News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Obama administration vetos Apple iPhone 4, 3G iPad 2 prod... by jivatmanx on Saturday August 03, 2013 @03:06PM (#6152991)
Intervening in one case for an iconic American company is protectionism, not free trade. That would have entailed reforming the patent system for everyone.

This is ominous, what if this is remembered as the equivalent of Smoot-Hawley? Patents are a hell of a lot more complex than tariffs... and at least the ITC is trying to do international coordination here, and Obama has just blatantly undermined them.

Re:Obama administration vetos Apple iPhone 4, 3G iPad 2 prod... by comex on Saturday August 03, 2013 @03:36PM (#6153080)
Taking legal action against FRAND abuse is hardly unique to the US.

http://www.fosspatents.com/2012/12/european-commission-to-is...

See also Mueller on this veto; while I often disagree with him, I tend to agree on this issue:

http://www.fosspatents.com/2013/08/obama-administration-veto...

Re:Obama administration vetos Apple iPhone 4, 3G iPad 2 prod... by jivatmanx on Saturday August 03, 2013 @03:47PM (#6153119)
The problem I have with this argument, is, isn't the point of every technological advance to become widespread and Standards-Essential? If we're going to disallow them, why have patents at all? For "Look-And-Feel" patents?
Re:Obama administration vetos Apple iPhone 4, 3G iPad 2 prod... by comex on Saturday August 03, 2013 @05:23PM (#6153459)
Because even strong software patents often have alternatives, and weak ones are easy to find an alternative to, decreasing their value, but once a standard protocol requires their use, the patent holder can jack up the price. As an extreme example, consider the exFAT patents: there are many file systems superior to exFAT that have no need for whatever bits of functionality Microsoft patented, but because Windows speaks exFAT as one of few alternatives, some companies have licensed them. Not exactly a standard, but the same idea.
Re:Obama administration vetos Apple iPhone 4, 3G iPad 2 prod... by josteink on Sunday August 04, 2013 @05:22AM (#6155124)
Apple was offered the same terms as everyone else but they "decided"that this wasn't fair and demanded special treatment.

Apple is the one not following the FRAND spirit here.

Re:Obama administration vetos Apple iPhone 4, 3G iPad 2 prod... by corresation on Saturday August 03, 2013 @04:29PM (#6153271)
The ITC specifically considered FRAND, so interesting that you or the perpetually wrong troll Mueller decide that it is abuse.
Re:Obama administration vetos Apple iPhone 4, 3G iPad 2 prod... by throwawaykf on Sunday August 04, 2013 @12:50PM (#6156128)
Well, evidently the ITC "considered" FRAND inaccurately, as their decision conflicted with both, the Obama Administration and the European Commission. (Not to mention the opinions of jurists such as Judge Posner.) You could cry "protectionism" on this veto, but what excuse could you make for the EC's actions?
Re:Obama administration vetos Apple iPhone 4, 3G iPad 2 prod... by corresation on Sunday August 04, 2013 @06:30PM (#6157352)
Bizarre how you group in multiple completely different actions and pretend that they're one. And the Obama Administration didn't make a statement about FRAND or the correctness of the ITC's judgment -- they simply decided that they'd rather not have an American company's products blocked.
Re:Obama administration vetos Apple iPhone 4, 3G iPad 2 prod... by throwawaykf on Wednesday August 07, 2013 @07:47PM (#6176446)
Completely different actions with precisely the same underlyng issue: abuse of standards essential patents. Bizarre how you do not notice this.

And this is not a new issue, and not just restricted to the smartphone patent wars. The same criticisms were made and similar outrage was outpoured in the semiconductor industry when Rambus tried to pull similar shenanigans. [1]

1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rambus#Lawsuits

Re:Obama administration vetos Apple iPhone 4, 3G iPad 2 prod... by tnuc on Saturday August 03, 2013 @04:16PM (#6153214)
I can't begin to imagine what the ITC will do having been completely undermined by Obama. I wouldn't be surprised if Apple suffers from some international retaliation for this.

Obama doesn't fully understand how commerce works.

Re:Obama administration vetos Apple iPhone 4, 3G iPad 2 prod... by rhizome on Saturday August 03, 2013 @04:29PM (#6153270)
No, it's that many of us don't agree with how commerce and government actually work together.
Re:Obama administration vetos Apple iPhone 4, 3G iPad 2 prod... by sillysaurus on Saturday August 03, 2013 @05:34PM (#6153497)
Care to expand?
Re:Obama administration vetos Apple iPhone 4, 3G iPad 2 prod... by rhizome on Saturday August 03, 2013 @07:33PM (#6153827)
Sure: government will always be two-faced with respect to "free" markets, interfering where it suits their and/or their friends/benefactors' interests, or not, as the case may be. It has been this way for centuries, Adam Smith just added to the lexicon of rationales.
Re:Obama administration vetos Apple iPhone 4, 3G iPad 2 prod... by sillysaurus on Saturday August 03, 2013 @07:41PM (#6153847)
Well, in what way was Apple the government's friend or benefactor?
Re:Obama administration vetos Apple iPhone 4, 3G iPad 2 prod... by rhizome on Saturday August 03, 2013 @08:28PM (#6154001)
Honestly, is that a serious question? Do you have no concept of what I'm describing such that I'm required to list these things out?

Pretty much all Apple hardware is made in China, which makes the company an instrument of foreign policy. That's one aspect.

Re:Obama administration vetos Apple iPhone 4, 3G iPad 2 prod... by sillysaurus on Saturday August 03, 2013 @09:54PM (#6154241)
Dude, you're being more than a little bit of a dick. I'm ignorant of government policy and politics in general, and it's only recently that I've begun rectifying that.

Yes, it was a simple, straightforward query for information that I lack. And you hardly answered.

Re:Obama administration vetos Apple iPhone 4, 3G iPad 2 prod... by rhizome on Saturday August 03, 2013 @10:32PM (#6154344)
Re:Obama administration vetos Apple iPhone 4, 3G iPad 2 prod... by sillysaurus on Saturday August 03, 2013 @10:42PM (#6154365)
You know what. I'm outta here for awhile. It's people like you that make me depressed to read HN or try to be involved. The guidelines even say "if you wouldn't say it to their face, then don't say it." Yet you were such an asshole to me right there without even an apology. That would've been okay if I had received an actual answer to my question, but instead I got a context-free link to a Wikipedia article with no way to interpret the complexities of how it relates to the issue at hand. The result is an unhelpful, unhealthy, negative state of mind. And that would be okay if I actually learned something from the experience. But the only thing I've learned from this is that you personally attack and belittle anyone who doesn't know the same things you know.
Re:Obama administration vetos Apple iPhone 4, 3G iPad 2 prod... by rhizome on Monday August 05, 2013 @12:22PM (#6161042)
I'm pretty sure that's not the case, but I appreciate your perspective.
Re:Obama administration vetos Apple iPhone 4, 3G iPad 2 prod... by _delirium on Saturday August 03, 2013 @05:05PM (#6153400)
Congress seems to have explicitly preferred this approach, however. They could've set up a system with uniform rules and a mandatory process that the president can't overrule, as is commonly done with other areas like environmental rules. The president does have some power over the EPA, but can't arbitrarily instruct the EPA to drop rules simply because he disagrees with the outcome of the rulemaking process. But here Congress said that if the President disagrees with any ruling of the IPC "for policy reasons", he need merely notify the ITC and the ruling will be voided. That seems to indicate Congress wanted case-by-case review of ITC determinations for policy conformance. Why would they write that into the law? My guess is precisely to allow national economic interests to take priority over the rules on a case-by-case basis.
Re:Obama administration vetos Apple iPhone 4, 3G iPad 2 prod... by jivatmanx on Saturday August 03, 2013 @05:34PM (#6153499)
Congress, in most cases of late, prefers to give more arbitrary authority to the Executive branch rather than actually craft specific and meaningful rules.
Re:Obama administration vetos Apple iPhone 4, 3G iPad 2 prod... by BrandonMarc on Monday August 05, 2013 @03:35PM (#6162381)
Sounds like they built a recipe for patronage with this law. By creating a system such as what you describe, it's ripe for businesses to $$ convince $$ the right politicians that their success is in the best interest of the country.
Re:Obama administration vetos Apple iPhone 4, 3G iPad 2 prod... by melling on Saturday August 03, 2013 @03:34PM (#6153074)
I've gotta ask if you understand anything about the case, or are you just trying to speak generally.
Re:Obama administration vetos Apple iPhone 4, 3G iPad 2 prod... by jolohaga on Saturday August 03, 2013 @06:57PM (#6153744)
Regardless. Apple's genius isn't patentable anyway.