One of the things I hate about green ideology is that it frames this issue in selfless religious moralistic terms when it's really all about pure self-interest.
To what extent can we continue doing this? For how long? We depend on these ecological systems, and the economic cost of replacing them would be far beyond our capacity to invest (if it's even within our technical capability). We depend on many, many resources that are presently being extracted far faster than their rate of formation, with fossil fuels being chief among these. Couriscant in Star Wars is fiction, and is likely impossible even with imaginary post-singularity-level technology. Its climate would have little or nothing to regulate it, and its atmosphere would revert to pre-photosynthesis reducing composition.
Less than a thousand years after mass die-off and the collapse of global civilization into a new dark age, most of the "damage" will be gone. This is less than a microsecond on geological timescales. The planet will be fine.
Such brutal die-offs have occurred before many times in geological history, and it's absurdly naive to think that it couldn't happen to us. Nature doesn't care about us. It doesn't care how much we suffer or how many of us die. We have to worry about that, or nothing will.
And even if it doesn't happen suddenly, there's the whole quality of life issue. Do we really want to live in a b-grade cyberpunk dystopia of endless ugly sprawl, routine Fukushima/BP Macondo type industrial disasters, increasing pollution, commodity hyperinflation, and unattainably distant gaps between the rich and everyone else? Because that might be what an ecologically depleted world looks like: a few super-rich demigods presiding over massive seething ghettoes policed by drones. That would also be a new dark age.
Edit: it might help people understand if we tried to estimate the cost of replacing these ecological systems with artificial industrial replacements. I'm gonna guesstimate somewhere in the neighborhood of 10,000X current world GDP.
You could probably arrive at an estimate by working backwards and assuming thermodynamic efficiencies at reconstructing the biosphere in the 10-15% neighborhood. So SUM(GDP,1012AD,2012AD) / 0.15?
Could it be, maybe, that your statements reflect the thought of some people that might be denying ecological disasters ?
What's religious about being horrified at the loss of 70% of the North American Forest ? If that is indeed the correct number (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deforestation_in_the_United_Sta... : a 25% loss for the US with a stabilized 20th century but this here http://www.globalchange.umich.edu/globalchange2/current/lect... hints that primary forest area aren't counted the same way http://www.globalchange.umich.edu/globalchange2/current/lect...)... What's wrong with being religious, anyway ?
> It's just that as I drive from coast to coast, as I have done more than once, I'm not overwhelmed with the horror of the landscape.
May it be because you can't compare to the same ride 500 years ago and so the impact doesn't sink in ?
That is a nakedly emotionally manipulative reply with no substance. I mean this judgment to apply to your entire post, just quoted the worst part.
That is the effect I wanted to achieve in order to better parody and criticize parent's own manipulative wording: "some" people, "sometimes", veiled attempt to accuse opponents of being "religious", etc. I thought it was more obvious, sorry.
Next time I'll just state it plainly like you did (no irony).
For what it's worth I couldn't find any numbers regarding the 70% loss and what it really refers to.
Not every genetic sequence is sacred, and the vast majority that modern taxonomy would consider "species" have come and gone without me shedding a tear.
Sure, there's the natural eb and flow of the environment. But that tends to happen over very long periods of time. When you're talking about 70% of forests being destroyed within 500 years though, that's something else entirely. Make no mistake: the change our planet has gone through over that short time period is unprecedented.
None. And I don't think mankind should hold itself back due to the other "species" lack of initiative.
Clearly it would be to some people, but not to me. I'm hardly arguing in favor of eliminating the remaining 30% of the forest and adding another billion or so North Americans. Being okay with some change doesn't mean I prefer the maximum amount of change. It's just that as I drive from coast to coast, as I have done more than once, I'm not overwhelmed with the horror of the landscape.
I am willing to work to clean up the mess we humans so often make and to take steps to avoid ruining things we can't fix. I don't want to live on a pile of garbage, and it does take constant effort to avoid letting garbage of various sorts (trash dumps, dirty water, smoggy air) get out of control. Sometimes we fail, and we need to do something about it. I'm especially worried about damage that is not obvious---the oceans come to mind.
But no, I'm not horrified at the thought of North America having 70% fewer trees than we had 500 years ago, if that's the real number. I want to take proper safeguards with respect to the environment, human health, human living standards, crime, political and economic freedoms, education, and numerous other important issues, but sometimes I think that some people get uncomfortably "religious" about the environment in particular. I'm not one of them.