I personally would like to see the NSA organization around defense and not offense. Make better tools to protect us. Don't backdoor things since any backdoor they have can be discover and used by others. etc.
Worth a read: "How the NSA could stop sucking and be awesome instead" by Ted Dziuba:
http://teddziuba.com/post/58735980543/how-the-nsa-could-stop...
The trouble is that, in aggregate, the knowledge acquired is powerful and transcends time-honored boundaries.
What I have a problem with is invading my privacy and gathering my communications and information without a warrant. My 4th amendment rights have been completely violated.
Whatever short-sighted jerk-offs came up with this grand plan ought to be put in prison for harming US interests. To say that Snowden is the one who harmed US interests for revealing these activities is an intolerable act of a government that values only one thing, loyalty. Principles? Nah. Principles are soooo pre-Industrial revolution. And let's face it: with all the thousands of people working on these projects, someone was bound to blow the whistle sooner or later, because no matter how far down the rabbit hole an agency like the NSA goes when it comes to defining new norms, there are always some awesome weirdos who don't buy it, no matter how normal everyone around them treats it. (Hat tip to you, Snowden, for not drinking the Kool-Aid).
Guess what bozos (yes, NSA, I'm talking to you): national security is affected by abrogation of trust and betrayal of people like you. Our position as an exemplar of personal freedom, and self-restrained government, has been badly damaged by you. Going after Snowden, doubling down on internal security...these damage you, and us, further. Maybe Congress is confused on this issue, but I (and most everyone I've talked to) am not: you need to stop collecting data without warrants immediately. You need to dismantle your capacity to do so. You need to delete all information that you've gathered under those conditions.
And this should be the last act of the NSA's senior leadership before resigning.
"...weirdos...."
I prefer to describe them as people with a conscience, that are cognizant of the consequences of hypocrisy and danger of the actions of the organization which they serve.What is the problem is the NSA doing this sort of blanket surveillance where a warrant is normally required but where they make an end-run around the Constitution.
We require warrants because we require magistrates to require particularity in the warrant.
But it gets worse. What will come out of this is a massive market for more secure communications, much of it designed to thwart this sort of surveillance. The NSA by not respecting our rule of law has now encouraged people to do exactly what they are afraid of and in the end, wiretaps will now go dark. The NSA broke their end of the legal bargain and now the entire government will pay a price, and that price will, no doubt, impede legitimate law enforcement efforts as well as this.
Information traversing the Internet has been legally deemed to not be included in one's "person, house, paper or effects" and as such is not constitutionally protected by the fourth amendment.
Please provide citations regarding SCOTUS. In fact, given that Katz v. United States was never overruled, that sounds very suspicious. The closest I think you can get is Amnesty International v. Clapper but that was a standing issue and never reached the merits.
https://ssd.eff.org/your-computer/govt/privacy
The "communications records that receive special protection" are limited to ECPA, I believe, which doesn't apply to NSA since foreign surveillance trumps that law (though, IANAL so feel free to read and analyze for yourself).
The much more concerning line of cases are the banking instrument cases, like US v. Miller (http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/cgi-bin/getcase.pl?navby=volpa...) and California Bankers Association v. Shultz (http://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/416/21/) which hold no 4th Amendment protection for banking transaction information.
The problem with communications is that while call detail records fall outside 4h Amendment protection in general, wiretaps require a warrant (see Katz v. United States) and Smith v. Maryland did have dissenters due to the fact that it is hard to draw a line between these two. More recently a circuit split has developed over whether cell site location data is at least potentially protected. The 5th Circuit (which also holds that all airport searches at security checkpoints are necessarily consented to, so presumably random strip and body cavity searches would be Constitutional) says they are not, while the third says they may be. See http://crimeinthesuites.com/circuit-split-brewing-over-gover...
My point is that "knowingly exposed to a third party" is not at all as clear as the page suggests. The reason this line is there is that it is an indication that certain information is not really expected to be secret, but if it was read literally, Katz would have come out very differently and wiretaps would not require a warrant.
Obviously if you write details of your criminal conspiracy on the back of a postcard, you can't complain when the postmaster reads it, but when you put it in an envelope then this would be a search. This sort of line is much harder to draw regarding papers outside that sort of home or mail environment than it is in them, but that's largely what I would describe the difficulty to be. This leads to the question of whether email is like a postcard or like a letter or a phone call and I don't think the answer is clear.
At any rate I would suggest that this is an area of developing law regarding electronic communications and I have been watching interesting developments there just in the last few years.
Actually, it's not clear to me that there is path for NSA-related activities to be considered in the SCOTUS.
For thousands of years, some groups of humans have been trying to find ways to protect their communications, and other groups of humans have sought ways to break those protections.
At times the code-makers become aware of the breakthroughs that the codebreakers have made and change their tactics, or new technology gives them a new cipher. Either way, the codebreaker sets a setback and has to change their tactics as well.
This new revelation doesn't seem like anything too different from that cycle - it is just revealing a larger breakthrough than is regularly revealed.
Smooth move, NSAssholes.