"Net taps without warrants"[1] was on the front page (already). Very interesting to look back and see the commentary and the way this was received 12 years ago(!) in light of all the NSA/Snowden stuff that's been going on lately.
Some highlights:
"Do we really have any reason to believe that the government is trying to create a giant evil spy machine to watch their own people as opposed to the terrorists? I tend to be more or less trusting of the government, but that's just me."
"This bill is quite limited in its scope, allowing only 48 hours to tap without approval and only for immediate threats to "National Security." Many civil liberties are restricted during threats to "National Security." Ever heard of martial law and curfews?"
"Anything that is truely our rights in a constitutional sense will be protected by the supreme court.
The congress will push, the courts will push back, and life wil lgo on as it has in the US.
I get the feeling a significant cross section of slashdot just likes to run around hystericly like the sky is falling."
"What's so hard about getting a warrant? [..] Or maybe you keep federal courthouses staffed with at least one judge with a security clearance 24x7, if its so important. "
[1] http://web.archive.org/web/20010914224344/http://slashdot.or...
http://slashdot.org/story/01/09/14/211241/net-taps-without-w...
Wow that's kind of creepy. Mainly because I responded to a comment worded exactly the same way on another site recently, in regards to the NSA story. Circulating a meme perhaps?
The concept of trusting your government implicitly just seems so wrong on the face of it, this comment boggles my mind every time I come across it!
http://slashdot.org/story/01/09/11/1314258/world-trade-tower...
The subject of one of the very top comments reminds me of why I've never cared for the Slashdot community: "We had it coming..."
Contrast with Metafilter which has fairly aggressive top-down moderation and, IMHO, still has a pretty strong community. I'm not a heavy user but it looks from the outside pretty similar to how it looked years ago.
Anyway, I think aggressive moderation is a big part of Metafilter's secret sauce.
It's definitely part of the secret sauce, but I wouldn't call the moderation aggressive - it'd call it targeted to preserve culture. If MetaFilter has a first defence then it is the 5$ account wall, the second is the (almost legendary) snark, the third is the moderation. Moderation is almost always employed as a last resort, and it's rationale is normally documented.
The "secret sauce" of MetaFilter is really the community and everything else works to preserve that. The moderators of MetaFilter are the last resort in that process, but their are neither "aggressive" nor numerous, they are just very well chosen - not by algorithms, but by other existing moderators who actually understand the organisation/community they work in.
(Out of curiosity, do you know if there's any way to see how many threads are closed by moderators? My recollection is that the rationale for closing a thread is included in its comments, but the thread disappears of the frontpage once its been axed so it's hard to know how common that it.)
Either way, I didn't mean it as a bad thing. Personally, I want a moderated experience... so long as I trust the moderator.
I'm pretty sure it's been discussed in MetaTalk too, so some creative searching of that sub-site might turn up the number.
I really, really like that idea. Not just EFF, because that would tend to create an echo chamber. Instead, you should be presented with a dropdown list of various unrelated but preapproved nonprofits. A $5 donation to any of them would earn you commenting privileges for a limited time.
Want to comment as an AC? Donate $5.00 for a one-time comment without logging in. Want to comment as a logged-in user? Donate $5.00 for a month.
Somebody should totally do something like this.
The [thing] is though, I don't really doubt the structure. A lot of "new" and few "front page," filtered algorithmically, seems like it can scale. Of course, for that the algorithm must be good, and for that, maybe HN needs an algorithm contest.
Should articles "pop" for both "velocity" (pace of up-votes, click-throughs, and comments) and "scoring" against a mission statement?
However, what led me to leave Slashdot wasn't any sort of Eternal September like effect. Yes, there were many troll comments there, but there's also lots of options to adjust moderation types to suit one's particular interests. Rather, what I found was that the editors themselves seemed to stop caring. Article summaries would be blatantly incorrect or have distorting editorializing in them. If the whole point of the Slashdot style of reporting was to present a small number of quality stories each day, how could I trust the site when what the editors presented was inaccurate?
When I came to HN I was surprised to discover that articles simply have a title and URL. Sometimes there's editorializing in the titles, but in general its pretty good. But I can understand what Malda is saying when he expresses his frustration in wading through the front pages of HN. I don't know if the solution is to implement topics of some sort or not, but the user volume on this site is picking up enough that I think some sort of organization beyond a single ranking algorithm is required. It might also lead some interesting stories that never make it onto the front page to reach an audience. This problem of course isn't unique to HN... whether its Slashdot or Twitter or Facebook, getting the signal to noise ratio to an appropriate level is a really hard problem.
That being said, in my short time here I have learned a tremendous amount -- albeit much of which lies in my bookmarks!