News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by pvnick on Monday June 24, 2013 @06:38PM (#5936204)
I am so saddened to hear that the country I pledged allegiance to as a child is now being accused of human rights abuses by Amnesty International :(
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by rdouble on Monday June 24, 2013 @06:56PM (#5936282)
Amnesty International has always been critical of human rights abuses in the USA. Guantanamo, prison conditions, death penalty, treatment of refugees and immigrants, etc.

http://www.amnestyusa.org/research/reports?country=334

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by jonknee on Monday June 24, 2013 @11:09PM (#5937289)
Guantanamo and torture are pretty new for the USA.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by slapshot on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @12:21AM (#5937503)
Trail of Tears, internment of the Japanese during World War II, slavery, suspension of habeas corpus during the Civil War, Tuskeegee...
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by Andrew_Quentin on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @12:52AM (#5937607)
Slavery, World War II and Prison Camps in a time of peace!

How are they comparable?

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by ngoel36 on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:11PM (#5936855)
This is such bullshit. Snowden still committed a crime, he leaked confidential information belonging to the United States government. An action he knew was illegal. And this is the _sole_ reason why we revere him and the sacrifice he made.

The action still holds consequences. When a piece of information is kept confidential, the US Government makes that initial decision to do so. Just because it pisses the public off, that is no excuse for anyone to leak information at will, let alone be pardoned for it.

Don't get me wrong. Snowden is a hero, a far braver man than I might have been. But he is still a criminal.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by mindcrime on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:18PM (#5936892)
Just because it pisses the public off, that is no excuse for anyone to leak information at will, let alone be pardoned for it.

I call bullshit. The government exists to serve the people, not the other way around. What is "legal" or "illegal" is bigger than just what Congress, the President or the Supreme Court think. As they say, "An unjust law is no law at all".[1]

Certainly an arguable point, but it's one I adhere to, and I think a lot of other HN'ers do as well. As well as a lot of Americans, and, for that matter, a lot of people period.

[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lex_iniusta_non_est_lex

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by rayiner on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @12:25AM (#5937522)
They also say, "we are a government of laws, not of men." The government should enforce, and follow, the laws as they are written, not go by what one man or another considers to be "just" or "unjust."

And as a practical matter, the majority of Americans think Snowden should be prosecuted.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by gasull on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @12:33AM (#5937545)
That's not what this Gallup poll found:

http://www.gallup.com/poll/163043/americans-disapprove-gover...

44% say Snowden did the right thing, 42% say it was wrong.

53% disapprove Government surveillance.

59% say it was right for the newspapers to publish the info.

Also: 31% say he's a patriot, 23% say he's a traitor:

http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/06/12/us-usa-security-po...

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by rayiner on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @12:38AM (#5937557)
A Pew Research poll found that Americans believe Snowden should be prosecuted, by a substantial margin (54-38): http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2013/06/17/ameri....
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by gasull on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @01:02AM (#5937638)
I would like to know the exact question they were asked. It's easy to induce people into answering what you want if you use the right wording.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by danielweber on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @11:27AM (#5940122)
It can both be a good thing as well as something he should have to answer about in court.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by anigbrowl on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:40PM (#5943593)
The same point applies to the poll whose results you like.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by mindcrime on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:26AM (#5939619)
The government should enforce, and follow, the laws as they are written, not go by what one man or another considers to be "just" or "unjust."

What "the law" is at any point in time is just a reflection of what men (well, "people") think is just. Except in this country, our political system has become so corrupt that a significant body of what passes for "law" here is total bullshit. People should feel empowered to violate unjust laws. Personally, I encourage everybody to break a few laws each and every day, simply as a matter of principle.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by rayiner on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @12:57PM (#5940792)
> Except in this country, our political system has become so corrupt that a significant body of what passes for "law" here is total bullshit.

What you mean is that you and your friends think they are bullshit. As far as I can see, they are for the most part quite reflective of what American voters want (or is at least consistent with a compromise position of the wants of the various voting demographics).[1] Most Americans are afraid of terrorism and are okay with some level of government surveillance, though they might quibble about the details. They want the government to be very harsh on crime (and are scared of computer hackers), and want the drug war to continue.[2] They wanted their elected leaders to be Christians, etc. I don't see corruption, I see a reflection of the wants and fears of the people.

Now, I don't always agree with the voter consensus, but, frankly, I'd rather have the laws I disagree with than a system where we ask mindcrime and his friends what transcendent principles should govern the country.

I think somewhere along the way, some people got confused about the precise nature of our society. It is a republic with a strong democratic streak as a result of amendments in the 1800's. The purpose of the Constitution is to enshrine this system of majoritarian rule. "Rights" (i.e. principles by which the courts tell the democratically-elected branches what they can't do) are a part of the foundational principles, but we are not a libertarian society where the fundamental purpose of government is to protect rights.[3] Rights must be respected, but when it comes time to interpret the scope of a right, whether broadly or narrowly, in the face of a conflict with the laws promulgated by the elected branches, I think it's critical to keep in mind that "The United States shall guarantee to every State in this Union a Republican Form of Government" made it to the main body of the Constitution--search and seizure and the other rights were added after the fact.

[1] I think it's a crucially important fact to understanding this country that while Americans hate Congress as a whole, they historically love their particular representatives: http://www.gallup.com/poll/162362/americans-down-congress-ow.... Americans don't hate what their representative is doing (at least historically). They hate what other peoples' representatives are doing.

[2] I think it might be the case now that a slim majority of people might now want to see at least some decriminalization. However, I think the majority of voters still want to wage the drug war. The suburban soccer mom/dad demographic that shrilly preached "Just Say No!" at every school function every American student attended in the 1980's and 1990's is more politically active than ever, and has a good 15+ years of voting left in it.

[3] I think a good example of this distinction is Hong Kong (or at least, the idealized depiction of Hong Kong that is common on HN). Hong Kong doesn't have any democracy to speak of, but it does have a strong history of protecting rights. Many people might find Hong Kong preferable to the U.S. because they care more about rights than democracy.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by mindcrime on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @01:16PM (#5940964)
What you mean is that you and your friends think they are bullshit.

And?

As far as I can see, they are for the most part quite reflective of what American voters want (or is at least consistent with a compromise position of the wants of the various voting demographics).

Yeah, well, majority rule is bullshit too, so what's your point? The "system" we have in place tries to avoid the "tyranny of the majority" but no political system can ever really avoid some element of that. There's no point pretending that the system we have in place doesn't have flaws, and that individuals are not sometimes justified in stepping outside of that system.

Now, I don't always agree with the voter consensus, but, frankly, I'd rather have the laws I disagree with than a system where we ask mindcrime and his friends what transcendent principles should govern the country.

Then I suppose you should hope that I'm never on a jury. :-)

I don't see corruption

You must not be looking very hard. But, being part of "the system", I guess that should be expected. What we all see is influenced by our fundamental worldview, and you clearly have a fundamentally different worldview than I do. So we'll probably always disagree on this.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by rayiner on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @01:57PM (#5941247)
I'm not criticizing your world view, I'm explaining mine and my take on what I think is the most appropriate description of the nature of our society. Our system does try to avoid "tyranny of the majority" but to a point. It is not a system that puts "rights" first and relegates democracy to whatever is left after various broad and expansive rights instituted. Rather, "rights" are the exceptions to the general rule of democracy.

If there is an animating principle to the Constitution, I think it's the phrase "consent of the governed." When you tell a starving man he can't kill his neighbor and take his livestock, a freedom of action he was born with and retains in the state of nature, or else some government which has no stake in either his neighbor's property or his huger will punish him, I don't think it suffices to appeal to some supernatural "right to life" or "right to property." I think it is wrong to impose that system on people on any other basis than democratic consensus. And I think there is a reason the founders spent so much ink describing how the U.S. was based on "consent of the governed," a key distinction between the U.S. and Britain, while they were by and large happy to inherit the system of "rights" from common law English principles.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by mindcrime on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @06:50PM (#5942959)
Fair enough. Also, FWIW, I'm not one of the people who downvoted your post above. We may not agree, but I generally don't do the "downvote to express disagreement" thing.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by pfraze on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:48PM (#5936991)
True, but I'm not sure I'd say the laws against leaking government secrets are unjust. I'd say the various monitoring systems are potentially dangerous and unconstitutional, but those issues are separate from Snowden's charge.

Also, I'm not a lawyer, but I'm pretty sure that the nature of the leak will factor into his trial, which is where it should be evaluated (right?).

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by drcube on Monday June 24, 2013 @10:21PM (#5937112)
Because secret treason courts are where justice is best served? In the very country being accused of civil rights violations by the defendant?

And besides troop movements, names and locations of undercover operatives, and other specific information that could get people hurt or killed, why should the government keep secrets from its citizens for any reason? Or what does "consent of the governed" mean?

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by rayiner on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @12:34AM (#5937550)
> Because secret treason courts are where justice is best served?

What secret treason courts? Snowden is not charged with treason, and even if he were, he'd be tried in U.S. District Court.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by jasonlotito on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @12:25AM (#5937520)
> and other specific information that could get people hurt or killed,

You've described the loop hole for a slippery slope. And I promise you, the first suggestions would seem so reasonable. After all, you didn't mention the descriptions of the operatives. Or the supplies needed to support the troop movements. Both of which are not specifically described by you, but could easily be used against the troops and agents. Both of which are reasonable to keep secret...

But it's still a slope. We think we are here overnight, but we are not. PRISM didn't just happens. It's been in the making for decades before you were born.

That's the part we need to realize. Obama didn't do this. Bush didn't do this. Hell, your parents didn't do this. We've all done this, one way or the other. We've all been apart of this.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by mindcrime on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @11:13AM (#5940008)
True, but I'm not sure I'd say the laws against leaking government secrets are unjust.

I think you have to consider context. To flip it around, the law may or may not be inherently unjust, but breaking it may well be justified in some circumstances. Nominally, this is part of the reason we have juries, and why juries are able to make their determination on any basis they see fit... so they can allow for this kind of "fuzziness" to the law.

There's also a reason that prosecutors have discretion in choosing what charges to pursue, what sentence to seek, etc.

Now, you can argue that, given our system and all its checks and balances and protections, that Snowden should come home and face a trail in front of a jury of his peers. But you can also argue that, given all the publicity around the case, he's correct in saying that he won't get a fair trail. You could also argue that even a "fair trail" is unfair from the perspective of the individual being judged, if they don't consider themselves guilty of a crime.

At the end of the day, this whole idea of "justice" is not black and white, sadly.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by diminoten on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:54PM (#5937006)
You don't get to end-run the justice system by being popular in the eyes of the people.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by eksith on Monday June 24, 2013 @10:03PM (#5937044)
While popularity may be irrelevant, being "right" in the eyes of the people is what justice is all about. After all, the civil rights movement was fairly unpopular for a large part of the U.S. population. Regardless, the legal precedents set during that time were "right" and just.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by mpyne on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @11:11AM (#5939987)
You contradicted yourself from one sentence to the next.

The population overwhelmingly supported oppressing the black minority. But the legal system disregarded what the large majority thought and did the right thing anyways.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by eksith on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @03:56PM (#5941994)
In "eyes of the people is what justice is all about" please replace "people" with "court".

Sorry, not enough coffee.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by mpyne on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @04:03PM (#5942046)
Ah, ok
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by jrockway on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:38PM (#5936958)
It's not "leaking confidential information" if the information is evidence of ongoing criminal activity. Imagine that the government was kidnapping children and grinding them into a paste for use as a new MRE flavor. Would you put the person who told the media about this up for trial on espionage charges? Of course not. You'd use the evidence to convict the people that were grinding up the children.

This is the same thing except on a more abstract level of illegality.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by xtc on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:57PM (#5937023)
A lot of hyperbole in that statement making it really off-base. You may think it's criminal/illegal activity, but the problem is it's completely within the law we have created. Whether or not it should be legal is a different topic.

The actions from what we've seen so far are completely legal; what Snowden did is not. It's incredibly simple.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by wtallis on Monday June 24, 2013 @11:26PM (#5937331)
> You may think it's criminal/illegal activity, but the problem is it's completely within the law we have created.

That's a completely unsupported assertion. Clearly what the NSA has been up to is compatible with a small secretive framework of laws and courts, but a large part of the outcry is due to the fact that this framework hasn't been publicly subjected to Supreme Court challenges, so the compatibility with the larger body of law and the constitution is fairly uncertain compared to things like normal law-enforcement procedures. (If PRISM et al had been thoroughly tested at the Supreme Court level, there would have to have been a decision as notorious as Dred Scott or Roe v Wade, and a corresponding movement to amend the constitution in order to overturn the Supreme Court. Neither has happened yet.)

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by sk00byd00 on Monday June 24, 2013 @11:32PM (#5937350)
> The actions from what we've seen so far are completely legal; what Snowden did is not. It's incredibly simple.

Ah, innocent until proven guilty and all that!

I am not entirely convinced everything we have seen the US do in this case in legal in international terms. By pressuring countries to ignore the asylum process in order to carry out an illegal extradition is already crossing a line. If he was to be extradited it would be breaking international law.

And the US was one of the primary authors of these international laws, treaties and standards of human rights.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by jasonlotito on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @12:11AM (#5937467)
Pressure is fine.

> If he was to be extradited it would be breaking international law.

What international law prevents a country from willingly deporting a foreigner?

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by sk00byd00 on Friday June 28, 2013 @03:36AM (#5956763)
There are non-refoulement[1] clauses in international refugee law that 181 countries around the world are bound to, I believe.

In previous cases[2] where people are deported whilst seeking asylum the UNHCR has said:

> UNHCR denounced the move as a violation of the "non-refoulement" policy that prohibits the forced return of asylum seekers to areas where they could face danger – a cornerstone of international refugee protection.

> "We cannot accept that these asylum seekers were deported without a chance to explain their case,"

In my opinion, for the rule of law to stand, the asylum process must conclude before he gets deported.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-refoulement [2] http://www.unhcr.org/3fe98ef84.html

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by newbie12 on Monday June 24, 2013 @10:08PM (#5937055)
It isn't that simple. The government's programs are kept secret, even from most of Congress and most of the courts, and certainly from the public. It is very hard to square the sweeping NSA programs with the plain language of the 4th Amendment, which is the highest law of the land.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by jlgreco on Monday June 24, 2013 @10:09PM (#5937061)
In his hyperbolic example, what makes you think that the government has not made grinding up children for MREs legal?
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by ekianjo on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:27PM (#5936926)
Reporting Constitutional violations should never be allowed to be considered as a crime in the first place. On the contrary, you will find that in many cases the person who reports the violation is protected and not hunted down by the authorities. But when the government is the violator... it goes the other way around.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by cgag on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:45PM (#5936977)
We recognize what he did was a crime, but we agree it was the right thing to do, why is there any reason to punish someone for what we agree is right? Preventing harm to the public is a great reason to leak information, and the people thinking it was the right thing to do seems like an excellent reason to pardon him for it.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by keefe on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:31PM (#5936941)
Not pursuing him sets a bad precedent; we can't allow any "slippery slope" effects in security. The impact on active operations is unclear, but it seems significant. I respect the principle of free information, but I recognize that we're at war and security is a very serious matter.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by amirmc on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:41PM (#5936968)
> "Not pursuing him sets a bad precedent..."

A bad precedent to what, exactly? Other people revealing more potentially unconstitutional actions by the Government of the day?

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by keefe on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @12:20AM (#5937499)
a bad precedent for leaking classified information at a time when serious military operations may be compromised. What right does this one guy have in making that decision and what are the odds that he has enough information to evaluate the consequences of that action? He may be a hero for revealing unconstitutional actions, but that doesn't mean he didn't commit a crime (possibly getting people killed in the process) nor does it mean he should be spared the consequences. I think we live in an international arena where traditional clearcut boundaries have mostly faded and a reality of exponentially increased personal destructive power is that we do indeed need to sacrifice some liberties for security.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by amirmc on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @04:20AM (#5938172)
There are two things wrong with your statement.

Firstly, you're implying that Snowden revealed info about current military operations. If you read his comments (eg Guardian Q&A), he makes it clear that his issue is with the suspicionless surveillance and that he took steps to avoid revealing more. If he's shared info of the kind you're describing, please point to it. Otherwise there is no precedent set here.

Secondly, your approach basically boils down to "Don't get in the way of the Military or Governement. Ever." There are plenty of other countries in the world with similar doctrines, which I find ironic. Also, What d'you think about previous whistle-blower actions in US history, like the Pentagon Papers [1]?

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pentagon_Papers

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by keefe on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @03:19PM (#5941753)
He took unilateral action in determining what he thought was safe. Neither of us really knows the impact of the leak or its actual scope (as far as other lesser security breaches likely concomitant with the major leak).

The approach doesn't boil down to that hyperbole at all. There's a place for opposition, but I don't see it as among those people who choose to work on classified projects for the NSA and CIA. Compartmentalized security relies on trusted individuals not choosing to make unilateral security decisions. If he wants to resign and then generally oppose governmental surveillance, then he is welcome to do that.

I see the pentagon papers as along the same lines as this. The remnants of my teenage agents sympathize with the whistle blower spirit, but I see this as effectively the same as vigilante justice and blatant disregard of the importance of trust in security and while it may have had positive societal benefits, that doesn't mean there should be no consequences.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by chii on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:45PM (#5936976)
you could argue that the other slippery slope if that by pursuing a whistleblower, it sets a chilling effect on whistle blowing, and the govt then had less oversight.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by doki_pen on Monday June 24, 2013 @10:16PM (#5937091)
I might consider your opinion if I thought he would be treated fairly in trial. If the last few years are any indication, there is no chance of that happening. The POTUS has already said that he is guilty of treason before any trial has begun. Do you realize the outrageousness of that simple fact?
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by jsz0 on Monday June 24, 2013 @10:53PM (#5937240)
Being that he has already confessed on video and presumably there's a good amount of other evidence the government would have nothing to gain from an unfair trial.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by mayneack on Monday June 24, 2013 @11:08PM (#5937286)
As opposed to all that they gained from their treatment of Bradley Manning.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by doki_pen on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @06:37AM (#5938525)
He never confessed to treason.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by mpyne on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @11:14AM (#5940018)
He confessed to infiltrating the NSA via B-A-H for the purpose of grabbing material to later leak to the public. He may not have realized it at the time but that's very damning, especially since he went out of his way to get information relating to Chinese hacking activities.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by doki_pen on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @03:35PM (#5941852)
[edit: added more]

Are we fighting a war with China?

From Wikipedia:

Oran's Dictionary of the Law (1983) defines treason as "...[a]...citizen's actions to help a foreign government overthrow, make war against, or seriously injure the [parent nation]." In many nations, it is also often considered treason to attempt or conspire to overthrow the government, even if no foreign country is aiding or involved by such an endeavor.

The point is, if we can argue about it, then there should be a fair trial to determine whether or not it was treason. The president and other leaders saying it's treason doesn't lend itself to a fair trial in the future. The appropriate response is "He committed crimes, we will have a trial to determine the extent of those crimes and whether or not it is treason".

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by mpyne on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @04:03PM (#5942044)
You're focusing way too much on treason. There's probably 5 other felonies besides that Snowden would be guilty of without even having to think about treason charges.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by sigkill on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @12:30AM (#5937537)
Also, isn't it true that the POTUS considers himself to have a remote killswitch for every American that exists?
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by pjnewton on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:50AM (#5939826)
What? What does this even mean? You're saying you think the President thinks he can assassinate any American he pleases without repercussion?

And who do you think will carry out these killings?

(Hopefully you have a credible source to back up your claims...)

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by mpyne on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @11:13AM (#5940004)
No. The Commander-in-Chief might, for non-state military members that happen to be Americans and a few other "Law of War" provisos. But that's why you don't oppose the U.S. militarily, it's been shown to be hazardous to one's health.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by anigbrowl on Monday June 24, 2013 @10:22PM (#5937115)
^ Not actually a fact.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by mcantelon on Monday June 24, 2013 @10:43PM (#5937205)
>Just because it pisses the public off, that is no excuse for anyone to leak information at will, let alone be pardoned for it

He alerted the public to the fact that an arm of the state is flagrantly, knowingly violating the Constitution of the United States. That's not crime, that's patriotism. Why isn't James Clapper being charged for lying under oath to Congress about state surveillance?

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by jasonjei on Monday June 24, 2013 @11:33PM (#5937354)
Just because it pisses the public off, that is no excuse for anyone to leak information at will, let alone be pardoned for it.

By that logic, anyone who freed slaves in the South during the Civil War shouldn't have been pardoned by the states whose laws they broke and prosecuted to the fullest extent.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by jimktrains2 on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:23PM (#5936909)
>Just because it pisses the public off, that is no excuse for anyone to leak information at will, let alone be pardoned for it.

Just because the actions documented in the documents are unconstitutional and hence illegal is an excuse to leak documents that were trying to be hidden.

FTFY

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by jlgreco on Monday June 24, 2013 @10:06PM (#5937053)
> "And this is the _sole_ reason why we revere him and the sacrifice he made."

What? No, not at all. I appreciate his actions regardless of the legality, would appreciate them whether or not he chose to reveal his identity, and will appreciate them whether or not he is eventually punished by the US government for what he did.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by Flenser on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @04:38AM (#5944813)
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by mindcrime on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:20PM (#5936898)
Good point, but if anything, this should serve as a reminder of why children, who are probably too young to even really understand what a "pledge of allegiance" even is, should not be being led through such a ritual everytime they turn around in school or whatever.

For that matter, it's probably a good warning against the whole idea of pledging allegiance to a nation-state at all.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by ekianjo on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:31PM (#5936942)
> a good warning against the whole idea of pledging allegiance to a nation-state at all.

Pleading allegiance is an ancient tradition inherited from Kingdoms and Lordships, where the individual was a mere subject of the crown or superior power. Why plead allegiance in our era ?

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by jrockway on Monday June 24, 2013 @06:52PM (#5936261)
This is not a new thing. The prisons in the US are used as a model for countries wishing to gain the status "third world".
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by SEJeff on Monday June 24, 2013 @08:57PM (#5936805)
You know... Most prisons in the US (non-maximum security) are more like hotels with free gyms, TVs, college class work, and Internet. Some of them where the non-violent white collar criminals go are seen almost (jokingly of course) as resorts. I disagree with your statement.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by gaelian on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:22PM (#5936904)
The fact that the US has a ridiculous amount of people in prison[1] seems like a fairly clear example of short sighted third world thinking to me. I know I personally find this fact rather concerning and I'm not even American. Some things should not be run for a profit.

Discussion on the conditions of low-security prisons in the US should be secondary to discussions about why so many Americans are in prison in the first place, IMO.

1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prison#Population_statistics

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by vbtemp on Monday June 24, 2013 @10:30PM (#5937151)
> about why so many Americans are in prison in the first place, IMO.

You are right and the prison situation in the USA is not ok. But that said, just as this situation could be called f--ked up, also keep in mind that many parts of US society are also REALLY F--KED UP. There's a lot of injustice and racism throughout the criminal "justice" system, but there's also a sick amount of senseless, senseless violence.

Source: Friends and family who are prosecutors and public defenders. A relative of mine was once in the position of having to defend a group of teenagers who lynched and murdered a stranger on the street with golf clubs.

Maybe without agreeing, you can at least understand the motivation for [definitely short sighted] tough-on-crime programs.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by gaelian on Monday June 24, 2013 @11:07PM (#5937283)
Yes, I can understand it while at the same time not agreeing with it.

It seems to me that one of the biggest questions on this issue that Americans need to face is: are you punishing or are you rehabilitating? I don't pretend to have a universally applicable and useful answer to that question, but societies should at least be very clear about which option is being chosen and what the consequences of that choice are.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by jlgreco on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @01:40AM (#5937745)
> It seems to me that one of the biggest questions on this issue that Americans need to face is: are you punishing or are you rehabilitating?

It seems to me that there is a third option: isolating. Some people we cannot cure, but should not be "punished". Even so, they need to be kept away from the general population for the sake of the population.

I personally think that using imprisonment as a sort of "punishment" is barbaric and has no place in a civilized society. It should only be used to rehabilitate or, barring that possibility, isolate. You have someone who just won't stop killing people and your psychologists are at a loss as to how to turn him into a safe productive member of society? By all means, keep him locked up and off the streets, but trying to frame this detainment as a "punishment" is how we start down a very dark road.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by gaelian on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @02:20AM (#5937874)
Quite so. The purpose of my simplified question was to contrast the concept of punishment with really any other option. Because I don't think America has faced the fact that many of its citizens still require punishment of criminals as opposed to rehabilitation, isolation or whatever may actually be a more appropriate and humane response, were religious or pseudo-religious doctrine taken out of the equation.

I believe the privitisation of the penal system in the US has set the stage for all kinds of misdirected incentives. I wonder if some who benefit from the system as it stands are in fact quite happy to perpetuate the need for revenge/punishment.

I do none the less understand the impulse for revenge on an individual level. Anyone who says they don't must have had a charmed life indeed. I just think it's time we start consciously removing such instincts from our penal systems.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by mnemonicsloth on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:55PM (#5937012)
The US has a lot of people in prison because it's a big rich country with a diverse population. It's easy to commit crimes against people not like you, and easy to vote for stiff sentences against criminals not like you. And we have lots of money for police and prisons.

This doesn't happen in Europe, for example, because European countries are ethnically homogeneous. The reason is WWII, which was really just the rest of WWI, which started because of tensions over ethnic minorities -- officially in the Balkans but more so in Austria-Hungary, which was really just a club of little states pretending to be one big one.

As Tony Judt put it in his (fantastic) history of Europe after 1945, "The stability of postwar Europe is due in large part to the achievements of Hitler and Stalin."

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by anigbrowl on Monday June 24, 2013 @10:26PM (#5937128)
This doesn't happen in Europe, for example, because European countries are ethnically homogeneous.

As a European, I feel pretty sure you've never been to Europe. Your assertions are almost comically inaccurate.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by snowwrestler on Monday June 24, 2013 @11:31PM (#5937349)
You don't have to go to Europe to look up population statistics. In fact if you live in a big international city like London or Paris, you might have a skewed perspective on the diversity of European nations.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethnic_groups_in_Europe#By_coun...

Reading down the list, most European nations have around 80% or more majority ethnicity. Even those with lower majorities tend to have closely related minorities, e.g. Belgium with its Flemings and Walloons.

By comparison the largest racial/ethnic group in the U.S., non-Latino whites, is under 65% and shrinking.

All that said, I personally think the high rate of imprisonment in the U.S. reflects a lot of latent to overt racism and can't be defended. I think that was the GP's point but I'm not sure.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by socksy on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @12:18AM (#5937494)
You don't have to go to Europe to look up population statistics. In fact if you live in a big international city like London or Paris, you might have a skewed perspective on the diversity of European nations.

But most of the crime is in the big cities, which attract people from all around Europe. Using the population statistics for countries as a whole could be seen as a little disingenuous with that in mind. Though, I'd be willing to bet that the Gini coefficient is more relevant a measure.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by anigbrowl on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @12:35AM (#5937551)
It's a lot more diverse than that. We also find it strange that the US classifies most of its Spanish-speaking population as non-white.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by snowwrestler on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:05AM (#5939485)
Latino is an ethnicity; people of that origin identify themselves according to racial classifications like white, black, Native American, etc. Most do identify themselves as white.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by kome on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @05:04AM (#5938281)
The very fact that in United States there is some kind of racial classification is strange to me (and quite suspect too).
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by mpyne on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @11:03AM (#5939938)
You can't run affirmative action without knowing who to discriminate for or against. Likewise you can't tell which racial groups are being disproportionally attacked by government programs without knowing each person's race.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by mnemonicsloth on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @11:17AM (#5940040)
You didn't bother to look up the author, did you?

Tony one - of - our - most - dazzling - public - intellectuals Judt? Whose special expertise was modern European history?

This is taken from the introduction to POSTWAR, finalist for the 2005 Pulitzer Prize:

""" p. 9

We should not idealize this [pre-1914] Europe. What the Polish writer Tadeusz Borowski called 'the incredible, almost comical melting pot of peoples and nationalities sizzling dangerously in the very heart of Europe' was perilously rent with riots, massacres, and pogroms -- but it was real, and it survived into living memory.

Between 1914 and 1945, however, THAT Europe was smashed into the dust. The tidier Europe that emerged, blinking into the second half of the 20th century had fewer loose ends. Thanks to war, occupation, boundary adjustments, expulsions and genocide, almost everybody now lived in their own country, among their own people. For forty years after WWII Europeans in both halves of Europe lived in hermetic national enclaves where surviving religious or ethnic minorities -- the Jews in France, for example -- represented a tiny fraction of the population at large and were thoroughly integrated into its cultural and political mainstream. Only Yugoslavia and the Soviet Union -- an empire, not a country, and anyway only part-European -- stood aside from this new, serially homogeneous Europe.

But since the 1980s, and above all since the fall of the Soviet Union and the enlargement of the EU, Europe is facing a multicultural future... voluntary and involuntary migrants from failed or repressive states at Europe's expanded margins have turned London, Paris, Antwerp, Amsterdam, Berlin, Milan, and a dozen other places into cosmopolitan world cities whether they like it or not.

This presence of Europe's living 'others' -- perhaps fifteen million Muslims in the EU as currently [2005] constituted, for example, with a further eighty million awaiting admission in Bulgaria and Turkey -- has thrown into relief not just Europe's current discomfort at the prospect of ever greater variety, but also the ease with which the dead 'others' of Europe's past were cast far out of mind. Since 1989 it has become clearer than it was before just how much the stability of post-war Europe rested upon the accomplishments of Josef Stalin and Adolf Hitler. Between them, and assisted by wartime collaborators, the dictators blasted flat the demographic heath upon which the foundations of a new and less complicated continent were then laid.

"""

On my trips to Europe I have seen students in Prague (none in Plzen), Arabs in Paris, some British tourists in Ljubljana.

Overall I was not surprised to learn that when Poles gained the right to emigrate by acceding to the EU, the richer member nations were swept by waves of anxiety over the arrival of a slightly different kind of white person.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by anigbrowl on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:38PM (#5943587)
I was already familiar with the late Tony Judt, and I don't wholly agree with his thesis. If there's one thing I find annoying it's the assumption that disagreement must be the result of ignorance. Bashing me over the head with Judt's accomplishment is little more than an argument from authority. I didn't say that europe was all a-OK with diversity, but that it was more diverse than the post above appreciates.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by PavlovsCat on Monday June 24, 2013 @11:34PM (#5937361)
The US has a lot of people in prison because it's a big rich country with a diverse population.

And it wasn't before 1980? That's news to me.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incarceration_in_the_United_St...

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by mnemonicsloth on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:00AM (#5939458)
Did you not read even one sentence of mine after the one you quoted?

"...and easy to vote for stiff penalties for criminals who don't look like you."

That's a reference to the Drug War. Which Reagan cranked into high gear in the 1980s, in response to the crack epidemic, by introducing mandatory minimum sentences for drug possession. Penalties for possessing crack were, infamously, 100 times those for an equivalent amount of powder cocaine. Congress revisited the issue in 2011 and reduced the ratio. Now it's just 20:1.

Most crack users are black, and so, as a result, are disproportionately many prison inmates. Only 13% of the population is black. The other 87% continue to vote enthusiastically for politicians who are "tough on crime".

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by krichman on Monday June 24, 2013 @11:50PM (#5937406)
Or is it because they have human rights and aim to rehabilitate instead of punish.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by jrockway on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:36PM (#5936953)
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by scythe on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:55PM (#5937013)
This is an extremely damaging myth and it needs to die. Prison conditions in the US are, by and large, deplorable. Worse than anywhere in Europe. Worse than most of Latin America. We look like Iran.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_rights_in_the_United_Stat...

>Examples of mistreatment claimed include prisoners left naked and exposed in harsh weather or cold air;[120] "routine" use of rubber bullets[121] and pepper spray;,[120][121][121] solitary confinement of violent prisoners in soundproofed cells for 23 or 24 hours a day;[120][122] and a range of injuries from serious injury to fatal gunshot wounds, with force at one California prison "often vastly disproportionate to the actual need or risk that prison staff faced."[121] Such behaviors are illegal, and, "Professional standards clearly limit staff use of force to that which is necessary to control prisoner disorder."[121]

>Human Rights Watch raised concerns with prisoner rape and medical care for inmates.[123] In a survey of 1,788 male inmates in Midwestern prisons by Prison Journal, about 21% claimed they had been coerced or pressured into sexual activity during their incarceration and 7% claimed that they had been raped in their current facility.[124] Tolerance of serious sexual abuse and rape in United States prisons are consistently reported as widespread.[citation needed] It has been fought against by organizations such as Stop Prisoner Rape.

http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2012/10/solitary-confine...

>He's right about that. After being apprehended on the Iran-Iraq border, Sarah Shourd, Josh Fattal, and I were held in Evin Prison's isolation ward for political prisoners. Sarah remained there for 13 months, Josh and I for 26 months. We were held incommunicado. We never knew when, or if, we would get out. We didn't go to trial for two years. When we did we had no way to speak to a lawyer and no means of contesting the charges against us, which included espionage. The alleged evidence the court held was "confidential."

>What I want to tell Acosta is that no part of my experience—not the uncertainty of when I would be free again, not the tortured screams of other prisoners—was worse than the four months I spent in solitary confinement. What would he say if I told him I needed human contact so badly that I woke every morning hoping to be interrogated? Would he believe that I once yearned to be sat down in a padded, soundproof room, blindfolded, and questioned, just so I could talk to somebody?

>I want to answer his question—of course my experience was different from those of the men at California's Pelican Bay State Prison—but I'm not sure how to do it. How do you compare, when the difference between one person's stability and another's insanity is found in tiny details? Do I point out that I had a mattress, and they have thin pieces of foam; that the concrete open-air cell I exercised in was twice the size of the "dog run" at Pelican Bay, which is about 16 by 25 feet; that I got 15 minutes of phone calls in 26 months, and they get none; that I couldn't write letters, but they can; that we could only talk to nearby prisoners in secret, but they can shout to each other without being punished; that unlike where I was imprisoned, whoever lives here has to shit at the front of his cell, in view of the guards?

It is a crazy, awful, and unnecessary black mark on America's human rights record. There is no excuse for this sort of thing, and it happens every day. Other first-world countries get along fine without systematic mistreatment of nearly eight people in a thousand.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by samstave on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:56PM (#5937015)
Gunna need actual proof. I do not see any jail anywhere as a "resort"
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by zanny on Monday June 24, 2013 @07:22PM (#5936402)
Well, you had a lot of peer pressure in that pledge thing. If you sat and didn't pledge (hell, some teachers would force you to stand) your peers would become quite hostile.

I find that odd though, since most children love being rebellious over frivolous things like that.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by jlgreco on Monday June 24, 2013 @07:40PM (#5936474)
It is so utterly bizarre to ask children that young to "pledge" their allegiance to something. I didn't even have a functional understanding of what those words meant until I was much older, before then they were just words that I had memorized. But because it was introduced so young, it only had the opportunity to appear strange in retrospect...
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by enraged_camel on Monday June 24, 2013 @08:08PM (#5936603)
Young children are ridiculously easy to indoctrinate. You see this type of thing with religious education and upbringing all the time. A lot of adults are religious not because they chose to do so, but because they were brought up in religious households and their childhood activities involved going to church. As such, religion became a part of their identity.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by jlgreco on Monday June 24, 2013 @08:13PM (#5936614)
There do seem to be plenty of parallels; enough for me to feel confident that the mechanism is the same.

I wonder though if these systems were implemented accidentally or in a cool calculating way. The religion one seems like something that could bootstrap itself from true belief (if you honestly think that you have life figure out, chances are you are going to tell your kids), but the pledge one seems more calculated to me. There just really is no reason to have young children pledging allegiance to a flag and its government.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by cpher on Monday June 24, 2013 @08:19PM (#5936644)
Personally, I'm glad my children say the "pledge" every day to start school. Yes, I'm religious, but I'm also liberal on some things. For instance, I think anyone charged with marijuana possession should be freed from jail-- that's absurd in my opinion. However, you have to draw the line somewhere. My childrens' identity isn't tied to "religion" per se, but rather "faith." But I wouldn't expect someone with hostility towards religion/faith to get that...
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by jlgreco on Monday June 24, 2013 @08:21PM (#5936658)
What do you think the benefits of having them recite the pledge at school every single day are? Some sort of loyalty to government that could not be taught?

If you think loyalty to government is a good idea, that is fine, but why not teach them why that is the case? I'm sure you have plenty of good reasons lined up, so give them those reason instead of making them recite a pledge...

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by cpher on Monday June 24, 2013 @08:36PM (#5936717)
It has nothing to do with "loyalty to government." It's loyalty to the concept of a free country, where you can even choose not to say the "pledge." I really don't care what you do. The point of the pledge has nothing to do with a physical piece of cloth, and everything to do with the "republic for which it stands." That's the benefit. It's a reminder to be loyal to the people, not to the mechanisms of the government. The fact that people from all backgrounds/countries can be united under common principles is the point.

So, no, I don't teach my children loyalty to "government", but rather their country, which, up until recently was pretty free from their government.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by Helpful_Bunny on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:03PM (#5936824)
As a non-American responder, are you talking about the original pledge, or the 1948-1954 changes that added the words "under God" to it?[1] The original was formally adopted in 1942 by Congress, prior to this change:

The original: I pledge allegiance to my Flag and the Republic for which it stands, one nation indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

This change was largely brought about by the realization that the pledge was dangerously close to the NAZI party's way of indoctrinating Nationalism (however Fascistic it was)[2] and that there should be some manner to differentiate between the good, moral, American version and the evil, unethical German version.

Nationalism (and Socialism) were ideologies of the 19th Century, and America does not have a great history of citizenship for all, with certain cultures not sharing in it until post WW1.[3]

So, I'm afraid: the pledge does, and always has had, a streak of Nationalism a mile wide to it. I find the modern American denial of this fascinating.

And, if you cannot see how it is used to indoctrinate children, then I am happy to provide non-wiki specific psychology papers proving that it does.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pledge_of_Allegiance#Addition_... [2]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bellamy_salute [3]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_Citizenship_Act_of_1924

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by newbie12 on Monday June 24, 2013 @10:15PM (#5937083)
Actually adding "under God" happened in the 1950s and was about the Cold War and the fight against godless Communism.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by Helpful_Bunny on Monday June 24, 2013 @11:00PM (#5937263)
Please read what I wrote, and the links provided. I stated 1948-1954, and this is exactly correct:

Louis A. Bowman [in 1948], an attorney from Illinois, was the first to initiate the addition of "under God" to the Pledge. The National Society of the Daughters of the American Revolution gave him an Award of Merit as the originator of this idea...

President Eisenhower had been baptized a Presbyterian very recently, just a year before. He responded enthusiastically to Docherty in a conversation following the service. Eisenhower acted on his suggestion the next day and on February 8, 1954, Rep. Charles Oakman (R-Mich.), introduced a bill to that effect

The "Daughters of the American Revolution"[1] were a political group that had considerable influence in American politics pre-WWII and their initial drives had nothing to do with fears of Communism (they were also against the revocation of the Bellamy salute until the declaration of war in 1941). So, your blase claim is not wholly correct ~ they're also a fascinating element of female power within the United States and the influences of matriarchal organization "behind the scenes of power" are little known, sadly. Well worth looking into.

However, yes, of course this period includes "the Red Scare", and this pledge was tied into this new strand of the American National Psyche. I apologize, I assumed this was a given at this level of debate.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daughters_of_the_American_Revo...

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by jlgreco on Monday June 24, 2013 @10:34PM (#5937171)
Correct, though the Bellamy salute was phased out because of the Nazis.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by cpher on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:10PM (#5936850)
I'm talking about the current incarnation which makes the most sense to me anyway. I know there were different versions but I like the current version the best. And it's clearly the most "liberal" in language.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by jlgreco on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:26PM (#5936921)
The only differences between the current pledge and the pledge as it was many decades ago are superficial. Changing the salute and adding the (problematic for other reasons) reference to a god serve to change the appearance of the pledge, but not its substance. It remains as nationalistic as ever.

(Also, the addition of the words "under god" and a reference to a particular government hardly make it more "liberal"?)

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by jlgreco on Monday June 24, 2013 @08:45PM (#5936753)
The pledge is not teaching, it is brainwashing. If you value the notion of a free society (and I am sure that you do) then you should be able to teach that appreciation (and I am sure that you could, if you tried). Explain to them why it is something to be valued, don't merely have them accept it as axiomatic by having them repeat it ad nauseam.

Also, the pledge is absolutely to a particular government; I don't know how that could be any more clear.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by cpher on Monday June 24, 2013 @08:54PM (#5936790)
Your condescension does nothing to further your argument. And I'm quite happy with what I teach my children about their country--warts and all. I was simply replying to the GP about the pledge. If you don't like my opinion I don't care and you can go pound sand.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by jlgreco on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:17PM (#5936887)
I don't think there was condescension in my comment. I am saying that if you believe something, you should be able to defend it. I am confident that you are right, a free society is something that is to be valued, and I am confident that you could teach it. If you are also confident that you are right, then you don't need to brainwash your children to agree.

So if you are pleased with what you are teaching your children, as you claim, then why is the pledge important? Your lessons should carry sufficient strength. Brainwashing is the tool of people who are not confident in what they say; it is not a tool for you.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by cpher on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:36PM (#5936954)
Let me put this briefly: the pledge was used to teach children the basics of what this country values. You can argue that this is brainwashing. So, then, argue that teaching rote math and English rudiments is brainwashing. Children can't internalize the important concepts of the constitution when they're 5-6 yrs old. They can recite them for a while, but the ideas are too abstract until they get older. You say "indoctrination", I say "rote memorization until they can understand it."

Do you think my 5 & 6 yr olds will understand my explanation of what Snowden did, and why?

And, yes, there was lots of condescension in your comment, just so you know for the future...

If you value the notion of a free society (and I am sure that you do) then you should be able to teach that appreciation (and I am sure that you could, if you tried).

Not to be a dick, but if you were one of my personal friends and said that to me at a bar, I'd slap you in the nuts to get your attention. Maybe midwestern Americans take that differently.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by jlgreco on Monday June 24, 2013 @10:02PM (#5937039)
If children cannot understand the pledge, then they are too young for their loyalty to a free society to be important. Seriously, when could that issue come up for someone who is incapable of understanding it?

Furthermore, the pledge is not some sort of "teaching through rote repetition". If it were, then why is it not done in social studies or american government classes (you know, like rote memorization of arithmetic tables is done in mathematics classes), why the emphasis on ritual (you don't stand up, face the front of the room, and salute a multiplication table...), and why does it continue past school grades for toddlers? What place does "rote memorization of why freedom is rad" have any place in, say, high schools? Those children are surely capable of receiving a proper lesson. And they get those proper lessons... but for some reason the pledge continues.

I don't think your interpretation of what the pledge it is holds water in the slightest. You are trying to treat it as something that it simply is not.

> "Do you think my 5 & 6 yr olds will understand my explanation of what Snowden did, and why?"

I am suggesting nothing of the sort. Not sure why you would think I am suggesting that.

> "I'd slap you in the nuts to get your attention. Maybe midwestern Americans take that differently."

Yeah, on the coasts we don't take kindly to physical assault in retaliation for minor perceived slights. What the hell... I hope you are exaggerating.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by enraged_camel on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @12:57AM (#5937618)
>>Yeah, on the coasts we don't take kindly to physical assault in retaliation for minor perceived slights. What the hell... I hope you are exaggerating.

I hope he doesn't treat his kid that way... holy hell.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by cpher on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:04PM (#5943486)
No, i'm not advocating assault. Don't you ever slap your friends in the arm, or somewhere not as sensitive as your nuts, when you're trying to get their attention. That's what I meant--sorry to derail the conversation.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by enraged_camel on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @01:01AM (#5937631)
>>Let me put this briefly: the pledge was used to teach children the basics of what this country values. You can argue that this is brainwashing. So, then, argue that teaching rote math and English rudiments is brainwashing. Children can't internalize the important concepts of the constitution when they're 5-6 yrs old. They can recite them for a while, but the ideas are too abstract until they get older. You say "indoctrination", I say "rote memorization until they can understand it."

Memorization != Understanding.

Nobody says that they need to understand the importance of the Constitution when they are 5 or 6 years old. Wait a bit longer until they actually can understand it, and then teach it to them.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by krichman on Monday June 24, 2013 @11:54PM (#5937419)
You lost all credibility with me by claiming you would assault someone over an argument.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by cpher on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:06PM (#5943491)
Yes, my words were too strong, but we do frequently "rough house". I wouldn't literally hit someone there. But, you're right, it was out of line.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by phaus on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @01:12AM (#5937659)
Not every non-believer is hostile towards religion and/or faith.

I dislike the pledge because every time I hear it I'm reminded that Americans were once stupid enough to believe that modifying the words to it would be enough to thwart communist spies. It's like they forgot that athiests don't really acknowledge the concept of blasphemy.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by mpyne on Monday June 24, 2013 @08:24PM (#5936668)
Should I become Benevolent Dictator of some future anarchist America, the Pledge might actually be the first thing I get rid of. I'm of the opinion that if people are going to pledge allegiance to anything it will be because they want to, not because they were made to recite some prose.

Of course I know that opinion isn't exactly controversial around here.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by zanny on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @06:47AM (#5938562)
Well, foundationally here, if you want to talk about voluntarism all those kids are forced to be there, and their parents often don't have a power to stop it (too busy to homeschool, too poor to private school).
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by mpyne on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:51AM (#5939831)
There's a very compelling societal interest in having children receive a basic education though. We make kids get shots, require them to learn to drive to get a license, etc. for the same reason.

There's no compelling societal interest in brainwashing kids to claim to support a government (since even making them recite the Pledge hardly makes them more reliable citizens).

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by zanny on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @08:44AM (#5945617)
Public schooling often doesn't provide a basic education, though. The graduating illiteracy rates, lack of any retained historical knowledge ("is Britain a state? or "isn't Toronto in the US?") the inability to do basic arithmatic without a calaculator, etc.

It also doesn't teach anything close to critical thinking, problem solving, questioning fundamentals, or anything close to an exposure to career domains.

Also, the shots are at a parents discretion, even if peer pressure is applied. The choice to get a drivers license is inevitably on the child (you can't force them to take the test). Public education is compulsory by gunpoint (ie, imprisonment of parents who withhold their children from the public school system or homeschooled exams, though there are so many exceptions it is silly).

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by Cobbler on Monday June 24, 2013 @07:57PM (#5936558)
It is amazing how our institutions enroll their new members into their private agenda with intent to promote the longevity of the institution, in the long term, and their immediate survival, in the short term. In some strange way, we feed off our young and consume them, rather than nourish them. Sad
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by steveklabnik on Monday June 24, 2013 @11:26PM (#5937332)
> This is not a form of brainwashing. This is not a form of brainwashing. This is not a form of brainwashing. There is nothing creepy about having children pledge allegiance every morning to something they don't even understand...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=618U-_8o31k

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by casual_slacker on Monday June 24, 2013 @07:38PM (#5936466)
I rebelled against the pledge in my freshman year of high school. I don't remember any significant outcomes though, other than sitting through pledges until I started missing homeroom every day from ever-increasing laziness.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by msutherl on Monday June 24, 2013 @07:45PM (#5936501)
Likewise, I stopped pledging freshman year of high school with no significant consequences. At some point the school stopped doing the pledge.

On the other hand, a friend of mine was nearly suspended for wearing a military jacket with an upside-down American flag patch on the shoulder.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by Zimahl on Monday June 24, 2013 @08:18PM (#5936637)
To be fair, it's not like the US hasn't had it share of human-rights abuses before, just historically less than some other countries.

As for the Snowden extradition actually being a human-rights issue that's another story. I get that what he did was probably morally right but it was still illegal. I'm not sure why everyone is so shocked (SHOCKED, I say!) at the US wanting to prosecute him.

That said, the US would be smart to just forget about the whole thing. The damage has been done and this continued talk about prosecution for Snowden is making him a martyr.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by Andrew_Quentin on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @01:04AM (#5937642)
It is legal to hang homosexuals in Iran.

Jews were legally killed as far as the Nazis were concerned.

Just become something is legal - in this case a wrong assertion because spying on citizens is against the constitution so it is illegal - does not mean that it complies with Human Rights.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by Zimahl on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @02:24AM (#5937884)
Quite a stretch between divulging state secrets to anti-semitism and homophobia combined with murder.

The fact is that Snowden had the opportunity to quit when he found out what his work was going to entail or what his work was being applied to if he didn't approve. He continued to work and collect a paycheck. He knew he was breaking the law.

As much whining goes on here at HN about the lack of personal responsibility it's ironic that there's a ton of people so willing to not face the facts about the situation.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by genwin on Monday June 24, 2013 @07:31PM (#5936441)
It's cause & effect. Pledging allegiance to a flag rather than the Constitution promotes a 1984-like outcome.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by chc on Monday June 24, 2013 @08:11PM (#5936610)
I fail to see how it's better to pledge allegiance to a piece of paper than a piece of cloth. Surely both are symbolic of the general idea of "America" rather than the actual object.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by dwd on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:14PM (#5936872)
The constitution is the "legal" document that ratifies the formation of the United States of America so it is far from symbolic. If you do away with it you would effectively dissolve the Union.

In pledging allegiance to the constitution Snowdens' actions are only illegal in the sense that the current government has laws against what he did and justify those laws based on its constitutionally granted power. On the other hand every citizen has a responsibility to uphold the constitution, so his actions while illegal under the governments' laws are supported by the constitution and its founding principles.

Amnesty is coming from a different position where they are making their judgement based on the Universal Declaration of Human Rights of which the United States is a signatory.

Articles 12 through 14 make for interesting reading. http://www.un.org/en/documents/udhr/index.shtml#a12

EDIT: grammar

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by jimktrains2 on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:26PM (#5936924)
I wonder why noöne ever brings up article 16 when it comes to gay rights.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by dwd on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:41PM (#5936964)
Doesn't mention gender so by the letter you could read it as meaning marriage is strictly heterosexual.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by genwin on Monday June 24, 2013 @08:21PM (#5936656)
The kids should be taught about the Constitution and that they should support and defend it (especially the spirit of it) against all enemies foreign and domestic, even the President. That would mean rejecting any obvious wrongdoing and ignoring flag-waving rhetoric.

You can see a negative manifestation of the current Pledge when passing by an auto dealership, like this: http://www.thedetroitbureau.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/07/C...

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by snowwrestler on Monday June 24, 2013 @11:16PM (#5937307)
I love the U.S., but it's not a perfect country. And Amnesy International has been pointing it out for as long as I can personally remember being aware of them. (nearing 25 years now)

This is not nearly the first time AI has accused the U.S. of human rights abuses. Just look at the history of the death penalty in this country for one example.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by silvestrov on Monday June 24, 2013 @07:43PM (#5936490)
It seems like the US government has made it into a large-scale version of the Streisand effect.

If they had just ignored him, "oh, that crazy guy", ...

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by e3pi on Monday June 24, 2013 @07:58PM (#5936564)
My take is the Streisand effect is this his best shield and his strategy spins on it. "Booz, Endgame, etc" are burning night oil, Russia, Beijing, Mossad also, on how to best take advantage with some possibly horrible false flag options as well. I believe all these experienced ``spy craft'' agencies are capable of imagining their own strategic desirable outcomes far greater than you or I, some dangerous, high-risk "ops" of unforeseen consequences not necessarily desirable for Edward.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by olalonde on Monday June 24, 2013 @10:20PM (#5937110)
Today I learned that American kids need to pledge allegiance to their country. Or were you an immigrant and had to pledge allegiance in order to gain citizenship?
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by stinky613 on Monday June 24, 2013 @10:27PM (#5937135)
"Congressional sessions open with the recital of the Pledge, as do many government meetings at local levels, and meetings held by many private organizations. It is also commonly recited in school at the beginning of every school day, although the Supreme Court has ruled on several occasions that students cannot be compelled to recite the Pledge, or punished for not doing so."

"According to the United States Flag Code, the Pledge of Allegiance reads: I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all."

The "under God" part was added to distinguish us from 'godless communists'

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pledge_of_allegience

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by gajomi on Monday June 24, 2013 @10:28PM (#5937139)
It's a grade school ritual that usually takes place once a week or so at the start of the day. Some teachers found this to be silly and were eager to make sure kinds knew it was voluntary or would come up with a better way to spend the three minutes. But some teachers would take it very seriously...