News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by anonymous592053 on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @01:25AM (#5784758)
[Continuing because of HN's length restrictions]

> In the code base that you live in, you quickly develop an > understanding of how the components fit together. Use this > knowledge: instead of only fixing a bug you're assigned, consider > how you can prevent that class of bug from ever happening > again. Instead of implementing a new feature, consider how you can > create a common abstraction between the new and old ones and share > 80% of the code. This might take more effort now but gives vastly > greater results in the long run.

This is a very beneficial thing to do, but it led to ugly code reviews. I was given a task, and solved it to satisfaction (code was written cleanly, tests passed, etc.) but was told, in review, that the code was not satisfactory, because it did not clean up code completely unrelated to the task -- even if such clean up actually didn't solve any old or new problems.

I was severely penalized for this.

> At a higher level, take ownership over the entire company. Don't let > your coworkers be less than the best that they can be. Understand > the trade-offs being made and the factors that led to them; > understand temporary solutions and the priorities that necessitate > them, but don't accept a decision that you feel is wrong without > raising the issue and getting a better understanding. This is your > company (your garden) and if you let people pull in the wrong > direction the entire plan will fall into disarray. Make sure that > you encourage changes and that you're confident that the changes > happening are the right ones.

This sounds entirely ideal, but when someone new goes up against someone who has been in the company for a while, the new guy is the one who is looked down upon and usually disagreed with, with the reason that the guy with tenure surely knows what he is talking about.

The part left unsaid is that there is no process for appeal. If you disagree with another developer, and your manager ultimately disagrees with you, tough luck.

I did not see democracy and debate. I saw tenure and social capital deciding issues by default.

> It's easy to fall into the mindset that you don't know everything, > everyone around you is smarter and more experienced, and that if you > say something incorrect you'll be judged by your peers. This isn't the > case. When you have an idea, share it with your team, even if you > aren't confident it's the right idea. Wrong ideas are often stepping > stones to right ideas, both because they help define the real > boundaries of the problem that you're facing and because you can > iterate on a wrong idea to reach a right one.

Saying incorrect things, in my experience, actually does have repercussions. During "bootcamp" at Facebook, you'll go through essentially a second set of interviews with managers and team members. If you ask the wrong things, or make seemingly incorrect statements, you will be judged, and as a result, they will not want you on their team.

Aside from the questions you ask and the interest you display, the number of questions you ask also is a form of penalty. I was informally rejected from a team because I was told I asked too many questions. Basically, since I asked too many questions, I allegedly did not have the competence to solve problems that team faced on my own. Even though it was the team I dreamed of being on, and the one I could make the most impact on, I was told by my manager that my reputation was irreparably befouled. Maybe if I tried again in a year.

As another anecdote, I was judged negatively for sharing my ideas without confidence (I'm the new guy, I don't want to be presumptuous!), and being indirect with criticism. Instead of telling another team member that he was wrong, I shared an experiment and results to demonstrate so, in order to minimize argumentation.

Even though I ended up being right about my assessments of the problem at hand, I was actually told that I should have been more assertive because of this, and my overall performance was deemed poor.

> It isn't immediately obvious how important it is to meet and > maintain relationships with people at the company who are outside of > your team. Find a random person with whom you haven't worked in > months and have a quick chat with them. It can provide a fresh > insight into problems you're facing and may even give a solution > that another team already has that you can use. FYI groups do a good > job of giving you a broad overview of the company, but talking to a > ground-level engineer from a different part of the code can yield > new ideas, new solutions, and new opportunities to combine forces.

True enough. Though, "joining forces" usually means "do something for the company on your own time, and if the idea is good enough during a hackathon -- also on your own time -- then it might lead to a new opportunity". You can shoot the shit with other developers, but there's no 20% time to take anything to the next level.

> I'm only just starting to learn some of these lessons. I hope this > note helps to inspire you to step up, take ownership, and lead your > team in the right direction. Enjoy your years at Facebook; I know I > have.

Good.

Overall, I did not enjoy my time at Facebook, and I was reminded of the value in having a good, experienced manager, and the futility of trying to retain professional dignity in the face of an incompetent one. It was something that could have been repaired, but there was no avenue to do so.

My tale also underlines the way at-will employment can be exploited as "endless probation". Food for thought for anyone seriously trying to build a tech career.

* Actually, I am glad to say that I am now happily employed.

Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by anonfbemp on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @02:13AM (#5784890)
I can confirm the same experience as a non-engineer.

I worked in a group that was not engineering, and had the same schizophrenic experience with respect to what I was told was the culture, what was expected and what the reality was.

The culture of facebook is that of a pretentious enclave of people who think that simply their being at facebook is validation of their any actions or motivations.

While the benefits of the company are amazing, the actual actions and methods of teams is utterly broken.

I was accused of not providing information in a timely manner, even though I was simply statusing other employees and teams on their activities. After multiple escalations regarding not receiving status from said teams, I was ultimately held responsible for those that literally ignored every request for an update, inclusive of escalations to both my and their managers.

I was accused of overstepping my bounds by looking into information required for various projects and interfering in other teams responsibility even after being explicitly asked to gather this information on thie behalf. I was told by my manager that I should document all requests in email to ensure that I was not perceived as being encroaching on their area. I complied, and was praised for covering for that team, then denigrated by my very manager for overstepping into their area....

I was accused of spending too much time in the social scene at FB, while I joined a total of ~5 groups within FB and only posted a total of ~10 times between all groups.

The fact is that there is a ruthless political system within facebook that ruthlessly seeks out people who are too active and cuts them as early as possible.

When I was fired, jsut minutes before I was assured by my manager that all was good and that the person who was difficult was just someone I was supposed to get to understand.

Then, all my colleagues disappeared from our desk line and I received a call that I needed to leave the building. It was the most cowardly and disgusting company exit I have ever experienced.

Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by smegel on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @05:29AM (#5785394)
Wow, quite a few similar stories. I wonder how indicative they are of fb as a whole, or just particular teams. Does anyone have any positive experiences to relay?
Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by alttab on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @10:02AM (#5786299)
Gotta love a social company run by a kid that was so incapable of making friends he had to build a website and make everyone want to be there.
Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by myko on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @10:25AM (#5786413)
I think this is a bit unfair. I'm not sure you know Mark well enough to know that.
Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by specialist on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @10:42AM (#5786517)
Ambiguous rules, ruthlessly enforced. Been there, been done like that.

Swimming With Sharks captures the pathos pretty well, for hollywood. Definitely painful to watch. http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0114594

Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by webvictim on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @04:48AM (#5785294)
Sounds like you had a truly sucky experience. I'm sorry to hear about that.
Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by anon12345678 on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @03:12AM (#5785076)
I was also fired from an engineering role at Facebook. However, I look at the experience very differently.

They seek candidates with strong engineering skills, and only do a little culture fit at interview time (this was my experience at least). The real culture fit test happens during bootcamp, where they try for 6 weeks to break any misfit. Now that isn't going to work for everyone, but their strategy is to go all-out and try get a strong candidate to work well in their culture.

It didn't work out for me. I constantly reflect on what made me decide to accept their offer, what I could have discovered that would have made me realise it wasn't going to work out for me. I take interviewing far more as a two-way discussion, trying to find out what a company sees in me that they like and sometimes I tell them they misread me rather than risk ending up in the same predicament.

There are a number of things not directly in my control that lead to me leaving though. I had some bad luck with many of my bootcamp tasks, e.g. task owner on vacation for a couple weeks, task owners not being responsive if I didn't get back to them with working code really fast (I was working on other tasks at the same time), etc. I was drawn in very strongly by a manager who recognised that my skills strongly matched his team's requirements. I felt uncomfortable around that team from day one and never really tried hard on their tasks, and that reflected very poorly on me. At the same time, teams I took the initiative to approach would setup an initial meeting and then I'd never hear back from them. It wanted to dig into stuff I was excited about, while my bootcamp manager wanted me to complete the boring tasks I was assigned. Other things at hackathons drew me in, and I spent too much time on those projects only to be told a week before being fired that those were not being counted in my evaluation so I had to scramble to work again with the team I didn't get along with. Soon after that, that team didn't want to give me new tasks and I was left with nothing.

If I was to go through the process again, there are a few things I'd do differently. I would avoid letting the side hackathon projects take up too much time in the early days until I was firmly settled in. I would get more clarification on tasks as early on as possible. I would focus on one or two tasks at a time, rather than trying to churn through five or six in parallel. This way turn around time with task owners would be faster making them happier to help. I would forget about looking for a team until week four at the earliest - focus on tasks instead. I wouldn't take their advice to pick any team, even if you had no experience in the area, too strongly. It's good to get a strong start, and take the other roads once you've proven yourself.

I found a new job within a month. As an H1-B holder, I needed to be quick, so I settled for what I could get. Companies reacted differently to me being fired. While I'm sure all of them take it as a negative, some seemed to sympathise. I'm now interviewing again, and depending on whether Facebook comes up I have told some companies what happened and not told others. It doesn't seem to make a huge difference, since I've proven myself at my current company, but some keep prodding to try find that fatal flaw in me that lead to the firing (which I don't believe exists). I'm considering removing Facebook entirely from my CV after my next job.

Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by nilkn on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @03:49AM (#5785156)
Are you suggesting they effectively treat the first six weeks of employment as little more than an "extended interview" and fire anybody who doesn't make their cultural fit in that time frame?
Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by masklinn on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @06:00AM (#5785463)
That seems acceptable though it's really shitty if you end up not making the cut.

FWIW most european countries allow 1-6 months probation periods (for non-temp jobs, temp jobs have either no probation or much shorter ones). During probation, either side can terminate the contract without most of the restrictive clauses applying, it's essentially a short period of "at-will" to check fit between the company and the new employee.

Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by nilkn on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @01:00PM (#5787504)
I think it's only acceptable if it's made very clear before you accept or decline the job offer. Otherwise it seems like it's taking advantage of people.

The main reason I view it that way is because Facebook hires a lot of fresh college graduates who don't necessarily have much (if any) money saved up. To work for Facebook, they're going to have to find a place to live in one of the most expensive areas of the United States. I think it is quite disrespectful to put young people with little money in a situation where they are signing extended leases only to be let go within six weeks.

Granted, Facebook gives out pretty good signing bonuses, so that softens the impact a bit, but still if I knew that the first six weeks were effectively a probationary period I'd make a special effort to find a housing situation where I could pay on a monthly basis rather than entering a six- or twelve-month lease.

Moreover, if I had a family, I'd definitely think twice before going into a sort of six week interview, no matter who the company was. I wouldn't want to put my family through the difficulties of moving there only for me to get let go soon after arriving.

Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by masklinn on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @02:33PM (#5788099)
An excellent point, I failed to notice that issue and completely agree. In EU contracts with probation periods the probation is explicitly spelled out in the contract (since labor laws allow for it but by no means mandate it), and generally discussed/mentioned during the interviews stuff.
Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by pseut on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @10:55AM (#5786581)
It's one thing if it's made clear that there's a probationary period; I've worked in (non-tech) companies where that was the case, although very different than what's been portrayed above.

If it's not clear that's the case, which seems to have been the case in these anecdotes, it would be pretty unacceptable.

Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by officemonkey on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @06:58AM (#5785595)
New federal government employees also have to serve a 1-year "probation" where they can be let go for pretty much no reason. I've seen agencies exercise that right rarely, but it does happen.
Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by fizzbar on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @11:45AM (#5786901)
I'd suspect that in more "mature" working environments the probation period is used more as a fail-safe mechanism, as opposed to being integral to the actual hiring process (which is what it sounds like at FB).
Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by officemonkey on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @03:34PM (#5788559)
Treating new employees in this manner is okay if everyone's up front about it.

Telling people "Welcome to Facebook," having them quit their old job, and have them relocate just so you can smoke 'em and throw out the trash might be efficient, but it sure isn't kind.

Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by anonymous592053 on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @04:01AM (#5785182)
Yes.
Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by zerr on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @03:36AM (#5785129)
With all this hackathon bullshit I think that companies try to squeeze out more free time from people for their needs, including advertisement.
Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by anon12345678 on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @03:43AM (#5785146)
I was told that working on those projects was a privilege and that we had to perform at our jobs (minus any output from hackathons) before we could work on the stuff we wanted to. I think it's a sensible strategy. Hackathons do keep engineers on the edge and excited about work, but you want to avoid it distracting from the core focus too much.
Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by calinet6 on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @09:07AM (#5786023)
Hackathons are bullshit, period. If you're working, producing anything of value to the company, even if that be simply "worker engagement," it better be on company time. Simple as that.
Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by alttab on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @10:06AM (#5786320)
Agreed. Unpaid labor is not "culture" its slavery.
Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by bcbrown on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @11:09AM (#5786684)
I like the way my company does it. We have periodical "hack weeks", where for the entire work week, you can work on whatever you want that's at least loosely related to company technology or objectives.
Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by jes5199 on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @01:19PM (#5787635)
I worked at a company that had "hack weeks" - most people loved them, and they produced good prototypes. But personally, I just hated hack weeks. But then again, I hated trying to work in that office at all, and trying to work on something "fun" there just felt worse than trying to do my regular job.

I think, though, if I was running a company, I wouldn't have hack weeks or 20% time - I'd try, for as long as possible, to give people extreme latitude to work on whatever they think might be useful/fun/interesting for the company - more like the Valve model, I guess.

Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by exodust on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @12:28PM (#5787243)
A whole week? That's unheard of. Sounds good, sounds like my kind of down time, but I doubt most companies would embrace that time span.

There's another way to do whatever you want at work, and that's covertly. During the times you're meant to be doing other things. Depends where your desk is I suppose, or if working remotely.

Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by calinet6 on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @01:04PM (#5787533)
Certain companies have code freezes during large sales pushes, mainly e-commerce and the like. These are times when whole weeks could be spent on a hackathon-like deal with little impact on other plans.
Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by jongraehl on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @06:39PM (#5789697)
So, don't accept an offer at Facebook unless you're confident you'll shine in the first months (even in unfair situations, with people working against you). I can see how it's great for the morale of those who pass the hazing, but it sounds like perhaps they need to work on their on-boarding process - that incumbent teams and engineers are guided by selfish incentives that have nothing to do with helping newbies succeed.

On the other hand, those rejected will always have hurt feelings, and at some point their failure will be sealed by the lack of confidence/patience/charity established engineers have for them.

Probably the incumbents are often failing to appreciate the body of domain (FB procedures + code) knowledge they've accumulated, and that a new initiate likely lacks. Engineers are often poor communicators in that sense.

Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by dasil003 on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @07:16AM (#5785626)
The thing about this story that strikes me is that it's impossible to know if this rejection was because of any objective quality that would have prevented you from being a good Facebook employee, or whether it was just politics. Even for the players themselves I don't think anyone can say for sure.

Even though Facebook has a reputation for a strong, engineer-driven culture, the fact is that at a certain size the politics are complicated. It's not a question of whether you have to play politics or not, but rather what do the politics look like? This is why I like working for startups, there just isn't any room for politics, and you can sink or swim based on highly visible contributions. Even though Facebook makes the claim that as an engineer you are responsible for the experiences of X million users, in practice that's not how it works.

Good luck in your new job.

Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by calinet6 on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @09:04AM (#5786010)
Even if it's "just politics"—politics is what prevents companies from thriving. It's a sign of poor management, poor culture, and poor understanding of human psychology.

In two words: screw that.

Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by dasil003 on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @09:36AM (#5786155)
My point is that politics are endemic to large organizations. You can't have no politics, you can only have different forms of politics.
Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by rhizome on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @01:39PM (#5787770)
Politics are endemic to all organizations, and the larger an organization becomes, the more it loses the ability to keep politics from interfering with an employee's work and abilities to do that work. Workplace politics are a kind of professional corruption, and this corruption easily hides behind headcount.
Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by calinet6 on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @09:56AM (#5786268)
Almost by definition, yes, I believe you're right. You need some sort of organization with large numbers of people, and politics are just the part that self-organizes.

I think the negative aspects can be controlled better than they are in most large organizations. But most large organizations don't focus on that, to their detriment.

Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by marssaxman on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @01:41PM (#5787779)
Sounds like an excellent reason to avoid large organizations.
Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by nvarsj on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @02:21AM (#5784922)
Wow, sounds rough. You seem bitter and hurt by the whole experience still. Let me just tell you: this experience is good for you in the long run. I can tell you as someone who sits on the ASD scale, I've had some painful periods in my early life where my brain locked on and obsessed over similar rejections. And the obsession and bitterness didn't do me an ounce of good. But later on I accepted it and realized the experience itself made me a wiser, better person.

As to your experience - sounds normal to me (unfortunately). You didn't fit the culture, or at least ended up working with some anti-you people. Maybe you weren't brogrammer enough. It happens to most everyone at some point in their career. I suggest you take from it what you can - when to recognize that things are not working out as early as possible, and to never expose yourself to risk as an at-will employee (always have a money backup!).

Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by orik on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @08:26AM (#5785844)
Sometimes "always have a money backup" seems to be as useful advice as "be white and have rich parents".
Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by nilkn on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @03:51AM (#5785160)
> always have a money backup!

If it was his first job out of college, he may not have had much of a choice here. Wouldn't his signing bonus have been revoked since he wasn't employed for a full year? (Not a Facebook employee, not sure on their offer details.)

Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by anon12345678 on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @04:24AM (#5785232)
You only lose it if you leave voluntarily, so no.
Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by curiousDog on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @01:44AM (#5784813)
Wow, that confirms a few rumors i heard about facebook. This is definitely not a first. Thank you for posting this anon. This will make mine and a few other people's decisions a lot easier.
Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by reledi on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @05:07AM (#5785337)
> Instead of telling another team member that he was wrong, I shared an experiment and results to demonstrate so, in order to minimize argumentation. [...] my overall performance was deemed poor.

That's interesting, because you often hear that "code wins arguments" at FB.

>> This might take more effort now but gives vastly greater results in the long run.

I'm also surprised by this. There seems to be a lot of importance placed on moving fast. Some of FB's mantras are "DONE IS BETTER THAN PERFECT", "MOVE FAST AND BREAK THINGS", and "STAY FOCUSED AND KEEP SHIPPING".

> * Actually, I am glad to say that I am now happily employed.

Your first comment starting by saying you were unemployed. Did someone just hire you since your comment?

Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by randallsquared on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @09:15AM (#5786052)
The reference to the asterisk you included was by that statement. I think it's clear that he was saying that for contrast, rather than because it is still true.
Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by vital_sol on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @02:41AM (#5784979)
I had similar experience at salesforce.com. Now I call it "failure to on-board." Partially my fault, partially theirs.
Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by rdl on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @02:22PM (#5788023)
The Facebook "bootcamp" process seems like the best way to get around the problems of "blind allocation" as well as the problems of "teams need warm bodies and thus lower standards, leading to eventual company-wide mediocrity".
Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by flyinRyan on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @10:04AM (#5786309)
This sounds more like what I would expect working at Facebook to be like.
Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by bconway on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @09:39AM (#5786174)
Good read. I'd be interested in hearing the other side of the story.
Re:“This week marks the beginning of my 4th year at Facebook” by edwardunknown on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @08:25AM (#5785842)
That's painful to read, I think most people have had similar experiences (though I've never had one quite this bad, they told you not to speak to people? WTF?) At least it teaches you that places like this exist and to listen to your Spidey sense when interviewing for a job.