, 2013 @09:51AM
(#6488848)
I believe the best application for this will be virtual reality headsets - such as Oculus Rift, where you can have virtual screens but having a keyboard would not be practical.
Re:8pen + Leap Motion
by sailfast on Thursday October 03, 2013 @09:37AM
(#6488760)
Agreed - and if they can't already they will likely just move to commercial dictation that transcribes accurately automatically. I'll use my leap motion to kick-off Dragon, Google, or another app to try their hand at voice recognition. Pretty sure I'd rather just type a transcript myself than learn a new symbol language.
Re:8pen + Leap Motion
by borplk on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:34AM
(#6489641)
I wish I could say something positive but unfortunately in my opinion this too falls under the new and emerging category of kickstarter-type-half-assed-product-with-a-fancy-video-that-over-promises. I hope I'm proven wrong.
Re:8pen + Leap Motion
by lnanek2 on Thursday October 03, 2013 @09:40AM
(#6488781)
Seems pretty lousy. No one wants to hold their arm up in the air tracing out full letters of each word like that. It will get tired.
They don't even let the demo guy keep his elbow on the table, something you should generally do for any gesture input mechanism you are writing that takes a while, even if it means they will just be using a short arc of space.
There are great uses for gesture tracking techniques. Heck, countless people love the various games out there that use motion control, and there's even more industrial use for 3D stuff and posing characters. This is not a great use.
Re:8pen + Leap Motion
by robertfw on Thursday October 03, 2013 @12:12PM
(#6489950)
When alternative text input comes up I always feel compelled to share Dasher[1]. Dasher is designed with accessible computing in mind, and can be driven using a wide variety of input method.
The project appears to be abandoned - so no leap support - though the leap would be an excellent fit for the interface, minus the gorilla arm problem.
Re:8pen + Leap Motion
by involans on Thursday October 03, 2013 @09:17AM
(#6488648)
I use the 8pen android keyboard. It takes a bit of time to get used to, but not more than a couple of days. For short strings of text, the learning curve is fine.
Re:8pen + Leap Motion
by skore on Thursday October 03, 2013 @09:32AM
(#6488731)
I tried to like it. Used it for three months, I think. Never really sunk in the way I would have liked to and clever auto-complete works a lot faster for me these days than 8pen ever could.
Re:8pen + Leap Motion
by neona on Thursday October 03, 2013 @10:32AM
(#6489129)
8pen is neat, but i'm still not entirely convinced it can be that fast an input method. I've started using it semi-recently (last month or so), as it seemed better than using a touchscreen keyboard (swype is an okay solution, but I prefer to avoid imprecise input when possible).
I'm getting faster, but it seems that I will need to dedicate a fair bit more time to it before it will be that practical as an input method.
I really wish companies would just continue making nice phones with hard keyboards, would make my life easier. :(
Re:8pen + Leap Motion
by edgeman27 on Thursday October 03, 2013 @09:08AM
(#6488599)
I think the promotional video should show something a little more useful than air-writing. One could have typed (or spoken) the same text in a fraction of the time. How about drawing or painting?
Re:8pen + Leap Motion
by eterpstra on Thursday October 03, 2013 @09:18AM
(#6488656)
Why is the guy in the video writing stuff by waving his finger around to make cryptic symbols when there is a perfectly good keyboard only inches away!
Seriously though, I agree there are practical uses for this - such as TV input or some sort of touchless kiosk (in a hospital maybe?). The video just did a poor job of showing what's what.
Re:8pen + Leap Motion
by andyhmltn on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:29AM
(#6489579)
Your link works, but you can't play the video. Go to http://8pen.com/joysticks and press the button instead :) Pretty bad implementation on their web developers part
Re:8pen + Leap Motion
by jamesbritt on Thursday October 03, 2013 @10:42AM
(#6489211)
Aside from a lack of range, I doubt the Leap can handle it. From my experience it routinely treats fingers held together as a single "pointable" instance. There will be a good number of ASL conditions it won't recognize.
Re:8pen + Leap Motion
by oulipo on Thursday October 03, 2013 @09:10AM
(#6488605)
This would be a neat way to search for television programs from the couch, or to write notes during surgery without having to remove gloves, or to search for recipes with the hands full of flour :)
There are definitely many applications for that technology!
Re:8pen + Leap Motion
by tjr on Thursday October 03, 2013 @09:16AM
(#6488641)
I type much slower on my phone than on a keyboard, but it's clearly still useful.
I have a music recording studio set up at home. I can imagine some scenarios where it might be easier for me to wave my hand for some brief computer interaction than to reposition myself for regular keyboard-typing and mouse-moving.
But, shrug, in any event, I think it's neat to see LeapMotion technology being brought to more applications. Maybe some of them will prove silly, but at least people are trying to figure out how to use it, which is more than I can say for myself thus far...
IMO, their three suggested use-cases are quite flimsy.
"...enable surgeons to take notes during an operation without removing their gloves" - They already can, it's called dictation which is subsequently transcribed by a medical secretary whose time is far less expensive.
"check recipes while cooking without spilling flour on the keyboard" - touchless navigation of a pre-chosen recipe, maybe. Actually stopping cooking to search for a recipe/technique that you're unsure about? I would rather quickly wash my hands and use a more traditional input method to find what I want.
"search for TV programs without leaving their couch" - Given the range of the Leap device this really doesn't make sense - are they envisaging a wireless version you take with you to the couch/coffee table. Some sort of device that can 'remotely control' your television...
I still think Leap Motion is great technology, but still missing a decent application.
They don't even let the demo guy keep his elbow on the table, something you should generally do for any gesture input mechanism you are writing that takes a while, even if it means they will just be using a short arc of space.
There are great uses for gesture tracking techniques. Heck, countless people love the various games out there that use motion control, and there's even more industrial use for 3D stuff and posing characters. This is not a great use.
The project appears to be abandoned - so no leap support - though the leap would be an excellent fit for the interface, minus the gorilla arm problem.
[1] http://www.inference.phy.cam.ac.uk/dasher/
Edit: apparently they have an Android version now.
Leap Motion in general is awesome technology, but it's going to remain grounded without a practical application.
I'm getting faster, but it seems that I will need to dedicate a fair bit more time to it before it will be that practical as an input method.
I really wish companies would just continue making nice phones with hard keyboards, would make my life easier. :(
Seriously though, I agree there are practical uses for this - such as TV input or some sort of touchless kiosk (in a hospital maybe?). The video just did a poor job of showing what's what.
There are definitely many applications for that technology!
I have a music recording studio set up at home. I can imagine some scenarios where it might be easier for me to wave my hand for some brief computer interaction than to reposition myself for regular keyboard-typing and mouse-moving.
But, shrug, in any event, I think it's neat to see LeapMotion technology being brought to more applications. Maybe some of them will prove silly, but at least people are trying to figure out how to use it, which is more than I can say for myself thus far...
"Write slower than ever and guarantee RSI. All for 3 easy payments of $19.95!"