Re:How Advanced Is the NSA's Cryptanalysis, and Can We Resis...
by maxk42 on Thursday September 05, 2013 @07:47PM
(#6337900)
Agreed. One advantage the NSA has is it can pay some of the best mathematicians to be full-time pure mathematicians. There are very few mathematicians that have the opportunity to do something like that -- even professors have to teach a few classes. I imagine it's a powerful draw to top talent and gives them the ability to spend more time on a problem than most others.
Re:How Advanced Is the NSA's Cryptanalysis, and Can We Resis...
by zorked on Thursday September 05, 2013 @07:57PM
(#6337944)
On the other hand your work is secret and you will never be recognized for what you do.
Re:How Advanced Is the NSA's Cryptanalysis, and Can We Resis...
by lesterbuck on Thursday September 05, 2013 @08:09PM
(#6337987)
You would be recognized inside the NSA, a large technical population.
In addition, as with the CIA and other clandestine US government organizations, they appeal to patriotism and helping the national interest. That appeal seems to be fraying somewhat lately for the NSA.
Re:How Advanced Is the NSA's Cryptanalysis, and Can We Resis...
by vinceguidry on Thursday September 05, 2013 @09:22PM
(#6338171)
If they're really trying to keep it secret, not even the NSA rank and file will know. It's all mostly need to know anyway.
Re:How Advanced Is the NSA's Cryptanalysis, and Can We Resis...
by nitrogen on Thursday September 05, 2013 @10:12PM
(#6338314)
Though I have no first-hand knowledge, I was under the impression that organizations like the NSA have internal peer-reviewed journals that their mathematicians can "publish" in, while remaining classified and unavailable to the public.
Re:How Advanced Is the NSA's Cryptanalysis, and Can We Resis...
by gizmo686 on Thursday September 05, 2013 @11:14PM
(#6338483)
I have a friend who interned with the NSA in high school. Although what he did is classified, he was allowed to say that his work got published internally.
Re:How Advanced Is the NSA's Cryptanalysis, and Can We Resis...
by lostlogin on Friday September 06, 2013 @01:15AM
(#6338804)
This is basically just a small step worse than many professions. Once you hit the pay wall on journal articles you want to read, how many people pay to go through?
Re:How Advanced Is the NSA's Cryptanalysis, and Can We Resis...
by andrewfong on Thursday September 05, 2013 @08:06PM
(#6337982)
There are some (if not many) mathematicians for which recognition is not a plus (and in some cases may even be a negative).
Re:How Advanced Is the NSA's Cryptanalysis, and Can We Resis...
by Mindless2112 on Thursday September 05, 2013 @08:13PM
(#6338000)
Not everyone works for public recognition. There are enough people who are willing to work on neat problems in exchange for plenty of money who are also willing to forgo public recognition.
Re:How Advanced Is the NSA's Cryptanalysis, and Can We Resis...
by smtddr on Thursday September 05, 2013 @08:06PM
(#6337980)
Or, if movies have taught me anything, after you've done your work and it's fully documented & reproducible... you'll be killed
Re:How Advanced Is the NSA's Cryptanalysis, and Can We Resis...
by bsullivan01 on Thursday September 05, 2013 @10:35PM
(#6338387)
Never is a long time, in a decade or two you might be. BUT either way, some very brilliant NSA mathematicians know what you came up with and so do you. That's enough for a lot of people.
Also, they might not have the most brilliant mathematicians, but private companies don't have the interest in using their math expertise to break encryption. There are more lucrative ways to exploit great math ability.
Universities may have more of an interest in advancing cryptography research, but they can't match the budget nor focus of the NSA.