News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My Personal Credit Crisis by Notorious_PWN on Friday May 15, 2009 @02:57PM (#611130)
Not sexist, but you're wrong.

Child support should represent the minimum acceptable contribution of the non-custodial parent (father, in the vast majority of cases) to the child's welfare. Should he contribute a lot more, in cash, gifts, and college support? Absolutely. I would. However, the government shouldn't require him to do so, and the spending should be at his discretion. Right now, that freedom is completely taken away. The custodial parent should not be getting a huge check and the freedom to spend the money however she wants. If I end up having a kid with a wife who divorces me to live it up with an illiterate biker, those CS payments damn better be going to the kid's college, not her beau's lottery-ticket budget.

It's a bizarre inconsistency. Parents can stay married and financially neglect their children. They can make $300k combined per year and still refuse to pay for their kids' college. Yet, if they divorce, the one parent who rarely sees the kids (usually father) is forced not to pay up merely to the minimum level of decency, but far beyond that if he's "rich" like the article's author.

Re:My Personal Credit Crisis by mynameishere on Friday May 15, 2009 @03:12PM (#611147)
The actual expense of raising children involves the time spent and associated opportunity cost.
Re:My Personal Credit Crisis by krschultz on Friday May 15, 2009 @03:32PM (#611180)
Which often the father wants to give but the court grants custody to the mother. And then he is forced to pay alimony as well.

Note that if you have a child out of wedlock the same things do not apply. Moral hazard anyone?

Re:My Personal Credit Crisis by sachinag on Friday May 15, 2009 @03:45PM (#611210)
Wait, what?

Of course you pay child support if you fathered the kid, regardless if you married the mother or not. It's the whole point of Maury Povich "You Are Not The Father" episodes.

Re:My Personal Credit Crisis by jibiki on Friday May 15, 2009 @03:53PM (#611229)
> Of course you pay child support if you fathered the kid

But not alimony?

Re:My Personal Credit Crisis by krschultz on Friday May 15, 2009 @08:55PM (#611650)
Right, which are two different things
Re:My Personal Credit Crisis by anamax on Friday May 15, 2009 @07:04PM (#611529)
Yes there are time and opportunity costs paid by the custodial parent. However, a custodial parent also gets significant benefits that the non-custodial parent doesn't get. (Otherwise, why fight for custody?) Surely it's fair to take those into account as well.
Re:My Personal Credit Crisis by jibiki on Friday May 15, 2009 @03:31PM (#611179)
The counterargument says that a marriage is basically an agreement where the woman agrees to lend her womb to a man in exchange for him supporting her and her children.

That's way too sexist for me (if that's what marriage is, then we should change it,) but I'm still not convinced that a man should be allowed to leave and only provide half the minimum support for his children. It seems like the woman is seriously getting screwed in that situation: she has to raise the kids on her own AND find > 1/2 the money to support them. Nobody gets married with that understanding, and nobody wants to.

Re:My Personal Credit Crisis by Notorious_PWN on Friday May 15, 2009 @04:13PM (#611265)
Nobody gets married with that understanding, and nobody wants to.

If she thinks he might be a shitty father who only contributes the minimum, then she shouldn't marry him or have kids with him.

Re:My Personal Credit Crisis by randallsquared on Friday May 15, 2009 @10:00PM (#611720)
I think the standard suggestion amounts to women generally wanting to find a strong/smart fellow to contribute genes, and then a reliable sucker to raise the resulting children. So "bearing children with" and "having a relationship with" might have very different types of men as an ideal.
Re:My Personal Credit Crisis by albertcardona on Saturday May 16, 2009 @04:07AM (#612008)
You have just described the academic paper "Women's Mating Strategies" by Elizabeth Cashdan, Evolutionary Anthropology 1997.
Re:My Personal Credit Crisis by jibiki on Friday May 15, 2009 @05:14PM (#611371)
> If she thinks he might be a shitty father who only contributes the minimum, then she shouldn't marry him or have kids with him.

The law frequently provides protection for people who enter certain contracts, even when they ought to know better. For instance, if I loan money to someone who then goes bankrupt, I am entitled to some of their property. Even if it was a really stupid loan.

In this particular case, women aren't particularly good at determining whether a potential husband will turn out to be a scumbag, so it makes some sense for society to protect them against that possibility. (Actually, men aren't very good at determining whether a potential wife will be a scumbag either, so society should probably protect them, too...)

Re:My Personal Credit Crisis by HSO on Saturday May 16, 2009 @02:52AM (#611976)
Or, perhaps, government should simply let them figure it out by themselves. And by the way, loan provisions are not mandated by government but negotiated up front. If you make a non-recourse loan, you won't get access to the borrower's personal assets even if his business goes belly-up.
Re:My Personal Credit Crisis by jibiki on Saturday May 16, 2009 @03:15AM (#611996)
> And by the way, loan provisions are not mandated by government but negotiated up front. If you make a non-recourse loan, you won't get access to the borrower's personal assets even if his business goes belly-up.

I did not know that. Admittedly, I don't have any examples that work quite as well. Maybe medical malpractice... or is that just a breach of contract?