News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by bifrost on Friday May 03, 2013 @11:11PM (#5653806)
I think this actually fits with what I think about Google overall. Search is great, everything else is just a mediocre tie in to search dollars.

Google is attracting more "nesters" and less "innovators" from what I see as an outsider, which is likely good for long term products but bad for everything else.

Glass is already a bad word (RE: glassholes), Plus is a wasteland, Voice is only popular due to branding, as is Calendar and Docs.

I've seen announcements of products that appear to be more functional than Voice/Cal/Docs on HN with better security and performance, but I think the likelihood of those taking over is probably low until Google gets out of those markets. The products are better, but the mindshare isn't there yet.

Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by samuellevy on Friday May 03, 2013 @11:47PM (#5653913)
I don't know why people keep insisting that G+ is a waste land. If you personally don't use it, or see a use for it, that's fine, but there are many people in the world who are not you.

Personally, I get far more value from G+ than I do/ever have done from twitter, Facebook, MySpace, or any of the many social networks over the years. I have a use for it, which it fulfills better than any of the other services out there, and so for me (and the thousand or so people who I'm connected to at various levels through G+), it's far from a waste land.

G+ isn't for everyone, and that's fine. It is a product which is now highly polished, and provides exactly what I and many other people have wanted from a social network. The exact numbers of users who actually actively use it may not be clear, but if it was a waste land, Google wouldn't be integrating all their services so tightly into it.

Google is not a stupid company, and they're not about to "break" all of their services to drive adoption of a service which can't stand on its own. G+ is a good service, and is providing massive amounts of value to Google. Reader was not creating new value for them; wave wasn't getting adopted; Google had reasons why continuing to support those products was a losing bet.

They are integrating so many of their services into G+, that you can pretty much guarantee that it's a winner (for them, at least).

</rant>

Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by chrisbolt on Saturday May 04, 2013 @02:38AM (#5654271)
> I don't know why people keep insisting that G+ is a waste land. If you personally don't use it, or see a use for it, that's fine, but there are many people in the world who are not you.

It's more that nobody I know uses it. All of my friends are on Facebook, and everyone is talking about Facebook. If I try finding my friends on Google+, it looks like a wasteland.

> They are integrating so many of their services into G+, that you can pretty much guarantee that it's a winner (for them, at least).

Why should I care if it's a winner for them? Google has a huge reach, and they are leveraging that reach to push Google+, but people are still uploading photos and updating their status on Facebook. Google+ may have many unique users, but their use is far more shallow than their use of Facebook.

Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by bifrost on Saturday May 04, 2013 @02:58AM (#5654321)
>If you personally don't use it, or see a use for it, that's fine, but there are many people in the world who are not you.

I wholly agree, but G+ is barely better than tribe.net (for me and my peer group) when you compare it to what Facebook has in terms of content and users. There's also the whole "Nym" issue. I also can't understand why people are excited by giving Google MORE data, the "don't be evil" days are clearly over with.

Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by anoncow on Saturday May 04, 2013 @01:44AM (#5654154)
They are integrating search so tightly with G+ that websites/authors have to get a G+ profile to make authorship data visible in search.

A fairer way would have been to use microdata alone to achieve the same thing. This would have been acceptable to other search engines too.

Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by DigitalTurk on Saturday May 04, 2013 @06:22AM (#5654635)
> G+ isn't for everyone, and that's fine. It is a product which is now highly polished, and provides exactly what I and many other people have wanted from a social network.

Is it possible yet to change the visibility of old posts? The absence of small privacy features like this—features that FB does have—always was very off-putting for me. When Google+ was launched they made a huge deal out of Circles, but it strikes me that since then Google has pushed Google+ more as an alternative to Twitter than as an alternative to Facebook (and I don't like Twitter much).

Anyway, I used Google+ so little that I deleted my account in a petty rage when they shut down Google Reader. It's actually nice to have one less social network to worry about.

Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by tsycho on Saturday May 04, 2013 @05:02PM (#5656312)
> Is it possible yet to change the visibility of old posts? The absence of small privacy features like this—features that FB does have...

Are you sure you have thought this through? Allowing retro-active changes to visibility (unless it's only in a more restrictive direction) can be a privacy violation for the commenters, who may have commented based on the original visibility list. And allowing visibility changes towards a more restrictive set will confuse the people who could see the post till yesterday, might even have commented on it, and suddenly can't see it anymore.

Privacy decisions are not as simple as they might appear on a cursory glance, and overall I find that G+ takes privacy very seriously. Seen from the above light, the current policy of not allowing visibility changes, but allowing the author to delete the post, makes a lot more sense.

Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by DigitalTurk on Sunday May 05, 2013 @05:52AM (#5657964)
I disagree.

Allowing more people to see a post is already possible by adding people to the circles that you shared the post with.

Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by bernardlunn on Saturday May 04, 2013 @01:00AM (#5654068)
Social is inevitably a winner take all market, so in this case the ignoramuses who never use G+ who declare it dead are probably right. Its not about great features, just ask FriendFeed.
Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by jmtulloss on Saturday May 04, 2013 @02:09AM (#5654207)
Why do you believe that social is a winner take all market?
Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by philwelch on Saturday May 04, 2013 @03:31AM (#5654376)
Metcalfe's Law.
Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by magicalist on Saturday May 04, 2013 @04:14AM (#5654446)
I hope you're being facetious. While (for instance) Facebook's ubiquity will insulate it for many years, come what may, raw connection numbers aren't nearly as important as local connection numbers, and "local" can mean many things, including distance on an interest graph. For instance, I joined Twitter (and Google+, for that matter) because there were interesting conversations happening there and I wanted to take part. Those networks continue to sustain interest for me, so I contribute, and that brings interest to other people, etc.

There might not be a steady state (either becoming abandoned over time, growing to monstrous proportions of popularity, or changing character enough to drive old timers away, or some combination of the three), but all the evidence for the entire history of social groupings suggest that other social groupings will pop up to take the place of any that fail and to fill in niches no longer served. It's certainly not zero sum.

Metcalfe's law was also only ever meant to be an observation (and really just boils down to a description of any network, with "value" being some nebulous term), and certainly was never meant to describe humans' social connections, if only because they cannot sustain an arbitrary number of them. Applying it to social networks for predictive purposes is just sloppy sociology, which is about as low as you can get.

Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by philwelch on Saturday May 04, 2013 @10:06PM (#5657157)
I wasn't being facetious, I just hadn't thought it through as thoroughly as you have. Good points.
Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by snogglethorpe on Saturday May 04, 2013 @12:01AM (#5653951)
You're nuts.

Google certainly has some mediocre "products," but they have many great products as well besides search.

Gmail, of course, essentially sets the bar for online mail, and is still leaps and bounds better than any of its competitors.

Google maps is very, very, good, vastly better than most of the competition (a point made starkly clear by Apple's recent maps C-F).

Google+ is, technically, absolutely excellent, much better than FB. If all your old high-school buddies are only on FB, it's a shame, but there's not much Google can do about that.

Android is vastly better than iOS (I use both, and using iOS always makes it feel like my hands are tied behind my back).

...etc.

Google has its downsides (e.g. their online support sucks), and you may not like them for other reasons, but they're very, very, good at writing software...

Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by shurcooL on Saturday May 04, 2013 @12:10AM (#5653968)
> Android is vastly better than iOS (I use both, and using iOS always makes it feel like my hands are tied behind my back).

For me, I feel like I have 2 hands when using iOS but 17 hands when using Android. It asked me to pick one of 3 power-savings modes for Wi-Fi when in sleep mode. I don't want to have to care about that (nor do I want to pick one of the three options without thinking, because then I'll not have an optimal configuration). I have enough things to tweak on my computer.

Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by w1ntermute on Saturday May 04, 2013 @02:05AM (#5654201)
Regarding the power-savings mode selection issue, that is most definitely not a part of stock Android. Google releases Android without any OEM or carrier modifications. If the OEMs/carriers decide to do something, Google is (generally) not involved.
Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by invisible on Saturday May 04, 2013 @02:52AM (#5654307)
This fragmentation issue is always presented when a flaw like this is incorrectly attributed to Google, but somehow that has nothing to do with Android? That seems like a silly thing to say. Yes, iOS suffers some problems but so does Android, as a fragmented beast that is still stuck on jelly bean as the majority version (which IMO is pretty lacking). I do look forward to Android's future though.
Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by ericd on Saturday May 04, 2013 @04:59AM (#5654511)
It's really pretty easy to avoid this by buying a Nexus branded device, though.
Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by ahsteele on Saturday May 04, 2013 @12:53PM (#5655429)
Agreed, but explain that to a regular consumer in the Verizon store.
Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by w1ntermute on Saturday May 04, 2013 @02:07PM (#5655713)
I don't think anyone is suggesting that we explain anything to regular consumers in Verizon stores. The point is that an HN member should be able to understand and appreciate the fact that stock Android is very different from what most Android phones have, and that those who want stock Android should get a Nexus.
Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by jsnell on Saturday May 04, 2013 @05:10AM (#5654533)
It's been part of stock Android at least since 2.0. But it's also hidden 4 layers deep within Settings (Wifi / Menu / Advanced / Keep Wifi On During Sleep / ...). Complaining about being "asked to pick" a setting when it's hidden that well is pretty disingenuous.
Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by shurcooL on Saturday May 04, 2013 @10:37AM (#5655068)
I'm not making this up. It was a Sony tablet with 3.x (much later there was an update for ICS). It asked me to choose a value for this during initial setup. It didn't even have a recommended setting iirc.

In any case, it's just one of many examples where I feel Android requires more maintenance than iOS. Which is perfectly great for those who want something to tweak and play with.

Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by w1ntermute on Saturday May 04, 2013 @12:06PM (#5655285)
> In any case, it's just one of many examples where I feel Android requires more maintenance than iOS.

Once again, this is not part of stock Android, it's part of "stock Android + some modifications Sony made." There's a big difference.

Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by shurcooL on Saturday May 04, 2013 @01:06PM (#5655478)
That is true. Unfortunately, that's the only first-hand experience with Android I've had so far. It wasn't by choice. If I had to get an Android device, I would without a doubt try a stock Google one. I don't expect a huge difference, but it should be more pleasant.
Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by eropple on Saturday May 04, 2013 @01:23PM (#5655549)
It actually is a pretty big difference. I had a really bad first impression of Android from using early HTC stuff, but my current job is Android development so I figured I should check out the alternatives--and I still had my iPhone, so I could swap the SIM. The AT&T store sold me a Motorola Atrix HD, running either 4.0 or 4.1, and it was awful. It was ugly, Motoblur stuck a bunch of crap I didn't want everywhere...just bad. I took it back the day I got it and bought a Galaxy Nexus online, with 4.1 on it, and it was remarkably impressive; I've been using Android ever since.

I've seriously considered a Galaxy Note 2, but TouchWiz's existence offends me. :) If there was a decent stock-ish build that supported the pen I'd be all over that.

Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by w1ntermute on Saturday May 04, 2013 @12:04PM (#5655281)
The setting may be part of stock Android, but being asked to pick one of the options is most definitely not part of stock Android.
Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by timmm on Saturday May 04, 2013 @12:19AM (#5653984)
Yeah I get that, you might like Google maps more if say you cared about the actual maps.
Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by 6d0debc071 on Saturday May 04, 2013 @05:11AM (#5654535)
That'd be Bing maps then - which I use pretty much exclusively these days.
Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by DigitalTurk on Saturday May 04, 2013 @05:43AM (#5654581)
Bing is great… unless you travel. It fails for many countries. Even for major cities in China it will only show the main roads.
Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by new299 on Saturday May 04, 2013 @08:40AM (#5654864)
> Android is vastly better than iOS (I use both, and using iOS always makes it feel like my hands are tied behind my back).

It's really in no sense "vastly better" the market pretty much bears this out.

From a developer/technical standpoint it can be a pain that you have less access to device features on iOS and the AppStore review process can be a nightmare. But developing on XCode isn't bad, as is the UIKit architecture. It's unfortunate that iOS isn't open source like Android, but I can see no way from a user or technical perspective that it's "vastly better".

Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by tripzilch on Saturday May 04, 2013 @03:42PM (#5656076)
> It's really in no sense "vastly better" the market pretty much bears this out.

Some markets. iOS is big in the US, Android's big in the EU. It's clearly network-effect.

Because of that, "the market" doesn't bear out anything regarding quality.

Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by new299 on Sunday May 05, 2013 @01:30AM (#5657538)
I'd like to see citations for that. But one of the reasons could be that low end smartphones and off contract phones are far more popular in Europe. That drives the market towards cheaper devices which tend to run Android.

In any case it was the word "vastly" I was objecting to. It's possible to subjectively think Android or iOS is better but I don't see how to can make a reasoned argument that Android is objectively vastly superior (aside from the fact that it's open source which could be considered critical).

Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by snogglethorpe on Sunday May 05, 2013 @09:41AM (#5658316)
Here's some data for Japan; Apple has about 1/3 of the smartphone market, almost all of the rest is Android. There's generally little difference in device capability or pricing between iphones and non-iphones in Japan, so it's not a low-end vs. high-end thing, and two out of the three major carriers heavily push the iphone, so it's certainly not marketing....

http://www.comscore.com/Insights/Press_Releases/2012/4/1_in_...

> I don't see how to can make a reasoned argument that Android is objectively vastly superior

It's an opinion... :]

Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by new299 on Sunday May 05, 2013 @10:25AM (#5658401)
> There's generally little difference in device capability or pricing between iphones and non-iphones in Japan

Actually Japan is probably one of the few places you could say Android phones are more capable as a lot of them have 1Seg tuners. :)

The iPhone plans in Japan also tend to me more expensive (partly due to LTE on the iPhone 5).

The situation is also slightly odd in Japan as the historically largest provider (docomo) doesn't distribute the iPhone. They are however rapidly losing customers possibly because of this:

http://japandailypress.com/docomo-bleeds-subscribers-as-ipho...

Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by philwelch on Saturday May 04, 2013 @03:29AM (#5654374)
> Gmail, of course, essentially sets the bar for online mail, and is still leaps and bounds better than any of its competitors.

If Gmail keeps lowering the bar instead of raising it, that's not going to be true for much longer.

Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by nijk on Sunday May 05, 2013 @11:44AM (#5658654)
There about two features that matter in consumer mail: storage quota, multi-location/mobile availability (not a fixed single client machine), and spam.
Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by philwelch on Sunday May 05, 2013 @02:43PM (#5659284)
Storage is storage, no worry catching up there. Multi-location availability is just IMAP. That leaves spam as the only hard problem, though admittedly it's a problem squarely in Google's wheelhouse.
Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by threeseed on Saturday May 04, 2013 @04:59AM (#5654513)
The days of Google Maps being vastly better than Apple Maps are fast disappearing. It is about 95% parity for Australia and UK at least and any differences are being eliminated rapidly. And the touted advantages of Street View aren't there since the data is at least 4 years out of date in some countries.

The fact is that Maps aren't something you can dramatically keep improving. You reach the "everything is mapped" point and then it becomes a keeping everything up to date scenario.

Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by snogglethorpe on Saturday May 04, 2013 @04:32PM (#5656224)
> The days of Google Maps being vastly better than Apple Maps are fast disappearing. It is about 95% parity [...]

Not where I live (Tokyo), it isn't.

I have an iPad mini (got it for free!! :] ), which has a nice large display, and I'd really like to be able to use a mapping app on it when I'm at home, but using Apple Maps is painful compared to Google Maps (which I have on my phone). The presentation in Apple Maps is very pretty (well, as long as you don't turn on satellite view and notice the super low-resolution images...), but the data/integration just isn't there.

If you live in Cupertino, of course, Apple Maps probably has fewer issues...

Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by new299 on Saturday May 04, 2013 @08:32AM (#5654846)
I don't know about the rest of the world, but it's still a lot worse than Google Maps in Japan. I'm sure it will come in time, but it's a difficult problem and one that google has a better handle on with it's background in "big data".
Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by nickles on Saturday May 04, 2013 @11:40AM (#5655219)
I'm not quite sure that this is true. I've been noticing many more house addresses in captchas recently, indicating that Google is working to make sure that home addresses in Maps accurately correspond to those in the real world. While improvements of this nature are far less noticeable, they demonstrate that many of the remaining improvements to the product are being made 'under the hood'.
Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by BitMastro on Saturday May 04, 2013 @05:47AM (#5654586)
Good luck with that. BTW aren't you going to point out once again that for example in Australia all the data comes from Tele Atlas and Whereis?
Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by turing on Friday May 03, 2013 @11:22PM (#5653844)
Glass is piquing more interest than any consumer electronics device since the iPhone, Plus is thriving, and Docs is by far the best cloud office suite I've seen. I am by no means saying that Google is the best in every market they enter--some of their offerings are pathetic compared to the competition-- but your claims of across the board mediocrity in their non-search products is severely overblown.
Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by zone411 on Saturday May 04, 2013 @01:05AM (#5654074)
Google+ doesn't appear to "thriving" to me. Here is one indicator: http://www.google.com/trends/explore#q=google%20%2B%2C%20goo... (flat line). For comparison, add "imgur" or "hotmail" to the input. Here is another where it looks a bit better: http://siteanalytics.compete.com/plus.google.com/. However, considering the amount of integration with their other products, I can't see it as anything more than a disappointment for Google.
Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by CatMtKing on Saturday May 04, 2013 @03:00AM (#5654326)
That's looking at search queries though, right? Why would any one Google for g+, when there's a link to it on the top left corner of Google's search page?
Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by rubinelli on Saturday May 04, 2013 @06:26AM (#5654641)
The concept behind Glass is fantastic. For all the talk of "cyborgs" and "glassholes", it's clear that it struck a nerve. What we don't have enough information to say yet is if Glass is the new iPad or the new Newton.
Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by wyclif on Saturday May 04, 2013 @12:33AM (#5654014)
As soon as I read "Plus is a wasteland", I knew you had no idea what you were talking about, and stopped reading.
Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by bergie on Saturday May 04, 2013 @08:21AM (#5654820)
Indeed. Communities has made G+ something I read multiple times a day, at the expense of Twitter
Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by antoinec on Friday May 03, 2013 @11:56PM (#5653944)
Google Maps/Earth, Android, I wouldn't call that mediocre and not innovative...
Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by bifrost on Saturday May 04, 2013 @02:54AM (#5654314)
Maps/Earth are cool, but they've stagnated, Barely changed in the last few years.

Android is neat, but its not innovative either. The only reason I use one is because of the wide variety of HW available.

Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by jacquesm on Saturday May 04, 2013 @05:55AM (#5654595)
> Maps/Earth are cool, but they've stagnated, Barely changed in the last few years.

That's a feature, not a bug.

I actually like the way maps works right now, I would not want change just for its own sake.

Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by tomkarlo on Sunday May 05, 2013 @01:27AM (#5657530)
There's been a ton of new features on maps over the past few years, including indoor maps, indoor streetview, transit info and all kinds of new aerial views. I'm not sure what you'd want from them... after all, they are still a map service.

http://google-latlong.blogspot.com/

Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by antoinec on Saturday May 04, 2013 @02:05PM (#5655705)
If you think android is not innovative, then I guess google search isn't innovative either: search engine existed before google.
Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by danieldk on Saturday May 04, 2013 @03:38AM (#5654388)
And yet, I have to resort to Garmin software and maps to do real trip planning (cycling, hiking, and even driving).
Re:Predicting Google Product Shutdowns by tomkarlo on Sunday May 05, 2013 @01:20AM (#5657519)
At least in my experience (in the US) the maps data on Google is much better for cycling routes, partially because users can go in and submit fixes, which I don't believe you can do for the Garmin data.