News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by GuiA on Sunday July 14, 2013 @01:43PM (#6041507)
See, that's one of the problems I have with outrageous tuition: it creates dumb expectations from students.

In most European countries, your education is quasi free, and as a result students don't complain about professors not providing "customer service". You go to the university to learn from some of the most eminent figures of your field, people who have devoted their life to it, and you do as they say. If you're not happy, well you can just leave. And sure, some of them are quirky or do dumb stuff, but you're 19- you'll live. And TBH, even the professors I had in college who exposed me to the most BS are nothing compared to some of the BS I've experienced in the real world, with clients/bosses/etc.

If you're going to University of Phoenix, sure, feel entitled to some degree of "customer service". But if you're studying under Dijkstra, just suck it up and soak in as much as you can, even if the "customer service" leaves to be desired. Again, you're 19- you'll live.

Sorry, this is a bit abrasive, but I've been on multiple sides of the equation (student in EU university, student in US university, TA in EU university, TA in US university), and the students who say things like "I pay tuition, I'm a paying customer, professors have to do X/Y/Z for me" are rarely the ones at the top of the class (and rarely aspire to do so).

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by 6d0debc071 on Sunday July 14, 2013 @04:07PM (#6042052)
No, god no. This idea that researchers should be teaching is just horrible, they're not significantly overlapping skill sets. Unless I have a specific research interest, I'm going to learn a lot more from someone who knows the material I'm trying to learn and has been trained in how to teach effectively than I am from someone who knows the material I'm trying to learn and a lot of other material that's not relevant.

It should be that you do your basic degrees with people who are primarily teachers and then you go and do your more research based work with people who are good at that sort of research, if you want to get into that.

The other way around is just people wasting their talents and their student's time by being really inefficient.

#

The rest of this just seems to be, 'oh they're 19, they'll live... oh we all have to put up with bullshit.' Maybe they will, maybe we do. It's a fully general argument for anything that's not going to kill you.

Life is shit - therefore don't go along with and keep quiet about the shit bits or it'll keep being shit.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by wisty on Sunday July 14, 2013 @07:56PM (#6042810)
Really?

IME, I've only had a couple of lecturers who are good researchers, and poor lecturers. They weren't that bad, they were just the guys who hated teaching and had no social skills. They were still pretty good at explaining things, even though they were dead boring and a little disorganised.

The worst lecturers are the ones who don't understand the subject well enough. They become massive assholes, and say things like "If you don't get it, that's your fault."

Look at Dijkstra's rules (excerpts that show he was not in any way an asshole):

> If I use a word you don't recognize or a sentence you cannot attach a meaning to, it is your duty to ask for clarification. If I go too fast, it is your duty to slow me down.

> Since first-class students can learn a lot from each other, I urge you to try to do the homework in little groups.

(Now, I think assessments should be individual, but at least he recognises that students will cheat so why bother stopping the ones who follow the rules?)

> At the end of the semester there is an oral examination for each of you, the principle being that, after having followed my thoughts for a full semester, you are entitled to two hours of my undivided attention.

God he takes a lot of responsibility. He can take a lot of responsibility, because he's not an idiot who has to hide behind excuses like "it's not my job to make sure you understand the subject".

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by GuiA on Sunday July 14, 2013 @04:16PM (#6042073)
Your argument does not take into account the fact that a significant number of researchers, including world class ones, enjoy/love to teach, and even the basic classes. For many (myself included), it comes hand in hand.

I agree that researchers who don't want to teach shouldn't be forced to, but that's the extent of it. I've been to 3 universities in 3 different countries, and the number of bad teachers I've had is much lower than good or excellent ones.

(of course this post and my previous one refer to computer science/math academia, since that's what I'm familiar with)

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by elbear on Sunday July 14, 2013 @04:42PM (#6042163)
If they love to teach, they should also get good at it, because being a good researcher doesn't necessarily mean that you're a good teacher. I'm saying this because, at least from the OP, Dijkstra doesn't strike me as a terribly great teacher.
Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by GuiA on Sunday July 14, 2013 @04:57PM (#6042207)
How do you measure "good at teaching"?
Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by bennyg on Sunday July 14, 2013 @05:14PM (#6042273)
The first key is the ability to recognize that a student or class of students is not understanding an explanation, and generalize it further or change the example to make it more clear. Do that ad infinitum (a really good teacher can get it right the first time).

The second key is the ability to use examples that pupils find relevant and introduce topics that might not fit directly in the class description, but enhance overall knowledge with the intended discussion's knowledge.

The third key is intangible. And that's the ability to make learning interesting, if not downright fun.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by speleding on Sunday July 14, 2013 @05:43PM (#6042374)
That definition would hold for the kind of teaching where the teacher transfers knowledge and skills to the pupil.

Dijkstra was probably the type of professor that aims to inspire/provoke students into teaching themselves.

I have a degree from a universities in Europe and one from the US and the European one had a much stronger emphasis on asking students to teach themselves (it was a Dutch university, Dijkstra was Dutch so I expect that's where he got the attitude), the US one had more "hand holding" in explaining what you needed to do.

As an aside, the drop out rate at the Dutch university was over 30%, while at the American university I think maybe 2 people dropped out in my year. So while there is some consensus that teaching yourself is better than being taught it's certainly not very efficient.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by oblique63 on Sunday July 14, 2013 @10:05PM (#6043249)
> So while there is some consensus that teaching yourself is better than being taught it's certainly not very efficient.

So under which conditions is expecting your students to teach themselves better for them exactly? It seems to me that there's some sort of selection bias going on here if the best students are the ones that successfully teach themselves, and then reflect on the fact that they were able to teach themselves as the cause for why they were able to learn so well. I'm pretty sure that if you stuck a self-learning student in a hand-held environment he would learn equally well, but might risk learning less due to the natural time cost such a teaching style has. The logical conclusion for this are the whole 'advanced placement' classes and such, because like it or not, not all students are going to be equally well-suited to teach themselves, and thus endure poor teaching. A self-learner meanwhile, will be able to endure such poor teaching, regardless of whether they're even aware of how bad the teaching is.

Teaching is not a fixed methodology, it's really an art that's quite broad in scope and requires honing in on each specific batch of students' needs. If you're going for 'mentor' style inspiration teaching, great -- but make sure you're applying it to a student that'll be receptive to it. If they're not, then maybe try to figure out how you can make them be receptive to it, but I guarantee you that it's going to require some level of hand-holding at the onset; and if you're a good teacher, you should be able to pick up on that.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by speleding on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @04:04AM (#6050513)
Self learning allegedly yields better understanding and retention then other types of learning, so in that regard students who do not drop out would be better off.

I agree that not every student may be able to get into the self-learning mode, although the success of Montesorri schools show that most kids can at least be able to at some level. If you are smart enough to make it into one of Dijkstra's classes, and aspire to comprehend the subject matter he teaches, then you should not need to much hand holding.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by coldtea on Sunday July 14, 2013 @06:19PM (#6042475)
>The first key is the ability to recognize that a student or class of students is not understanding an explanation, and generalize it further or change the example to make it more clear. Do that ad infinitum

Em, that's spoon feeding knowledge to a group of random people, with no expectations from them or their previous qualifications.

Might be OK for elementary school, but it's not a good definition for a university professor.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by derleth on Sunday July 14, 2013 @08:32PM (#6042941)
If effective communication isn't part of a professor's job description, what is?
Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by coldtea on Sunday July 14, 2013 @09:03PM (#6043048)
Effective communication is not dumbing down "ad finitum" as the parent comment suggests.

That said, the major part of a professor's job description is knowing his shit, and being able to convey it clearly.

This has nothing to do with whether the students can understand it easily or not. He could be communicating effectively (e.g as Knuth does in his Art of Computer Programming books) with the students still not getting it.

Science is hard -- you have to work up to it. Merely getting some high level view spoon fed to you because you cannot/don't want to study and understand the actual science is not "effective communication".

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by oblique63 on Sunday July 14, 2013 @10:17PM (#6043299)
> This has nothing to do with whether the students can understand it easily or not. He could be communicating effectively (e.g as Knuth does in his Art of Computer Programming books) with the students still not getting it.

If the audience doesn't get it, then the communication is ineffective, period. You can't just send corrupt data to a server that doesn't understand it and say that the communication was successful -- same deal with humans. [1]

Maybe there are some topics that the students will need to 'sleep on' in order for it to really sink in, but that's not the same as them 'not getting it'. Being someone who's taught myself, I guarantee you that not only is there a difference between those two states, but that you can actually see them in action - as a teacher. If you get to know your students, you can tell when they successfully process enough of the information to be able to figure it out themselves later, from when they just don't get anything you're saying. If you leave things off thinking they could figure it out themselves when they actually got no meaningful data to work with off you, then it doesn't matter how long you give them, they still aren't gonna get it. That is faulty communication. Good teachers can sense this happening and correct for it. Unfortunately, a lot of teachers seem to rely on this idea as a crutch to prevent them from the work of trying to dig into their students' psyche, when the reality is that you really need to be able to do that to become a good effective communicator/teacher.

[1] There is also the fact that the audience may not be fully prepared to understand what you're telling them, but hey, prerequisite knowledge is part of communication too (like a server protocol would be). Fact is, if you're failing to communicate effectively as a result of some unmet prerequisite knowledge, that means some other teacher down the line in the student's life must've dropped the ball on communication too. As you might expect, this can easily snowball quite quickly and lead to a total communication breakdown by the time a student enters the higher levels of education. Thus, effective communication should be a hugely important part of a teacher's skill set, cause even the slightest communication screw-up can trigger a whole chain of breakdown events for a large number of students in the future, which only serves to bite all of society in the ass.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by bennyg on Sunday July 14, 2013 @09:56PM (#6043216)
I didn't say nor suggest the "dumbing down." An effective communicator gets his/her point across - that's the definition. Trust me, if you can't create another example or analogy off of the material you are supposed to be teaching, then you actually don't know it as well as you think. Simple as that.
Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by oblique63 on Sunday July 14, 2013 @11:20PM (#6043500)
> if you can't create another example or analogy off of the material you are supposed to be teaching, then you actually don't know it as well as you think

This is actually a fairly good metric for telling a good teacher from a bad one. Constant use of analogies without making things too convoluted is a pretty good strategy to become an effective communicator.

People love seeing/matching patterns, so if you give them patterns that they can associate with, that'll do like 90% of the communicating for you, then all you have to do is just fill in the blanks.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by coldtea on Sunday July 14, 2013 @10:40PM (#6043378)
I'm afraid ypu did.

"""the ability to recognize that a student or class of students is not understanding an explanation, and generalize it further or change the example to make it more clear. Do that ad infinitum"""

You never examine the cases of students owning up to the work they have to do to understand in the first place.

It's like as you describe a world in which they do everything perfectly, and the only factor in getting that knowledge into their heads is the professor and his "further generalizing".

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by bennyg on Sunday July 14, 2013 @11:28PM (#6043525)
You're describing the complete other end of the pendulum swing from me. You're placing the burden on the student - and when it comes to new material, that is the absolute last place you want to place the burden of learning on. Look at oblique's last post under your response to him/her and you'll see what I mean.
Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by coldtea on Sunday July 14, 2013 @10:37PM (#6043367)
>If the audience doesn't get it, then the communication is ineffective, period.

The communication in the sense of the end-to-end transfer of information might be ineffective, but that does not mean the professor's contribution to it was inffective, period.

You seem to only check the professor for failure. How about failure of the receiving end to parse the information. Because of lazyness, entitlement, easy grades acquired in other classes, and sometimes even pure stupidity.

>You can't just send corrupt data to a server that doesn't understand it and say that the communication was successful -- same deal with humans.

Only you had to use the "corrupt" qualifier for the data. Who said they are corrupt in the first place.

I can very well send perfect data according to some protocol to a client that is incompetent to parse them (e.g because he only implements a simplified and ad-hoc subset of the protocol).

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by oblique63 on Sunday July 14, 2013 @11:02PM (#6043448)
> that does not mean the professor's contribution to it was inffective

To the particular student that doesn't get it, yes it was ineffective. In any given group of students, that'll yield different percentages of effective communication, but it should be the teacher's duty to maximize his communication ratio. As such, the teacher as an 'effective' communicator is purely a function of how many effective communications he actually establishes.

Like I said in my first post, it could be that the student isn't up on the prerequisite knowledge and communication could suffer because of that. The important thing to note here is that:

1) Teachers are usually the ones that trigger this chain of communication breakdown somewhere down the line in the student's career.

2) That effective communication is a verb, and stands on it's own outside of both the teacher and the student, but it should be the teacher's duty to maximize it as much as he can, because that's effectively what he was hired for, and if he doesn't, then other teachers that have his students later on will suffer because of it.

> You seem to only check the professor for failure. How about failure of the receiving end to parse the information. Because of lazyness, entitlement, easy grades acquired in other classes, and sometimes even pure stupidity.

There are plenty of things that could go wrong in the pipeline, and that's why it's impossible for a teacher to ever have a 100% communication success ratio. But let me say that 'laziness' and 'stupidity' are almost never gonna be the reasons a student fails.

First of all, there is such a thing as 'general intelligence' [0], and it should be the teacher's (or management's) duty to account for it, because by definition, the student may not always be able to.

Secondly, 'laziness' is actually the lack of motivation, and the lack of motivation as seen in students is usually a product of poor teaching. Not necessarily on behalf of the student's current teacher, but as an accumulation of bad qualities on all the teachers the student has had. And what could those bad qualities possibly be? You guessed it: bad communication.

If a student feels he's not getting what you're saying, and then he goes on to find the same thing from another teacher, and then another, what on earth is he supposed to conclude other than that he's just stupid? If he's allowed to come to this conclusion, guess what he's gonna do... he'll become lazy. Because why bother trying in a system that you've already been trained to understand you won't be successful in? 'Laziness' as a concept almost never appears in isolation -- nobody is ever lazy "just because", it's just not human to be so. The fact that this is ever used as a legitimate reason for anything is quite indicative of the current state of society.

Entitlement could be an issue, but at least in my experience, it's relatively rare for that to actually be a legitimate hindrance because it's usually a symptom of something else (see: 'laziness' above).

> Only you had to use the "corrupt" qualifier for the data. Who said they are corrupt in the first place.

Alright, I'll agree, but it was just an example. The flip-side of it would be that the data isn't corrupt on the sender's end, but that the server just hasn't been set up to understand the protocol yet. Same deal. Both are key components to effective communication, so if either one of them doesn't work, the action of 'communicating' isn't happening.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G_factor_(psychometrics)

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by elbear on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @06:09PM (#6060419)
You can measure how much the students learned. I know that's not very easy though. You can also take feedback from students which could be useful, if you know how to collect the feedback.
Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by MaysonL on Sunday July 14, 2013 @07:42PM (#6042760)
To judge for yourself, I'd suggest spending a little time on Youtube, watching him teach.
Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by fnordfnordfnord on Sunday July 14, 2013 @04:37PM (#6042143)
There is also the rare individual like Feynman, who managed to be a master at everything.
Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by mkramlich on Sunday July 14, 2013 @08:23PM (#6042903)
indeed: bongos, ladies, safecracking, QED, troubleshooting exploding space shuttles, and explaining things
Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by VLM on Monday July 15, 2013 @08:57AM (#6045198)
Fundamentally, even the ladies and bongos were by his own description iterative application of the scientific method. In his writings it seems to boil down to the same formula for all. Including his story about spinning plates. Gets a bit repetitive once you recognize the formula.
Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by LnxPrgr3 on Monday July 15, 2013 @03:02AM (#6044116)
Long after my formal academic career ended, I continue to learn from people. Not all of them are the best teachers, but if I think someone has something to teach me, I put in the effort myself to learn whatever lessons they offer.

Sometimes I think the biggest problem with higher education is we're encouraged to go through it long before we're really ready for the challenge. I graduated high school at 17—I was a smart kid, but still immature. Now, at 28, I'd love to spend a semester studying under someone like Dijkstra, even if he did (hopefully accidentally) inspire a horde of programmers to hate on every use of a single language construct without thinking.

Chances are good someone like Dijkstra could teach me things a teaching expert with a cursory knowledge of the subject matter could never hope to. The only disadvantage is it might take more effort to learn from a subject matter expert who isn't as good at teaching, but I think that's a price worth paying.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by graycat on Sunday July 14, 2013 @09:56PM (#6043219)
> This idea that researchers should be teaching is just horrible, they're not significantly overlapping skill sets.

It would seem so, but you have to be careful because too frequently the claim is badly false. Let's consider courses in your college major from junior year or later (and there can be other cases, e.g., for advanced students who get into serious material before their junior year). Reasons:

(1) It's a big, often bad world out there with a lot of dumb, badly adjusted, sick, injured, confused people. One way academics filters whom they let teach is by insisting on some research accomplishments.

(2) To do a good job teaching (in your major, junior level or higher) there can be challenges in understanding the material really well, that is, the details, done well, an overview, balance, judgment, synthesis, bigger picture, important connections with other parts of your major, applications, research, etc. So, for this level of understanding, it can be important for you to have the brightest, most knowledgeable prof you can get. That is, a less bright, less knowledgeable prof may not have such understanding themselves.

(3) One thing, on a good day, you might get in a classroom, face to face with a good prof is an example of how he thinks. There's a lot of junk that can find its way into thinking; it can be a real surprise to see, from a really bright prof, how he manages to filter out all the junk, set aside the not very good content, and keep the best content. Once as a graduate student I heard a lecture by S. Eilenberg, and afterward a junior prof said: "He sure doesn't waste time with little ideas.". That could be a good remark to hear. You typically won't get good remarks of that kind from profs who are able to teach the material but don't bring a lot more into the classroom.

(4) Actually, in some fields, starting at the junior year, you can begin to notice that "it's a small world". So, if you have a good researcher as a prof, then you can be surprisingly few connections from the best people in the world in the field; not good to miss out on that.

(5) Yes, it's important to learn, but, really, from the junior year on in your major, there's often some question about just what and how much you should learn. Or, yes, in K-12 and the first two years of college, the emphasis is on the student learning. By the junior year, the lesson, quite clear somewhere in a Ph.D. program and starting to become clear in the junior year, is that no one can carry all the research library around between their ears. So, a big question is, since you will be learning only a tiny fraction of everything in the research library, what fraction should you learn? One path to a good answer is to have a prof who has, from his research, a good view of the future of the field and can use that view to help select and weight what to present in the course. That is, it's easy to waste time on junk, trivia, less important material, dead end detours, etc., and a prof who does much of that can't be good at research.

(6) This stuff about bad teaching is not a small problem. Instead, it's far too easy for academics to fall into some rigid nonsense such as in some of the stories about teaching in Asia -- nose to the grindstone, shoulder to the wheel, ear to the ground, dot all the i's, cross all the t's, but still don't have even a weak little hollow hint of a tiny clue what the material is about. E.g., recently here on HN is a link to the famous Feynman description of teaching in a country in South America. It's too easy for the nonsense Feynman described to walk in and take over. The peer-review process in the better journals tends to cut out that nonsense.

(7) In some majors, it can be important for you to meet people, hopefully via your coursework. A good researcher well known around the world might give you some introductions that could prove priceless.

There's more: Broadly a big issue is quality, and there's no easy substitute.

One response, at one time common at Courant, is "If you just want to learn the basic material, then don't bother with classes and, instead, just get some books and study."

At one time the Web site of the Princeton math department said, (from memory, likely not exactly correct): "The courses given are introductions to research by world class researchers. No courses are given for preparation for the qualifying exams. Instead, students are expected to teach themselves such material.". So, by the junior year, a course should have more to offer a student than just the basic material a good student could just get from the books.

Education is about the future, preparing to do well in the future. As from character Yoda in Star Wars, "Always difficult to see, the future.". Yup, he was correct. Good researchers have some advantages in seeing what is more promising for the future.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by mkohlmyr on Sunday July 14, 2013 @02:02PM (#6041565)
Conversely, in Sweden where it is indeed mostly free that has created a culture where university is just "something you do" and where the education provided is not valued in the same way by students and has become commoditized in a way which I would argue is detrimental. There's a balance to be struck somewhere. I'm from Sweden but studying in the UK and I think the university culture here is far superior. That being said the recent hike in fees here is probably a move in the wrong direction.
Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by Heliosmaster on Sunday July 14, 2013 @02:13PM (#6041606)
maybe the key is not an increase in fees, but in a stricter admission.

Even in Italy everybody does university, even the ones that do not want to study: they find some subject like "political sciences" and lower down the level of the degree.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by ndr on Sunday July 14, 2013 @02:32PM (#6041678)
I'd like to see some numbers about `in Italy everybody does university`, maybe also showing how most people do "political science" sort of thing and how THAT is supposed to lower down the level of the degree, because it looks made up.

OTH It's true that a lot of people drop out or take way longer than they are supposed to graduate. In that I agree using a stricter admission we could let fewer people to get university education but there would be more funds to treat them better.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by fnordfnordfnord on Sunday July 14, 2013 @03:17PM (#6041855)
>maybe the key is not an increase in fees, but in a stricter admission.

Or, better alternatives. How do you make skilled trades more attractive?

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by rdouble on Sunday July 14, 2013 @03:20PM (#6041865)
High paying jobs available in those trades.
Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by fnordfnordfnord on Sunday July 14, 2013 @03:30PM (#6041905)
Right, but good plumbers don't usually get the respect of a bad philosopher. And as far as that goes, education in the trades often fails to prepare the plumbers adequately for say, running their own plumbing business.
Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by glogla on Sunday July 14, 2013 @03:58PM (#6042012)
That remind me of one of my friends, who went to do MBA ... so he can be more successful carpenter.
Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by fnordfnordfnord on Sunday July 14, 2013 @04:14PM (#6042067)
>who went to do MBA ... so he can be more successful carpenter.

Really? Wow. How did that work out for him?

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by glogla on Monday July 15, 2013 @02:27AM (#6044028)
He was running his carpentry business (starting from being one guy in garage and coming to several employees) so it's hard to say, but lately he talks about his new BMW a lot, so I guess it worked :)
Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by derleth on Sunday July 14, 2013 @04:24PM (#6042106)
> Right, but good plumbers don't usually get the respect of a bad philosopher.

Good physicists don't usually get the respect of bad philosophers, and vice-versa. This isn't really a problem you can solve using the university system, as far as I can see.

> And as far as that goes, education in the trades often fails to prepare the plumbers adequately for say, running their own plumbing business.

This, on the other hand, is a very good point.

I'd like to expand on it, in fact: Beginning in grade school, there should be "Adult Living" courses that introduce kids to the kinds of things they'll be expected to know the first day they're on their own.

Think of it as Home Economics with basic law (family law, what abuse is, what mortgages and contracts are, rental property law), real practical economics (budgeting, not balancing checkbooks), basic home maintenance (stuff that's also useful for apartment-dwellers) and, generally, a lot of diverse stuff that you have to know to avoid getting ripped off and/or laughed at and/or killed when you're living by yourself.

You can say that the parents should be teaching this stuff. I agree, but you can say exactly the same thing about arithmetic and English, and we have the schools teach that stuff. More to the point, some kids kinda have shitty or ignorant or stupid parents, so they don't get the same education out of them others do.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by fnordfnordfnord on Sunday July 14, 2013 @04:46PM (#6042173)
>This isn't really a problem you can solve using the university system, as far as I can see.

I think you're probably right.

>Think of it as Home Economics with basic law (family law, what abuse is, what mortgages and contracts are, rental property law), real practical economics (budgeting, not balancing checkbooks), basic home maintenance (stuff that's also useful for apartment-dwellers) and, generally, a lot of diverse stuff that you have to know to avoid getting ripped off and/or laughed at and/or killed when you're living by yourself.

To be fair, my own high school did a fair job, they tried to address most of the things you mentioned, but there just wasn't enough of it, and a lot of the training I got (in maintenance, and not killing myself with tools) was extracurricular (FFA).

So, what parts of high school do you want to throw out?

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by derleth on Sunday July 14, 2013 @06:53PM (#6042579)
> So, what parts of high school do you want to throw out?

Most of the traditional English courses, on the grounds that they're nearly always taught badly and have become jokes even in otherwise good schools.

Replace them with sections in the Adult Living course that teach how to do close reading on advertisements and contracts. The best, most practical part of a good English course is the close reading training, but it really needs to be applied to something practical, as opposed to languishing in a course most students and teachers don't take very seriously.

I don't care if eighteen-year-olds never read Hawthorne again if it means fewer of them get ripped off by unfair contracts or suckered by misleading ads.

Shop class should be folded into Adult Living in its entirety, and the 'make a birdhouse' stuff should be de-emphasized and replaced with 'fixing your toilet' and similar household maintenance tasks. Learning how to use a band saw is great, but other things are more important.

Beyond that, it would have to depend on what the individual school was doing and doing badly. There are general tropes but schools have a lot of local or at least state-wide autonomy, even public schools.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by fnordfnordfnord on Sunday July 14, 2013 @07:23PM (#6042676)
Most of the traditional English courses,

That's what I was thinking too. There's got to be some way to get them to understand their there and they're in less time than is usually taken. And, TBH, studying literature in HS made me hate it. It took years before I'd read again for fun.

>'make a birdhouse' stuff should be de-emphasized and replaced with 'fixing your toilet'

Agreed, but in my HS the wood-shop was where all the special folks went, it seemed to keep them busy.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by derleth on Sunday July 14, 2013 @08:29PM (#6042930)
> There's got to be some way to get them to understand their there and they're in less time than is usually taken.

You can learn this in any course which involves writing. It doesn't need to be the focus to be present.

> Agreed, but in my HS the wood-shop was where all the special folks went, it seemed to keep them busy.

This is something else again. 'Mainstreaming', as it's currently known, is probably better than just warehousing the less able, but the whole notion of everyone being in the same stream in the first place is damaging to everyone, because people typically have different aptitudes and will be at different levels in different subjects.

For example, I'd progressed beyond secondary-education-level English classes before I'd actually begun secondary education, but my math skills were sub-par and didn't really catch up until college. Therefore, I was coasting through AP English and struggling with math courses, indicating wasted time in both endeavors.

I know it isn't economically feasible to remove the lockstep entirely, but allowing people to pass or repeat subjects rather than grades would be an improvement.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by Sven7 on Sunday July 14, 2013 @01:55PM (#6041544)
When it comes to profs of the stature of Dijkstra it doesn't matter what you pay the school.
Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by prostoalex on Sunday July 14, 2013 @03:08PM (#6041820)
US higher education system mixes two types of professors:

1) Those who do an excellent job researching

2) Those who do an excellent job teaching

I don't know anything about Dijkstra's teaching abilities, but (1) and (2) are frequently an OR for each professor, not an AND.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by eitally on Monday July 15, 2013 @09:19AM (#6045301)
The fact is that unless it's in the student's own field of research interest, it's far much profitable to the kids to be under the tutelage of a teacher rather than a researcher. Perhaps universities should offer independent research/study options to undergraduates in the same way they do for graduate students: describe your interests, create a plan of work, recruit a review committee (or for undergrads, perhaps just a single professor), and have at it. As a history major I had a couple of folks treat their own courses this way and by acting as a facilitator to self-discovery I learned far more than in traditional lectures. Standing out for me was Terry Belanger (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terry_Belanger), but he's something of a "Dijkstra" celebrity in the field of bibliophilia so ymmv. One of the options he gave students was to curate their own exhibit in the University of Virginia's most prominent display museum (the Dome Room of the http://www.virginia.edu/rotunda/), and this experience was one of themost impactful experiences in my college career. ... It also steered me away from public history and toward technology, and I'm glad that happened BEFORE I graduated than afterward.
Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by null_ptr on Sunday July 14, 2013 @03:35PM (#6041921)
So a XOR :-)
Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by sukuriant on Sunday July 14, 2013 @03:52PM (#6041985)
The AND professors I've had are some of the finest. I think I had 1, maybe 2.
Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by tomjen3 on Sunday July 14, 2013 @02:51PM (#6041749)
What, other than the (rather trivial) algorithm named after him, has he really done that is worth noting? To me he is like Crockford - all talk, no code.
Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by michaelhoffman on Sunday July 14, 2013 @03:02PM (#6041794)
Here is the citation for his 1972 Turing Award, the highest distinction in computer science:

"Edsger Dijkstra was a principal contributor in the late 1950s to the development of the ALGOL, a high level programming language which has become a model of clarity and mathematical rigor. He is one of the principal proponents of the science and art of programming languages in general, and has greatly contributed to our understanding of their structure, representation, and implementation. His fifteen years of publications extend from theoretical articles on graph theory to basic manuals, expository texts, and philosophical contemplations in the field of programming languages."

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by greenyoda on Sunday July 14, 2013 @03:24PM (#6041885)
And let's not forget his work on concurrent processes: he invented the concept of the semaphore, which is still widely used almost fifty years later.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Semaphore_%28programming%29

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by fnordfnordfnord on Sunday July 14, 2013 @03:35PM (#6041923)
>he invented the concept of the semaphore,

I think he may have borrowed that from the railroads, even if he didn't invent it independently though, he was smart enough to see its usefulness and apply it.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by marvin on Sunday July 14, 2013 @03:21PM (#6041869)
...and for those on HN who are self-taught and aren't aware of the history of computer science, ALGOL is the foundation of imperative programming and inspires just about every imperative language today.

Crucially, this means C and C++, which means that Dijkstra's work is part of the foundation for most operating systems and low-level code in the world - indeed most software systems period, since the vast majority of these are somehow based on C.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by srean on Sunday July 14, 2013 @03:25PM (#6041888)
Never ever have I felt a stronger urge to downvote. Its one thing to be ignorant and vapid, entirely another to cast judgements from a position of entitlement, without even the bare minimum of an effort to edify yourself.

The shortest path algorithm comes nowhere close to his other accomplishment. A significant part of computer science stands on its feet, because of the foundations he built.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by Derander on Sunday July 14, 2013 @03:01PM (#6041792)
http://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/EWD/

Feel free to read one of the thirteen hundred things he published. Most relevant to you (probably) is that he championed the use of "structured programming" -- aka, if, for, while, and other narrowly focused constructs -- as opposed to GOTO: he's the author of "Go To Statement Considered Harmful ".

Also, remember also that many algorithms seem trivial once you've learned them.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by wglb on Sunday July 14, 2013 @03:20PM (#6041864)
He wrote an OS, in conjunction with students, called THE. It had a total of something like four errors in its lifetime.

He also spearheaded a compiler project which was made up of two teams where one part would check each other.

You should check out some of his work, in particular, his calling out computer manufacturers for making bogus hardware.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by innguest on Sunday July 14, 2013 @07:53PM (#6042796)
This is one of the most interesting posts here, but some of those are hard to search for. Care to link?
Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by wglb on Sunday July 14, 2013 @10:18PM (#6043305)
There are vast archives of his writing here: http://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/EWD/

A paper describing THE: http://www.cs.virginia.edu/~zaher/classes/CS656/p341-dijkstr...

This paper here http://www.tomandmaria.com/tom/Writing/DijkstrasCrisis_Leide... has a worthwhile quote:

Dijkstra’s crisis was rather more idiosyncratic than has generally been acknowledged. He took up the language of crisis to convey the need to replace “Chinese armies” of badly trained and mediocre programmers with an elite corps of “mathematical engineers” modeled on himself.

Here is an article of personal reflections about a correspondence with Dijkstra: http://vanemden.wordpress.com/2008/05/06/i-remember-edsger-d....

Folks today don't seem to read much Dijkstra. I think the growing security industry is one side effect of that.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by innguest on Monday July 15, 2013 @04:31AM (#6044340)
Much obliged!
Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by logical42 on Sunday July 14, 2013 @04:08PM (#6042053)
I suspect you may have overpaid for your education.
Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by eruditely on Sunday July 14, 2013 @03:37PM (#6041928)
Implying that being at the top of the class is some aspiration that should be sought after for everybody, debasing life into some competition.
Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by GuiA on Sunday July 14, 2013 @04:23PM (#6042103)
The key to this sentence lies in the second statement: "and rarely aspire to do so". I have no qualms with students working enough to understand the material and not wanting to get 100% on every test; that's perfectly fine.

But in my experience teaching, the students who hold the "customer service" arguments are mostly the ones who are asking me if they can leave the lab early because it's half price Margarita night at the local bar (direct quote here, and not the only one of its kind). That's what I meant, sorry if it wasn't clear.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by LockeWatts on Monday July 15, 2013 @06:47PM (#6049022)
I'd really just like professors to grade things with some amount of expediency. You have TAs to help you with the work, and we had a deadline for getting it to you. Since my cost-benefit analysis on how much work I'm going to devote to your class versus another class is directly proportional to my grade on previous assignments, too long of a delay can wildly impact grades.
Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by drmr on Sunday July 14, 2013 @05:50PM (#6042400)
Even at the top of the class standards can be pretty low.

Regularly I get the impression that a lot of grading in the US is rank or curve-based, which seems like total bullshit to me.

The best performing student could still very well provide poor quality work.

A good teacher evaluates students individually and tries to take each of their levels and learning-speeds in to account.

Luckily I have mostly had university classes with 15-30 students, which gives the teachers a lot of space to approach students individually.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by LockeWatts on Monday July 15, 2013 @06:48PM (#6049026)
"Regularly I get the impression that a lot of grading in the US is rank or curve-based, which seems like total bullshit to me.

This is also a sweeping assumption that you shouldn't have made.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by jimmaswell on Sunday July 14, 2013 @03:40PM (#6041939)
do you have a problem with competition?
Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by acuozzo on Sunday July 14, 2013 @04:22PM (#6042099)
I do. I loathe competition; always have, always will.

I hate watching others compete amongst themselves (e.g., sports) and I hate participating in all forms of competition, academics or otherwise. It just doesn't turn me on. Rather, it makes me feel uncomfortable.

With that being said, I graduated near the top of my CS class and now make over six figures per year, so I guess one can "succeed" (whatever the fuck that means) even when one finds all forms of competition reprehensible.

I did what I did to start and support a family. I didn't do what I did for the high one gets when one feels superior to everyone else on something that, in the end, is totally unimportant (pale-blue-dot, remember?).

It's all bullshit.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by MaysonL on Sunday July 14, 2013 @07:55PM (#6042806)
An interesting quote from Dijkstra on that:

"I have never competed with Peter Naur. (I was raised somewhat puritanically: we had to try our hardest and give the most, but we were not allowed to compete. I am still grateful to my parents for this education.)"

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by moogleii on Monday July 15, 2013 @10:05AM (#6045569)
I loathe competition as you describe it, yet I can be very competitive. I hate being acknowledged for my accomplishments; it makes me very uncomfortable. But I relish the accomplishments and achievements themselves.
Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by superuser2 on Sunday July 14, 2013 @06:17PM (#6042471)
I have a problem with setting the expectation that in order to be a valuable person or good student, one must be better than everyone else. The bottom quartile of Stanford is still pretty damn smart.

We can't expect to be in the top 1% of achievers, because by definition everyone can't. So you end up with 99% of the population that has failed to live up to expectations and deal with the economic and psychological consequences of that. Always, with no exceptions ever, as a matter of statistical fact. That's just stupid and unhealthy.

People should be encouraged to go above and beyond, but making it an expectation of all students is just stupid. If all students could do it, it wouldn't be above and beyond.

We should be looking at absolute measures of competency instead. This eliminates the problem of the A student who didn't actually learn the material, as well as the C student who is perfectly qualified. I would love to see schools raise the standards for "Pass" to a useful level of competency, then grade everything pass-fail. The very best students could still shine on the basis of the quality of their research.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by yuliyp on Sunday July 14, 2013 @08:06PM (#6042849)
We can't all be in the top 1% of achievers, but that doesn't mean we all shouldn't try. Far more than 1% of people are capable of being above the threshold for "top 1% of achievers" as judged by today.

Similarly, striving to be the best doesn't mean you're trying to put others down, it means you're trying to improve yourself. That unless others do likewise you'll improve on a relative basis is not the important thing, rather that you'll improve compared to your old self.

tl;dr Compete with yourself.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by eruditely on Monday July 15, 2013 @03:11AM (#6044148)
Not at all. Just life is greater than competition.
Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by ronaldx on Monday July 15, 2013 @12:30PM (#6046605)
>the students who say things like "I pay tuition, I'm a paying customer, professors have to do X/Y/Z for me" are rarely the ones at the top of the class (and rarely aspire to do so).

I would suggest this is biased, since the top-rated students who understand their needs and are proactive about it won't be around to complain.

The only reason you can get away with providing a worse service to 19-year olds (as you mention twice) than you would to adults is because you have a naive, captive audience who have limited freedom of choice.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by tomjen3 on Sunday July 14, 2013 @02:48PM (#6041739)
So just because you are only 19 your money isn't as good as somebody who is older? And here I thought one of the best things about capitalism is that it doesn't discreminate.

Anyway fuck that, customer service matters if the professor can't deal with that he can go back to typying out papers.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by acurtis on Sunday July 14, 2013 @03:50PM (#6041977)
You are there to learn, not to pay money and get an A.

If you desire teachers to stoop to your level and explain things best left to self-reading in textbooks, you are probably in over your head and have no one but the overly lenient admissions department at your university to thank. University is a big business, that makes admissions easier to let in more students and make more money. Do not fool yourself into thinking otherwise.

Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by chc on Sunday July 14, 2013 @07:49PM (#6042778)
I don't think anybody is talking about automatic A grades. This is indeed about learning — they're talking about whether teachers need to do more to help people learn.