Also, everyone would be better off if these contingencies were all written into contract before marriage/child birth. It would save everyone a lot pain. Unfortunately, the judicial system has gradually replaced our great tradition of contract law with arbitrary rule by judges, much to the loss of everyone.
I think a lot of the problems with prenups is a chicken and egg sort of thing. If they were a standard part of the process they'd be less offensive.
Then there has to be full and/or fair disclosure (your spouse needs to know about that $50,000 you have put away). The other (possibly the easiest reason why prenups can fall apart) is that the agreement has to be entered upon voluntarily by both parties, so if your spouse only agreed to the pre-nup because you threatened a break up then the pre-nup is automatically void.
The sad thing is that if pre-nups were made into law then they would never be enforceable, because everyone would have been forced into them under duress. How can you voluntarily sign an agreement when it could prevent you from being legally married.
This is the heart of the matter. The courts have redefined the word "voluntary" in an unbelievably Orwellian way.
Younger, and let people just figure it out.
Many, almost all?, people go to work for a company thinking that they'll spend a specified amound of time with it. Very few people that I know think that they'll spend their entire life there.
In fact in the financial industry it's a very accepted practice to jump around from company to company.
Even in the tech industry there are many people who graduate with a plan to work for a Google or Microsoft for a few years to get experience and then plan to go out on their own or to join another startup.
Contrast this with marriage were very few people go in thinking that their marrige is only a 4 year commitment and that they'll get divorced and trade up every 5 years.
Marriage is very much a business relationship. I don't know when it turned awkward to acknowledge this fact.
I have no idea why it still exists, however.
I know an alarming number of counterexamples.
I think most states stop alimony when she remarries, though, which is why women who want to play that game will have live-in boyfriends but not remarry.
> I was handing over $4,000 a month in alimony and child-support payments
So no, he did mean alimony and child-support.
What I don't understand is how we almost never hear of such people packing up and moving to some country which is hostile to US interests, or simply has weak record-keeping and is thus friendly to those who want to leave their past behind. Are all such countries mournful hellholes to live in? Surely not.
Seriously, if I were ever sentenced to the perpetual confiscation of over half of my income, I would run off - doesn't matter much where to. Perhaps the Somalian pirates - or North Korea - are hiring? I also recall once reading that France will not extradite a French citizen - perhaps you can become one? (They might still allow American debt collectors to find you, however. Does anyone know?) Seriously, just about any life is better than being a part-time slave, which is what such extortion amounts to.
Also, the beginning and end.
B) When you get married you're making a very serious promise to share everything and build a life together. The state provided default contract for a marriage is very clear about the separation terms up front. If you don't like them, then negotiate a pre-nup with your spouse.
Good luck.
B) US courts routinely and capriciously invalidate pre-nups.
Yeah, let's bring back Victorian work-houses. I sincerely hope that you and your family end up in one.
There is very little functional difference between this guy and a bonded laborer from pre-independence India.
So quit with this slavery nonsense. Slavery is not slavery when opted for, in full knowledge. Likewise, honest mortgages are no more slavery than education loans.
Honest mortgages and education loans are not slavery. Intentionally ignoring checks to economically subjugate someone... I am not gonna call that slavery but it's really not that far from it or at least thats how I see it.
No, he's suggesting that consent makes a situation that looks like slavery not slavery at all.
Anyway, what has
> If they'd been left behind, stranded far away from the "land of opportunity," would they have been better off?
got to do with consent?
That apart, informed consent cannot nullify a crime. That is a well accepted principle. You cannot give informed consent for murder and such stuff. There is a libertarian school of thought that wants to change that but I don't subscribe to that school of thought. Slavery under consent is just as much a violation of human dignity and just as much a crime as far as my views are concerned.
That apart, informed consent cannot nullify a crime. That is a well accepted principle. You cannot give informed consent for murder and such stuff.
If there's consent, there's no crime, though. You can't give informed consent for murder because if you gave informed consent, it's not murder, but "assisted suicide" or some such. Current law has lots of victimless and presumed-victim crimes, it's true, but I don't subscribe to that school of thought. :)
Screw Libertarian "consent." Screw their "non-coercion." They are Orwellian concepts: their in-practice meanings in that ideology allow for the exact opposites of what those words mean in everyday language to slide through and flourish.
This is only partially true. Food (and, due to the existence of land ownership, shelter) is more scarce today (in the sense of requiring more effort to obtain) than in the age of hunter-gatherers.
Not to mention, the need for "shelter" in a heavily populated world implies as much the need for protection from other people as for protection from the elements. Thus, in a very real sense, it is a need imposed on me by other people. Even the need for protection from the elements falls into this category. If there were few enough people, everyone could (theoretically) live comfortably in those parts of the world which have a temperate climate year-round.
That sounds like it's slavery too.
One solution would be to put an end to usury. Houses, cars, etc. will have to become far more modest, but in the end they will be affordable without debt slavery.
People should have the choice to borrow money from other people, and the people lending it should be able to make enough money to make up for the risk of the people they lend it to not paying it back. I don't think society needs to change, though.
Spend tax dollars educating and discouraging the borrower. This is valid because such conditions hurt the nation in the long run.
Quite often false, in the ancient world. Debt slavery is probably as old as mankind.
But I don't understand why cjbos is getting downmodded for making a valid argument that $4k isn't that much money to raise a 4-person family.
IF the author points out that his ex-wife is now re-married, or is working and bringing home more than $4k blah blah blah, then yes, evil witch, bad system. But let's not jump to judgment here, guys, especially when the author himself hasn't vilify this woman.
He has almost 3 times the disposable income as his wife in reality.
... and whatever she earns.
Taking care of teenagers after school is not a full time job.
Health coverage should really be provided by the government, but that's a separate issue. Also, individual health insurance on teenage boys is going to be cheap: closer to $150 per month than $1000/month.
School is provided by the government, for 12 years. College, on the other hand, is ridiculously expensive, but if the government isn't forcing married couples to pay for it (I know some $100-300k couples who paid nothing) it doesn't have a leg to stand on in forcing divorced parents to pay for it.
Agree. I was really impressed that he managed not to express any bitterness towards his ex-wife in the article. That says a lot about his character.
Am I a horrible sexist if I disagree with this?
Child support should represent the minimum acceptable contribution of the non-custodial parent (father, in the vast majority of cases) to the child's welfare. Should he contribute a lot more, in cash, gifts, and college support? Absolutely. I would. However, the government shouldn't require him to do so, and the spending should be at his discretion. Right now, that freedom is completely taken away. The custodial parent should not be getting a huge check and the freedom to spend the money however she wants. If I end up having a kid with a wife who divorces me to live it up with an illiterate biker, those CS payments damn better be going to the kid's college, not her beau's lottery-ticket budget.
It's a bizarre inconsistency. Parents can stay married and financially neglect their children. They can make $300k combined per year and still refuse to pay for their kids' college. Yet, if they divorce, the one parent who rarely sees the kids (usually father) is forced not to pay up merely to the minimum level of decency, but far beyond that if he's "rich" like the article's author.
Note that if you have a child out of wedlock the same things do not apply. Moral hazard anyone?
Of course you pay child support if you fathered the kid, regardless if you married the mother or not. It's the whole point of Maury Povich "You Are Not The Father" episodes.
But not alimony?
That's way too sexist for me (if that's what marriage is, then we should change it,) but I'm still not convinced that a man should be allowed to leave and only provide half the minimum support for his children. It seems like the woman is seriously getting screwed in that situation: she has to raise the kids on her own AND find > 1/2 the money to support them. Nobody gets married with that understanding, and nobody wants to.
If she thinks he might be a shitty father who only contributes the minimum, then she shouldn't marry him or have kids with him.
The law frequently provides protection for people who enter certain contracts, even when they ought to know better. For instance, if I loan money to someone who then goes bankrupt, I am entitled to some of their property. Even if it was a really stupid loan.
In this particular case, women aren't particularly good at determining whether a potential husband will turn out to be a scumbag, so it makes some sense for society to protect them against that possibility. (Actually, men aren't very good at determining whether a potential wife will be a scumbag either, so society should probably protect them, too...)
I did not know that. Admittedly, I don't have any examples that work quite as well. Maybe medical malpractice... or is that just a breach of contract?
Assets earned during the marriage are earned by the couple and should be equitably split, but child support should be no more than 1/2 the minimum cost of raising a child (of course, if the father's not a prick, he'll contribute much more; but the govt. should not require him to) and alimony should not exist.