It's the other way around. When property is owned by all, we take care of it better. Think of parks.
There are already companies who own lakes, rivers, areas of land; and pollute the hell out of them. They used these areas as waste dumps. Which, in the end, end up hurting us all.
Go to any pork farm in NC and have a look around. You'll see first hand what ownership of lands by "the" company does to the land.
Living space: how many landlords you know that actually take care of their properties now - without getting their arm twisted?
Likewise, your criticism of private ownership is too extreme. The vast majority of landlords take excellent care of their properties for example. Others take the right amount of care so that the place isn't great, but can be rented for less. Some landlords let a place decay until it's unsafe, but that's usually when incentives are set up that its in their best interests to do so. Such incentives are the opposite of private property rights and are usually in the form of rent controls, etc, where you can raise rent only when you drive tenants out, or its not profitable to use a property as housing and the only way to change its use is through its destruction.
On the flip side, the example of privately owned waterways is a terrible one, because there's no way to avoid the communal, commons nature of the ecosystem. And companies might have a use for the lake or river (disposal of toxic waste) that is counter to the common interest, as you rightly point out. Then they poison everyone.
So: communal ownership. Suboptimal but we're stuck with it in many situations, so we need to implement it as effectively as we can.
I'm not really sure that you can make that kind of blanket statement. How ownership and care is organized, communal or not, has more to do with how properties end up.
> Likewise, your criticism of private ownership is too extreme. The vast majority of landlords take excellent care of their properties for example. Others take the right amount of care so that the place isn't great, but can be rented for less. Some landlords let a place decay until it's unsafe, but that's usually when incentives are set up that its in their best interests to do so. Such incentives are the opposite of private property rights and are usually in the form of rent controls, etc, where you can raise rent only when you drive tenants out, or its not profitable to use a property as housing and the only way to change its use is through its destruction.
This is really contrary to the history of housing property ownership in the US. Pre-housing reglations saw that properties used by the poorest members of society were not well taken care of and were often extremely dangerous due to lack of adequate plumbing, structural integrity, lighting, etc. Even today we have issues getting landlords to obey regulations and provide adequate housing as they are required to by law, although the state of housing will vary by locale. Also, landlords have no incentive to fix property issues until there is a legal threat that affects their ability to operate a property and even then getting action may be difficult, esp. if you are a poorer tenant and do not have the resources to take action against your landlord to suddenly move to a new place.
It's not nearly that simple. Someone needs to do most of those jobs, and a substantial proportion of them are in companies that can't hide illegal hires easily. E.g. try to explain to tax authorities why you're not paying payroll taxes for servers if you're a restaurant. Instead many companies will have to increase prices. Sure, that sucks for export businesses, so it is not without cost.
It is almost comical when people present government protections as making it worse compared to US conditions, which are at a level that most Europeans shudder at the thought of being subjected to US working conditions. The US is a shining beacon of how individual negotiation does not work to get decent working conditions for the vast majority.
What would most likely happen is that one set of restaurants would increase prices, whilst another would try to avoid doing so, by trying to find ways to reduce service costs (e.g. customers place their order at a machine, rather than with a human). Some of each would be successful, some would not. But over time the trend is towards more and more low paid jobs being pushed back to the customer themselves. In many countries minimum wage has been a key factor in killing off many jobs, (e.g. as pumping gas.)
Also, if minimum wage is raised to above your current wage, you're now competing for it with people who were in that higher wage bracket before. If a business now has to pay someone, say, $10 an hour instead of $7, they will be able to get people with more experience / skill for that price, making it harder for people to get entry-level jobs in the first place.
Countries like Norway does not have massive unemployment by international standard, despite one of the flattest salary curves in the world.
> If a business now has to pay someone, say, $10 an hour instead of $7, they will be able to get people with more experience / skill for that price, making it harder for people to get entry-level jobs in the first place.
This assumes the more qualified people want those jobs, even at $10 instead of $7.
If I could get a job as a cleaner for what I make as a software developer, I'd still pick the (much less physically demanding, and less soul destroying) job as a software developer.
If salary was even the main determinant for why people pick the jobs they do, then we'd practically have no nurses or teachers, for example - both jobs that require disproportionally long education for the often very low salaries they command.
Or even law.
In the UK, the average salary for solicitors (who require 3 or 4 years for a degree plus the Legal Practice Course of one year plus two years of practice before you become qualified) is lower than the national average salary.
You can make far more in many professions that don't require even a degree. In fact, there are people in retail and fast food jobs that make more than many UK solicitors, yet work normal hours where many solicitors work hours that are illegal in most European countries.
But most of the positions that are in the territory that would be affected by minimum wage restrictions tends to be positions primarily attracting the totally unqualified that are generally positions that are extremely unattractive for qualified workers and remain so for most even if the salary was better.
How many people do you come across that actively want to make a career for themselves working themselves up the ladder in McDonalds? Yet making manager at a McDonalds in the UK can net you 45k GBP/year or more - far above the average UK salary. Economically, a large proportion of UK solicitors, teachers, nurses and many others would be better off working at McDonalds. Yet we don't see a massive flight of highly qualified people to McDonalds or similar.
Right, like 15-20% unemployment rates.
>Countries like Norway does not have massive unemployment by >international standard, despite one of the flattest salary >curves in the world.
Because they make gigantic profits on gas and oil. Saying socialism is good because the economy flourishes in Norway is akin to saying monarchy is good because the economy flourishes in Saudi Arabia.
>If I could get a job as a cleaner for what I make as a >software developer, I'd still pick the (much less physically >demanding, and less soul destroying) job as a software >developer.
And if you have no experience what so ever and want to get this first job cleaning for $7/hr you won't stand a chance with minimal pay at $10/hr. Because the employer will get someone experienced instead of you in that price range. So the minimal wage will effectively put you out of the job market. That's why there are so many more unemployed among unskilled young workers than in general population across all age groups. Without the minimal wage law you could get a first job for let's say just $3/hr, then get experience and then get more money as an experienced worker in another job. With minimal wage enforced this is not happening, you stay out of the job market never being able to get this first job. Before minimal wage law was imposed the unemployment rate among young was the lowest among all group ages. Currently is the highest among all groups ages. This is precisely because of the minimal wage law. Minimal wage was on a political agenda of Unions that lobbied successfuly for it, to actually protect their union members from price competition with young unskilled workers. Singapore has literally no unemployment among young and has had none for decades. Also has no minimal wage and GDP per capita of over $60K compared to $50k in the US. And then the whole discussion is really utter nonsense because as long as you can get free labor that's called "internships". So instead of paying minimal wage companies end up paying nothing to guys who could actually make at least these $3/hr. Wouldn't that be better? You see too much regulation completely screwed-up the job market for young unskilled workers. You can get them for minimal wage or for free, but if you want to get them for the market rate it's illegal. That's just plain stupid.
Price is always in favor of who is better organised. In terms of negotiation, it often resembles a mexican standoff. Who wins a mexican standoff? Well, you dont find out by counting bullets. (Which is what you are doing).
Workers get exploited by companies if they have less savings on the bank. Companies get exploited by their workers if they have less savings. In the end they often need each other more than they are willing to admit.
The whole socialism vs capitalism debate does actually end up in either revolution or an authoritin state. But to consider minimum wage "socialism" or exploiting interns "capitalism" feels like more americans anally inserting their one dimensional culture war into reality. Does this bullshit pass for "intellectual debate"? I sure hope not.
So please dont refer to Europe in your arguments. We are neither socialist nor capitalists. Not into the extreme of these arguments. And not on this one dimensional axis.
And unemployment may be high in certain parts of Europe. Its high because we let capitalism do its thing. The economy has to reform itself. Certain economic activity has to burn, to make room for progress. But we do actually take care of each other.
Though, I feel I am being too cynical, fearing the unknown. I would like to know what the situation was in a pre-minimum-wage era.
Any material to back up this wild claim?
What I'm interested in is: 1. Name of the revolutions. 2. Their place. 3. Their date. 4. Professional historian who claims that the "wage slavery" lead to the events in points 1-3. (not a communist with an agenda)
I assure you that the Marxist (or rather Bolshevik) revolution in Russia in 1917 wasn't caused by "wage slavery". As any other communist revolution too.
Probably you watch too much KGB-TV... sorry RussiaToday.
Sure it was. Wage slavery -> the work of Marx (alone and with and Engels) -> core of the propaganda basis for the Bolshevik revolution (with suitable adaptations to be applied in a something other than an industrialized, democratic, capitalist environment.)
Now, it wasn't a proximate cause, but...
Aside from that, I suppose, you could look at the generally-less-violent process by which virtually every state even approximately meeting the necessary preconditions for Communism in Marx's work has adopted a substantial subset of the platform laid out in the Communist Manifesto as a form of "Marxist revolution" that is more like the Green Revolution or the Industrial Revolution than the Bolshevik Revolution; in that case, "wage slavery" was more of a proximate cause than it was of any of the various violent revolutions driven by Leninism/Stalinism/Maoism, et al.
I lived in communistic country, trust me workers were exploited much more in the communism than in capitalism. They had to work for free in gulags (slave labor), they had to work overtime (i.e. 16 hour shifts), the child labor was common. And any complaints regarding this were equaled to anti-communistic act of treason and punished with jail time. Ever heard of Dear Leader and North Korea?
I think you got it backwards. You really did. The revolution of workers against the communistic rule is ultimately this what destroyed communism in the Eastern Block. Solidarnosc was a trading union fighting against communism. If communism was so great for workers why they were the ones who lead the revolution against it in places like Poland?
Communism is much more worker unfriendly system than capitalism. So, yep, you got it opposite. There were workers revolutions against communism and not capitalism.
But because communism is a religion, you won't listen to these arguments based by facts in recent history, you'll keep mumbling about Marx, so I'll leave you with that. It's like trying to explain to a Catholic that a virgin can't give a birth to a child.
I don't trust you on that point. I would agree that countries that claim to be "communist" exploit workers far more than workers are exploited in modern mixed economies like those in most of the West, of course, but that's somewhat beside the point of the discussion. First, because no one claimed anything to which that is directly relevant, and second, because, while the modern west is often called "capitalist", it bears little resemblance in economic system to the system in the 19th century whose critics (notably, Marx) coined the term "capitalism" to refer to, differing from those systems largely by having adopted, on top of the old capitalist system, a number of reforms, many of which are straight out of the Communist Manifesto.
> The revolution of workers against the communistic rule is ultimately this what destroyed communism in the Eastern Block.
Sure, largely. That doesn't make it any less true that the exploitation of workers under capitalism was the source of Marxism and a proximate cause for the adoption of many policies that were part of the original Communist program as near-universal policies throughout the developed world by Social Democrats/Democratic Socialists, and that the same dissatisfaction was a less-proximate contributor to the "Communist" revolutions of Lenin and his ideological heirs.
> If communism was so great for workers why they were the ones who lead the revolution against it in places like Poland?
I don't recall anyone arguing that "communism was so great for workers". Arguing that capitalism being so bad for workers was one of the causes of the development and spread of Communist ideology is not equivalent to arguing that Communism, as implemented by Lenin et al., was "good for workers". It does not even require the weaker claim that Leninism was better than 19th capitalism for workers.
> Communism is much more worker unfriendly system than capitalism. So, yep, you got it opposite.
Well, except that you are the only one who is arguing about the topic of whether Communism is more worker friendly than capitalism, on either side.
I.e. a revolution of some type in Russia in 1917 would happen for sure because people were tired of monarchy. Not capitalism.
There is probably some strained definition of "workers revolution" for which this is true, but since it doesn't contradict anything I said, I am not sure what your basis is for the claim that it is contrary to my point of view, rather than a complete non-sequitur.
And, if it wasn't workers, who exactly is that drove the revolutionary change in western economic systems that led to late 19th Century capitalism being replaced, pretty much universally in the West by the mid-20th Century, with the modern "mixed" economy which adopts a wide range of socialist elements?
Voters - you can even substitute "voters" with "workers" - in a democratic process (non-violent) and not workers in a revolutionary anti-capitalistic revolution.
So, it's not like they hated capitalism so much that they had to do revolutionary violent acts to overthrow the system. They modified it by voting. Evolution, progress, not a revolution.
Again, revolutions there were against communistic rule. Communism was much worse so people revolted against it and not opted for an evolutionary change.
Funny how communism propaganda has always been all about revolution, but that never happened. History shows us that people - mostly workers who were supposed to have it so good under the communistic rule - revolted against communism. Not capitalism. In capitalism they voted for a change and they got it.
[1] http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/mar/07/spain-unemployme...
| As soon as the waters have an owner, the owner has
| an incentive to protect them
What if the owners don't care? What if it's not possible to police it (it's not like a local stream is monetizable in the way that a section of the Mississippi would be).What if major waterways like the Mississippi were owned? What if a section of the Mississippi were owned by some guy that would only allow people/companies through if they were (e.g.) Christians?
What happens when I dump toxic waste on my own property but it seeps into ground water that the entire area (or just my neighbors via pumps) uses for water? What happens when it runs off and onto my neighbor's property? What if my neighbor is a farmer and this wrecks his livelihood?
Or, the owner has an incentive to exploit the heck out of the river/lake until it's saturated with pollution, and then they move on.
Under that scheme, who would have the property rights for the atmosphere? I rather like living in a place where atmospheric pollution (both domestic and commercial) is tightly controlled by regulations. We tried the alternative years ago and it was a disaster on many fronts.
Regulations are kind of a roundabout way to solve the problem. You want the polluter to be concerned about affecting its neighbors, not just to meet (or help set) some arbitrary government standard.
It should be possible to sue air polluters for putting
toxins on your property
Not possible. For example, diesel exhaust and wood smoke both contain carcinogenic submicron particulate matter pollution. It's not possible to sue every truck driver and person with a campfire who is within several miles of one's home. This is why we need regulations like burn bans and diesel engine emission regulations.Also, aggregation techniques could be used for both defendants (polluters) and plaintiffs (landowners and other people being poisoned.)
> Environmental destruction happens because government restricts property rights and creates commons which belong to no one. For example, when the river waters belong to no one, people feel free to dump into it. As soon as the waters have an owner, the owner has an incentive to protect them. See http://mises.org/daily/2120
Ok, now i think you've gone full retard. If the rivers a protected by a rivers authority then they are not ownerless.
I am curious. How do you go about deciding ownership on a long river? What rights does "owning" a river give you?
I think that there's something wrong with an upstream owner polluting the river and causing damage to people downstream. The situation is analogous to burning poisonous chemicals on land and letting the wind currents carry the chemicals onto neighboring property. In this case the burner would be liable.
The overall point is that pollution can and should be handled as a property-rights matter and that the state need not and should not "regulate" pollution.
Bullshit.
> Similarly child labor is only a problem when families are too poor to survive if the children don't work.
Bullshit.
> Minimum wage laws "protect" the least profitable workers from getting legal jobs, forcing them to get illegal jobs or survive on government handouts.
Bullshit.
> Environmental destruction happens because government restricts property rights and creates commons which belong to no one.
Big surprise, bullshit.
For example, many illegal aliens in the US are exploited because they are prohibited by law from getting a job. So they can only get hired by the few employers willing to break the law to hire them. If it were legal for them to work, they would find better jobs.
Similarly child labor is only a problem when families are too poor to survive if the children don't work.
Minimum wage laws "protect" the least profitable workers from getting legal jobs, forcing them to get illegal jobs or survive on government handouts. To see this, imagine if the minimum wage were set just above your current wage. You would then be out of a job.
Environmental destruction happens because government restricts property rights and creates commons which belong to no one. For example, when the river waters belong to no one, people feel free to dump into it. As soon as the waters have an owner, the owner has an incentive to protect them. See http://mises.org/daily/2120