News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by baddox on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @01:13PM (#6021237)
> Monopolies, which Amazon does not even have and is unlikely to gain, aren't illegal.

Except for all the mergers and acquisitions that are stopped by the government because the government feels the result would be too monopolistic.

Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by Kylekramer on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @01:58PM (#6021619)
Yes? That seems unrelated. Amazon didn't get to their position via M&A and the DoJ not approving certain M&A doesn't mean monopolies are illegal.

The government certainly doesn't like monopolies, but as long as they are achieved in the prescribed ways and not abused, they are perfectly legal.

Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by baddox on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @03:52PM (#6022360)
Well, if the government will predictably use legal methods to prevent and even break up monopolies, that's indistinguishable from "monopolies being illegal" even if there is no explicit law that says that.
Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by dragonwriter on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @07:17PM (#6023463)
> Well, if the government will predictably use legal methods to prevent and even break up monopolies, that's indistinguishable from "monopolies being illegal" even if there is no explicit law that says that.

It is illegal to take certain acts that would form a monopoly (which is why the government blocks or puts terms on, e.g., some mergers) and it is illegal to use monopolies in certain ways to advance market power in other markets (one of the remedies for which may be breaking up the monopoly which was illegal leveraged.)

But simply gaining and maintaining a monopoly is not illegal, so long as you don't gain it by illegal methods or do illegal things with it.

Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by gamblor956 on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @03:52PM (#6022362)
A naturally earned monopoly is perfectly acceptable, because it is the result of market forces.

The DOJ only opposes mergers and acquisitions which would substantially alter market conditions to increase prices faced by consumers in a way that market forces would not normally support. For example--Verizon and AT&T could never merge, because their combined market power would effectively let them set whatever price they wanted for nationwide cell+data plans. On the other hand--Sprint and TMobile could merge, because without the merger both companies are in danger of failing but as a result of a merger could theoretically compete with Verizon and AT&T.

Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books by baddox on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @04:53PM (#6022723)
I'm not seeing the distinction between "market forces" and whatever other forces you're talking about. If Verizon and AT&T merged, how would that not be the result of market forces? Of course, that's a bad example, because there's already not a whole lot of market forces in telecoms since the government controls access to the airwaves.