News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by alan_cx on Saturday August 31, 2013 @03:21PM (#6307778)
Why no appreciation of the apology? If all people are going to do is find fault with people apologizing, why bother? How should Tumblr reacted? What are they supposed to do?
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by ben0x539 on Saturday August 31, 2013 @04:08PM (#6307902)
Why should we appreciate the apology? We might blame tumblr a little less now than if they'd stayed their course, but I don't see why it should swing over into appreciation of what they're doing.

Perceivedly, it happens a lot that big scary companies bully smaller entities with meritless but expensive-to-fight legal threats. That sometimes there's enough of a public notice of that to make the company reconsider and to limit the damage done is just part of the game and doesn't really leave them without blame, it just means they got "caught" this time.

Re:Retraction from Tumblr by aespinoza on Saturday August 31, 2013 @04:56PM (#6308048)
I think you are missing the point here. It is stupid to blame Tumblr for all the other big scary companies. They made a mistake. They apologized and fixed the problem, and according to the apology they found a bug in their process and fixed it.

Instead of bashing Tumblr for apologizing, we should be happy they retracted. If HN was the reason why they retracted, then great. But let's stop looking down on Tumblr purring ourselves at the top.

We are all at the same boat and same level. We are all trying to make our companies work.

Re:Retraction from Tumblr by whistlerbrk on Saturday August 31, 2013 @05:13PM (#6308115)
He is missing the point, it's not even his apology to accept, it's Zach's. He's appeared to do since he considers the apology 'genuine'.

The thing to note in all this is:

"Our legal department very recently started using a third party vendor to assist us in pursuing trademark infringers and, due to an error in our new process, your domain was mistakenly caught in the cross-fire."

If tumblr has switched to yahoo! legal, that is not a nice side effect of the acquisition.

Re:Retraction from Tumblr by ben0x539 on Saturday August 31, 2013 @05:18PM (#6308147)
> He is missing the point, it's not even his apology to accept, it's Zach's.

Of course it's not for me to accept or not accept that apology and no one should care about my opinion on the matter. But I think not appreciating the apology is a defensible position to take and I'm trying to articulate why I feel so. Feel free to dismiss me. :)

Re:Retraction from Tumblr by ben0x539 on Saturday August 31, 2013 @05:14PM (#6308125)
The apology fits the patterns of those big scary companies. It's better than not giving an apology, sure, but in just my personal, humble opinion it does not exonerate them.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by Groxx on Saturday August 31, 2013 @04:06PM (#6307897)
Probably because, as nice as this is, fixing an instance doesn't imply fixing the problem. The problem is (arguably) over-zealous protection - this does nothing to address that, it just brings back a single high-profile HN-popular site.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by zachinglis on Saturday August 31, 2013 @04:25PM (#6307969)
I am appreciative. I wrote as much to the lawyer who contacted me. I should put that I am appreciative in.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by geuis on Saturday August 31, 2013 @03:28PM (#6307799)
Well said. A company can either continue on as before, which makes us associate them as bullies, or can correct a mistake. The real test is what comes after.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by jcromartie on Saturday August 31, 2013 @09:18PM (#6308725)
They could fire the third party who is sending erroneous legal threats to people who couldn't possibly fight them.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by mikeash on Saturday August 31, 2013 @05:12PM (#6308110)
It's a bad apology. There's no real admission that they messed up (they implicitly blame a third party, and "process") and no mention whatsoever of doing anything to avoid future mistakes like this.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by bjackman on Saturday August 31, 2013 @05:15PM (#6308126)
I disagree: "We deeply apologize for our mistake". I interpret the mention of a third party as an attempt to say "this was a mistake, not just us deliberately being dicks", not "this was not our fault".
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by obilgic on Saturday August 31, 2013 @02:35PM (#6307638)
That means, unless you are on HN's front page you don't have rights to use word tumblr in your domain
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by bilalq on Saturday August 31, 2013 @02:45PM (#6307681)
It's become an interesting phenomena now. The rise in availability of the internet and pervasiveness of social media is making companies accountable for their wrongdoings. Of course, the more prominent/visible the complaint, the more likely it is that a company will try to act on it.

However, I don't believe that most companies would just handle problems like this in a case by case basis. IsTumblrDown made some noise, and that noise led Tumblr to recognizing a flaw in their process. At the very least, it'll make them more cautious going forward. Incidents like this can lead to long-term improvements.

Re:Retraction from Tumblr by raverbashing on Saturday August 31, 2013 @02:52PM (#6307701)
Good

It means that legal departments have to stop the "shoot first ask questions later" strategy

It's very easy to just go around threatening legal action against people unchecked.

Re:Retraction from Tumblr by asdfologist on Saturday August 31, 2013 @02:38PM (#6307648)
Let's not flatter ourselves here.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by zachinglis on Saturday August 31, 2013 @02:47PM (#6307689)
I agree and disagree. HN is not massive, but it is a force.

HN can be one scary angry mob which is nice to be backed by, but horrible to be on the end of. Remember the Aria Richards debacle which was heightened by this community. Just one of many. (That wasn't my intention by the way and everyone's been pretty calm.)

The HN effect is a strange one. :)

Re:Retraction from Tumblr by nknighthb on Saturday August 31, 2013 @03:12PM (#6307753)
HN's readership wields significant influence in SV/SF tech, both collectively and individually. Check your server logs, I bet you got hits from inside Tumblr's IP block almost the instant it hit the front page, along with virtually every other tech company, whose employees and even executives were glowering at their friends (and former and future colleagues) at Tumblr.

To use the indelicate phrasing of my first manager, bay area tech is highly incestuous.

Re:Retraction from Tumblr by jared314 on Saturday August 31, 2013 @02:45PM (#6307682)
The same has historically applied to google search misclassifications and ignored bug/error reports for any major company. Publicity is to be the only recourse for anyone without a contractual agreement.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by mayoff on Saturday August 31, 2013 @03:11PM (#6307749)
It doesn't matter to Tumblr if HNers boycott Tumblr the web site.

It might matter to Tumblr if HNers boycott Tumblr the employer or Tumblr the business partner.

Re:Retraction from Tumblr by mcintyre1994 on Saturday August 31, 2013 @03:27PM (#6307795)
It's also worth considering Yahoo! the employer or Yahoo! the business partner.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by joeblau on Saturday August 31, 2013 @02:33PM (#6307630)
So essentially, a legal team was spamming anything with the word tumblr in it?
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by cabalamat on Saturday August 31, 2013 @02:37PM (#6307643)
> a legal team was spamming anything with the word tumblr in it

There ought to be some comeback on people who do this, just like there ought to be for people who send out false DMCA takedown notices.

Re:Retraction from Tumblr by loceng on Saturday August 31, 2013 @03:34PM (#6307815)
Lawyers basically say until a cease and desist is received (confirmed received), then they've spent money and are serious.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by spindritf on Saturday August 31, 2013 @02:35PM (#6307637)
Well, a company they contracted did. So yes, close enough.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by molecule on Saturday August 31, 2013 @02:38PM (#6307650)
IsTumblrsLawsuitDown.com
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by rlongstaff on Saturday August 31, 2013 @02:43PM (#6307676)
The cynical reaction would be to say this is all about damage limitation to their brand since it appeared on HN, as they meant to do it rather than it being a 'clerical error'.

Good thing I'm not cynical.

Re:Retraction from Tumblr by saosebastiao on Saturday August 31, 2013 @02:55PM (#6307705)
HN, and its readership, simply isn't that important to tumblr. If it were reddit, maybe the cynical reaction would be accurate.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by Zaheer on Saturday August 31, 2013 @03:04PM (#6307732)
Yes it is. Tumblr's parent is Yahoo and Yahoo will be keen on being friendly to the developer community to attract top talent. Much of which reads HN.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by dylangs1030 on Saturday August 31, 2013 @03:14PM (#6307758)
I know it seems that way, but that's actually reddit and r/programming. Based on sheer numbers, I think most engineers don't frequent Hacker News.

I was just at dinner with an ex-Zynga game dev last night who had never even heard of it.

Re:Retraction from Tumblr by pearjuice on Saturday August 31, 2013 @05:53PM (#6308271)
>ex-Zynga game dev

Well, he did say "top talent"!

Re:Retraction from Tumblr by dylangs1030 on Saturday August 31, 2013 @06:58PM (#6308438)
I'm not sure if you're being sarcastic, but it's unfair to judge someone's ability based on where they used to work.

This friend of mine was laid off in New York and received his severance; based on what I know about him, he could work in a multitude of places right now if he wanted to.

Zynga's vilified image aside, there is no reason to believe their engineers are not "top talent."

Re:Retraction from Tumblr by pearjuice on Saturday August 31, 2013 @05:50PM (#6308266)
"So I'll be bringing it online in a few weeks again."

Wait, what? He gets to keep his product but post-pones its availability by a "few weeks"? Opportunity missed. Or am I missing something?

Re:Retraction from Tumblr by zachinglis on Saturday August 31, 2013 @05:57PM (#6308282)
It's not really a product. It's a page that says "Tumblr is up" or "Tumblr is down." Very very niche and incredibly limited functionality.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by bowlofpetunias on Saturday August 31, 2013 @03:55PM (#6307868)
> ...pursuing trademark infringers...

That's the part they should be apologizing for.

Unless their business is actually getting hurt in any way (is someone selling fake Chinese made Tumblr t-shirts on the black market?), this is just a systematic exercise in corporate bullying.

They shouldn't be engaged in this in the first place. Tumblr is not friggin' Nike.

Re:Retraction from Tumblr by sjtgraham on Saturday August 31, 2013 @04:11PM (#6307911)
There's no choice in the matter. Do you realise trademark holders have to vigorously defend their marks in order for them to remain protected? Failure to do so jeopardises protection.

Disclaimer: IANAL

Re:Retraction from Tumblr by calbear81 on Saturday August 31, 2013 @06:16PM (#6308337)
Thank you for pointing this out. Tumblr is just doing what any company who has spent time building their brand must do if they want to be able to retain their trademark. Their 3rd party enforcement company didn't exercise "common sense" and when Tumblr realized this they said sorry.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by chadwickthebold on Saturday August 31, 2013 @05:03PM (#6308068)
... and istumblrdown.com is somehow stealing tumblr's business?
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by a3n on Saturday August 31, 2013 @06:56PM (#6308433)
Only when tumblr is down.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by samuelfine on Saturday August 31, 2013 @04:00PM (#6307885)
"...is someone selling fake Chinese made Tumblr t-shirts on the black market?"

I wouldn't be surprised. Tumblr just sold for a billion dollars, remember? That's certainly a brand worth protecting.

Re:Retraction from Tumblr by sillysaurus2 on Saturday August 31, 2013 @02:35PM (#6307636)
This seems like a risky move for tumblr, no? Doesn't this mean they're not actively defending their trademark? In which case this could cause them legal problems in the future.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by spindritf on Saturday August 31, 2013 @02:40PM (#6307656)
This duty to defend a trademark has grown to completely mythical size. Like "fiduciary duty" of company officers.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by darrenkopp on Saturday August 31, 2013 @02:39PM (#6307651)
IANAL, but to me it seems more like "we are actively defending our trademark (ala the hiring of the legal company), but we do not believe that you are infringing on that trademark and what you are doing is fair use, so carry on"
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by AYBABTME on Saturday August 31, 2013 @02:51PM (#6307698)
I can't help but read `I'm anal` when somebody uses this acronym. It always take me a couple seconds to remember `I am not a lawyer`.

Sorry for the off topic.

Re:Retraction from Tumblr by chimeracoder on Saturday August 31, 2013 @02:59PM (#6307716)
DannyBee (who is a lawyer) pointed out in the thread last night that this doesn't need to be "defended" against. He explained that, since they use the term "Tumblr" to refer specifically to the real company Tumblr, and since it's clear that they're not trying to masquerade as Tumblr or cause any confusion, that this is a legitimate use of the term and does not need to be "defended against" in order to protect the trademark.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by pcwalton on Saturday August 31, 2013 @03:14PM (#6307761)
The legal term here, incidentally, appears to be "nominative use". (I learned a lot from that thread!)
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by einhverfr on Sunday September 01, 2013 @12:31AM (#6309156)
This is correct. However, I think it is good practice to properly attribute trademarks in those cases to make sure that it is clear that it is intended in this way.

A small disclaimer at the bottom of the page saying:

Tumblr(R) is a registered trademark of Tumblr, Inc. which is not affiliated with this site. All other trademarks are owned by their respective owners.

goes a long ways towards avoiding problems like this.

Re:Retraction from Tumblr by sillysaurus2 on Saturday August 31, 2013 @03:09PM (#6307746)
Thank you for answering my question.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by eCa on Saturday August 31, 2013 @03:23PM (#6307781)
The way I understand it (IANAL) is that you need to protect your trademark against people who uses confusing namings on things that isn't you. In this case "tumblr" clearly and explicitly refers to tumblr.com.

If you had to make sure that no one uses your trademark to talk about you, wouldn't that lead to a very strange place?

Re:Retraction from Tumblr by lvs on Saturday August 31, 2013 @02:41PM (#6307660)
This type of thinking is poisonous to the industry and to all industries.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by sillysaurus2 on Saturday August 31, 2013 @02:52PM (#6307702)
It's not "thinking." It's a question. It's annoying that I can't ask a startup question in a startup community without being characterized as an evil capitalist.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by bcoates on Saturday August 31, 2013 @03:31PM (#6307806)
You don't want to be "could this get us sued?" guy. Lots of people have run into the type that uses it as a go-to passive aggressive way of opposing things. It's superficially reasonable because literally anything can get you sued in the US, but it's also a completely counterproductive attitude to actually making correct decisions.

Even if you, personally are asking the question in a reasonable context where the answer is probably "yes", just saying it gets you bucketed into the "toxic people who must be contained or avoided" bucket in a lot of otherwise reasonable people's minds. Unless you are actually employed as a lawyer, it would probably be a good career move to strike discussions of legal risk from your vocabulary.

ps: Yes, I know you were asking more about what Tumblr needs to do to keep the right to stop others from using their trademark, but nobody read past "legal problems"

Re:Retraction from Tumblr by sillysaurus2 on Saturday August 31, 2013 @03:41PM (#6307835)
Even if you, personally are asking the question in a reasonable context where the answer is probably "yes", just saying it gets you bucketed into the "toxic people who must be contained or avoided" bucket in a lot of otherwise reasonable people's minds. Unless you are actually employed as a lawyer, it would probably be a good career move to strike discussions of legal risk from your vocabulary.

This is America. We're here to make money, and to win. That means operating in a legal system that can work for us or against us depending on the law. If a startup is too immature to see my question as anything other than a straightforward request for information, then I wouldn't want to work for them anyway.

Re:Retraction from Tumblr by Kequc on Saturday August 31, 2013 @02:56PM (#6307708)
No it's not a "risky" move by Tumblr to not sue someone.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by lvs on Sunday September 01, 2013 @02:24AM (#6309335)
You're right: it's not really thinking after all.

I wouldn't see a reason for annoyance. It seems you asked a question, and you got answers. I'd declare success.

Re:Retraction from Tumblr by diminoten on Saturday August 31, 2013 @02:54PM (#6307704)
Who called you an evil capitalist?
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by raverbashing on Saturday August 31, 2013 @02:55PM (#6307707)
And by the way, this is not (mainly) because it was front page on HN.

HN users do not overlap (a lot) with the target audience for Tumblr. (not a lot at least)

HN is of course an important news outlet in the industry.

Re:Retraction from Tumblr by DocG on Saturday August 31, 2013 @09:49PM (#6308778)
true, but it is same with google reader. it is not profitable, but who is target audience? the guys who install and recommend most of the software for casual users. So in some cases, you need to please a smaller group, to win over bigger group.

I think any company can win market, if your local it friend/guy starts recommending you specific brand. For example, I changed 10 peoples mind how to think about AV. They went over from AVG to MSE, because I recommended. Why? Because, there is less chance for them to fuck it up and install trial.

Re:Retraction from Tumblr by smegel on Saturday August 31, 2013 @11:41PM (#6309056)
I wonder what the threshold is for pursuing trademark infringement...obviously imposters but what else?
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by kumarski on Saturday August 31, 2013 @03:04PM (#6307730)
With our powers combined....
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by solray on Saturday August 31, 2013 @04:03PM (#6307892)
This is a classic case of TDC. (i.e. Tumblr Damage Control).