Regardless of how safe it is, the problem is still social engineering hacks, key loggers etc (you'll always have this issue) - just wondering to what lengths a government will go...
I think it's a worthwhile project, but beyond the tech community, I'm not entirely sure how much traction usage will get... Thunderbird/Enigmail is a PITA to setup and use for sure. A step in the right direction, but all m00t unless everyone is using encryption and it becomes the defacto when communication via email.
I think that what you are missing is that the server stores encrypted keys, rather than no key.
Your secret sauce, if I understand it correctly, is open sourcing the client side code and providing some mechanisms to assure end users that what they are executing matches the publically published code.
That makes sense to me, but I don't see why you wouldn't go one step further and store the secret key in the browser plug-in. Is it an multiple-installation issue?
Yes, the js client is fully intended to work exactly this way.
> That makes sense to me, but I don't see why you wouldn't go one step further and store the secret key in the browser plug-in. Is it an multiple-installation issue?
There are a few issues here.
1. The first is the general crypto principle: minimize your TCB. I want the key to have to touch as few places as possible. For this reason, I have plans on moving the keys from the server to a clients machine(s). Doing so, however, involves a lot more problems including: NAT and the lack of a fallback. In the future, when I have more time to work on these details, I want to try and make that an option for people.
2. Another problem with placing the key in the browser is as you say: it allows anyone who is able to access the browser to access your key (including malware and other users).
3. Lastly, where would this key come from (remember rule #1: the server never has access to an unencrypted key)? If it is generated on the local machine that would then mean that you have no way of distributing it to your other machines (or at least not in ways that your grandmother will be able to do). Even if there were some super snazzy interface, it would be prone to attack as well.
At the end of the day this is how filesharing evolved... from FTP to Napster to Kazaa to Torrents to Magnet links. They slowly solved each of the attacks out there.
Seems a shame to depend on a browser extension—you lose most of the advantages of webmail when you can't log into it from anywhere.
A browser extension could in theory be used to verify the code against a signature or something to that effect, or it could sandbox the crypto routines and keys from the app itself (though that wouldn't prevent the app from stealing the decrypted data)
And it'll "just work", so ordinary people have a chance to use and trust it too.
And as I mentioned, merely having the crypto parts and key management built into the browser isn't good enough because a malicious site could still trick you into decrypting data which it could then steal, even if the keys themselves are perfectly safe.
As you hint at in the other comment, there are various ways that third-parties could vouch for the code running on the decryption domain.
Solving that problem would go a long way in making secure communication more accessible, but it's a hard problem.
> All innovation in the secure email space has been blocked for the past 13 years by one primary problem: webmail.
We are working on solving this very problem. We do this via js crypto. The main problem with js crypto is modification of the crypto with the transfer. We aim to solve this via having a browser extension be the default js store (so that all the crypto is verifiable by outside sources).
> That way if the anyone compels my VPS provider for access, they just get a bunch of encrypted email.
This is also true of any service which provides end-to-end encryption (With the exception of the plaintext headers).
> So my problem isn't receiving or encrypting email, it's reading it.
We use SMIME for encryption which is supported by a variety of clients: Outlook, iMail, and our own client. For internet mail, as I said, we are working on browser extensions for gMail.
The main problem that this does not solve is the routing and timestamp metadata problem as that is still necessary for the transfer of the email.