Ask HN: New founder in need of advice
My cofounder seems to think VC are more concerned with appearance than performance... He thinks the most important thing in a VC's mind is that we have an office with a full team in it every day. I disagree.
He thinks that having our team all in the same city/state is necessary to be taken seriously by investors. I disagree.
I'm constantly getting yelled at any time there is a bug... In his mind if a VC sees a bug, we're finished. My opinion is that as long as we're forthcoming and open and honest about mistakes and communicate with our clients and investors, we'll be fine (to an extent).
He wants a 90/10 split because its his idea and he's put about $80k into the business so far... I think 65/35 is more fair because I've built the software from scratch, have put in about 500 hours so far (no pay), and will continue to work around the clock for free until we're profitable. 10% is pretty unfair right? In his defense, he has crazy connections in the VC industry, has sold a (domain) company before, and has pretty deep pockets. That's the only reason I'm comfortable with going less than 50/50. I'm a sr engineer making $150k/yr now and I've worked for several software startups. Also I'm functioning currently far beyond my CTO capacity -- managing contractors, handling finances, and more.
I also don't think we should raise money... He's got tons of money and we're already making money. Our burn rate right now is about $10k/month and most of that is going to our designer. At the rate we're at, we should be break even in then next 3 months. I don't see a need to pull in a few million dollars and give up 1/3 of the business.
But you're going to have to pick a side here. Either your cofounder knows what he's doing when it comes to investor relations (and showing off downtrodden employees shackled to their desks can count as that) and you need to trust him, or he doesn't and you shouldn't keep treating him like he does.
If it were me... stop what you're doing and sign some papers. Friendships tend to break when dealing with the potential for making a lot of money. Is your relationship worth a million dollars? Maybe. What about a $100 million dollars? You're friendship isn't going to hold up if what you are forecasting is true. (I'm sure Zuck has 'lost' a lot of friends)
Without much other information on your company, here are some considerations:
If you don't get your % split, would you still be as motivated? work as hard? be as involved? What about your partner? How will it affect your business?
Your partner has crazy connections - how has that helped your business? How will it help your business in the future? How come you haven't raised money yet? If you don't raise money, how else does a VC play in your business?
He's put in $80k, why don't you just give him $80k for 100% of the company?
What if you just up and left, would the company be able to continue without you? (aka are you reasonably replaceable?) What if you just took the code and left?
How will all of this play out with the rest of the team?
Just some food for thought. Good luck!
PS. Unless your designer is doing front-end dev, I feel like you are overpaying your designer.
EDIT: I also agree that you don't always need to raise money. If you guys have the means to continually fund yourselves (as you mention break-even in 3 months), it's really not necessary especially once you hit a substantial profit margin.
http://ycombinator.com/apply.HTML
> 3. We decide who to fund after each day of interviews. Yes decisions will include the amount we'll invest and the percent of the company we'd want for it. We usually invest $11,000 + $3000n, where n is the number of participating founders, up to 3 (i.e. 2 founders get $17,000, 3 or more get $20,000), in return for between 2% and 10% of the company. The average is 7%.
Another thing. You got no pay yet. Did he get payed during this time?
Also, YC invests at that rate for companies without even an idea. We have a product launched in beta making several hundred dollars a day (inflates on weekends), with about 82 signed up clients most of which are going to start becoming more active (spending more money) as soon as we launch our iPhone app. We should be fully launching in the next month, at which point we expect to start raking in way more money.
You're good friends - for now. That can change in an instant.
Code "ownership" doesn't matter if he can afford better lawyers than you.
If you're not compensated in writing in the LLC agreement (which you would've signed), and you haven't been compensated otherwise or signed away your rights, then you own the code you've written and can act accordingly when it comes to negotiations. That may not get you very far, but it does give you some leverage.