News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bruce Eckel on why he's moving back to Windows from Mac by MBCook on Saturday April 27, 2013 @05:23PM (#5619095)
> And he presents it as "what I had trouble with", not "what's wrong with the Mac", which is commendable.

I couldn't agree more. Whenever I see a title like this my immediate thought is "here we go again", but I clicked through anyway and was pleasantly surprised.

I've never used Windows 8 (or 7/Vista for more than a few minutes), but his criticisms seemed well considered. Macs can be more expensive for the same amount of CPU. I expected he was going to be talking about the Mac Pros (which are based on what, 2010 hardware?) so I was a little surprised to see he was talking about laptops.

The other thing that caught my attention was his note about trackpads. It seems like every review I read about a non-Mac laptop (which, to be fair, doesn't happen much) seems to mention how they are either terrible or just OK. Considering how important the trackpad is on a laptop, it always surprises me that this seems to continue to be an issue.

I remember years ago when Macs had 3" trackpads and PCs still had tiny 2" models. My MacBook Pro has a 5" pad, but I've seen 17" desktop replacement laptops with 3" pads.

Worse was that while Macs gained two finger scrolling (which was a great step up), may PCs gained "scroll areas", so that you'd lose a large fraction of the trackpad. The fact that part of it was horizontal scrolling (which is far less common) was even worse.

Are trackpads in the non-Mac world really that far behind, or is it just selection bias where the few laptop reviews I read only mention the trackpad because it's bad and the rest don't even discuss it.

Re:Bruce Eckel on why he's moving back to Windows from Mac by Joeri on Saturday April 27, 2013 @05:36PM (#5619139)
Windows laptop trackpads are indeed universally horrible. I've never come across a non-mac laptop i could use all day without an external mouse. Apple kust have some jealously guarded patents on trackpad tech.
Re:Bruce Eckel on why he's moving back to Windows from Mac by phaus on Saturday April 27, 2013 @05:58PM (#5619202)
Trackpads are universally horrible even on Apple computers. Apple's are far superior to Windows trackpads, but nothing can make using a trackpad a pleasant experience for me.
Re:Bruce Eckel on why he's moving back to Windows from Mac by cjh_ on Saturday April 27, 2013 @06:27PM (#5619274)
I find the modern synaptic trackpad on my Thinkpad X1 carbon to be amazing, it worked well under windows and runs very well under Linux (maybe even a bit better as I am more familiar with how to configure it).
Re:Bruce Eckel on why he's moving back to Windows from Mac by Tmmrn on Saturday April 27, 2013 @05:39PM (#5619155)
I haven't used Mac Touchpads much yet, but every time I do use one the acceleration feels extremely weird.

On my laptop the touchpad does pretty much behave how I expect it to behave.

Also, a Netbook I bought 2008 or so had two-finger scroll. True, many backwards notebook manufacturers were behind the times but most just have been using the standard synaptics hardware I think. The windows drivers have the scroll area preconfigured by default but then the scrolling behaviour with the synaptics tool is pretty bad no matter how you configure it.

On linux synaptics touchpads are just fine (for me).

Re:Bruce Eckel on why he's moving back to Windows from Mac by knowaveragejoe on Saturday April 27, 2013 @06:09PM (#5619233)
You need to use one for a bit and fiddle with the settings. Most store models have the speed jacked up and I can understand why you'd feel it's weird. Once you get it adjusted to your liking, I've never used a trackpad that remotely compares... Everything is incredibly smooth. Clicking on the trackpad itself, including right clicking... genius. Gestures are simple and intuitive. Two-finger scroll is just buttery smooth and precise, and to top it off the two-finger back/forward.
Re:Bruce Eckel on why he's moving back to Windows from Mac by Tmmrn on Sunday April 28, 2013 @03:20PM (#5622376)
As I said, with xf86-input-synaptics I can't complain about my notebooks touchpad. Two finger scroll is ok in both directions. I don't really need the "genius" of mac touchpads as tapping on the touchpad will be a "left click", a two finger tap will be a middle click and a three finger tap will be a middle click.
Re:Bruce Eckel on why he's moving back to Windows from Mac by MBCook on Saturday April 27, 2013 @06:29PM (#5619282)
The acceleration this is just the OS. You get used to it pretty quickly. The only time I even remember it exists is when I boot my Mac into Windows.
Re:Bruce Eckel on why he's moving back to Windows from Mac by what_ever on Saturday April 27, 2013 @07:49PM (#5619517)
Genuine question - What trackpad functionality do you use often on a Mac that you think saves your time compared to using the corresponding keyboard actions? I have used Mac for about 4 months in the last year as my primary machine and although the trackpad actions are quite flashy, I never found them useful.

I know Unity is universally hated, but I am fond of its keyboard support. I rarely have to use my mouse and I using keyboard instead of trackpad in those situations saves my time.

Re:Bruce Eckel on why he's moving back to Windows from Mac by MBCook on Saturday April 27, 2013 @08:52PM (#5619701)
Sure. I have a MacBook Pro for personal use, and at work I'm a Java developer using an iMac with a Magic Trackpad.

I don't use all the gestures, just a few of them. But I've been doing it for so long they're second nature to me.

Two finger scroll one of the most important. I remember trying to use friend's PCs before it became common and being frustrated every time.

Two finger click works like a right-click, so I don't need to hold a key or dedicate part of my touchpad to right-clicking.

Three finger swipe left/right is amazing. It functions as a forward/backward gesture. In Safari it moves through history. In IntelliJ (my IDE of choice) it does the same thing, which is invaluable. I don't even know the keyboard shortcut in IntelliJ, it just works. And it works in Chrome. And Xcode. Having a universal gesture is fantastic.

Another favorite is four fingers up, which activates Expose. When you're moving between multiple applications and copying & pasting it makes makes things so much easier. I don't have to move my hand off command-C/V.

Four finger spread shows the desktop, which I use occasionally.

Double-tap with two fingers zooms in iOS style in Safari, which can e useful

Double-tap with three fingers opens the dictionary (& Wikipedia!) anywhere in the os on whatever you tap on. Reading an article and don't know what something is? Just double-tap three fingers and a little pop-up tells you. It's one of those functions that's always been there but it's so easy to get to I actually use it now.

That's what I use. There are a few more. Four fingers together opens Launcher. In Safari the zoom out gesture (pinch two fingers) brings up a tab-list, but I keep forgetting that's there since it's a relatively recent add. Four fingers down is Expose for one application, but I don't have much need for that. Two fingers from the right edge opens the notifications in Mountain Lion (which I don't really use).

If you're a multi-desktop person, four fingers left or right switches between desktops (including Dashboard) and every full screen application. This also works for app switching on iPad 2/3/4s.

Really it's like using command-c/v to copy and paste or command-tab to switch applications. It's quick and easy to do, and you quickly forget it's there and start doing it automatically.

Honestly I hate helping coworkers with a problem in IntellJ because they all use normal mice and I can't easily jump back to the last place I did an edit (even in another file). I'm working on helping them and then all of a sudden there is a brain stall while I realize that I can't just do a swipe and have to think to go click on the tab I want.

I feel handicapped without them; like something is missing. I remember how much I liked getting a button on the side of my MS IntelliMouse I could use to go back when surfing, this is like 100x that.

Edit: It just occurred to me that these aren't default gestures. A few of them changed in Mountain Lion and I set my Macs back to the way Lion had them, so you may have to experiment.

Re:Bruce Eckel on why he's moving back to Windows from Mac by what_ever on Saturday April 27, 2013 @09:27PM (#5619794)
I am a Java developer as well and I use Ubuntu on both my personal and work machine. I think I have equivalent key combinations/mouse gestures for most of the things you listed. e.g.

two finger scroll and two finger right click is almost universal now. When inside a browser, I rarely use the mouse scroll and prefer to use spacebar or up/down keys to scroll for granularity and I know where each action is going to land me (spacebar = page down, up/down key = just one line)

For forward/back I use Alt + right/left arrow. This works in browser, file browser, Eclipse. I suppose this would work in IntelliJ as well. In Eclipse, This doesn't take to the last place you made edit at, but the last place you had focused at (across files). Besides there is a shortcut Ctrl + q to go to the last place of edit (across files) in Eclipse. There are equivalent shortcuts in other editors that I have used.

There is no equivalent of Expose in Ubuntu. But how does it differ from using Alt + tab? When all the windows are exposed do you have to move your mouse pointer to the window you want to focus on and four fingers again? I think that's how I remember it. I love Ubuntu's Alt + tab and Alt + ` to be honest. You can also use left/right arrow keys with these two options. Granted, I do have to take my hand of Ctrl if I am doing copy/paste.

So three finger double click seems to be the only action I see myself to be missing that I would use.

As I programmer, I am typing for most of the time. So honestly, I think keyboard shortcuts work faster as I don't have to move one of my hand everytime. This is specially true if you are working on a desktop as you really have to move your hand to the magic mouse. YMMV though.

One of the things I hated about Mac was there are no equivalent of 'Super' key shortcuts which are present on both Windows and Ubuntu. Like Super + 1 launches the first application in my doc. This is much faster than opening spotlight and launching an application from there using a keyboard. Also, some of the shortcuts are not universal. Chrome used Ctrl + tab to change the tab and Firefox used Cmd + tab (I suppose?). Being from Windows/Ubuntu background, it was really frustrating to get used to the Cmd key at some of the places.

One more mouse gesture related thing I would like to add is that I love FireGestures add-on on Firefox. If I am just reading news/sites and not typing, I use my mouse and FireGestures + mouse works great. Firefox is my primary browser and I didn't find any equally good extension for Chrome.

Re:Bruce Eckel on why he's moving back to Windows from Mac by MBCook on Saturday April 27, 2013 @11:11PM (#5620017)
I use a number of keyboard shortcuts, but I still use the mouse a fair bit, especially when surfing/doing email/etc.

The nice thing about forward/back gesture is that it works almost everywhere, and I don't have to learn a different keyboard shortcut for each program. I accidentally discovered it worked one day and it stuck. It had never occurred to me to go searching for a keyboard shortcut to do it.

Expose is quite nice. In OS X command-tab switches between open applications (not windows, applications). There is no list displayed like Windows XP had. When you trigger Expose, every open window is automatically arranged on screen. You just click it with your mouse and everything moves back into place with the window you clicked now at the top.

I use command-tab when I'm in keyboard mode (such as coding) and Expose when in mouse mode (surfing, browsing email, etc).

I think you're right bout the Super-1 shortcuts. I don't think there is anything like that in the Mac. I usually have every program I'm using open, but when I need something else I just use Spotlight. Command-space opens it (I believe that was the old key combo, which I set Mountain Lion to use), I type a few letters, and hit enter. There are other programs that are faster or more powerful (Quicksliver and Alfred are popular), but Spotlight was good enough.

Tab switching doesn't seem to be standard. I know that in Safari the key commands are Command-[ or Command-], but I don't know if that works in other programs. When I first switched it didn't take too long to learn when to use command. But I also used Macs when I was a kid, maybe that helped.

One pleasant side-effect of the way the Mac has evolved is that the keyboard shortcuts work perfectly with Terminal. Both control and meta ('option' on the keyboard) work exactly as you expect. Control-c quits programs, control-d sends end-of-line, emacs is easy, etc. But the command key isn't used by any unix program I know of.

That means it's free to make life easy. Copy and paste are still command-c and command-v. You can clear the terminal with command-k, and standard window management things (-h for hide, -tab for program switch, -` for window switch) all work without interfering with whatever program you're running.

It's a total accident of history, but it worked out great.

Re:Bruce Eckel on why he's moving back to Windows from Mac by white_devil on Sunday April 28, 2013 @05:16AM (#5620702)
Have you ever tried Opera's Mouse Gestures? Trying to use another browser is a similar experience to you helping your colleagues with IDEA.
Re:Bruce Eckel on why he's moving back to Windows from Mac by what_ever on Sunday April 28, 2013 @07:28PM (#5623285)
I use Firegesture add-on on Firefox and it's awesome with a mouse. Not so much with a trackpad.
Re:Bruce Eckel on why he's moving back to Windows from Mac by TYPE_FASTER on Saturday April 27, 2013 @09:51PM (#5619842)
Two finger scroll and two and three finger swiping are awesome. I always try to use them on Windows laptops before realizing they're not there.
Re:Bruce Eckel on why he's moving back to Windows from Mac by lostlogin on Saturday April 27, 2013 @05:34PM (#5619128)
Yeah, I was recently handed a new laptop - brand escapes me. Whatever it was had high specs and a big price. Asked what I thought I opened a web page then automatically tried two finger scrolling. The confused owned asked what I was doing then directed me to the little arrows in the corner of the widow. I couldn't happily own a laptop that didn't have this functionality or similar.
Re:Bruce Eckel on why he's moving back to Windows from Mac by what_ever on Saturday April 27, 2013 @07:41PM (#5619496)
I can't believe a recent laptop (on any OS) not supporting two finger scrolling. Some laptops have it disabled by default, but it is there. I haven't seen a laptop without 2 finger scrolling on last 15 (friends') laptops I have used.
Re:Bruce Eckel on why he's moving back to Windows from Mac by jamesbritt on Saturday April 27, 2013 @06:44PM (#5619312)
Considering how important the trackpad is on a laptop, it always surprises me that this seems to continue to be an issue.

Less important if there is a trackpoint mouse, something near and dear to my heart. I've disabled the trackpad on my latops; they don't suit me and end up getting in the way. I get much better behavior using the trackpoint mouse.

Re:Bruce Eckel on why he's moving back to Windows from Mac by TYPE_FASTER on Saturday April 27, 2013 @09:49PM (#5619839)
> Are trackpads in the non-Mac world really that far behind

YES. I have a Thinkpad T530 from 2011 and a MacBook Pro from 2009 and the older Mac's trackpad is so much better.