News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My Personal Credit Crisis by bokonist on Friday May 15, 2009 @03:22PM (#611166)
The injustice is when the court strips the father of custody and then forces him to pay child support. Child support should only be required if the father voluntarily renounces custody. Otherwise, custody should be split equally and no child support should be owed by either party.

Also, everyone would be better off if these contingencies were all written into contract before marriage/child birth. It would save everyone a lot pain. Unfortunately, the judicial system has gradually replaced our great tradition of contract law with arbitrary rule by judges, much to the loss of everyone.

Re:My Personal Credit Crisis by ivankirigin on Friday May 15, 2009 @09:28PM (#611684)
Nothing says "I love you" like a prenup. There is a very good reason why they aren't that common.
Re:My Personal Credit Crisis by wheels on Friday May 15, 2009 @10:58PM (#611781)
Nothing says "nice to have you on board" as "here's your vesting schedule and you've got a one year cliff", but it's still a good idea to do.

I think a lot of the problems with prenups is a chicken and egg sort of thing. If they were a standard part of the process they'd be less offensive.

Re:My Personal Credit Crisis by zmimon on Saturday May 16, 2009 @12:04AM (#611839)
I'd actually like to see pre-nups made into law. If you don't make one yourself, you get a pre-nup that says what already happens now when you divorce - but you have to sign it and acknowledge - "yes, I want to be raped in the ass if he/she leaves me". That might remove some of the emotion and distill a bit of clarity.
Re:My Personal Credit Crisis by electromagnetic on Saturday May 16, 2009 @11:24AM (#612219)
The thing is pre-nups aren't always enforcible. The major reason is that no one makes provisions for hitting the jackpot (either literally or founding a business that makes you rich), or that if one person does the partner can contest it in court as an unforeseeable circumstance. This usually ends up falling under the 'unconscionable' clause in the law.

Then there has to be full and/or fair disclosure (your spouse needs to know about that $50,000 you have put away). The other (possibly the easiest reason why prenups can fall apart) is that the agreement has to be entered upon voluntarily by both parties, so if your spouse only agreed to the pre-nup because you threatened a break up then the pre-nup is automatically void.

The sad thing is that if pre-nups were made into law then they would never be enforceable, because everyone would have been forced into them under duress. How can you voluntarily sign an agreement when it could prevent you from being legally married.

Re:My Personal Credit Crisis by bokonist on Saturday May 16, 2009 @11:45AM (#612238)
The other (possibly the easiest reason why prenups can fall apart) is that the agreement has to be entered upon voluntarily by both parties, so if your spouse only agreed to the pre-nup because you threatened a break up then the pre-nup is automatically void.

This is the heart of the matter. The courts have redefined the word "voluntary" in an unbelievably Orwellian way.

Re:My Personal Credit Crisis by HSO on Saturday May 16, 2009 @02:27AM (#611945)
Exactly. If prenups were required by law there would be no emotional baggage in bringing up the topic.
Re:My Personal Credit Crisis by ivankirigin on Saturday May 16, 2009 @01:49PM (#612356)
We need fewer laws related to marriage, not more.
Re:My Personal Credit Crisis by HSO on Sunday May 17, 2009 @05:03AM (#613202)
Agreed! A legal obligation to do a prenup would be like a law protecting you from the law... Perhaps you can scrap the laws about custody, alimony, etc. in the first place and let people figure it out by themselves.
Re:My Personal Credit Crisis by ivankirigin on Sunday May 17, 2009 @04:49PM (#613942)
Or you could just scrape the laws about custody, alimony, etc. and just let people figure it out for themselves. If the child is old enough (say >8 yo) ask them which parent they want to stay with.

Younger, and let people just figure it out.

Re:My Personal Credit Crisis by chollida1 on Tuesday May 19, 2009 @04:56PM (#617606)
This isn't a bad analogy but it leaks a fair bit.

Many, almost all?, people go to work for a company thinking that they'll spend a specified amound of time with it. Very few people that I know think that they'll spend their entire life there.

In fact in the financial industry it's a very accepted practice to jump around from company to company.

Even in the tech industry there are many people who graduate with a plan to work for a Google or Microsoft for a few years to get experience and then plan to go out on their own or to join another startup.

Contrast this with marriage were very few people go in thinking that their marrige is only a 4 year commitment and that they'll get divorced and trade up every 5 years.

Re:My Personal Credit Crisis by kingkongrevenge on Saturday May 16, 2009 @02:32AM (#611952)
Negotiation over dowry was once a part of the process in America, and it still is in much of the world.

Marriage is very much a business relationship. I don't know when it turned awkward to acknowledge this fact.

Re:My Personal Credit Crisis by kingkawn on Saturday May 16, 2009 @11:52AM (#612247)
It turned awkward when people started taking considerations other than business into account, such as "love". I believe Wolfram Alpha has an article on it.

http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=love&a=*C.love-_*Wo...

Re:My Personal Credit Crisis by billswift on Saturday May 16, 2009 @09:28AM (#612138)
It's usually seen as a matter of trust. I consider the phrase "I trust you absolutely" not only pretty stupid but incredibly arrogant - you are not only saying you trust the other (which is good and reasonable) but you are also saying you could not be mistaken (which is foolish). Trust, but be prepared for being wrong in doing so.