News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by ChrisNorstrom on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @01:42AM (#5784806)
These gifs are pretty much useless in showing the real destruction because they're only looking back 30 years and showing the changes of little plots of land here and there.

If you compare North America today with what it was before Europeans landed. You'd see a truly horrifying picture. Something like 70% of the forests of North America are gone. Just load up google maps in satellite mode and look at the USA. Farms and settlements are literally everywhere. Brazil too has lost a massive chunk. Entire forests along the ocean are gone. So has europe. And in Australia Koalas are becoming endangered because of the loss of their habitat. In Asia, rain forests are being cut down for palm oil plantations. And don't even get me started on the "Great African Land Grab" in which rich countries bought prime fertile African land for pennies per hectare.

This continues to this day: 6 percent of [the US lost it's] forest cover in just five years time, a total of 120,000 square kilometers (46,332 square miles)

( http://news.mongabay.com/2010/0427-hance_forestloss.html#PuE... )

Let's not forget the enormous swaths of plastic swimming around in all the major oceans: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Pacific_garbage_patch

The fact that more than half of all the streams in the USA are too polluted to support normal life: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2300022/More-HALF-U-...

And don't get me started on particles from the pollution in China crossing the Pacific Ocean and entering the US Eastern Coast. As well as residents living near highways have a 27% increase in Asthema. And the list goes on and on.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by SiVal on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @02:32AM (#5784951)
No, at the risk of "getting you started", I'm not "horrified" at the loss of 70% of the North American forest over the past 500+ years, if that is, in fact, the correct statistic. Try running the film in reverse, regrowing the lost forest at the cost of 95+% of the people. Would that be an absolute delight, the undoing of the horror, the horror?

Clearly it would be to some people, but not to me. I'm hardly arguing in favor of eliminating the remaining 30% of the forest and adding another billion or so North Americans. Being okay with some change doesn't mean I prefer the maximum amount of change. It's just that as I drive from coast to coast, as I have done more than once, I'm not overwhelmed with the horror of the landscape.

I am willing to work to clean up the mess we humans so often make and to take steps to avoid ruining things we can't fix. I don't want to live on a pile of garbage, and it does take constant effort to avoid letting garbage of various sorts (trash dumps, dirty water, smoggy air) get out of control. Sometimes we fail, and we need to do something about it. I'm especially worried about damage that is not obvious---the oceans come to mind.

But no, I'm not horrified at the thought of North America having 70% fewer trees than we had 500 years ago, if that's the real number. I want to take proper safeguards with respect to the environment, human health, human living standards, crime, political and economic freedoms, education, and numerous other important issues, but sometimes I think that some people get uncomfortably "religious" about the environment in particular. I'm not one of them.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by api on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @01:10PM (#5787582)
As George Carlin said: "Stop talking about saving the Earth. The Earth is fine. We're fucked."

One of the things I hate about green ideology is that it frames this issue in selfless religious moralistic terms when it's really all about pure self-interest.

To what extent can we continue doing this? For how long? We depend on these ecological systems, and the economic cost of replacing them would be far beyond our capacity to invest (if it's even within our technical capability). We depend on many, many resources that are presently being extracted far faster than their rate of formation, with fossil fuels being chief among these. Couriscant in Star Wars is fiction, and is likely impossible even with imaginary post-singularity-level technology. Its climate would have little or nothing to regulate it, and its atmosphere would revert to pre-photosynthesis reducing composition.

Less than a thousand years after mass die-off and the collapse of global civilization into a new dark age, most of the "damage" will be gone. This is less than a microsecond on geological timescales. The planet will be fine.

Such brutal die-offs have occurred before many times in geological history, and it's absurdly naive to think that it couldn't happen to us. Nature doesn't care about us. It doesn't care how much we suffer or how many of us die. We have to worry about that, or nothing will.

And even if it doesn't happen suddenly, there's the whole quality of life issue. Do we really want to live in a b-grade cyberpunk dystopia of endless ugly sprawl, routine Fukushima/BP Macondo type industrial disasters, increasing pollution, commodity hyperinflation, and unattainably distant gaps between the rich and everyone else? Because that might be what an ecologically depleted world looks like: a few super-rich demigods presiding over massive seething ghettoes policed by drones. That would also be a new dark age.

Edit: it might help people understand if we tried to estimate the cost of replacing these ecological systems with artificial industrial replacements. I'm gonna guesstimate somewhere in the neighborhood of 10,000X current world GDP.

You could probably arrive at an estimate by working backwards and assuming thermodynamic efficiencies at reconstructing the biosphere in the 10-15% neighborhood. So SUM(GDP,1012AD,2012AD) / 0.15?

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by johnchristopher on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @05:11AM (#5785349)
> [...] but sometimes I think that some people get uncomfortably "religious" about the environment in particular. I'm not one of them. [...]

Could it be, maybe, that your statements reflect the thought of some people that might be denying ecological disasters ?

What's religious about being horrified at the loss of 70% of the North American Forest ? If that is indeed the correct number (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deforestation_in_the_United_Sta... : a 25% loss for the US with a stabilized 20th century but this here http://www.globalchange.umich.edu/globalchange2/current/lect... hints that primary forest area aren't counted the same way http://www.globalchange.umich.edu/globalchange2/current/lect...)... What's wrong with being religious, anyway ?

> It's just that as I drive from coast to coast, as I have done more than once, I'm not overwhelmed with the horror of the landscape.

May it be because you can't compare to the same ride 500 years ago and so the impact doesn't sink in ?

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by jerf on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @09:46AM (#5786210)
"Could it be, maybe, that your statements reflect the thought of some people that might be denying ecological disasters ?"

That is a nakedly emotionally manipulative reply with no substance. I mean this judgment to apply to your entire post, just quoted the worst part.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by johnchristopher on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @02:09PM (#5787943)
> That is a nakedly emotionally manipulative reply with no substance.

That is the effect I wanted to achieve in order to better parody and criticize parent's own manipulative wording: "some" people, "sometimes", veiled attempt to accuse opponents of being "religious", etc. I thought it was more obvious, sorry.

Next time I'll just state it plainly like you did (no irony).

For what it's worth I couldn't find any numbers regarding the 70% loss and what it really refers to.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by jerf on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @02:28PM (#5788062)
Heh, yes, that never works. To be clearly a parody one must post something that would "obviously" never be posted seriously by someone. This turns out to be a high bar. Especially in emotional areas like environmentalism.
Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by sageikosa on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @10:17AM (#5786379)
Maybe because 5 billion years ago there wasn't anything life-like going on around these parts. Many changes have occurred since then, and many will occur yet again.

Not every genetic sequence is sacred, and the vast majority that modern taxonomy would consider "species" have come and gone without me shedding a tear.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by enraged_camel on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @01:18PM (#5787633)
That is correct, but which species before humans has caused so much change to the environment in such a short time?

Sure, there's the natural eb and flow of the environment. But that tends to happen over very long periods of time. When you're talking about 70% of forests being destroyed within 500 years though, that's something else entirely. Make no mistake: the change our planet has gone through over that short time period is unprecedented.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by hnaccount8888 on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @02:00PM (#5787888)
Make no mistake: the change our planet has gone through over that short time period is unprecedented.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/K/T_event

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by enraged_camel on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @04:42PM (#5788928)
Context is king. The T event was caused by a meteor, as opposed to a species.
Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by sageikosa on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @03:31PM (#5788543)
> That is correct, but which species before humans has caused so much change to the environment in such a short time?

None. And I don't think mankind should hold itself back due to the other "species" lack of initiative.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by ChrisNorstrom on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @10:42PM (#5790561)
Do you live in the USA? Do you know how notorious we are for paving over land with strip mall parking lots that will never be anywhere near full? How we run from our problems rather than solving them? How we move further and further away from the city, create massive traffic from the long commutes, and in turn move further and further away again? How county folks strike down and red tape high density apartments anywhere near their neighborhood, even vote against light rail and trollies because they're afraid the overhead wires will "lower their property value". We create neighborhoods that require a 3 mile drive just to get to your neighbors house a few yards away: http://www.chrisnorstrom.com/2011/10/the-great-cul-de-sac-pr... We're really bad at city planning.
Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by Zimahl on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @02:00AM (#5784850)
I can't speak to the forest practices of S. America or other continents but regarding US and Canadian forest practices that article is complete FUD.

First, it equates 'forest loss' to legitimate forest management - grow, cut, replant. Second, there is more forests now than there were in 1930 (I'll find the source in the morning). Now that's a slightly dubious stat since post-railroad logging there was only natural regrowth but we manage our forests very, very well these days.

The last place for environmental concern in the US and Canada should be to the forests. It's in everyone's interest to have healthy forests - from the logger to the landowner to the mill worker to the multinational.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by johnchristopher on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @05:24AM (#5785378)
From disparate information I gathered it seems second growth forest don't come with the same ecology (animals, fungus, etc.) so the argument could be made that regrown managed forest don't equate primary forests. I am not sure I am proponent of this argument but it seems to make sense.
Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by specialist on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @11:07AM (#5786662)
Yup. Tree farms are not habitat.

I have no problem with timber companies managing their tree farms, so long as they protect water ways (offsets), slopes (no clear cuts causing mud slides), etc. I also think we need new management practices (eg permit more smallers fires to reduce likelihood of huge fires).

My problem is when timber companies must extract every board foot from every acre, threatening critical habitat, from public forests. To add insult to injury, we (the public) build the roads, and sell the timber at a loss.

I wouldn't mind so much if the mythical "free market" was working, so that timber, mining, fishing, and ranching companies actually paid fair market price for the resources they're stealing.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by Zimahl on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @12:41PM (#5787356)
Tree farms are not habitat.

How is a 40 year old forest not habitat?

My problem is when timber companies must extract every board foot from every acre, threatening critical habitat, from public forests. To add insult to injury, we (the public) build the roads, and sell the timber at a loss.

Lies, lies, and more lies. Have you even been to a cut down forest within the last 20 years? Streams have required easements, there are requirements for leaving a number of trees per acre and any logging roads are paid for by the landowner. The roads are a cost of the harvesting.

...actually paid fair market price for the resources they're stealing.

You act like it's a quick turn around. We are talking decades after replanting, there are very few industries that have to follow this. And then, after waiting all that time, you need to hope that the market isn't in the state that it's currently in. Domestic timber is in the dumpster right now due to foreign logs and a lack of new housing.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by enraged_camel on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @01:24PM (#5787670)
>>How is a 40 year old forest not habitat?

Did you not read the parent's comment? 40 year old forests are not habitat because they don't come with the same ecology. It takes a very, very long time for a proper ecosystem to establish in an area. 40 years is not enough for that.

I went camping in Holland ten years ago. Almost all the forests there are second growth forests. As we were setting up our tents, my buddy stopped in his tracks and motioned at me to hush. In the silence, do you know what we heard?

Absolutely nothing.

No birds, no insects, no forest animals or any kind. It was eerily quiet. It was a forest alright, but it had no ecosystem. It was the most bizarre camping experience I've ever had.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by Zimahl on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @02:34PM (#5788112)
So obviously you didn't read my original post where I said I was talking about the US and Canada exclusively, which the parent comment was responding to.

Go into Canada and the US and camp. Railroad logged anywhere from 150 to 100 years ago, second growth logged from then on. Birds. Deer. Elk. Insects. Owls (even Spotted ones!). Fish in the streams.

The US and Canada isn't Europe. This continent has been largely undisturbed until about 300 years ago, and most of it untouched until the last 100 years. We've seen Europe's folly and fortunately didn't make the same mistakes or at least have had time to correct the problem. We also didn't have 2 world wars march across our lands, no trenches, no mustard gas.

Much of N. America from just east of the Rockies to the Pacific Ocean is amazing forests. We've made our mistakes with forestry but have atoned and things have healed up nicely. Now we manage the forests for the good of everybody - everyone can have what they want without sacrificing the quality of that resource.

Don't be so blind as to just blanket all logging in the world as 'logging bad'.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by specialist on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @02:51PM (#5788253)
Lies, lies, and more lies.

Nice.

Domestic timber is in the dumpster right now due to foreign logs and a lack of new housing.

Um, no. Timber, pulp, paper are all cyclic. Always have been, always will be.

We are talking decades after replanting, there are very few industries that have to follow this. And then, after waiting all that time, you need to hope that the market isn't in the state that it's currently in.

We're talking about public lands. What are you talking about?

I care little what timber companies do with the land we gave them last century. But if they're cutting down OUR trees on OUR land, then they have to replant that acreage. If they can't do that profitably, then too bad. There is no right to profit.

Don't be so blind as to just blanket all logging in the world as 'logging bad'.

You said it. Not me. Projection much?

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by Zimahl on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @03:04PM (#5788360)
I care little what timber companies do with the land we gave them last century. But if they're cutting down OUR trees on OUR land, then they have to replant that acreage. If they can't do that profitably, then too bad. There is no right to profit.

You have shown you know very little of the timber industry. Private landowners are under the same laws with respect to replanting as the public lands are. Public lands are logged, sold, and the profits returned to the public in the same free market system. No matter, it ALL has to be replanted.

On what planet do you think someone is just letting perfectly good land that can support a forest just sit barren? Unless it's re-zoned into something else, that's not profitable nor sustainable. Our forests are very sustainable.

Timber, pulp, paper are all cyclic. Always have been, always will be.

If you think the pulp and paper industry will ever be what it once you are fooling yourself. In the electronic age paper is far down it's not even funny. I grew up in a pulp and paper town that is a shell of what it once was.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by specialist on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @04:53PM (#5789000)
I grew up in a pulp and paper town that is a shell of what it once was.

Blame automation. Full stop.

But look at the bright side. Twilight themed tourism is booming.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by Zimahl on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @05:22PM (#5789198)
Snark aside, you are showing your spots and how little you know. Forks is not a pulp and paper town. It's a logging town. Thus, I didn't grow up in Forks.

You're just plain wrong about automation, that isn't what is killing the pulp and paper mills. If that were the case the mills and the companies associated with those mills would be doing fine - just with less people. No, the mills themselves are in decline due to a lack of use for their product.

E-books, electronic documents, decline of newspapers. This isn't the 70s, this is a paperless world and only going to get more so.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by specialist on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @06:17PM (#5789573)
No contest the decline of print media is effecting the paper industry.

It's been a while since I've looked (or cared). I've long assumed growth in pulp tracked with the economy. I didn't consider increased recycling or the economic crash (2008). Either way, I couldn't quickly find info (e.g. Wolfram Alpha).

We're talking past each other. I really don't care about the fortunes of the timber, pulp, paper industries. They've been terrible stewards of the earth. You say they've improved. Sorry, I just can't imagine that.

It's possible that the "fallow" restored forests of the northeast (mentioned upthread) are the future for elsewhere. Maybe. I don't see it in the short term. Between the pine beetle and ever greater risk of forest fires (in hindsight the bad burn mgmt as well as drying due to climate change), our forests are in trouble. To say nothing of sprawl and over development in fire prone areas...

Any way.

You really need to cut out the ad hominen. You're convinced you're right and I'm a noob. Fine. I feel you're just repeating industry misinformation. Fine. But there's no discourse when you sink to throwing around insults.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by Zimahl on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @07:35PM (#5789975)
I feel you're just repeating industry misinformation.

Industry misinformation or the actual laws for the states of Washington and Oregon, which follow countless other states and provinces in the Western US and Canada? You on the other hand are stuck repeating misinformation from the 80's anti-logging spotted owl rhetoric.

BTW, it's hardly an ad hominem. I'm not attacking you personally to discredit what you are saying - what you are saying is just factually wrong.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by specialist on Thursday May 30, 2013 @12:14AM (#5790890)
More projection. I have no idea what you're talking about.

You got sideways when people (correctly) pointed out that tree farms are not the same as rain forests. Much like how a corn fields is not a wetland.

Utterly uncontroversial.

But you imagined a slight and made it personal.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by talmand on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @10:59AM (#5786608)
That's true, but you could also go with the notion that for every acre of managed timber land there could be an acre, if not more, of untouched primary forest.

Hopefully anyway.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by asmithmd1 on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @06:31AM (#5785545)
The forest cover in New England is almost 80% - about what it was when the Pilgrims landed. Since hitting a low below 40% in 1830 it is now the most forested region in the US as well as one of the most densely populated.

http://www.wildlandsandwoodlands.org

How did this happen? People stopped trying to eke out a living farming the thin rocky soil during the short growing season and went to work at the mills and factories.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by smackfu on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @10:26AM (#5786420)
Yep, it's quite common in New England to find stone walls in the middle of a forest, that used to be on the edge of a field. Further, it's kind of amazing to think that the woods down the street had someone pull all the rocks out at some point... makes you reconsider what you consider "natural".
Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by asmithmd1 on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @02:06PM (#5787924)
And makes you reconsider what hard work is.
Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by kokey on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @07:59AM (#5785757)
It also helps that we can transport food over longer distances, have working markets to facilitate this, and crop yields having tripled since the 60s, and if it wasn't for biofuels the US would have been reducing the amount of land for agriculture instead of increasing it.
Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by talmand on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @10:56AM (#5786597)
It also helps that we actively do our best to prevent and put out forest fires.
Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by dpark on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @02:30PM (#5788080)
People also stopped cutting down all the trees to heat their homes. Moving to fossil fuels for heating meant that people could reasonably keep trees on their property without needing to cut them down for firewood (and without neighbors cutting them down for the same reason).
Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by downandout on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @07:46AM (#5785702)
Why is it that so many left-wing rants leave me with the unnerving impression that their authors care more about Koalas than humans? You created an impressive list of eco-complaints, but the simple fact is that human life expectancy - my primary concern as a human - has risen dramatically in the same 30 years. Perhaps a little more focus on humans and a little less on sad Koalas will keep us on track toward even higher life expectancy.
Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by rayiner on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @08:15AM (#5785805)
Human life expectancy rising over that period has nothing to do with the lost forest cover. Indeed, the vast majority of the increase is due to a few relatively low-tech advances targeted at reducing infant mortality.
Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by marknutter on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @08:47AM (#5785929)
relatively low-tech advances that were made possibly by modern civilization, which was made possible by our expansionism.
Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by rayiner on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @08:49AM (#5785938)
That's hardly an iron-clad causal chain there. I'm pretty sure penicillin would have happened whether or not we deforested California and turned it into a giant collection of freeways and parking lots.
Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by marknutter on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @09:02AM (#5786004)
Penicillin isn't the only medical advancement from the past 100 years that is contributing to our high life expectancy rates.
Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by rayiner on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @09:16AM (#5786065)
Yes, but the majority of the improvements stem from a handful of relatively low-tech things: antibiotics, clean water, improved nutrition, urbanization leading to most births happening in the presence of a medical professional, social changes reducing pregnancy among young teenagers, and a handful of key vaccines. Its not blockbuster cancer drags driving the increase.
Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by downandout on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @03:32PM (#5788548)
The point is that deforestation obviously isn't killing us.
Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by aerique on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @10:38AM (#5786493)
Maybe because many "left-wing" people think it would actually be good to trade in a couple of years of life expectancy to make the world a better place for other living beings than just humans?

At least I think it would be a good thing to focus less on humans now that there's 6 billion of us.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by specialist on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @11:10AM (#5786687)
Citation needed.

Left wing thought, in my world, is creating the maximum benefit for the maximum number of people. We against "robbing peter to pay paul".

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by wtbob on Thursday May 30, 2013 @01:31PM (#5793879)
> Left wing thought, in my world, is creating the maximum benefit for the maximum number of people. We against "robbing peter to pay paul".

But that's exactly what welfare is: robbing Peter to pay Paul!

(yes, I'm aware that folks claim stuff like, 'ah, but if we rob Peter nicely than there's less risk of Paul robbing and killing him, so really Peter's expected value is higher if we rob him')

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by emddudley on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @12:40PM (#5787346)
I think your question is a philosophical one. What is the proper role of the human species in Earth's ecology? It sounds like you think "might makes right", and that any choice which maximizes human life expectancy is the right choice.

It saddens me to think that people are willing to push so many living organisms to extinction, just to make our lives a little more comfortable and last a little bit longer. I think it is important to protect life, in all its forms.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by danmaz74 on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @11:13AM (#5786700)
So, if human life expectancy went up doing X, we're guaranteed that it will still go up if we continue to do X? That's the same reasoning that caused so many bubbles.

I'm no tree-hugger, but also from a purely egoistical point of view I worry about the consequences of the very fast changes we're causing to the environment in which humans evolved and to which we are adapted. Nothing guarantees that the changes will lead to an environment that can sustain 6+B human beings, so trying to predict the consequences is a very wise thing to do.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by specialist on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @02:56PM (#5788291)
False equivalency.

Conserving the koalas is done at the expensive of corporate profits, not human lives.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by ChrisNorstrom on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @07:33PM (#5789967)
Our life expectancy doesn't go up by fucking the place up and mismanaging sustainable living. Just because I care about other species and the planet that live on (you know, it's not easy to find a planet that can sustain life) doesn't mean I'm a left-wing liberal. FYI, I'm independent.

There's 7 billion of us and growing. We can take care of ourselves and our life spans are nearing 80-90 years, animals that took billions of years to evolve into their current species are being wiped out because we have selfish attitudes. We're draining the water tables and fucking over the oceans. Aside from the medical advances to help ourselves, we're screwing EVERYONE and EVERYTHING on this planet.

"But what about us humans?" What about us? Being on every continent other than Antarctica isn't enough?

Also, we lost 160 million people in wars just in the 20th century alone. At least Koalas & Gorillas won't send your family to a concentration camp, invade your country, slaughter your citizens, get drunk and slam into your family van, rape and kill, or fuck your children. Frankly, I'd rather help the animals keep their habitat than help humanity grow it's population. At least animals don't ask for taxes or welfare. Animals won't rob you at gun point. Leave them in their forest and they'll be happy and leave you alone.

Being a human and being more intelligent than other species doesn't entitle you to being a total dick and fucking the place up for everyone. There's more to life than cheap gas, car culture, and shopping malls.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by downandout on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @08:03PM (#5790113)
Frankly, I'd rather help the animals keep their habitat than help humanity grow it's population.

That was the point of my comment - eco-ideologists generally hate humans, and given the chance are more than willing to inconvenience other humans (rarely themselves) in order to satisfy their world view. Fortunately for the rest of us, that opportunity rarely comes.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by ChrisNorstrom on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @10:33PM (#5790531)
Ok then, what should the cut off be for making it acceptable to inconvenience other humans for the sake of sustainability? How many droughts should we go through? How low and polluted should the water supply get? How shitty does life have to get for all of us before it's ok to ask everyone to make some changes that may be "inconvenient". If you don't inconvenience 314 million Americans right now in 2013, you're going to screw 500 million Americans a few decades from now, and even more a few centuries from now.

I'm not asking for eugenics and one child policies. And no I'm not in favor of bio-fuels. They've done more environmental damage than they've helped, and they mess with the pricing of the food. It's not about ideas that sound nice and make people happy, it's about solutions that actually work and are realistic. I'm asking for common sense sustainable strategies. Rethinking water rights (just because you bought some land doesn't mean you own the ground water and can pump out massive amounts of water thus lowering the water table for everyone else), ending zoning policies that favor single family homes and push out apartment complexes, stop subsidizing home ownership, expand conservation areas and create new ones, investing in a smart grid, map out and setting cyclical conservation areas that are reserved for future use, filtering storm drains, allow cities to be able to mandate mpg policies (they currently cannot).

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by brc on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @11:52PM (#5790815)
>I'm not asking for eugenics and one child policies.

These are the only proven solutions to population control.

You are either for allowing people to have kids as they decide, or you are not. There is no middle ground here. As a human I don't favor any type of population control of any type because denying people the right to reproduce is one of the cruelest things you can do.

The alternative is to just let the population ebb and flow naturally. It might double, it might halve, we don't know.

The truth is that quality of life has been improving for centuries and will probably continue to do so.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by ChrisNorstrom on Thursday May 30, 2013 @01:21AM (#5791067)
>These are the only proven solutions to population control.

NOT true. Statistically the more educated a group becomes + the higher the standard of living the lower the groups birth rate. Jews and Japanese are the prime example. Higher educatation alone correlates with lower birth rates. The birth rate for African American's alone has fallen 60% in 10 years. Much in part due to increased education in the form of college scholarships and grants.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fertility_and_intelligence

http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/pressroom/97facts/edu2birt.htm

http://www.un.org/News/Press/docs/2011/pop994.doc.htm

http://www.eea.europa.eu/data-and-maps/figures/correlation-b...

Simply put. Educating humanity allows it to naturally direct itself back towards sustainable levels without drastic and extreme eugenics or one child policies.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by brc on Thursday May 30, 2013 @03:52AM (#5791406)
I agree on one thing : increasing prosperity naturally reduces populations, but I don't class that as population control. Control means having a set target. Control is the Chinese one-child policy, which is a demographic disaster unfolding before our eyes.

Being wealthier generally means choosing to have less children as the cost of child rearing increases. But this isn't population control. That is letting the natural ebb and flow of populations come and go.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by qu4z-2 on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @08:41PM (#5790250)
I'm against inconveniencing existing humans for the benefit of the environment, but arguing that trying to reduce human population increase is "hating humans" is like arguing that pro-choicers "hate babies".

I mean, sure, let's look out for the humans that are already around. But I don't feel much obligation to destroy huge swathes of beautiful landscapes just so we can have more people. Quality of life over quantity of life, etc.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by precisioncoder on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @07:59AM (#5785752)
http://xkcd.com/164/

As an extra note if we manage to make large portions of this planet unlivable then maybe through trying to alter them to be livable again we'll unlock techniques that we could use on other planets to make them livable as well.

The future is going to be awesome and horrifying and exciting. I'm so happy I get to live in this age, even if I do end up dying horribly it will probably be exciting.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by Gravityloss on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @11:49AM (#5786939)
You read the xkcd post as serious? To me it's clearly sarcastic.
Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by precisioncoder on Thursday June 06, 2013 @03:34AM (#5831017)
I read it as serious, but that's the lovely thing about art, everyone can have a different interpretation.
Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by mikeash on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @09:49AM (#5786224)
500 years ago is a hugely artificial point to start your forest comparison. For a fair comparison, you need to go back far enough to reach the peak of pre-Columbian civilization in North America. That civilization was heavily agricultural and cut down plenty of trees to make farmland. Old World diseases subsequently wiped out nearly the entire population, and the subsequent reforestation sucked so much CO2 out of the atmosphere that it may have substantially contributed to the Little Ice Age.

For a proper comparison, you need to look at more like 600-1000 years ago. I don't know what the result of that comparison is, or how accurate it can be given how little is really known about pre-Columbian North America, but that's what you need to look at.

The standard picture of North America being virgin wilderness inhabited by scattered tribes until the arrival of the Europeans is dead wrong. That's how settlers found it, but only because roughly 90% of the population had been killed off by disease not long before.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by noonespecial on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @12:32PM (#5787294)
OTOH, look at upstate New York, patrticularly adirondack park. They basically logged the whole place flat to build NYC but with careful stewardship, it is once again a beautiful forest wilderness. The point is that we can fix it if we want to.