News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by mindcrime on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:18PM (#5936892)
Just because it pisses the public off, that is no excuse for anyone to leak information at will, let alone be pardoned for it.

I call bullshit. The government exists to serve the people, not the other way around. What is "legal" or "illegal" is bigger than just what Congress, the President or the Supreme Court think. As they say, "An unjust law is no law at all".[1]

Certainly an arguable point, but it's one I adhere to, and I think a lot of other HN'ers do as well. As well as a lot of Americans, and, for that matter, a lot of people period.

[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lex_iniusta_non_est_lex

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by rayiner on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @12:25AM (#5937522)
They also say, "we are a government of laws, not of men." The government should enforce, and follow, the laws as they are written, not go by what one man or another considers to be "just" or "unjust."

And as a practical matter, the majority of Americans think Snowden should be prosecuted.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by gasull on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @12:33AM (#5937545)
That's not what this Gallup poll found:

http://www.gallup.com/poll/163043/americans-disapprove-gover...

44% say Snowden did the right thing, 42% say it was wrong.

53% disapprove Government surveillance.

59% say it was right for the newspapers to publish the info.

Also: 31% say he's a patriot, 23% say he's a traitor:

http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/06/12/us-usa-security-po...

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by rayiner on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @12:38AM (#5937557)
A Pew Research poll found that Americans believe Snowden should be prosecuted, by a substantial margin (54-38): http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2013/06/17/ameri....
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by gasull on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @01:02AM (#5937638)
I would like to know the exact question they were asked. It's easy to induce people into answering what you want if you use the right wording.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by danielweber on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @11:27AM (#5940122)
It can both be a good thing as well as something he should have to answer about in court.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by anigbrowl on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:40PM (#5943593)
The same point applies to the poll whose results you like.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by mindcrime on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:26AM (#5939619)
The government should enforce, and follow, the laws as they are written, not go by what one man or another considers to be "just" or "unjust."

What "the law" is at any point in time is just a reflection of what men (well, "people") think is just. Except in this country, our political system has become so corrupt that a significant body of what passes for "law" here is total bullshit. People should feel empowered to violate unjust laws. Personally, I encourage everybody to break a few laws each and every day, simply as a matter of principle.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by rayiner on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @12:57PM (#5940792)
> Except in this country, our political system has become so corrupt that a significant body of what passes for "law" here is total bullshit.

What you mean is that you and your friends think they are bullshit. As far as I can see, they are for the most part quite reflective of what American voters want (or is at least consistent with a compromise position of the wants of the various voting demographics).[1] Most Americans are afraid of terrorism and are okay with some level of government surveillance, though they might quibble about the details. They want the government to be very harsh on crime (and are scared of computer hackers), and want the drug war to continue.[2] They wanted their elected leaders to be Christians, etc. I don't see corruption, I see a reflection of the wants and fears of the people.

Now, I don't always agree with the voter consensus, but, frankly, I'd rather have the laws I disagree with than a system where we ask mindcrime and his friends what transcendent principles should govern the country.

I think somewhere along the way, some people got confused about the precise nature of our society. It is a republic with a strong democratic streak as a result of amendments in the 1800's. The purpose of the Constitution is to enshrine this system of majoritarian rule. "Rights" (i.e. principles by which the courts tell the democratically-elected branches what they can't do) are a part of the foundational principles, but we are not a libertarian society where the fundamental purpose of government is to protect rights.[3] Rights must be respected, but when it comes time to interpret the scope of a right, whether broadly or narrowly, in the face of a conflict with the laws promulgated by the elected branches, I think it's critical to keep in mind that "The United States shall guarantee to every State in this Union a Republican Form of Government" made it to the main body of the Constitution--search and seizure and the other rights were added after the fact.

[1] I think it's a crucially important fact to understanding this country that while Americans hate Congress as a whole, they historically love their particular representatives: http://www.gallup.com/poll/162362/americans-down-congress-ow.... Americans don't hate what their representative is doing (at least historically). They hate what other peoples' representatives are doing.

[2] I think it might be the case now that a slim majority of people might now want to see at least some decriminalization. However, I think the majority of voters still want to wage the drug war. The suburban soccer mom/dad demographic that shrilly preached "Just Say No!" at every school function every American student attended in the 1980's and 1990's is more politically active than ever, and has a good 15+ years of voting left in it.

[3] I think a good example of this distinction is Hong Kong (or at least, the idealized depiction of Hong Kong that is common on HN). Hong Kong doesn't have any democracy to speak of, but it does have a strong history of protecting rights. Many people might find Hong Kong preferable to the U.S. because they care more about rights than democracy.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by mindcrime on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @01:16PM (#5940964)
What you mean is that you and your friends think they are bullshit.

And?

As far as I can see, they are for the most part quite reflective of what American voters want (or is at least consistent with a compromise position of the wants of the various voting demographics).

Yeah, well, majority rule is bullshit too, so what's your point? The "system" we have in place tries to avoid the "tyranny of the majority" but no political system can ever really avoid some element of that. There's no point pretending that the system we have in place doesn't have flaws, and that individuals are not sometimes justified in stepping outside of that system.

Now, I don't always agree with the voter consensus, but, frankly, I'd rather have the laws I disagree with than a system where we ask mindcrime and his friends what transcendent principles should govern the country.

Then I suppose you should hope that I'm never on a jury. :-)

I don't see corruption

You must not be looking very hard. But, being part of "the system", I guess that should be expected. What we all see is influenced by our fundamental worldview, and you clearly have a fundamentally different worldview than I do. So we'll probably always disagree on this.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by rayiner on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @01:57PM (#5941247)
I'm not criticizing your world view, I'm explaining mine and my take on what I think is the most appropriate description of the nature of our society. Our system does try to avoid "tyranny of the majority" but to a point. It is not a system that puts "rights" first and relegates democracy to whatever is left after various broad and expansive rights instituted. Rather, "rights" are the exceptions to the general rule of democracy.

If there is an animating principle to the Constitution, I think it's the phrase "consent of the governed." When you tell a starving man he can't kill his neighbor and take his livestock, a freedom of action he was born with and retains in the state of nature, or else some government which has no stake in either his neighbor's property or his huger will punish him, I don't think it suffices to appeal to some supernatural "right to life" or "right to property." I think it is wrong to impose that system on people on any other basis than democratic consensus. And I think there is a reason the founders spent so much ink describing how the U.S. was based on "consent of the governed," a key distinction between the U.S. and Britain, while they were by and large happy to inherit the system of "rights" from common law English principles.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by mindcrime on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @06:50PM (#5942959)
Fair enough. Also, FWIW, I'm not one of the people who downvoted your post above. We may not agree, but I generally don't do the "downvote to express disagreement" thing.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by pfraze on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:48PM (#5936991)
True, but I'm not sure I'd say the laws against leaking government secrets are unjust. I'd say the various monitoring systems are potentially dangerous and unconstitutional, but those issues are separate from Snowden's charge.

Also, I'm not a lawyer, but I'm pretty sure that the nature of the leak will factor into his trial, which is where it should be evaluated (right?).

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by drcube on Monday June 24, 2013 @10:21PM (#5937112)
Because secret treason courts are where justice is best served? In the very country being accused of civil rights violations by the defendant?

And besides troop movements, names and locations of undercover operatives, and other specific information that could get people hurt or killed, why should the government keep secrets from its citizens for any reason? Or what does "consent of the governed" mean?

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by rayiner on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @12:34AM (#5937550)
> Because secret treason courts are where justice is best served?

What secret treason courts? Snowden is not charged with treason, and even if he were, he'd be tried in U.S. District Court.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by jasonlotito on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @12:25AM (#5937520)
> and other specific information that could get people hurt or killed,

You've described the loop hole for a slippery slope. And I promise you, the first suggestions would seem so reasonable. After all, you didn't mention the descriptions of the operatives. Or the supplies needed to support the troop movements. Both of which are not specifically described by you, but could easily be used against the troops and agents. Both of which are reasonable to keep secret...

But it's still a slope. We think we are here overnight, but we are not. PRISM didn't just happens. It's been in the making for decades before you were born.

That's the part we need to realize. Obama didn't do this. Bush didn't do this. Hell, your parents didn't do this. We've all done this, one way or the other. We've all been apart of this.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by mindcrime on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @11:13AM (#5940008)
True, but I'm not sure I'd say the laws against leaking government secrets are unjust.

I think you have to consider context. To flip it around, the law may or may not be inherently unjust, but breaking it may well be justified in some circumstances. Nominally, this is part of the reason we have juries, and why juries are able to make their determination on any basis they see fit... so they can allow for this kind of "fuzziness" to the law.

There's also a reason that prosecutors have discretion in choosing what charges to pursue, what sentence to seek, etc.

Now, you can argue that, given our system and all its checks and balances and protections, that Snowden should come home and face a trail in front of a jury of his peers. But you can also argue that, given all the publicity around the case, he's correct in saying that he won't get a fair trail. You could also argue that even a "fair trail" is unfair from the perspective of the individual being judged, if they don't consider themselves guilty of a crime.

At the end of the day, this whole idea of "justice" is not black and white, sadly.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by diminoten on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:54PM (#5937006)
You don't get to end-run the justice system by being popular in the eyes of the people.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by eksith on Monday June 24, 2013 @10:03PM (#5937044)
While popularity may be irrelevant, being "right" in the eyes of the people is what justice is all about. After all, the civil rights movement was fairly unpopular for a large part of the U.S. population. Regardless, the legal precedents set during that time were "right" and just.
Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by mpyne on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @11:11AM (#5939987)
You contradicted yourself from one sentence to the next.

The population overwhelmingly supported oppressing the black minority. But the legal system disregarded what the large majority thought and did the right thing anyways.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by eksith on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @03:56PM (#5941994)
In "eyes of the people is what justice is all about" please replace "people" with "court".

Sorry, not enough coffee.

Re:USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden by mpyne on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @04:03PM (#5942046)
Ah, ok