News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by cjensen on Monday August 19, 2013 @06:16PM (#6240270)
His boss fired him and told him why?

Never do that. When firing someone in an at-will state, just do it and explain nothing. Explanations can easily lead to lawsuits. It's just not worth the risk.

Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by md224 on Monday August 19, 2013 @06:33PM (#6240349)
Unrelated to the validity of this advice: it's kind of sad that our society has evolved legal structures that make it prohibitively risky to tell another human being why you're taking an action against them.

Hmm... what if you could have an employee sign a release as a precondition of being told why they were fired?

Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by redthrowaway on Monday August 19, 2013 @06:54PM (#6240447)
It is a sad statement, made all the more so when you have an experience that bucks the trend.

A year or so ago, I was applying for an internship at a small, local web dev shop that had some pretty cool projects in their portfolio. As the second interview was wrapping up, I had the impression that I wouldn't get the job. My default reaction would have been to simply ride out the rest of the interview, grab a coffee then move on, but for some reason I decided to ask them what their thoughts about me and my suitability for the position were.

And they told me.

They said that they would be completely candid, and asked if I wanted to proceed. I said of course. They then laid out all the areas that I had impressed them, as well as those that were red flags to them. Some of those were technical, and some were more about their general impression of me and my passion for the work.

Ultimately, I didn't get the job. I did, however, get to spend 20 minutes digging into depth on what potential employers viewed as my weaknesses and how I could go about addressing them, and that was perhaps even more valuable. They certainly weren't obliged to offer that advice, and I can't imagine they got much from it. Were we not all straight, white men in our mid 20s, I imagine they could have opened themselves up to a discrimination lawsuit. But, at the end of the day, they went out of their way to help me out and the advice stuck. I'll forever be grateful for that.

Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by shubb on Monday August 19, 2013 @06:49PM (#6240422)
I got a CV through the other day from a stranger.

The guy had some great experience but the CV was weird.

It was 10 pages long for 4 jobs. He listed every course he'd ever been sent on, including health and safety and diversity training ones, and just mixed his degree in somewhere with them. He listed each version of word he'd used (seemly every version released) with equal prominence as Java and SQL. Each time he'd been hired as a temp contractor he wrote his job title as CEO, because he was getting paid via his company.

My boss laughed at it and told me to bin it.

He needed to know what was wrong, or he'd stay unemployed (which was a shame for a guy with some great skills). I agonized for about a day and finally sent him some tips from my personal email, but I'm sure we could get sued if the strangeness was due to a disability. Something wrong there.

Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by nknighthb on Monday August 19, 2013 @09:03PM (#6240986)
You can't be liable for a disability you don't know about, and I wouldn't assume he has one.

At some point, probably around the time he was graduating from high school or college, somebody helped him put together his first resumé, and since it was naturally thin, they probably encouraged him to put in everything that might catch an employer's eye. He's probably never read anyone else's resumé.

I've seen this several times, and I've seen the opposite extreme, too. Somebody gets told early on "fit it on one page", and thinks that's how all resumés should be, forever. None of these people have any disabilities I'm conscious of, though in tech, a mild ASD would hardly be shocking. They've just been given advice that's either wrong or incomplete.

Meanwhile, I know one guy very well who does have a disability, and whose resumés have frequently been complimented. You'd have no way of knowing from them that he's in possession of a document from a psychologist that says PDD-NOS on it, and unless you know exactly what you're looking for, you're not going to notice when you meet him, either.

Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by 7Figures2Commas on Monday August 19, 2013 @09:54PM (#6241207)
> You can't be liable for a disability you don't know about, and I wouldn't assume he has one.

When it comes to employment matters, you can be sued by just about anyone for just about anything.

Opposing counsel can and will spin every fact that seems meaningless or innocuous. For example, the poster here indicates that he responded to the applicant through a personal email. This is not normal behavior, so you can bet a plaintiff's attorney would focus in on that and try to use it to suggest that the poster didn't response through his work email because he knew something wrong was being done.

Talk to any defense-side employment attorney and they'll all tell you the same thing: flimsy, baseless lawsuits are filed against employers every single day. But responding to a flimsy, baseless lawsuit costs money, and many of these lawsuits are settled because it's more cost-effective and expedient to pay to make the case go away.

Bottom line: taking action based on an unrealistic "you can't be liable..." attitude is extremely dangerous.

Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by bobbles on Monday August 19, 2013 @09:51PM (#6241193)
IMO CVs should be 3 pages.

1) Cover letter. Explain why you want the job and why you're a good person for that job.

2) Contact Details & Education. Most relevant and recent should be top of the list.

3) Previous Work experience. List only relevant skills from each position.

Less is more. If they want more detail they will ask for it in the interview.

Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by nilkn on Monday August 19, 2013 @11:59PM (#6241639)
How does (2) fill an entire page outside of someone applying for an academic post who has to list all the conferences they've been to, etc.?
Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by bobbles on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @02:37AM (#6242145)
All mine has is name / address, etc followed by course studied and the relevant topics studied during that course.

It's not a 300 word page filled with text.

Leaving space is also a good way for people to take notes on the CV (I've found that during my interviews the interviewer often used the CV like a checklist for asking their questions on my experience)

Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by 7Figures2Commas on Monday August 19, 2013 @08:13PM (#6240776)
I'm curious about your comment "but I'm sure we could get sued if the strangeness was due to a disability." If the possibility that the candidate's "strangeness" was due to some sort of disability crossed your mind, how did you justify putting your employer at risk of a lawsuit by communicating with the candidate, particularly when your superior had directed you to ignore his submission?
Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by Retric on Monday August 19, 2013 @08:32PM (#6240856)
Doing the right thing is worth taking a little risk. As a side note, some people send out a crap resume while on unemployment so they don't get interviews. In theory you need to look for work, but if you have a fair amount of savings and want to spend the summer surfing then it's a 'safe' way around the rules.
Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by 7Figures2Commas on Monday August 19, 2013 @09:43PM (#6241163)
> Doing the right thing is worth taking a little risk.

I won't disagree outright with that, but what is "the right thing" here?

The threat of litigation is incredibly real when it comes to employment issues. Even the most proactive employers (those that attempt to follow the law and keep meticulous records) face lawsuits from employees, former employees and job applicants. The potential damages can be significant (particularly for certain causes of action) and even small and seemingly baseless claims can easily result in five figures worth of attorney's fees (or more).

Here, despite apparently having some idea that his actions could expose his employer to a lawsuit, an employee decided that his employer should take on legal risk despite the fact that his supervisor effectively told him to proceed in a manner that would reduce risk substantially.

If as a result of this employee's actions, the company was unable to pay someone's salary, or had to allocate money from expansion to legal expenses, would you still suggest that the employee did "the right thing"?

Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by tomrod on Monday August 19, 2013 @11:29PM (#6241525)
Yes. Ethics are often at odds with legality.
Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by 7Figures2Commas on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @01:08PM (#6245025)
So it's ethical to disobey instructions from your superior and take an action that could negatively affect your employer and the other people it employs? That's not "ethics". That's an unwillingness to make a difficult decision (leave your job if you truly believe that you have been asked to take an unethical action).
Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by Spooky23 on Monday August 19, 2013 @10:18PM (#6241293)
Well, we have laws in place to protect people against discrimination. Unfortunately, when people's backs are to the wall and they lose their jobs, some like to make up all sorts of things to make a few bucks.
Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by lostlogin on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @03:18AM (#6242255)
Not all societies do this. New Zealand seems to be headed to a blame based system, but our healthcare system, while far from perfect has a fairly good part called the accident compensation corporation. It's no fault, pays out for accidents, prevents lawsuits and helps get to the bottom of issues constructively, without a defensive mask. It has had rough times of late unfortunately.
Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by cheald on Monday August 19, 2013 @06:44PM (#6240396)
Then you'd have them sign it before you fire them for a bullshit, actually-worthy-of-a-lawsuit reason.
Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by Thrymr on Monday August 19, 2013 @06:51PM (#6240433)
In which case, the waiver may be invalid anyway, since there are rights that you cannot legally waive.
Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by jacques_chester on Monday August 19, 2013 @08:07PM (#6240755)
A lot of waivers and disclaimers have no legal effect, but they deter people who don't know that.

Bluffing is part of legal risk management.

Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by liquidise on Monday August 19, 2013 @06:35PM (#6240358)
At the fear of being labeled immature/unprofessional: i have found that in many cases i morally owe my employees reasons for their being let go. I have never had to release an engineer on behavioral issues, so i always try to be clear with them about paths to improvement.

i'm certain this varies across companies, but in the startups i have worked for i've build very close relationships to many of my coworkers. i like to think there is a mutual trust established in that relationship. Part of that trust includes me looking out for their best interests, which i feel includes explaining to them what their next steps are to further their careers after they depart.

Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by robomartin on Monday August 19, 2013 @07:26PM (#6240589)
The vast majority of the people I've had to fire have been salesmen who simply did not perform. At first I thought we should have a solid agreement with the sales person; one that laid down the expected metrics for the first 90 days and thereafter.

My attorney insisted I understand that when you fire anyone in California you must --you must-- say nothing pertaining to the reasons for the firing. I made the mistake of behaving like a human being once and it cost me thousands.

Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by jtheory on Monday August 19, 2013 @07:59PM (#6240723)
Can you share more details of the story? I've been assuming this rule exists mostly to avoid the danger that you might accidentally phrase the reason for termination such that it could be treated as discriminatory... but this really sounds like the problem is deeper than that.
Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by robomartin on Monday August 19, 2013 @08:40PM (#6240891)
Facts matter not when the Labor Department gets involved. I walked in with a legally-binding contract done by my attorney and singed by the guy I fired. He was required to sell a certain dollar amount in 90 days. He sold exactly zero. Zero. The Labor Department mediator made me pay him several thousand dollars in ADVANCE COMMISSION I withheld at the time of firing. In reality, per the agreement, he owed ME several thousand dollars or advance commission he, effectively, never earned because he sold nothing. It didn't matter.

This happened because I told him I was letting him go because he did not sell anything. He (and the Labor Department folks, I'm sure) came up with some bullshit reason why I should pay him money anyway.

Had I given no reason whatsoever it is likely that there would have been less grounds to even bring forward a case. I'm summarizing something that is a bit more complex than the above but the overall idea is very much there.

Regrettably what you have to do is smile every day, take notes, document everything and, if the decision to fire is made, simply fire people without any explanation whatsoever. It goes something like this: "I'm sorry. I have to let you go. Here's your check." And walk them out immediately.

Oh, yes, if you can you should really consider having a witness to the firing. I was laid off twice in my life and both times there were three people in the room. Years later I would understand the reasons behind something that seemed weird and almost demeaning to me at the time.

I don't like having these kinds of relationships with people I work with but the legal framework in our state pretty much dictates you act this way for simple self preservation.

Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by moocowduckquack on Monday August 19, 2013 @10:02PM (#6241237)
In reality, per the agreement, he owed ME several thousand dollars

How does an unsuccessful salesman owe you several thousand dollars? And you are saying you withheld money at the time of firing.

Sales is precarious, but sales without a base is nasty.

I also notice in your language terms like "he, effectively, never earned". Basically, it sounds like this guy worked for you, didn't do so successfully and then you were forced by a court to pay him for his time, rather than you getting into trouble for letting him go.

I was going to treat you to a tune on the worlds tiniest violin, but I told the mice about your plight and now they are refusing to play it for you.

Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by robomartin on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @12:04AM (#6241660)
> How does an unsuccessful salesman owe you several thousand dollars? And you are saying you withheld money at the time of firing.

There are many approaches to paying a sales person. I've probably tried them all. This particular variant was one where you pay a base salary, say, $30K/year and, on top of that, a advance on unearned commissions. So, every week the sales guy is getting a check with two components, one he earned and one he is presumed to earn in the future.

In most agreements the sales person is liable for any commission that was not earned at the time of separation. If I paid you $5,000 in advanced commissions and you only earned $2,500 at the time of separation you owe me $2,500. That's money I was loaning you every week on the assumption that you would sell and actually earn it in the future.

This is standard stuff, nothing revolutionary here. I have to say that as an engineer dealing with sales people was one of the most difficult and gut wrenching things I've ever had to do. It took me years to understand the, sorry, sub-species. I've seen it all.

Anyhow, the fellow in question had been advanced commissions for nearly 90 days before I let him go. Yes, I was a sap back then. I actually kept thinking that this guy would wake up after my frequent pep talks and start selling. I let him float by all the way to the 90 day mark. When I laid him off I gave him a check equivalent to four weeks of his base pay and withheld (did not pay him) the commission advance I had been paying him all along. Why? He was gone. Like I said, he actually owed me money. And, again, I was nice. I was only supposed to pay him two weeks at the point I let him go. It was near the holidays and I decided to give him another couple of weeks to be helpful. Big mistake. This was during my early days of dealing with such folks and, true to what I said above, I was a total sap. BTW, I've never had problems with engineers, web developers, marketing people, production folks, not even the shipping dudes (other than the occasional swiping of wrenches and minor tools from the shop). No, it was always the sales guys that kept me up at night until I learned.

Here in California the labor department is decidedly anti-business. It was almost a foregone conclusion that his complaint would be decided on his favor. I was too naive and inexperienced to understand the game being played.

Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by moocowduckquack on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @03:18AM (#6242256)
Ok, sorry, it read a lot worse the first time. The mice are considering it.
Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by tehwebguy on Monday August 19, 2013 @09:44PM (#6241172)
What is advance commission? Was he paid a base?
Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by robomartin on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @12:15AM (#6241721)
It's an amount of money paid above a base pay. This amount represents future commissions not yet earned by the sales person. This is done in order to provide a more stable paycheck during the initial "on-boarding" process as well as during lean times.

Frankly, I never understood why sales professionals don't just work for a good wage and that's it. The very engineers who build the products earn a decent wage, work long hours, are continuously studying and sharpening their skills and devoted years of schooling to even be able to get the job.

In my early exposure to sale folk I recoiled at the idea of paying someone commission because I felt that if one person got commissions then everyone involved in bringing the product to market was just as entitled to them. Of course, the problem is far more complicated than that and I quickly learned you simply could not hire a good sales person unless they saw some kind of pot of gold at the end of the rainbow. That's just the way that side of the universe has devolved and that's it.

One approach I have never tried is to have everyone on stock options. Pay the sales folks a good salary, not some crapy $30K/y base + commissions. The theory being that they are going to want to work just as hard to get the company to a level where their stock will make them a bundle of money. A lot of folks in sales are very mercenary in nature and end-up living from battle to battle, commission to commission. This sets-up a situation where it might actually be difficult to convince them to use a forward looking approach and forgo the usual deal in favor of stocks at some time in the future.

My experience got me to the point where I determined it was a far better idea to identify someone with no sales experience and bring him/her up into sales from within the company. No bad habits, better connection to the business, actually thankful for bringing them up to a level where they could earn real money and a whole host of other benefits. Once I tried that approach and had good results I never hired another sales person from the "real world" again.

Live and learn.

Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by cjensen on Monday August 19, 2013 @07:19PM (#6240560)
It's always great if you can tell the employee what they need to do to improve. Do that while they still have a job. Work with them on it more than once.

Just don't do that at firing time.

Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by HeyLaughingBoy on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @02:06PM (#6245437)
Exactly. I wonder if some of these places have performance reviews. The first time you find out you're doing a crappy job should never be on the day you're fired!
Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by j_baker on Monday August 19, 2013 @07:14PM (#6240541)
You're absolutely right. You should never tell someone you're firing why you're firing them. They should already know that before they've even walked in the room.
Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by Renaud on Monday August 19, 2013 @09:02PM (#6240977)
I find it frightening that people's livelihood is subjected to the whims of their boss to such extent.

If anything, a justifiable reason as to why you are fired should be mandatory. You don't have to be a 'protected' minority to deserve a fair justification for being fired.

I'm all for the right of employers to fire who they want, but we can't expect employees to be responsible for how their actions impact the company and not expect the same in return.

He's lucky to have been a self-reliant young entrepreneur with probably other ways to make a livelihood. It could have turned very ugly had he been a father caring for a sick child without other resource than his job, all that because some nitwit didn't like his hairdo.

Duties and rights, not just one or the other.

Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by ams6110 on Monday August 19, 2013 @10:45PM (#6241379)
Should it work both ways then? Should you have to give a justifiable reason to your employer before being permitted to quit your job?
Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by coldtea on Monday August 19, 2013 @08:06PM (#6240749)
>Never do that. When firing someone in an at-will state, just do it and explain nothing.

That's what you got from this article? Yay for hypocrisy!

Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by AliEzer on Monday August 19, 2013 @06:48PM (#6240420)
So in the US you don't have to give explanations? Damn that sucks for the ex-employee. In France you have to write a report in order to fire someone unless they're in their trial period.
Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by cjensen on Monday August 19, 2013 @07:16PM (#6240552)
Which is why people HATE to hire in France: it's so hard to undo a bad hiring decision that no one will take a chance on a candidate who only "might" work out.

The right solution, in my opinion, is allow fire-at-will like we do in California, and have thorough unemployment benefits so that it's not worth making a fuss over.

Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by frenchman_in_ny on Monday August 19, 2013 @10:01PM (#6241234)
Well, that and the fact that an employer in France pays something of the order of 42% of the employees salary [1] to the government for taxes.

The Zappos model [2] of $2,000 bonus for quitting one week in is great, I wish more places would use it.

[1] http://hrmagazine.be/fr/newsitem/la-france-au-top-des-cotisa...

[2] http://www.businessweek.com/stories/2008-09-16/why-zappos-of...

Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by perlgeek on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @12:32AM (#6241791)
But that's what the trial period for, isn't it? If you can't figure out in 6 months (typical trial period in Germany) if he's a good fit, you have a problem anyway.
Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by jonstewart on Monday August 19, 2013 @09:22PM (#6241073)
It differs by state in the U.S. (business law being left to the states, by and large). California is an "at-will" state, where you can be terminated by a firm with no notice, for no reason. However, California also has strong unemployment insurance regulations, a healthy litigation industry, and corporate laws that tend to shift more liability to employers than employees. I was able to tell an employee I fired that his performance was not up-to-par, but I had pretty substantial written documentation prepared in advance. It is certainly the case in California that you don't give recommendations to ex-employees nor provide unsuccessful job candidates with detailed feedback.

Some other states are more employer friendly, and others are less.

Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by wdr1 on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @02:17AM (#6242106)
> Never do that. When firing someone in an at-will state, just do it and explain nothing. Explanations can easily lead to lawsuits. It's just not worth the risk.

Explain nothing? It may not be worth the risk, but it's a pretty shitty thing to do to another human being.

Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by crygin on Monday August 19, 2013 @06:55PM (#6240452)
There's a terrible irony in this as the response to a post which explicitly states: "We all need jobs. We need to be employed. But at the cost of what? Our ethics? Our passions? Those that trust us?"
Re:Why I Was Fired From a Tech Startup and What My Boss Had ... by opminion on Monday August 19, 2013 @07:08PM (#6240511)
Conversely, all other conditions being equal, employees in an at-will state have more incentives to mislead their management.