News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by jacquesm on Saturday August 10, 2013 @06:34AM (#6190626)
Obama has his own reality distortion field.

In time Snowden will enter the history books for what he did, Obama not so much. Maybe only to serve as a reminder that the Nobel peace prize lost its prestige.

Part of this is that Snowden did a service to everybody on the planet (including Obama) and Obama serves a limited set of interests.

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by corin_ on Saturday August 10, 2013 @07:14AM (#6190685)
Let's not exaggerate and say that Obama won't be entering the history books for what he's done. Love him or hate him, he's a US president, he's in the history books even if he never gets out of bed for his entire term.
Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by TsiCClawOfLight on Saturday August 10, 2013 @07:19AM (#6190702)
in the US history books.
Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by scotth on Saturday August 10, 2013 @07:59AM (#6190769)
Why wouldn't he be in all in them? Is there a size limit?
Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by jacquesm on Saturday August 10, 2013 @08:05AM (#6190784)
History books tend to remember things of note. Obama is more of a footnote.

Honestly, not a single thing of world class importance stands out. Capturing Bin Laden, maybe.

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by SkyMarshal on Saturday August 10, 2013 @09:32AM (#6191028)
>Honestly, not a single thing of world class importance stands out.

First non-white male US president in history? Interesting how quickly such a thing becomes non-notable.

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by jacquesm on Saturday August 10, 2013 @10:13AM (#6191128)
That was about what he did during his presidency, not about achieving the presidency in the first place.

If becoming president is your main achievement including two terms as president then that's sad, not good.

Even Reagan will be remembered because he's seen as a factor (not all good, but ok we'll give him a pass) in the collapse of the former Soviet Union. And Reagan was embarrassing in many other respects.

Obama will be remembered as the guy that could have changed so much but didn't. Part of that is his own fault, he was harping so much on hope and change that some of us (including me) actually believed he meant what he said.

Consider me disappointed.

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by pstuart on Saturday August 10, 2013 @12:24PM (#6191592)
I'm extremely disappointed in him as well (without buying into the hope hype). We do have to take into consideration that the opposing party has declared that their number one priority was to limit him to a single term and had been entirely obstructionist.

Also, as President he is in theory limited in what he can actually do. Case in point: he promised to close Gitmo but is unable to do so because it requires Congress to make it happen and they are not cooperating.

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by angersock on Saturday August 10, 2013 @10:36AM (#6191206)
I really hope that one day we will have progressed far enough that the skin color or ethnic heritage of our presidents is ignored by the history books--ideally diminishing to a factoid on the same class with "so and so hated broccoli".
Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by corin_ on Sunday August 11, 2013 @06:21AM (#6194602)
I also hope (and think) that we will get to that point, but that doesn't mean the history leading there won't be important, and things like Obama becoming the first non-white president will likely be remembered as key things which helped get there, next to people like Rosa Parks.
Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by jasonkolb on Saturday August 10, 2013 @10:16AM (#6191138)
Who was the first US president to speak out against slavery? (Hint: it wasn't Abe Lincoln.) I think this factoid will ultimately matter about as much to the average American after we've had 5 more black presidents.
Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by ccernaf on Saturday August 10, 2013 @01:13PM (#6191820)
Who was the first Catholic president? Sure JFK did several other important things, and there were other events that transpired that made him famous.

Still, I think it's pretty important that Obama was at least partly black - it showed that it could be done, and I'm sure he inspired millions of people (black and otherwise).

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by uptown on Saturday August 10, 2013 @10:41AM (#6191217)
"History books tend to remember things of note. Obama is more of a footnote."

You can't be serious.

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by jacquesm on Saturday August 10, 2013 @10:54AM (#6191257)
Why not?

Give me some examples of stuff that you believe Obama will be remembered for that he did during his time as the most powerful man in the world in 100 years or more from now.

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by mpyne on Saturday August 10, 2013 @11:21AM (#6191360)
Won election as President with no substantial prior notoriety, overcoming a strong Democratic candidate in Ms. Clinton, a popular "maverick" Republican candidate, and did it all while being black and wearing "Hussein" as a middle name.

Further strategic arms limitations treaties negotiated with Russia.

Osama bin Laden.

Withdrew from Iraq as promised and on schedule.

Set a timetable for withdrawal from Afghanistan and, so far, every indication of sticking to that.

Shifted American strategic policy away from Cold War Europe plans over to the Asia-Pacific.

"ObamaCare", which if you think is not notable, can only mean you're not paying attention... Hillary herself had tried to push for health care reform in 1994 and been utterly and completely stonewalled.

Managed to get re-elected as a black president, in a fairly decisive victory against a very capable Republican opponent (for everyone who was afraid of Romney's Mormonism there were 3 who were happy the GOP had finally fielded a not-crazy candidate).

But either way, 100 years is a fairly long period of time, especially in the Age of the Internet. Ask your average person the difference between the accomplishments of McKinley, Harding, or Taft and they'll just stare at you and drool. If you're lucky they'll have at least heard of Woodrow Wilson and Teddy Roosevelt.

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by kalms on Saturday August 10, 2013 @02:24PM (#6192079)
I think he meant for the rest of the world. We only remember US presidents if they were killed or notoriously bad at their jobs - maybe except for F.D Roosevelt. (A bit tongue in cheek, but it also has some truth to it).
Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by saraid216 on Saturday August 10, 2013 @12:56PM (#6191738)
> Hillary herself had tried to push for health care reform in 1994 and been utterly and completely stonewalled.

Health care reform has been a struggle since a lot earlier than 1994. This subpoint actually understates the significance of Obama's achievement.

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by uptown on Saturday August 10, 2013 @11:14AM (#6191325)
1. First non-white President of the United States

2. Authorized mission that killed Bin Laden

3. Passed health care reform

4. Committed Federal money to US auto industry at a time when nobody else would do so

5. Repealed 'Don't ask don't tell' and held office during major national shift in acceptance of gays and lesbians.

6. NSA

That's six things that I believe will be historically notable for Obama's Presidency.

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by jacquesm on Saturday August 10, 2013 @12:27PM (#6191609)
1. that was before he became president

2. Quite a nice example of the kind of justice the USA likes to export

3. Extremely limited reform, check on France, the UK and Canada for other options

4. Too big to fail, who else would have done so?

5. Gays & Lesbians, Transgenders and Transsexuals have a long long way to go in the US before parity is achieved. The fact that there was a don't ask don't tell policy in the first place was bad, repealing it is not a victory of any kind.

6. NSA -> that's Snowdens ball, Obama is mostly doing damage control. It's how this whole thread got started in the first place, by Obama claiming that this debate would have happened without Snowden.

History books tend to take the long view, 100 years from now the 'first non-white President of the United States' (which is something he achieved before becoming president) is the one thing that I think may just make it.

But given the opposition (Palin as VP was unthinkable to me, when they chose her as McCain's running mate they handed the presidency to Obama, and it is surprising how close it still was) it wasn't all that impressive to me.

Still, I'll concede that that is what makes his presidency noteworthy. If he'd only done something a bit more useful with the power that he wielded it would have been more impressive. Change we can believe in...

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by res0nat0r on Saturday August 10, 2013 @04:11PM (#6192480)
1. True. Born black. Became first black president. Still relevant.

2. True. I'd fathom most of the US population and probably many around the world agreed with us taking him out though.

3. 180 degree healthcare changes can't happen over night. Obamacare is still relevant.

4. Not the Republicans

5. Of course repealing it is a victory.

6. The NSA issue is only being carried here and there on NBC news because of Snowden. Honestly the media and public attention will die out soon when the next major news cycle happens. This was known and talked about back in 2006 in published books, no one cared to pay attention though. This will become the reality again soon and the NSA will get back to doing exactly what it does now.

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by venomsnake on Saturday August 10, 2013 @09:01AM (#6190946)
Well bin Laden is not a big deal. Nice publicity stunt, surely and nice display of power.

I think the main achievement is keeping the economy afloat during 2009 ...

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by ippisl on Saturday August 10, 2013 @08:36AM (#6190876)
And possibly that healthcare thing, depending on how it will turn out ?
Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by smithian on Saturday August 10, 2013 @08:59AM (#6190940)
And then there was the saving of the US auto industry - but, you know, nothing of note.
Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by mhb on Saturday August 10, 2013 @11:37AM (#6191407)
Tesla success shows what a bad investment the GM/Chrysler bailout was:

http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/philg/2013/07/28/tesla-success-...

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by uptown on Saturday August 10, 2013 @12:26PM (#6191604)
I'm a huge fan of Tesla, but GM/Chrysler wasn't just about the vehicles. It was about the employees, the economies in that part of the country, and the ripple effect that killing off American auto-makers would have had to every industry they touched.

I truly hope what Tesla is doing becomes the future of the American auto-industry, but the nation was in no position, at that time, to facilitate that transformation in a way that was logistically, economically, or politically acceptable.

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by ajuc on Saturday August 10, 2013 @08:53AM (#6190917)
What do you know about social policies of the biggest empires from a few centuries ago?

Such stuff is lost in noise after a few centuries, only people from the country where it happened learn about it, often not even that.

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by saraid216 on Saturday August 10, 2013 @01:02PM (#6191767)
I have a history book detailing the minutiae of the Gettysburg battle, and I keep meaning to read Robert Caro's books. Did you know that historians are different people and write different books on different topics that are of interest to them? Shocking, but true! In fact, one of the many reasons they do this is because they want to provide interesting information about people in the past to the people in the present!

> Capturing Bin Laden, maybe.

I like how you can't even get the facts straight here. Bin Laden's dead, dude.

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by res0nat0r on Saturday August 10, 2013 @11:52AM (#6191475)
This comment solidifies why HN is out of touch with reality. There is more to the Obama presidency than his (up until now lack of involvement with the NSA). Try and think outside the tech bubble for a few minutes on this issue and you will become enlightened.
Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by zorked on Saturday August 10, 2013 @08:18AM (#6190833)
There is a limit, actually. From my non-American point of view, people who want to understand the context and direction of the US in the early 21st century will study Bush as he is the US president that defined this era.
Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by paganel on Saturday August 10, 2013 @08:58AM (#6190936)
Exactly, it's like mentioning Gerald Ford of Jimmy Carter outside of the States. Of course that people have heard their names and sort of know who they are, but not as much as they know about Nixon or Reagan.
Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by flexie on Saturday August 10, 2013 @09:31AM (#6191023)
I think he will be mentioned on the same page as Warren Harding.

And also again in the chapter about notable African Americans. Let's not forget that getting elected president as the first African American is an achievement in itself, and one which I believe benefits the African American community, even if Obama's performance as a president doesn't live up to our initial hopes.

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by andy_ppp on Saturday August 10, 2013 @09:40AM (#6191040)
Yeah but he hasn't done fuck all for all those people who are persecuted because they are black in America. Look at the prison system and the way drug cases are prosecuted. In fact just watch this TED talk - this black president is for the 65 year old white corporate executive more than anyone:

http://www.ted.com/talks/bryan_stevenson_we_need_to_talk_abo...

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by toyg on Saturday August 10, 2013 @10:06AM (#6191110)
One would argue it was the only way a black person could be elected US President: by being whiter inside than white old men. Someone threatening like Jesse Jackson never stood a real chance; in fact, giving the electoral system, no real reformer will ever have a chance: old white people from rural states are overwhelmingly over-represented, the game is rigged in their favour.

It's like the football/soccer rule-changing committee being structured in a way that nobody can change anything if British federations don't agree.

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by pessimizer on Saturday August 10, 2013 @12:57PM (#6191742)
>being whiter inside than white old men

>Someone threatening like Jesse Jackson

Be careful of this kind of talk. I understand and probably agree with what you probably mean to say, but reifying whiteness as some sort of meaningful quality of the soul, and by contrast characterizing blackness as "threatening" is not a good way to think about it.

You're using "white" and "black" here as stand-ins for something else. It's easier for everyone if you just refer to the actual qualities that you intend to refer to, rather than implying that there's a proper ways for people to behave or be that are appropriate or inappropriate in relation to their skin colors.

sorry:)

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by toyg on Monday August 12, 2013 @06:04AM (#6198466)
sorry, I apologise if I wasn't clear. By "whiter inside" I meant "unquestioningly faithful to institutions and systems that purposely (an occasionally violently) discriminate not-whites, not-rich and not-Americans". Which I think fits the current US President quite well at the moment, regardless of his skin.
Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by nsxwolf on Saturday August 10, 2013 @10:48AM (#6191239)
"I have a dream that my four little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character." -- Guess Who
Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by mgkimsal on Saturday August 10, 2013 @12:31PM (#6191632)
Was that from "American Woman" or "These Eyes"?
Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by carlyle4545 on Saturday August 10, 2013 @01:44PM (#6191939)
>One would argue that was the only way a black person could be elected US President:by being whiter inside than old white men.<

Can you explain how exactly one acts "white"? Are you suggesting being educated and well-spoken are inherently white characteristics?

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by toyg on Monday August 12, 2013 @05:59AM (#6198461)
No, "acting white" is about unquestioningly serving a system that purposely discriminates non-whites.

I believe this sort of language had been debated to death, btw.

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by flexie on Saturday August 10, 2013 @10:21AM (#6191159)
Thank you for the link. I am not African American (neither African nor American) but when I lived in America it always struck me how racially divided the country still is, even in New York, and how poor many African Americans are.
Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by jonknee on Saturday August 10, 2013 @04:29PM (#6192560)
What do you suggest he do? He cannot even close Gitmo, real reform of the prison system requires buy in from Congress. About the only thing they were able to squeak through was reducing the penalty gap in mandatory sentencing guidelines between crack and powder cocaine. Then the GOP took control of the House and any further legislation seen as being soft on [non white collar] crime have nearly a 0% chance of passing.
Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by tokipin on Saturday August 10, 2013 @10:50AM (#6191245)
Health reform alone will land him in a nice place in the history books. Even against the immutable recalcitrance of congressional republicans he has managed to accomplish a lot.

I think most people don't recognize how accomplished Obama is because 1) the rapid news cycle and 2) Obama himself doesn't run around telling everybody what he's done.

I don't like this NSA crap either, but overall Obama is an amazing president.

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by hga on Saturday August 10, 2013 @12:42PM (#6191670)
You certainly have a strong point, Democrats have been trying to accomplish this since Harry Truman right after WWII, and e.g. Hillary! infamously botched it.

On the other hand, that chicken is not yet hatched, e.g. while it's been airbrushed out of Wikipedia, look at the single thing Dan Rostenkowski is most remebered for: https://www.google.com/search?q=dan+rostenkowski+angry+senio...

And e.g. if Obama's "trillion dollar deficits as far as the eye can see" cause a fiscal collapse of the Federal government including Obamacare, Obamacare will be a footnote aside from explaining why he focused on it as opposed to the fiscal health of the government like Clinton did.

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by tokipin on Saturday August 10, 2013 @01:34PM (#6191912)
Yes there are still ways for the law to be hurt, beyond Republicans pointlessly voting to repeal it 40 times. Long story short however, the law will survive mostly in tact, which is definitely for the better in my opinion.

By the way, the federal deficit under Obama has gone down.

http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=US+deficit+last+ten+yea...

The "reckless spending" thing is just another example of the style of politics that republican politicians are good at. You'll notice, for example, that "spending" wasn't an issue until Obama was president. And if anything, there hasn't been enough spending for the sake of the economy.

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by hga on Saturday August 10, 2013 @02:08PM (#6192034)
Please don't move the goalposts. While they're of course inextricably linked, I'm talking about the issue of "reckless borrowing", i.e. that stuff we have to pay interest on.

And I don't care so much how they're trending down as how they're still above a trillion dollars. By the same token, should we give Bush and the Republican Congress credit for reducing deficits 2005-7? With 2007 still above 2002..?

As for spending, debt etc. being an issue, while it certainly matters what "Republican politicians" say and do, "conservatives" and libertarians have been raising as big a fuss about it as we can since the days of Nixon, and I gather longer (I became politically aware during his Administration so I can only vouch for it starting then).

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by speeder on Saturday August 10, 2013 @11:58AM (#6191509)
You mean amazingly.bad right?
Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by newnewnew on Saturday August 10, 2013 @12:25PM (#6191598)
Isn't that a bit patronizing? It doesn't matter if he sucks at his job, because being black and doing it is accomplishment enough? I know this is what some people actually believe, but it just sounds racist to me.
Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by Kylekramer on Saturday August 10, 2013 @12:52PM (#6191720)
If you put it in those terms, yes. But you are the one who put it in those terms. No one said a black president has lower standards for the job, they said it was notable that a person from a community who has been historically marginalized by American society reached the highest office in the country by winning a majority vote.
Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by flexie on Saturday August 10, 2013 @02:49PM (#6192199)
No, it's the opposite of racist. I am saying that it is such an acomplishment to be voted president of the US as an African American and that it will inspire other African Americans irrespective of how he actually performs.

On a side note: You should't accuse people of racism or other terrible character traits unless you are sure about it.

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by jivatmanx on Saturday August 10, 2013 @12:23PM (#6191583)
He's not really an African-American in the strongest sense of this term, he doesn't have black American ancestors who lived through slavery, or even the civil rights movement.
Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by res0nat0r on Saturday August 10, 2013 @11:35AM (#6191402)
HN has its own reality distortion field.

In time Obama will enter the history books for what he did, Snowden not so much. Maybe only to serve as a reminder that the Nobel peace prize lost its prestige.

Part of this is that Obama did a service to everybody on the planet (including Snowden) and Snowden serves a limited set or interests.

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by madaxe on Saturday August 10, 2013 @07:16AM (#6190691)
The victor writes the history books.

Snowden will be your Emmanuel Goldstein.

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by asgard1024 on Saturday August 10, 2013 @08:07AM (#6190792)
Victor who?

I have a book about Emmanuel Goldstein in my library. Funny thing, the dictator's name didn't make it to the book.

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by northwest on Saturday August 10, 2013 @07:24AM (#6190711)
> Obama has his own reality distortion field.

Another possibility would be: He has (or thinks he might have) a gun to his head and fears to meet a JFK-like fate (for himself or his family). In this case he should step down and denounce the degree of corruption of the system.

EDIT: ...because in case he's unable to have enough courage to correct the issues, stepping down and stating why would open up the possibility for the People to have a frank discussion about the system in place and to correct it for the next x decades to come. Because don't kid yourselves, the system itself is sick and it's not with cosmetics that it will be fixed and future corruption eliminated.

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by madaxe on Saturday August 10, 2013 @07:30AM (#6190722)
I think you give him too much credit.

If this were the case, he's the goddamned POTUS, and should grow a pair and accept the fate he signed himself up for.

With great power comes great responsibility.

Re:The president is wrong: The NSA debate wouldn’t have happ... by RBerenguel on Saturday August 10, 2013 @07:43AM (#6190740)
Being a non-native English speaker (although I instantly decompressed the acronym) the first thing to come to mind was this, for me: https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epipremnum_aureum