News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by masklinn on Friday September 06, 2013 @06:42AM (#6339640)
> Her proposals have faced fierce opposition from the largest networks, including Vodafone, Orange and Telefónica, which say the end of roaming within Europe could cost them €7bn (£5.9bn).

Delicious tears.

Though I object to the use of the word "cost", it will remove unmerited earnings but will not add costs to their balance sheet: notice how the operators whining the most are the pan-european ones? That's because they can currently charge roaming fees for operations within their network, fleecing their own users.

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by noselasd on Friday September 06, 2013 @02:19PM (#6341831)
That's not how it works. If you're a cell provider, you've bought a lot of gear, permits, licenses, more gear - which cost. If you ever thought spending a couple hundred thousand $ for a big cisco switch was bad, the big mobile switching centers and thousands of cell sites needed are really expensive to commision and operate.

This means you take on huge credit when building the networks, meant to be downpaid over years and decades. If the future revenue stream disappears, you may very well be losing money on your initial investment.

I'm not saying many of the telcos couldn't do with a bit less profit, but don't pretend losing revenue is a non-issue. I'd say its likely a complete restructure of networks and service operators would be needed to really get rid of the roaming charges.

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by anologwintermut on Friday September 06, 2013 @02:42PM (#6341967)
They could also loose revenue from competition because their prices suck. Companies are not entitled to being profitable, they have to compete.

Except in this case there are constraints that prevent full competition. There are only a handful of mobile phone companies that operate their own infrastructure. They constitute a oligopoly and a form of natural monopoly that can more or less dictate prices. The point of regulating utilities is to prevent this.

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by icebraining on Friday September 06, 2013 @04:50PM (#6342605)
What are the constraints? Couldn't those be removed/aleviated instead?
Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by anologwintermut on Friday September 06, 2013 @05:49PM (#6342887)
The classic economic problem with utilities (power, water, phone,gas) is they occupy what is called a natural monopoly[0]. My econ 101 prof explained it thusly: It would be really wasteful if there were 100 different power lines going to your house, yet you'd need at least that many power companies to have something approaching a free market where supply=demand. Not just is the 100 power line outcome wasteful, it won't emerge in a free market.

You can't remove the reasons this happens, you can however regulate it to either somehow cause a competitive market or prevent the monopolist from leveraging their position and price gouging.

Now, obviously cell phone carriers are not a monopoly. They are actually an oligopoly[1], but that doesn't change much and the barriers that lead to it are the same.

[0]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_monopoly [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oligopoly

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by emiliobumachar on Saturday September 07, 2013 @12:15AM (#6343948)
One of the big ones is that there is only so much feasible bandwidth to go around. The governments auction it off (in the best case).

In a really free market, anyone could transmit in any frequency, jamming everyone else. Could quickly degenerate into a costest of who jacks up power more.

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by mixmastamyk on Saturday September 07, 2013 @12:46AM (#6344007)
They won't reduce their profits, they'll raise regular fees to compensate.

Everyone should get a more consistent bill, which they can plan for accordingly, instead of a disgusting surprise defilement as is the case now.

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by devx on Friday September 06, 2013 @08:20AM (#6340008)
Not to mention this could potentially make them more money if all of the sudden people can just talk to their relatives in other EU countries without having to pay "special fees".
Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by pisarzp on Friday September 06, 2013 @08:38AM (#6340092)
I think this is still years ahead of us. Only roaming charges will be cancelled, calling German numbers from UK will still cost you a fortune.

What is idiotic, it only makes everyone to install Viver/Skype/whatever and use phone functionality less.

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by kristofferR on Friday September 06, 2013 @09:00AM (#6340178)
Most carriers in Norway has begun to charge the same rate for calls/SMS/data to all the Nordic countries (Denmark, Sweden, Finland and Iceland) as local usage, so it's not that unrealistic.
Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by porsupah on Friday September 06, 2013 @11:22AM (#6340864)
Not necessarily. With UK carrier rate structures as they are, it can often be cheaper to call internationally than within the UK.

Consider, for example, GiffGaff (part of O2): within the UK, 10p/min. Meanwhile, calling internationally from the UK: Germany, 5p/min; India, 2p/min; USA, 3p/min.

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by MichaelGG on Friday September 06, 2013 @03:56PM (#6342306)
Telecom rate tarrifs are usually convoluted and political. Some places have the opposite of what you outline, where international calls pay an extra kickback to the telecom/government. Other places, like the US, had things setup so that calling people inside your state was more expensive than calling another state or calling from an international location.

This also creates incentives for people to setup grey routes. It's common to buy local prepaid SIM cards then hook them up to a GSM bank and sell "international" connectivity to calling card companies. One guy had his setup inside a van, so he could drive around town and avoid being triangulated by the local telco. (The local equivalent of the FCC will raid and steal your equipment if they can find you.)

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by sliverstorm on Friday September 06, 2013 @01:15PM (#6341479)
In the age of unlimited minutes? Doubtful.
Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by JoshTriplett on Friday September 06, 2013 @11:05AM (#6340789)
> it will remove unmerited earnings

If people are currently paying roaming costs, then the earnings are clearly merited. You might find the practice distasteful, and wish it did not exist, but that does not make it illegitimate; they found something the market would pay for, and successfully got the market to pay for it.

There's no monopoly on cell carriers, as evidenced by the three separate carriers mentioned just in the sentence you quoted.

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by anologwintermut on Friday September 06, 2013 @11:21AM (#6340856)
Ok, first, there is an oligopoly of cell phone carriers: you don't actually have enough for it to be a free market. Second, you likely don't want there to be enough real carriers(i.e. with their own towers), for there to be a free market. That would involve massive amounts of wasted infrastructure. Thankfully, third, because of those infrastructure costs, it's unlikely you'd ever see that many cell phone carriers. Cell phone infrastructure isn't quite a natural monopoly[0], but it's close.

[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_monopoly

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by matwood on Friday September 06, 2013 @11:22AM (#6340870)
I normally agree with free market comments like the one above. The problem with cellular is that companies use a shared public resource. We the public grant monopolies to various frequencies for a fee. Even though a company paid the fee, it still remains a public resource and can fall under additional regulation.

Now, there could be argument that the public should not change the rules after the fact or whenever we feel like it. Instead review the contracts every 5 years or so and make changes then.

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by njs12345 on Friday September 06, 2013 @11:08AM (#6340800)
Roaming charges are too high and I want to start a new cell carrier to compete on this basis. How would you suggest I go about it?
Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by EliRivers on Saturday September 07, 2013 @05:11AM (#6344487)
If people are currently paying roaming costs, then the earnings are clearly merited.

I could apply the same logic to a protection racket [1]; if people pay up, it's merited.

[1] I'm not saying this is a protection racket; I'm saying that people paying doesn't necessarily make it merited.

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by burgerz on Friday September 06, 2013 @11:13AM (#6340827)
The fact that this was downvoted shows people on HN don't understand how the free market works. Adding more and more regulation only makes things worse for the end paying customer. Good luck.
Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by anologwintermut on Friday September 06, 2013 @11:27AM (#6340890)
You are right, some people on HN don't under stand how free markets work. Here[0][1], maybe after reading those, you will be one step closer to not being one of them.

[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oligopoly [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_monopoly

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by bowlofpetunias on Friday September 06, 2013 @01:34PM (#6341592)
Yes, that's why in the strictly regulated European telecom market consumers are systematically better off than Americans when it comes to cable, mobile, internet etcetera.

And not just on lower prices and better service, but actually more freedom and choice.

Cross-border roaming was the last thing that was still unregulated. Other than that, Europe is a telecommunications paradise for businesses and consumers compared to the US.

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by icebraining on Friday September 06, 2013 @04:56PM (#6342632)
As far as I know, the US market is heavily regulated, with providers successfully suing municipalities and preventing them from building competing services.

Bad regulations is not the same as unregulated.

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by arethuza on Friday September 06, 2013 @11:34AM (#6340924)
The regulation here in the UK to force BT to allow other ISPs to use their infrastructure seems to have worked well - now most people have a large number of ISPs competing for their business (including BT). A quick check suggests I have at least 15 ISPs competing for my business with all manner of deals and packages - sounds pretty much like a healthy marketplace to me.

And all because of regulation.

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by matwood on Friday September 06, 2013 @11:25AM (#6340880)
Adding more and more regulation only makes things worse for the end paying customer.

This is simply not universally true. The cell market doesn't exist without regulation. If any company can throw up a tower on any frequency and start a cell company the end paying customer is going to have a horrible experience.

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by jpadkins on Friday September 06, 2013 @12:52PM (#6341345)
like the wifi market? Oh right, open spectrum laws actually create useful services for consumers.

It is a fallacy to believe that frequency regulation is needed for services to come to market. Coopetition does happen in the real world (see all the devices made for open spectrum like 2.4ghz)

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by kd0amg on Friday September 06, 2013 @01:52PM (#6341684)
like the wifi market?

47 CFR 15 (and other countries' equivalents) probably counts as regulations.

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by burgerz on Friday September 06, 2013 @11:53AM (#6341040)
You can make a similar argument about any market. It's so much easier to believe the intuitive bs that the state can just control everything and keep prices down for everyone.

I'm outta here I just thought the userbase here would be less liberal.

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by EliRivers on Saturday September 07, 2013 @05:15AM (#6344497)
If only there was some way to look at reality and see what can happen when government regulation is applied in the telecoms industry. If only there was some way you could read the posts above that give solid examples of where government regulation has forced competition to the massive benefit of consumers.

Have fun back at your anti-vaccination ultra-Christian extreme right-wing shill site, paid for by the Koch brothers in the hope that poor people will keep voting against their own interests (yup, we can say emotional trigger-words instead of presenting facts as well, just like you can!)

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by pjc50 on Friday September 06, 2013 @12:18PM (#6341183)
Large areas of EU policy show that this isn't the case. There's a valid "regulation is hard on small businesses" argument, but it doesn't apply to telcos, which are necessarily giant businesses. This sort of market is very prone to "gotcha" fees resulting in unexpected huge bills, and the EU has so far done an OK job of controlling them.
Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by rdc12 on Friday September 06, 2013 @11:33AM (#6340916)
Good to know that customers paying high roaming fees is good for the customers
Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by burgerz on Friday September 06, 2013 @11:50AM (#6341025)
We pay high roaming fees because of regulation and government intervention.
Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by Karunamon on Friday September 06, 2013 @01:40PM (#6341623)
Do tell. I'd love you to explain this in detail instead of just snarking and running like all the other "free market über alles" folks infesting this thread.
Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by Shivetya on Friday September 06, 2013 @12:57PM (#6341375)
Nah, they understand. They common trend on this site and a few other techy sites I frequent is the same, something for nothing. If a megacorp is making money it can surely stand to not make so much.

The very reasons to maintain some form of roaming charges comes down to, who built the towers? Who invested in the hardware, software, and persons, working to provide the service? I do not care one wit about this claim "public resources" when it comes to cell phones? Why not? Because it is a patent excuse to take. The same excuse is used when people want specific speech censored from the airwaves but not another. However, hell and high water reign should the same taking be done to something techies hold near and dear to their hearts, you would never see them support taking of speech rights or such with regards to their blogs, sites, and whatnot.

Back to roaming charges. Should we not then force nation states to not charge access fees to their networks? Many do. They charge carriers for calls going into their state owned agencies.

Simply put, don't allow roaming charges and costs will be spread to anyone using a cell phone, whether they roam or not. You cannot legislate away costs, you certainly can profit, but I guess the private investor should have known better. Kind of like government bonds, they are only really guaranteed the day they are written