I think unions served a purpose in the past, and hopefully still do now, but honestly once you look at the overtime pay it's painful.
http://www.mercurynews.com/salaries/bay-area/2012
p.s. Some dude took a stab at liberating the data further, but it could use some work. http://public.tableausoftware.com/views/BARTsalaries/BARTsal...
In other places, some mass transit systems are at least partially automated.
Safe Automated BART Train Controls Doubted (1972)
Legislative Analyst A. Alan Post expressed doubt Tuesday that a $36 million automated
train control system for the Bay Area Rapid Transit District can be made "fail safe" to
adequately protect its passengers."
http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/latimes/access/660715472.html?di...It's only political inertia, in my opinion, which keeps things manned (and womanned). I suspect that even as Google cars take off in popularity and prove their safety, public transit will resist and insist that drivers who are susceptible to weariness, exhaustion, sleep deprivation, disease, etc. are still the safer to steer buses through our streets.
http://sanfrancisco.cbslocal.com/2013/07/01/bart-workers-off...
Use IIRC or AFAIK when you remember something, but don't remember exactly or cite a source for anything stated as fact.
They also, on average, get a $50,000/year benefits package, including a fixed-benefit pension. Plus paid overtime. That's not high, or astronomical, it's absolutely outrageous.
Wow. One of the factors contributing to the problems that many, many cities across the country have. Pensions should always be tied to rates of return of what the employee and employer put into the plan, otherwise future workers or tax payers will end up footing the bill when the market goes lower than the pension requires to break even.
Fact: California and Illinois have huge debt problems. They both have really high taxes yet still can't fix them. These problems are both, funnily enough, related directly to underfunded government pension liabilities, related directly to public services with strong unions involved. In essence, precisely what you are saying is false is exactly what has happened in these states.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5975252
"Did you know that there are currently 3,459 BART retirees, and that the average pension payment per retiree/beneficiary is only $21,049?"
The news organization didn't even bother to cite their source. We don't know where they're getting their information from. Seeing a slide doesn't tell us anything. They could be reporting the misleading information that the comment I linked to you goes through. Or information given to them from management over at BART. Especially when there's conflicting information, it makes no sense to trust one side over another. Especially when it's management vs. labor because both sides want to appear as best as they can to the general public.
(Assuming you live in America, that is.)
Not much else to say, just wanted to point out that the decision to strike is not taken lightly by any union. The potential downside is huge.
It is also hard to even hire temps. They must cross the (sometimes aggressive) picket line, get called names (like scab), etc. Then there is the chance that the would-be temps are also in a union and therefore unable/unwilling to take the temp job.
There was that one time that all the striking air traffic controllers got canned and permanently replaced[2]. But that was federal and Pres. Reagan got in on it. So that is not likely to be an option with BART.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extortion [2] http://www.politico.com/news/stories/0808/12292.html
Third, public transportation is generally valued more highly here than
in other places for a variety of reasons.
If various professionals employed by the state were paid in accordance of their value to the society (even if only to a certain slice of society), members of the armed forces would be centi-millionaires.That line of reasoning is utter bunk.
I don't mean to dispute, but I don't understand this. I had thought that it was impossible that the US' military could be worth the $682 billion per year the US spends on it, that it was a sinecure for contractors. At >1.4 million active personnel, you're talking a value of hundreds of trillions, at least 10x the US GDP. The military is only useful as a threat deterrent and threat defense, what threat could possibly justify that?
I guess the moral is that people shouldn't try to be cute when using metric prefixes.
But what if you look at it from a slightly different angle. First, these workers work in one of the highest cost of living areas in the country. Second, they work for a critical piece of infrastructure. You only have to look at the havoc one day of them being off has caused. Third, public transportation is generally valued more highly here than in other places for a variety of reasons.
Oh, and I overheard on KQED this morning that the base pay is $71,000, which is high, but not astronomical.