Privacy advocates worry that video of police officers searching a suspect’s home could end up on the evening news.
But I agree with the ACLU, as quoted later in the article, that:
“[The cameras] do raise privacy concerns, but ones that can be addressed by strong privacy policies.”
I nevertheless agree that on-duty police officers should have no expectation of privacy except in cases of undercover work. And frankly, with the multitude of undercover operations that border on entrapment, maybe those operations need to be documented better as well.
Oversight was created in the teens. The first states to use the procedure were California and Washington. With so much information on citizens recorded daily by vid, home monitors, fibe and satlink uploads, and neighborhood surveillance systems, a separate branch of the judiciary was established to hear appeals from those seeking to use that information for legal purposes.
Early abuses--and the far worse systematic abuse under the Raphkind presidency--has made the system painfully complex for all concerned. Each avenue of information has been wrapped in labyrinthine rules of legal engagement; and an appeal for release of data can be made only once a year for any given case.
-- Slant, Greg BearIf we rely solely on the recordings that are produced by the powerful, it seems all too likely that things will be presented out of context, recordings will be 'lost', etc
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z4obTZV2QEM (jump to 1:33)
Please don't be naïve.
Indeed--this is a standard evidentiary rule (and jury instruction) in almost every U.S. jurisdiction. In a criminal case, it would be enough to throw out the case, with prejudice. In a civil case, the judge would even be within his authority to issue a finding of fact against the party that "lost" the video.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nixon_White_House_tapes#The_18....
According to the guy, he was stopped because there was traffic in front of him, and pulled over after the light turned green and the cars blocking him in cleared out.
The guy (a casually dressed minority with tattoos all over his arms and neck) seemed frustrated as hell when all the cop did was was to simply tell the judge "I didn't see anyone in front of him" over and over as the guy tried to explain his side of the story. The ruling: guilty as charged.
I don't know what the truth was, but it sure would have been nice if there was videotape to see who was lying. As it was, it was the cop's word against the word of a guy who looked like it would be all to easy to declare him guilty.
But in this case, it is the cops who are being watched. As you note, "any interaction that occurs off camera" will be suspicious...aficionados of irony can recognize how this turns the cop-favorite-notion of "if you're doing nothing wrong, what do you have to hide?"
And the digital/systematic nature of the cameras' operation makes it even more pervasive to the officer. It's not just what you saw, but...why were you looking there, of all places? Why is your camera off during a time that you're supposed to have it on?
One thing I would've liked to see in the OP is to know the change in absolute number of officer initiated stops. If you know you have this extra layer of scrutiny to deal with, you may decide to not harass someone who is just barely breaking the law.
It could become the ultimate case of people policing each other (in the sinister neighborhood watch committees sense --ala Cuba, Vietnam, etc.)
More traditional etiquettes include the concept of what happens in public following different rules from what happens in private. "I do not care as long as he does not scare the horses in the street" is the old saying. Just do not cause other people hassles, please. (This has a dark aspect, too, overlooking domestic violence hidden behind closed doors, but that is not important to the question on hand.)
If we move to a world where your public behavior might be displayed to your family and co-workers, I think that will be a good thing overall. If you want to misbehave, please keep it in private locales.
I think any authority that accepts money from the public should be obligated to surveil themselves. Not just cops, but federal, state, and local regulators as well. What you do on the public's dime should be publicly available, with an API to your speech and location.
Pic: http://www.stcofhouston.org/PoliceCarPhotos/Houston_Police_G...
Article: http://m.policemag.com/blogpost/1474/houston-pd-s-traffic-en...
Unrelated: I had no idea police had a magazine.
If this cuts down on police abuse (and other wasteful crap), then I'd say the pluses outweigh the minuses.
If you weren't breaking the law, then that's not what I would call a good thing.
>If there's a cop watching, it doesn't really matter to me whether or not he's got a camera on his glasses; either way, I'm being watched.
Right, at least with the camera, there is less chance for the officer to make a mistake, or lie.
>If this cuts down on police abuse (and other wasteful crap), then I'd say the pluses outweigh the minuses.
I would agree. The point of my earlier comment was to imply that all policemen may not welcome the 'intrusion'.
Note that it is not a violation of anyone's privacy. Police interactions with the public cannot be private, with the only exception being undercover police work or other times when the identity of the other person must be protected as in the case of a minor. These cameras can and will prevent petty (and egregious) abuses of power that American police have grown used to getting away with. Right now there are insufficient safeguards against police misconduct, and ubiquitious cameras would be a good step toward making those safeguards sufficient.