News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by magicalist on Sunday June 09, 2013 @08:33PM (#5851485)
Blow the whistle on what? The problem with the "conversation" going on in these threads is that no one is defining that first.

If we're talking about the first leaked version of PRISM, we still don't even know if it exists or how it works. Subsequent revisions have made it seem that if the NSA doesn't have the immediate ability to query the companies' backends, then they have some kind of carte blanche ability to ask for data and immediately receive it. If either of these are true, then certainly, where are the whistleblowers? If not, and there's a very real chance that neither of these are true, then the question doesn't make sense.

If instead we're talking about FISA orders, there's nothing secret to blow the whistle on. Everyone knew what they would allow. Congress was briefed on what they actually have allowed. The EFF has been in court for years (7 and 5 on different cases) to try to just figure out if their clients have standing to sue over FISA. Many of the companies on that PRISM list now have transparency reports that tell you exactly how they disclose data and provide numbers for requests (other than FISA, which you're not allowed to do). There's been tech blog coverage for years by sites like Ars Technica that discuss everything from the flawed ECPA to the attempts by the Obama administration to use national security as a guise to subvert all attempts to find out what these intelligence programs even do, let alone who they do them to. So, what did you expect them to blow a whistle on?

For instance, Google and Microsoft are both now reporting ranges of the NSLs they receive; in effect, a kind of whistleblowing, albeit a legal and vetted one. NSLs are very much like FISA orders, in that they contain gag orders and have minimal oversight (and no public oversight) for their approval. Where's the indignation and action over those?

If we're going for hindsight here, the real question is where the hell were the major news outlets and where the hell were the American people? Or why has Congress been willing to approve this program on multiple occasions? Assuming incompetence in all three of those groups, the usual response to those questions, is not an acceptable answer.

If instead we're actually looking to the future, we need to ask how we're going to hold the Obama administration and Congress's feet to the fire to make sure that this ends, and that any real search beyond basic information (in a very narrow scope!) requires probable cause demonstrated before a judge, and that notification of a warrant can't be gag-ordered and withheld indefinitely.

Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by LowKarmaAccount on Sunday June 09, 2013 @08:55PM (#5851587)
Section 215, known as the "business records" portion of The PATRIOT Act allows "FBI agents to obtain any "tangible thing," including "books, records, papers, documents, and other items," a broad term that includes dumps from private-sector computer databases, with limited judicial oversight."[1]

That Section 215 exits is public record. However, the government has a "secret interpretation" of the law that allows itself many more powers than what is written in the publicly accessible version.

Only congressmen on the Senate Intelligence committee were briefed on the secret interpretation. With the exceptions of Mark Udall and Ron Wyden, who tried warn the American public without revealing anything classified (in 2011), the rest of the congressmen on the committee did not have a problem with what the NSA was doing. Many of the congressmen on the SIC are ex-military or receive large campaign contributions from defense contractors and/or the intelligence community.

[1]: http://news.cnet.com/8301-31921_3-20067005-281.html

Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by brown9-2 on Monday June 10, 2013 @12:32AM (#5852400)
It would appear that the FISA court agrees with that interpretation as well, correct?
Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by LowKarmaAccount on Monday June 10, 2013 @02:16AM (#5852701)
The court's opinion is classified. The DOJ is trying to block a FOIA suit filed by the EFF to release the opinion.

https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2013/06/government-says-secret...

Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by shawn-butler on Monday June 10, 2013 @07:56AM (#5853697)
To be honest I don't really understand the EFF's position. The FOIA explicitly applies only to executive branch government agencies. The FISA court is fully under the control of the SCOTUS.

"...agency" as defined in section 551(1) of this title includes any executive department, military department, Government corporation, Government controlled corporation, or other establishment in the executive branch of the Government (including the Executive Office of the President), or any independent regulatory agency..."[0].

I suppose it might be possible to go after the briefs and evidence presented by the DoJ to the FISA court with FOIA requests but anything you would get would be redacted to nothing.

[0] [pdf]: http://www.justice.gov/oip/amended-foia-redlined-2010.pdf

Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by weland on Monday June 10, 2013 @02:34AM (#5852759)
Court opinions can be classified? What in the actual fuck?
Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by JanezStupar on Monday June 10, 2013 @03:48AM (#5852951)
In ex Yugoslavia we had secret laws, published by secret official journal and enforced by secret courts.

So you could easily get persecuted for breaking the law that you were prohibited to know it even existed.

The same was going on in east Germany and other socialist countries.

I warmly recommend watching The Lives of Others (http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0405094/) to those who haven't seen it yet.

Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by flyinRyan on Monday June 10, 2013 @04:48AM (#5853131)
Amusing that the US claimed victory in the cold war and then ends up adopting all their "enemies'" worst stuff.
Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by junto on Monday June 10, 2013 @08:26AM (#5853847)
They didn't give all those ex-Nazi scientists jobs for nothing you know.
Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by weland on Monday June 10, 2013 @04:07AM (#5853002)
My surprise was directed at the fact that people have this in a system advertised as democratic. I am quite well-acquainted with cases like those you quote.
Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by dllthomas on Monday June 10, 2013 @11:04AM (#5854878)
"Advertised as democratic" won't get you very far in predicting how democratic a country is.
Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by bbotond on Monday June 10, 2013 @03:26PM (#5856624)
The Soviet Union was advertised as democratic. Nazi Germany was advertised as democratic. Communist China was/is advertised as democratic.
Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by discodave on Monday June 10, 2013 @08:14PM (#5858607)
My old debating coaches saying was that any country with 'democratic' or 'peoples' in it's name was most certainly not either of those things.
Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by weland on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @03:38AM (#5866987)
Aye, but no Chinese without political involvement and no mental problems would freely claim (and believe!) he's a free man living under a democratic regime.
Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by gizzlon on Monday June 10, 2013 @05:41AM (#5853267)
This seriously sounds like Kafka's The trial :( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Trial)
Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by maratd on Monday June 10, 2013 @03:40AM (#5852926)
Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by mtgx on Monday June 10, 2013 @05:01AM (#5853167)
"In its response filed with the FISC today, the government offers a circular argument, asserting that only the Executive Branch can de-classify the opinion, but that it is somehow prohibited by the FISC rules from doing so."

It seems to me the FISA Court still has the power the make the ruling public, even if the government classified it. It wouldn't be the first time a judge overrules classified information, right?

It seems to me the judges are accomplices to the government (why would they still grant the warrants, if they already found it unconstitutional?), and even if there was some kind of conflict in the law, I assume they would know this could go to the Supreme Court and it would be solved there.

Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by rtkwe on Monday June 10, 2013 @10:54AM (#5854798)
IIRC only the Supreme Court can really decide on constitutionality other judges are just supposed to follow the laws laid out by Congress.
Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by brown9-2 on Monday June 10, 2013 @09:30AM (#5854162)
Then why did the court re-authorize the Verizon order in April 2013?
Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by zt on Sunday June 09, 2013 @09:29PM (#5851734)
I'm just not sure there are easy answers in any direction here. Should they have the program at all? If they should, did they choose the right parameters? If the parameters are right, is the oversight adequate to both preventing misuse of these undeniably broad powers and making the rest of us feel like it is still, in the end, our government? Who should make each of those decisions? Given democratic uncertainty over whether all the forgoing are within spitting distance of 'correct' (whatever that means), what is any individual actor's responsibility -- even assuming he has full knowledge of the program -- to undermine most of those decisions when he feels it's wrong? How wrong would he have to feel it was, and on what axes?
Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by flyinRyan on Monday June 10, 2013 @04:50AM (#5853136)
There are easy answers here: there should be no program at all. Terrorism is no legitimate threat to the US and never has been. Any time you give the government the ability to override checks and balances, they are already abusing that ability (and usually want it applied to previous behavior so they can't be prosecuted for past infractions).
Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by dhimes on Monday June 10, 2013 @09:46AM (#5854248)
I hold a less extreme position, that (1) The laws should have a two-year sunset clause (2) The government should have to prove the law's efficacy to the public. Fuck this 'it works but we can't tell you' bullshit. (3) We have to understand full well that when we allows these laws they will be used fully. I don't think it takes an evil person for this to be true. I think most of us, if we were given the responsibility of protecting the public and the authority for doing so, we would use that authority. Nobody wants to be the guy that people look back on after a terrorist act and say, 'but YOU could have prevented this.' Look at all the grief the spooks are getting with this 'Marathon Bomber' kid (Tsarnaev). Apparently they were warned that he could be a threat. But they respected his rights and let him be free. And now they are being accused of being incompetent.
Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by moultano on Sunday June 09, 2013 @09:10PM (#5851652)
>If not, and there's a very real chance that neither of these are true, then the question doesn't make sense.

Particularly since every tech company leader (and the NSA) are insisting that neither is true.

Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by leoc on Sunday June 09, 2013 @10:59PM (#5852040)
This is just it. This time last week it was public knowledge that (for example) Google complied with FISA 702 orders. Now it's public knowledge that Google complies with FISA 702 orders, using a workflow-automation system. There are hints of extra reasons to be more worried than before, but so far it seeems they're all either speculative or disputed:

(I'll keep talking about Google specifically just to narrow things down for now.)

* NYT suggested that FISA orders can be broad and shallow ("a broad sweep for intelligence, like logs of certain search terms") instead of narrow and deep (eg. everything on person or company X), but CNET's source contradicted that https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5845878 .

* The Washington Post used language which suggested that Google's lawyers may have been taken out of its FISA-702-order-execution loop altogether, but NYT contradicts that and Google has denied it https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5847846 .

* The Verizon mega-warrant suggests that NSA might be gathering data under similarly broad FISA orders, something that (like broad-and-shallow orders) would make "no direct access" a lot less meaningful, but that's been denied by Google https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5847959 and the various anonymous sources seem to be contradicting it too.

* The NYT article http://www.nytimes.com/2013/06/08/technology/tech-companies-... seemed to hint at the possiblity that the Google lawyers processing FISA orders could be suffering some kind of reverse regulatory capture or that Larry Page and Chief Legal Officer David Drummond could have lost track of the extent and nature of what they were approving. There doesn't seem to be any specific evidence for that though.

One thing that does seem to be true is that if you make it more convenient for the NSA to get data under FISA 702 orders it will respond by getting a lot more of it. Apparently the NSA's PRISM stack boasts of a 63% increase in the number of communications obtained in 2012 from Google http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/jun/06/us-tech-giants-n... (and much larger increases at other companies). Still, it seems the PRISM system hasn't - or at least, hasn't yet! - facilitated an order-of-magnitude or game-changing increase in the scale of FISA 702 snooping. Overall there doesn't seem to be any great change in what we think we know http://www.wired.com/images_blogs/threatlevel/2013/05/fisaca... about that.

So, unless some of those hinted worries are true, there doesn't seem to be anything very big that Larry Page could have brought to our attention that wasn't public knowledge last week already. The biggest news is probably the increase in the scale of the data requested, and if Page cared enough about that he could presumably just have done a Twitter and declined to build a semi-automatic pipeline...

(IANAL or anything else.)

Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by declan on Monday June 10, 2013 @03:14AM (#5852872)
Not a bad summary. (I wrote one of the articles you cited.)
Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by jesseendahl on Monday June 10, 2013 @05:01AM (#5853169)
One more. The new slide released yesterday:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/jun/08/nsa-prism-server...

Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by rdl on Sunday June 09, 2013 @08:38PM (#5851503)
What exactly happens if you just don't respond to a FISA warrant?
Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by mpyne on Sunday June 09, 2013 @08:42PM (#5851526)
Well it's a real (if secret) court, so I assume it would be what normally happens for contempt of court.
Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by eightyone on Sunday June 09, 2013 @09:12PM (#5851661)
It's my understanding that the secret court ruled the primary legal justification for PRISM (FISA Section 702) as unconstitutional. The Justice Department is trying to keep that ruling as secret as possible. [1] So, really, what would they do?

[1] https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2013/06/government-says-secret...

Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by Andrew_Quentin on Sunday June 09, 2013 @10:39PM (#5851977)
How can they rule the justification as unconstitutiona when the judges were giving court orders under that justification?

More broadly though, I don't understand how you can possibly have secret courts. Justice not only must be done but must be seen to be done, otherwise its not justice.

Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by JanezStupar on Monday June 10, 2013 @03:52AM (#5852963)
Secret courts are not about justice.

They are about masking injustice behind the veil of "law".

Since US is a country with long tradition of rule of law. The easiest way of subverting the rule of law is by subverting the concept of a judge and of a court.

There.

Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by eightyone on Sunday June 09, 2013 @10:53PM (#5852022)
I'm not a lawyer, but I believe they declared only part of FISA unconstitutional. The part they declared unconstitutional happens to be the primary crux of the legal argument for PRISM.

I don't understand how you can have secret courts either. It's a perversion of what this country was founded upon.

Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by rdl on Monday June 10, 2013 @12:20AM (#5852368)
I'm personally most interested in ACLU's challenges about Tor/VPN providers and FAA.
Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by jes5199 on Sunday June 09, 2013 @08:47PM (#5851544)
What sort of consequences can they impose without revealing the existence of the secret court?
Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by mpyne on Sunday June 09, 2013 @08:53PM (#5851567)
The existence of the court itself is not secret, the proceedings are. But they could issue a fine or jail sentence without leaking the rest of the proceedings themselves, if I understand the legal process right.

Edit: Way to mind-meld on the comments, team. Holy crap.

Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by invisible on Sunday June 09, 2013 @11:33PM (#5852181)
Your edit just reminds me of all of the people screaming that all of the companies wrote their stories using a "template" because each press release they put out sounded similar and used similar words. Heh...
Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by steveklabnik on Sunday June 09, 2013 @08:55PM (#5851586)
The existence of the court isn't secret, it's the proceedings that are.
Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by davmre on Sunday June 09, 2013 @08:53PM (#5851566)
The existence of the court is not secret, only its proceedings.
Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by mcherm on Monday June 10, 2013 @09:36AM (#5854195)
Also its members and its decisions.
Re:Why didn't tech company leaders blow the whistle? by ekianjo on Monday June 10, 2013 @01:07AM (#5852517)
> Or why has Congress been willing to approve this program on multiple occasions?

From what Obama said, "Congress was informed", it was not asked to approve anything. That's very different.