Why is that obvious? If violating copyrights was impossible, I would probably just be exposed to a lot less music, and would thusly end up spending less on music (I pay for iTunes Match, usually spend $50-100 a year on albums, and $100-200 a year on concerts).
Oh? If Pandora already spends half its revenues on the music, how is observing that doubling (for example) royalties would cause music costs to eclipse revenues, bullying and threatening? It sounds like Pandora is the one that should feel threatened.
Wait, no, it wouldn't be wonderful, because then you'd be angry that every company was making 50% net profit off you left and right.
I'm not sure most average people use bit torrent anymore. And the web is an extremely inconvenient way to try to access illegal content.
Google searching for 'pink floyd the wall' and clicking the three most obvious links in order gets you a well seeded torrent file. None of the links on the page obviously lead you to somewhere to pay to stream/download the album legally (although there is an iTunes link for the movie at the bottom).
Pirates are still winning on convenience, let alone cost.
Yeah, many people don't - because of Pandora and Spotify. Take those away and people will go back to piracy.
http://blog.pandora.com/2012/10/09/pandora-and-artist-paymen...
I don't think that's obvious, I think it's an empirical question. With N subscribers, Pandora currently makes $36 * N per year. If they raise the cost to $50, they'll make $50 * (N - x), where X is the number of subscribers they'd loose.
Of course, all the profit is basically split between the licensors. Pandora currently keeps nothing.
You are suggesting that 50 * (N-x) is "obviously" bigger than 36 * N, but I would suspect that Pandora has already tested it, and $36 provides the maximum possible revenue. If they haven't tested that, they are truly incompetent.
The Pink Floyd article mentions their IPO, but doling out IPO money to licensors is a temporary solution, and probably one Wall Street wouldn't take particularly kindly to. So the choice really is "the current licensing terms, or $0".
I'm pretty sure they made the money from selling the music people heard on the radio.
a song isn't an advertisement for ANYTHING for the songwriter. It is the entirety of the songwriter's creation. The songwriter does not make a living from t-shirts, ticket sales, endorsements, or hosting a reality TV show.
http://blog.startmysong.com/2010/01/02/songwriting-how-much-...
The linked blog do nothing of the sort. It simply state that song writers get in average an $800,000 for radio and TV for a "hit song".
It doesn't say how much is TV vs radio. It doesn't say what a hit song mean, or how many CD's such song will in average sell. It doesn't say what the average number of songs of a singular author is in such CD. It doesn't say what the average income from digital downloads are from producing such hit song, or how it effect sales from the authors other works.
And worst of... Its a blog without any source for its data, and has a disclaimer at the bottom that says: ... the information is the opinion of the author only.
I didn't realize I need a citation to explain what is obvious to any music industry professional: performance royalties from radio play are a major source of revenue for songwriters of hit songs.
If the passle of you want to wave your opinions around for decades while literally enabling and rationalizing the destruction of an industry through targeted technology (napster, for example, originally ONLY supported mp3s) maybe you should do your own research and educate yourself, and not expect me to footnote every assertion.
Otherwise, just admit you want everyone else's IP for free and stop making up justifications.
Instead, the public starts from the stance that music should basically be free, and artists are lucky to be paid anything at all.
The purpose of statutory rates is to create an economic environment where businesses can operate without constant negotiation, and creators can earn a living.
Virtually no one is earning a living from Pandora or Spotify, so, it isn't working. Meanwhile the public has access to a functionally infinite amount and variety of music for nothing, or next to nothing.