News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by downandout on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @07:46AM (#5785702)
Why is it that so many left-wing rants leave me with the unnerving impression that their authors care more about Koalas than humans? You created an impressive list of eco-complaints, but the simple fact is that human life expectancy - my primary concern as a human - has risen dramatically in the same 30 years. Perhaps a little more focus on humans and a little less on sad Koalas will keep us on track toward even higher life expectancy.
Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by rayiner on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @08:15AM (#5785805)
Human life expectancy rising over that period has nothing to do with the lost forest cover. Indeed, the vast majority of the increase is due to a few relatively low-tech advances targeted at reducing infant mortality.
Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by marknutter on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @08:47AM (#5785929)
relatively low-tech advances that were made possibly by modern civilization, which was made possible by our expansionism.
Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by rayiner on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @08:49AM (#5785938)
That's hardly an iron-clad causal chain there. I'm pretty sure penicillin would have happened whether or not we deforested California and turned it into a giant collection of freeways and parking lots.
Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by marknutter on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @09:02AM (#5786004)
Penicillin isn't the only medical advancement from the past 100 years that is contributing to our high life expectancy rates.
Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by rayiner on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @09:16AM (#5786065)
Yes, but the majority of the improvements stem from a handful of relatively low-tech things: antibiotics, clean water, improved nutrition, urbanization leading to most births happening in the presence of a medical professional, social changes reducing pregnancy among young teenagers, and a handful of key vaccines. Its not blockbuster cancer drags driving the increase.
Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by downandout on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @03:32PM (#5788548)
The point is that deforestation obviously isn't killing us.
Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by aerique on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @10:38AM (#5786493)
Maybe because many "left-wing" people think it would actually be good to trade in a couple of years of life expectancy to make the world a better place for other living beings than just humans?

At least I think it would be a good thing to focus less on humans now that there's 6 billion of us.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by specialist on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @11:10AM (#5786687)
Citation needed.

Left wing thought, in my world, is creating the maximum benefit for the maximum number of people. We against "robbing peter to pay paul".

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by wtbob on Thursday May 30, 2013 @01:31PM (#5793879)
> Left wing thought, in my world, is creating the maximum benefit for the maximum number of people. We against "robbing peter to pay paul".

But that's exactly what welfare is: robbing Peter to pay Paul!

(yes, I'm aware that folks claim stuff like, 'ah, but if we rob Peter nicely than there's less risk of Paul robbing and killing him, so really Peter's expected value is higher if we rob him')

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by emddudley on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @12:40PM (#5787346)
I think your question is a philosophical one. What is the proper role of the human species in Earth's ecology? It sounds like you think "might makes right", and that any choice which maximizes human life expectancy is the right choice.

It saddens me to think that people are willing to push so many living organisms to extinction, just to make our lives a little more comfortable and last a little bit longer. I think it is important to protect life, in all its forms.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by danmaz74 on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @11:13AM (#5786700)
So, if human life expectancy went up doing X, we're guaranteed that it will still go up if we continue to do X? That's the same reasoning that caused so many bubbles.

I'm no tree-hugger, but also from a purely egoistical point of view I worry about the consequences of the very fast changes we're causing to the environment in which humans evolved and to which we are adapted. Nothing guarantees that the changes will lead to an environment that can sustain 6+B human beings, so trying to predict the consequences is a very wise thing to do.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by specialist on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @02:56PM (#5788291)
False equivalency.

Conserving the koalas is done at the expensive of corporate profits, not human lives.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by ChrisNorstrom on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @07:33PM (#5789967)
Our life expectancy doesn't go up by fucking the place up and mismanaging sustainable living. Just because I care about other species and the planet that live on (you know, it's not easy to find a planet that can sustain life) doesn't mean I'm a left-wing liberal. FYI, I'm independent.

There's 7 billion of us and growing. We can take care of ourselves and our life spans are nearing 80-90 years, animals that took billions of years to evolve into their current species are being wiped out because we have selfish attitudes. We're draining the water tables and fucking over the oceans. Aside from the medical advances to help ourselves, we're screwing EVERYONE and EVERYTHING on this planet.

"But what about us humans?" What about us? Being on every continent other than Antarctica isn't enough?

Also, we lost 160 million people in wars just in the 20th century alone. At least Koalas & Gorillas won't send your family to a concentration camp, invade your country, slaughter your citizens, get drunk and slam into your family van, rape and kill, or fuck your children. Frankly, I'd rather help the animals keep their habitat than help humanity grow it's population. At least animals don't ask for taxes or welfare. Animals won't rob you at gun point. Leave them in their forest and they'll be happy and leave you alone.

Being a human and being more intelligent than other species doesn't entitle you to being a total dick and fucking the place up for everyone. There's more to life than cheap gas, car culture, and shopping malls.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by downandout on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @08:03PM (#5790113)
Frankly, I'd rather help the animals keep their habitat than help humanity grow it's population.

That was the point of my comment - eco-ideologists generally hate humans, and given the chance are more than willing to inconvenience other humans (rarely themselves) in order to satisfy their world view. Fortunately for the rest of us, that opportunity rarely comes.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by ChrisNorstrom on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @10:33PM (#5790531)
Ok then, what should the cut off be for making it acceptable to inconvenience other humans for the sake of sustainability? How many droughts should we go through? How low and polluted should the water supply get? How shitty does life have to get for all of us before it's ok to ask everyone to make some changes that may be "inconvenient". If you don't inconvenience 314 million Americans right now in 2013, you're going to screw 500 million Americans a few decades from now, and even more a few centuries from now.

I'm not asking for eugenics and one child policies. And no I'm not in favor of bio-fuels. They've done more environmental damage than they've helped, and they mess with the pricing of the food. It's not about ideas that sound nice and make people happy, it's about solutions that actually work and are realistic. I'm asking for common sense sustainable strategies. Rethinking water rights (just because you bought some land doesn't mean you own the ground water and can pump out massive amounts of water thus lowering the water table for everyone else), ending zoning policies that favor single family homes and push out apartment complexes, stop subsidizing home ownership, expand conservation areas and create new ones, investing in a smart grid, map out and setting cyclical conservation areas that are reserved for future use, filtering storm drains, allow cities to be able to mandate mpg policies (they currently cannot).

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by brc on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @11:52PM (#5790815)
>I'm not asking for eugenics and one child policies.

These are the only proven solutions to population control.

You are either for allowing people to have kids as they decide, or you are not. There is no middle ground here. As a human I don't favor any type of population control of any type because denying people the right to reproduce is one of the cruelest things you can do.

The alternative is to just let the population ebb and flow naturally. It might double, it might halve, we don't know.

The truth is that quality of life has been improving for centuries and will probably continue to do so.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by ChrisNorstrom on Thursday May 30, 2013 @01:21AM (#5791067)
>These are the only proven solutions to population control.

NOT true. Statistically the more educated a group becomes + the higher the standard of living the lower the groups birth rate. Jews and Japanese are the prime example. Higher educatation alone correlates with lower birth rates. The birth rate for African American's alone has fallen 60% in 10 years. Much in part due to increased education in the form of college scholarships and grants.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fertility_and_intelligence

http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/pressroom/97facts/edu2birt.htm

http://www.un.org/News/Press/docs/2011/pop994.doc.htm

http://www.eea.europa.eu/data-and-maps/figures/correlation-b...

Simply put. Educating humanity allows it to naturally direct itself back towards sustainable levels without drastic and extreme eugenics or one child policies.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by brc on Thursday May 30, 2013 @03:52AM (#5791406)
I agree on one thing : increasing prosperity naturally reduces populations, but I don't class that as population control. Control means having a set target. Control is the Chinese one-child policy, which is a demographic disaster unfolding before our eyes.

Being wealthier generally means choosing to have less children as the cost of child rearing increases. But this isn't population control. That is letting the natural ebb and flow of populations come and go.

Re:A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human ... by qu4z-2 on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @08:41PM (#5790250)
I'm against inconveniencing existing humans for the benefit of the environment, but arguing that trying to reduce human population increase is "hating humans" is like arguing that pro-choicers "hate babies".

I mean, sure, let's look out for the humans that are already around. But I don't feel much obligation to destroy huge swathes of beautiful landscapes just so we can have more people. Quality of life over quantity of life, etc.