News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups” by graycat on Sunday July 14, 2013 @09:56PM (#6043219)
> This idea that researchers should be teaching is just horrible, they're not significantly overlapping skill sets.

It would seem so, but you have to be careful because too frequently the claim is badly false. Let's consider courses in your college major from junior year or later (and there can be other cases, e.g., for advanced students who get into serious material before their junior year). Reasons:

(1) It's a big, often bad world out there with a lot of dumb, badly adjusted, sick, injured, confused people. One way academics filters whom they let teach is by insisting on some research accomplishments.

(2) To do a good job teaching (in your major, junior level or higher) there can be challenges in understanding the material really well, that is, the details, done well, an overview, balance, judgment, synthesis, bigger picture, important connections with other parts of your major, applications, research, etc. So, for this level of understanding, it can be important for you to have the brightest, most knowledgeable prof you can get. That is, a less bright, less knowledgeable prof may not have such understanding themselves.

(3) One thing, on a good day, you might get in a classroom, face to face with a good prof is an example of how he thinks. There's a lot of junk that can find its way into thinking; it can be a real surprise to see, from a really bright prof, how he manages to filter out all the junk, set aside the not very good content, and keep the best content. Once as a graduate student I heard a lecture by S. Eilenberg, and afterward a junior prof said: "He sure doesn't waste time with little ideas.". That could be a good remark to hear. You typically won't get good remarks of that kind from profs who are able to teach the material but don't bring a lot more into the classroom.

(4) Actually, in some fields, starting at the junior year, you can begin to notice that "it's a small world". So, if you have a good researcher as a prof, then you can be surprisingly few connections from the best people in the world in the field; not good to miss out on that.

(5) Yes, it's important to learn, but, really, from the junior year on in your major, there's often some question about just what and how much you should learn. Or, yes, in K-12 and the first two years of college, the emphasis is on the student learning. By the junior year, the lesson, quite clear somewhere in a Ph.D. program and starting to become clear in the junior year, is that no one can carry all the research library around between their ears. So, a big question is, since you will be learning only a tiny fraction of everything in the research library, what fraction should you learn? One path to a good answer is to have a prof who has, from his research, a good view of the future of the field and can use that view to help select and weight what to present in the course. That is, it's easy to waste time on junk, trivia, less important material, dead end detours, etc., and a prof who does much of that can't be good at research.

(6) This stuff about bad teaching is not a small problem. Instead, it's far too easy for academics to fall into some rigid nonsense such as in some of the stories about teaching in Asia -- nose to the grindstone, shoulder to the wheel, ear to the ground, dot all the i's, cross all the t's, but still don't have even a weak little hollow hint of a tiny clue what the material is about. E.g., recently here on HN is a link to the famous Feynman description of teaching in a country in South America. It's too easy for the nonsense Feynman described to walk in and take over. The peer-review process in the better journals tends to cut out that nonsense.

(7) In some majors, it can be important for you to meet people, hopefully via your coursework. A good researcher well known around the world might give you some introductions that could prove priceless.

There's more: Broadly a big issue is quality, and there's no easy substitute.

One response, at one time common at Courant, is "If you just want to learn the basic material, then don't bother with classes and, instead, just get some books and study."

At one time the Web site of the Princeton math department said, (from memory, likely not exactly correct): "The courses given are introductions to research by world class researchers. No courses are given for preparation for the qualifying exams. Instead, students are expected to teach themselves such material.". So, by the junior year, a course should have more to offer a student than just the basic material a good student could just get from the books.

Education is about the future, preparing to do well in the future. As from character Yoda in Star Wars, "Always difficult to see, the future.". Yup, he was correct. Good researchers have some advantages in seeing what is more promising for the future.

There are no comments on this comment yet.