Re:In California, a Champion for Police Cameras
by gamblor956 on Thursday August 22, 2013 @03:39PM
(#6259547)
The difference is that if there was supposed to be a video, and the video went missing while in the sole custody of the police, it is a reasonable inference that the video went missing because it supports the defendant's version of events rather than the police version.
Indeed--this is a standard evidentiary rule (and jury instruction) in almost every U.S. jurisdiction. In a criminal case, it would be enough to throw out the case, with prejudice. In a civil case, the judge would even be within his authority to issue a finding of fact against the party that "lost" the video.
Indeed--this is a standard evidentiary rule (and jury instruction) in almost every U.S. jurisdiction. In a criminal case, it would be enough to throw out the case, with prejudice. In a civil case, the judge would even be within his authority to issue a finding of fact against the party that "lost" the video.