News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by pinaceae on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @09:56AM (#6019514)
Amazon 1 : Consumers 0

and another great ruling. let's wait for that monopoly around ebooks to fully develop until it's too late.

Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by Kylekramer on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @10:32AM (#6019873)
This angle of "why prosecute Apple when Amazon has the monopoly" is just lazy. Monopolies, which Amazon does not even have and is unlikely to gain, aren't illegal. Conspiring to raise prices is illegal. Amazon just has the potential to abuse consumers (maybe, possibly, in the future) due to their entirely legal success. Apple already did abuse consumers.
Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by DannoHung on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @12:03PM (#6020650)
Give me a call back when Amazon removes the drm from their file formats and I'll give a flying fuck about what's legal or not.
Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by fpgeek on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @12:39PM (#6020932)
To be fair, any book a publisher wants sold DRM-free, Amazon sells DRM-free. Many publishers insist on DRM as a condition of sale. Your beef is with them, not Amazon.

And by the way, DRM is at the heart of this ebook conspiracy. One of the publishers' fears was that too many readers would be trapped in Amazon's ecosystem by DRM, giving Amazon too much leverage. The correct response to that problem is to drop the pointless, self-inflicted DRM (as some have started doing in response to the antitrust cases). Instead, the publishers chose to work with Apple to try and limit Amazon's power...

Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by ernesth on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @01:13PM (#6021233)
> To be fair, any book a publisher wants sold DRM-free, Amazon sells DRM-free.

But only after threatening them that their books won't benefit from the latest amazon technologies such as text-to-speech if they opt out of DRM!

Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by fpgeek on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @09:15PM (#6023924)
Oh? I hadn't heard about that. It certainly sounds bad. Do you have a pointer to more on this?
Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by ernesth on Sunday July 14, 2013 @11:39AM (#6041140)
Yes, in french unfortunately: http://lexbrage.tumblr.com/post/13212628647/amazon-bragelonn...

"Nous avons rencontré [Amazon] recemment pour comprendre cet ajout de DRM sur nos titres et en quoi consitait cette DRM un peu spéciale. [...Elle] embarque également une couche software qui active les fonctionnalités de l’ecosystème Amazon. La liste est variée mais passe du “Text to Speech” au “Facebook Connect” et toutes les prochaines évolutions d’Amazon. Et croyez moi, elle vont être nombreuses dans les mois à venir."

Quick translation: we (the publisher bragelonne) have met with amazon to understand why they added DRM to our books without our consent and what purpose this DRM served. [...] It contains a software part that enables various amazon features such as Text-to-speech or facebook connect as well as the many future evolutions.

Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by azernik on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @01:08PM (#6021171)
iBookstore has DRM too, you know. It's not like Apple is morally superior from that perspective.
Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by baddox on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @01:13PM (#6021237)
> Monopolies, which Amazon does not even have and is unlikely to gain, aren't illegal.

Except for all the mergers and acquisitions that are stopped by the government because the government feels the result would be too monopolistic.

Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by Kylekramer on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @01:58PM (#6021619)
Yes? That seems unrelated. Amazon didn't get to their position via M&A and the DoJ not approving certain M&A doesn't mean monopolies are illegal.

The government certainly doesn't like monopolies, but as long as they are achieved in the prescribed ways and not abused, they are perfectly legal.

Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by baddox on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @03:52PM (#6022360)
Well, if the government will predictably use legal methods to prevent and even break up monopolies, that's indistinguishable from "monopolies being illegal" even if there is no explicit law that says that.
Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by dragonwriter on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @07:17PM (#6023463)
> Well, if the government will predictably use legal methods to prevent and even break up monopolies, that's indistinguishable from "monopolies being illegal" even if there is no explicit law that says that.

It is illegal to take certain acts that would form a monopoly (which is why the government blocks or puts terms on, e.g., some mergers) and it is illegal to use monopolies in certain ways to advance market power in other markets (one of the remedies for which may be breaking up the monopoly which was illegal leveraged.)

But simply gaining and maintaining a monopoly is not illegal, so long as you don't gain it by illegal methods or do illegal things with it.

Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by gamblor956 on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @03:52PM (#6022362)
A naturally earned monopoly is perfectly acceptable, because it is the result of market forces.

The DOJ only opposes mergers and acquisitions which would substantially alter market conditions to increase prices faced by consumers in a way that market forces would not normally support. For example--Verizon and AT&T could never merge, because their combined market power would effectively let them set whatever price they wanted for nationwide cell+data plans. On the other hand--Sprint and TMobile could merge, because without the merger both companies are in danger of failing but as a result of a merger could theoretically compete with Verizon and AT&T.

Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by baddox on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @04:53PM (#6022723)
I'm not seeing the distinction between "market forces" and whatever other forces you're talking about. If Verizon and AT&T merged, how would that not be the result of market forces? Of course, that's a bad example, because there's already not a whole lot of market forces in telecoms since the government controls access to the airwaves.
Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by JimmaDaRustla on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @10:16AM (#6019732)
Amazon found a way to compete before anyone else did, so that makes it excusable for illegally orchestrated price fixing to attack their legal approach?

Sorry, but this isn't the "Think Different" approach the customers deserve.

Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by rimantas on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @11:24AM (#6020323)
I am not sure "sell at the prices below the cost to drive out competition" is not some new way.
Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by smackfu on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @12:57PM (#6021068)
Interestingly, the decision PDF says that originally Amazon's $9.99 was not below wholesale cost. The publishers raised the wholesale cost above $9.99 thinking it would force Amazon to raise their prices, but Amazon decided they would rather take a loss:

"With a digital book discount, Amazon’s $9.99 price point roughly matched the wholesale price of many of its e-books. " ... "One of the strategies that they [publishers] employed was the elimination of the existing discount on wholesale prices of e-books. This meant that the wholesale price for e-books would equal the wholesale price for physical books, and as a result, the wholesale price that Amazon paid for an e-book would be set at several dollars above Amazon’s $9.99 price point. This tactic, however, failed to convince Amazon to change its pricing policies and it continued to sell many NYT Bestsellers as loss leaders at $9.99.9"

Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by JimmaDaRustla on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @12:30PM (#6020870)
Lose money on one book, earn it on three others because you have customers that are bought into your ecosystem. Also, prices subsidized by Kindle sales.

The point is that Publishers weren't losing.

But, Amazon is not notorious for making profits, and I can understand how them dominating a market may be a bad thing. Doesn't justify Apple's tactic though.

Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by fpgeek on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @10:10PM (#6024097)
Breaking open the ebook market after many other companies had tried and failed certainly was a new thing.
Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by baddox on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @01:15PM (#6021250)
> so that makes it excusable for illegally orchestrated price fixing to attack their legal approach?

No, the fact that the laws which make it illegal are ridiculous is what makes it excusable.

Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by fpgeek on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @10:54AM (#6020095)
Amazon's customer service (especially with respect to books) second-to-none, by a large margin. Consumers are doing far better than zero.

And I wouldn't hold my breath waiting for that ebook monopoly. Even if Microsoft/B&N and Apple both decide to bow out (not at all likely they both care too much about content for mobile devices to do that), Amazon still would have Google and Kobo/buy.com/Rakuten (aka "the Amazon of Japan") to contend with both of which are more than capable of fighting a price war.

Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by josefresco on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @11:52AM (#6020559)
Yes let's totally raise prices now to protect us from Amazon whom may or may not raise prices in the future.
Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by esolyt on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @08:32PM (#6023766)
Irrelevant. If they do, that would be another trial.
Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by Pxtl on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @12:05PM (#6020666)
Amazon has built its empire on undercutting the competition in price. If there was a real competition in prices, Amazon's e-book offerings would stomp the paper publishers and Apple alike.

No matter what, price-fixing or not, Amazon can do just fine. The only way they don't completely win is if they're forced to keep prices on e-books high and at identical level to dead tree ware and the glitzier Apple brand. And that's just what happened, thanks to collusion between Apple and the publishers.

Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by MatthewPhillips on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @10:32AM (#6019876)
This is a cynical view point. Do we really have to choose between monopoly and collusion?
Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by PauliaCred on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @10:08AM (#6019628)
Just like the monopoly Apple developed around digital music...
Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by stephenr on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @10:47AM (#6020031)
oh yeah, and they've totally destroyed all competition in that market too.. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_online_music_stor...

Amazon sells ebooks for the sake of selling ebooks - to make a profit. Apple sells music as a tie-in for its hardware offerings - it has no reason to "squeeze out" competitors in this space.

Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by Tyrannosaurs on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @10:59AM (#6020138)
Don't disagree with your point on Apple but worth saying if Amazon's goal is to make a profit it's doing remarkably badly.

On a turnover of around $60bn it makes a profit of about $90m. Given that it's nearly 20 years old and beyond the point where it should be struggling to break even either it's doing a very bad job of being profitable or being profitable isn't the companies primary goal right now.

To me it looks like they're managing profit to zero to continue the land grab.

Now that may be legal and fair and in the short term it's good for consumers, but in the longer term I'm not sure it's good for the market (and therefore for consumers) given that most of it's competitors have shareholders who probably do expect profits.

Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by stephenr on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @12:32PM (#6020883)
Amazons goal has to be profit eventually, or there is no point being in business.

That they make razor thin margins now, is just evidence they are still undercutting the smaller competition until they're the only player and can set prices to what they want.

Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by jljljl on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @10:59AM (#6020137)
Sure there are a number of competitors, but iTunes still dominates when it comes to dollar share of music purchases. Regardless of their intention, Apple has certainly "squeezed out" most of the competition, and remains the dominant platform for purchasing music.

Similarly, there are still options outside of Amazon when it comes to eBooks. There's Nook, Kobo, iBooks, Google Books, Sony, and others. So Amazon's desire to make profit hasn't completely wiped out the market.

So this argument does not really hold in either direction...

Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by bjustin on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @02:43PM (#6021910)
>Amazon sells ebooks for the sake of selling ebooks - to make a profit.

No, Amazon sells ebooks for the sake of selling Kindles first and foremost (or did, before the launch of the iPad). Before the switch to the agency model, Amazon sold many ebooks at a loss. They sold ebooks at $9.99, less than what they paid publishers per copy for popular books.

Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by fpgeek on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @10:59AM (#6020133)
Hold on. Apple has huge incentives to push content competitors off of iOS. It dramatically increases the switching costs to other platforms (see: video in particular).

And while pushing competitors off of iOS technically might not be squeezing them out of the space, it is still awfully damaging - especially when backed up by something like agency ebook pricing.

Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by smackfu on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @11:35AM (#6020421)
I would think a lot of those online music stores get sales by selling at a lower price than Apple. If Apple had the same kind of MFN clause that they had for books, that wouldn't have been possible. Apple probably thinks it was a bad idea to leave that hole open for the music stores, which is why they closed it for books.