The anti-virus comparison is a misnomer as it stands to reason that such systems would be more akin to intrusion detection systems (IDSs) or intrusion prevention systems (IPSs) that are actively monitoring and isolating certain system resources and services.
If you remove a person's ability to access information, that's the same as censorship.
[1] http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/crime/8705281/Scotlan...
Replacing that content with propaganda would be even more complex(and potentially vulnerable to discovery).
Instead of actively censoring or manipulating information, I imagine they could certainly just make it go away.
Let's say you an I are emailing or texting back and forward about a particular leak or topic, surely the NSA could make some of those emails/texts never be delivered, thus severing our line of communication. If they were picky about this, I would just think you never replied, not that someone was manipulating our communication channel.
It's imaginable that we will live in a future with good encryption and privacy controls.
I'm a little scared that if things are allowed to continue, the NSA will get such deep level access to the web, that they will be able to censor information anywhere, in real time. They already say they want to be the "anti-virus of the Internet" or something along those lines. If they will ever be able to do what they claim now, then they'll probably be able to censor information, too.
I don't know if they actually have that capability or not, but at least that's what they say when they lobby the government for new laws and bigger budgets.
So think about what happened in DoD, where they said employees can't read TheGuardian because their computers don't have the clearance level required to learn about those things. Now extend that to the world (given that they have the capability).
How hard would it be for them to say "sorry, world Internet users - you don't have the required clearance level to view those leaked documents", and censor the information for everyone. What happened with the Snowden leaks now, simply won't be possible anymore in the future, if their power over the Internet becomes that great.