No, these issues are very much related. It is the very nature of proprietary software that you cannot inspect and modify it, so you cannot know if it will track you or not, and cannot fix things if you are.
(Inspecting outgoing traffic is helpful, but unless you monitor all activity all the time, and make the effort to actually understand every single bit that is transmitted, you can't be certain.)
Furthermore, some of these browsers explicitly do track you. For example, Internet Explorer, Chrome and Safari provide ways to sync your bookmarks, all of which track you - and some of them encourage you to do this, for example if you do not log in to Chrome it says "you're missing out". (Firefox also has a sync service, but it is encrypted on the client, so the server cannot read the information, and you can't be tracked.)
True, there is a difference with the bookmark sync - I do not think it is valid to discount a browser entirely based on this.
Emphasis mine. Yes, you might trust them not to track you, or to trust that someone will find out if they do, and that you will hear about it if so. But far better would be to use an open source browser (either Firefox or Chromium).
Safari is getting especially terrible. You can either sync "Safari" with iCloud or you don't. This includes bookmarks, but also ALL OPEN TABS ("iCloud tabs"). My bookmarks are absolutely harmless, my open tabs are highly sensitive. Apple sucks at services. :(
The assumption that the NSA would never compel software vendors to include tracking code seems completely unjustified to me. It makes no sense at all to accept all the inconvenience that comes with avoiding NSA tracking and then use closed source software.
But I think many of the suggestions on this list are completely unworkable. Using Tor isn't just a little slower. It's unusably slow for regular browsing. Using noscript is nonsense. It breaks almost all websites nowadays.
> Windows won't track you
Pinky-promise?
By default Chrome sends the text you type in the location bar to Google. I am not sure but they may also use visited urls to source the crawler.
Using Google is a privacy risk but at least you can control it with Firefox, when typing URLs that need privacy. Who the hell can verify what Google (and the NSA listening to their pipes) does with your visited URLs? If you use another search engine, Google can see that, and it's one more piece of information.
Can you elaborate a bit on this, how do you know they won't? My default assumption is that anything I can't see the source code of and compile myself is compromised.
Technically: if the browsers were somehow phoning home, even if the data were highly fuzzed, I'm sure there would be guys like tpatcek who would manage to detail, if not the content of the tracking, at least the amount of data sent and the targets. I don't recall there being such a scandal in recent memory.
> Although proprietary software may be easier for a government to compel to be modified to add tracking, it still runs the risk of being noticed in most reasonable cases, and there is in fact no evidence that any Western government is doing any such thing. It does increase the chance that you are being tracked due to incompetence, but I don't think this is particularly likely for such well-known software.
Did you also write and compile the compiler that compiled your compiler?
http://c2.com/cgi/wiki?TheKenThompsonHack
"a hack (in every sense), the most subversive ever perpetrated, nothing less than the root password of all evil."
A very very good read :)
Eventually, somewhere down the chain, you have to have trusted a compiler that wasn't GCC and you probably don't have the source to.
Since we are talking about checking the compiler that compiles your compiler here.
It might help against tracking and such, but I feel like it's just an illusion that I'm making for myself. No matter what I do to try to prevent it they it won't matter in the long run, it just makes it that much more inconvenient for me.
Ugh, not sure what to do/think.
(At least, for the present! I could totally imagine a near future where the government had a standard method to collect the data of various self-hosted services from VPS providers.)
More like gave direct access to their backends. [1]
Let's be honest, Why would NSA force MS to add a key like that, in such a way?
How do you know? Too much trust in MS and Apple? Backdoors in such systems is a normal thing to expect.
- None of the proprietary browsers will track you - well, beyond what's specified in the privacy policy. Two of the alternatives are Tor applications, but the other two are Firefox (which provides no additional protection) and GNUzilla IceCat (which has little reason to exist other than free software politics).
- Most of the browser add-ons are mostly about third-party tracking; these could be subject to PRISM, but the notes suggest that the concern is more about the third-party tracking itself and non-free software (in the case of Ghostery).
- Ditto with the notes in cloud storage, which discount three storage systems with client-side encryption (i.e. equal protection) because they are proprietary.
- The media publishing section promotes third-party blog publishing services for "privacy and security", even though most blogs are public and thus have no need for either.
- Ditto above with Icedove vs. Thunderbird in the email desktop clients section.
- iOS is advised against with a misleading claim that "iOS devices contain hardware tracking" due to an long-patched bug. The claim about it being impossible to verify whether an iOS app was compiled from the original source is disingenuous, as this is rarely done on any platform, but would certainly be possible to do on iOS if the developer cared.
- OS X and Windows won't track you. (Chrome OS won't either, but it strongly encourages using cloud services which will, so I'll concede that.)
In the claims that proprietary software won't track you, I am assuming that the NSA will not compel (or has not compelled) these companies to modify their software to include secret tracking. This claim is made explicitly under the operating system section: "Apple, Google, and Microsoft are a part of PRISM. Their proprietary operating systems cannot be trusted to safeguard your personal information from the NSA." But even considering all that we have heard about the NSA, this seems absurd, far beyond what they are willing to do, and even if it were true, using free software would not necessarily prevent the US-based host of the download from being similarly compelled. Moreover, someone would probably notice (unless it were an intentionally introduced but otherwise unremarkable security bug, but it's sure easy enough to find real zero-days in software, free or not, without having to resort to that! - not that that should necessarily make you feel better.)