News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by alan_cx on Saturday August 31, 2013 @03:21PM (#6307778)
Why no appreciation of the apology? If all people are going to do is find fault with people apologizing, why bother? How should Tumblr reacted? What are they supposed to do?
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by ben0x539 on Saturday August 31, 2013 @04:08PM (#6307902)
Why should we appreciate the apology? We might blame tumblr a little less now than if they'd stayed their course, but I don't see why it should swing over into appreciation of what they're doing.

Perceivedly, it happens a lot that big scary companies bully smaller entities with meritless but expensive-to-fight legal threats. That sometimes there's enough of a public notice of that to make the company reconsider and to limit the damage done is just part of the game and doesn't really leave them without blame, it just means they got "caught" this time.

Re:Retraction from Tumblr by aespinoza on Saturday August 31, 2013 @04:56PM (#6308048)
I think you are missing the point here. It is stupid to blame Tumblr for all the other big scary companies. They made a mistake. They apologized and fixed the problem, and according to the apology they found a bug in their process and fixed it.

Instead of bashing Tumblr for apologizing, we should be happy they retracted. If HN was the reason why they retracted, then great. But let's stop looking down on Tumblr purring ourselves at the top.

We are all at the same boat and same level. We are all trying to make our companies work.

Re:Retraction from Tumblr by whistlerbrk on Saturday August 31, 2013 @05:13PM (#6308115)
He is missing the point, it's not even his apology to accept, it's Zach's. He's appeared to do since he considers the apology 'genuine'.

The thing to note in all this is:

"Our legal department very recently started using a third party vendor to assist us in pursuing trademark infringers and, due to an error in our new process, your domain was mistakenly caught in the cross-fire."

If tumblr has switched to yahoo! legal, that is not a nice side effect of the acquisition.

Re:Retraction from Tumblr by ben0x539 on Saturday August 31, 2013 @05:18PM (#6308147)
> He is missing the point, it's not even his apology to accept, it's Zach's.

Of course it's not for me to accept or not accept that apology and no one should care about my opinion on the matter. But I think not appreciating the apology is a defensible position to take and I'm trying to articulate why I feel so. Feel free to dismiss me. :)

Re:Retraction from Tumblr by ben0x539 on Saturday August 31, 2013 @05:14PM (#6308125)
The apology fits the patterns of those big scary companies. It's better than not giving an apology, sure, but in just my personal, humble opinion it does not exonerate them.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by Groxx on Saturday August 31, 2013 @04:06PM (#6307897)
Probably because, as nice as this is, fixing an instance doesn't imply fixing the problem. The problem is (arguably) over-zealous protection - this does nothing to address that, it just brings back a single high-profile HN-popular site.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by zachinglis on Saturday August 31, 2013 @04:25PM (#6307969)
I am appreciative. I wrote as much to the lawyer who contacted me. I should put that I am appreciative in.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by geuis on Saturday August 31, 2013 @03:28PM (#6307799)
Well said. A company can either continue on as before, which makes us associate them as bullies, or can correct a mistake. The real test is what comes after.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by jcromartie on Saturday August 31, 2013 @09:18PM (#6308725)
They could fire the third party who is sending erroneous legal threats to people who couldn't possibly fight them.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by mikeash on Saturday August 31, 2013 @05:12PM (#6308110)
It's a bad apology. There's no real admission that they messed up (they implicitly blame a third party, and "process") and no mention whatsoever of doing anything to avoid future mistakes like this.
Re:Retraction from Tumblr by bjackman on Saturday August 31, 2013 @05:15PM (#6308126)
I disagree: "We deeply apologize for our mistake". I interpret the mention of a third party as an attempt to say "this was a mistake, not just us deliberately being dicks", not "this was not our fault".