News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by ck2 on Friday April 19, 2013 @10:30PM (#5579695)
It took hundreds of police and probably millions of dollars to catch a teenager who didn't even bother to leave the area or go into hiding - and even TWEETED after the event.

If we were attacked by real, organized terrorists, we are screwed.

I really do not get all the celebration and back-patting, it's disturbing.

Oh and while this huge distraction was going on - no background checks for guns, the most basic bill failed.

But several senators were quick to voice their desire for no miranda rights.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by mindcrime on Friday April 19, 2013 @10:54PM (#5579808)
Oh and while this huge distraction was going on - no background checks or database for guns.

Background checks are already required for almost all gun sales, including ones at gun-shows. This whole discussion is a red-herring. And what the f%!# good do you think a "database for guns" is going to do? You think the terrorists buy their guns over the counter, with legit IDs and happily register them with the authorities? You expect the terrorists to register their pressure cookers? Maybe we should have background checks for buying those?

And then what? Background checks for buying nichrome wire, because it can be used as a bridgewire in a detonator? A database of Arduinos, since they can be used as timers for bombs?

Or how about a national database of people who guy gasoline, Drano, nails, ball-bearings, lithium-ion batteries, soldering irons, solder...

Better still, let's implement a Great Firewall of America to keep people from accessing subversive content like Inspire magazine, the Unabomber manifesto, the writings of Timothy McVeigh, the Koran, Cryptome, Wikileaks, Paladin Press, Justin Bieber songs, Anarchist's cookbook, Poor Man's James Bond or the Federalist Papers...

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by InclinedPlane on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:01PM (#5579834)
People talk about the "90%" or whatever support that universal background checks had among the voting public. However, ignoring the problems of legislating based on shallow polls, nobody seems to be talking about the 90+% of sherrifs and police officers who believed that neither universal background checks nor a so-called "assault weapons ban" would have any beneficial effect on gun crime.
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by scottkduncan on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:24PM (#5579925)
"As we have discussed, the most logical starting point to address gun violence is the expansion of the background check system. Incomplete or absent background checks create a gaping hole in the wall between firearms and criminals. Loopholes in the background check system give criminals unprecedented opportunity to access firearms. This problem must be remedied quickly."

- National Fraternal Order of Police President Chuck Canterbury, February 16, 2013

http://www.coloradofop.org/index.cfm?zone=/unionactive/view_...

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by mindcrime on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:36PM (#5579974)
For another take on gun-control issues from the LEO perspective:

PoliceOne’s Gun Policy & Law Enforcement survey was conducted between March 4 and March 13, 2013, receiving 15,595 responses from verified police professionals across all ranks and department sizes.

http://ddq74coujkv1i.cloudfront.net/p1_gunsurveysummary_2013...

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by scottkduncan on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:49PM (#5580028)
Well, it's an online opt-in survey so you have to keep that in mind. Also, they didn't directly poll on the question of background checks, which is the subject that gets the 80 - 90% approval rating in other polls. Instead they asked about the effect of "currently proposed White House legislation" and got a much different result.
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by mindcrime on Saturday April 20, 2013 @12:03AM (#5580084)
Those are true points. I just wanted to point out that there isn't necessarily unanimous support for increased gun-control amongst LEOs. And regarding the FOP, I don't have a citation handy, but I'm pretty sure I've heard that a lot of the rank and file police officers differ with their leadership on gun control issues.
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by homosaur on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:20PM (#5579909)
90% is some BS fake skewed poll run by some organization with an anti gun agenda. It's not possibly accurate. You can make any poll say anything if you word the question skewed enough.
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by krschultz on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:51PM (#5580036)
I own guns. My parents own guns. My brother owns guns.my cousin owns 15+ guns and is a police officer. My girlfriends father owns guns. Some of us belong to the NRA. My brother and cousin going shooting a couple times a month. In some cases, we own guns that would be banned under a lot of gun control laws. My cousins response to Newton was to buy an AR15.

Yet we all support background checks. I don't find the 90% number hard to believe at all.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by mindcrime on Saturday April 20, 2013 @12:01AM (#5580075)
Yes, but... if the question on the survey was "Do you support background checks for gun purchases?" you might, indeed, get a 90% "yes" score. But, that question would be bogus vis-a-vis the recent proposal, since background checks are already required for the majority of gun purchases. To get a meaningful response, the question would need to be "do you support even stricter background check rules than are currently in place?" and you'd really need a way to eliminate answers from people who don't know what the current rules are.

So quoting that 90% number might be technically accurate for some specific question on some specific poll, but I'd question whether or not it actually reflects public sentiment on this issue, from people who actually have an informed opinion on the issue.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by homosaur on Saturday April 20, 2013 @01:05AM (#5580328)
It's not that I'm against background checks per se, it's that they are useless in stopping crime. It's simply a feel good badge we can throw on our sashes.

Plus, if we're serious about reducing gun violence, we limit handguns, not rifles. We can pat ourselves on the back and make us feel better over dead kids, but the real problem in this country with gun violence is handguns. The fact that it's all about "assault rifles" (a meaningless loaded nonsense term) shows that people are not the least bit sincere or knowledgable.

I know 3 places right now I can purchase a handgun without paperwork that are not gun shows.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by wyager on Saturday April 20, 2013 @12:06AM (#5580095)
>Yet we all support background checks.

Sure do love that anecdotal evidence.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by lotyrin on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:19PM (#5579903)
But it's worth sacrificing our freedoms in exchange for (only theoretically improved) safety (from causes of death that we are already extremely safe from - statistically speaking).
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by reader5000 on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:35PM (#5579969)
You and your neighbors packing assault weapons does not make you "free". It makes you "the Taliban".
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by GHFigs on Saturday April 20, 2013 @12:52AM (#5580295)
That's a weak point. You could just as easily say it makes you "the Northern Alliance", "the French Resistance", "the Black Panthers", or "the Swiss". Weapons do not dictate ideology.
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by reader5000 on Saturday April 20, 2013 @01:20AM (#5580379)
Point wasn't about ideology but way of life. For example, one of the great things about living in a largely gun-free society is that my probability of getting murdered in a drive-by revenge killing tomorrow is pretty low, since I do not belong to an armed faction responsible for an assault on an opposing faction last week.
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by GHFigs on Saturday April 20, 2013 @01:43AM (#5580444)
I think it's disingenuous to bring up the Taliban and then deny you were saying anything about ideology. It was an emotional appeal that buries your true point. You know who else did that? Hitler.
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by LeeHunter on Saturday April 20, 2013 @09:29AM (#5581324)
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by lotyrin on Saturday April 20, 2013 @12:12AM (#5580133)
I don't own or currently have plans to purchase an assault weapon. I do, however observe that a state in which only the established power may have such things is certainly not free (neither liberated nor without cost).
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by vy8vWJlco on Saturday April 20, 2013 @12:07AM (#5580100)
Tell that to the minute-men (Minutemen), coincidentally originating in Massachusetts.
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by ck2 on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:00PM (#5579833)
Why do we bother to have laws at all if people are going to break them?

I mean look at all the silencers people have to get away with murder - oh wait, they don't - because they are illegal and highly regulated.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by mindcrime on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:09PM (#5579864)
oh wait, they don't - because they are illegal and highly regulated.

OR, it could be because they're expensive, ineffective, don't last, and hurt accuracy. Or because most murders are not planned out in advance, in excruciating detail, by criminal masterminds (or even the crooks in episodes of Columbo). Somebody who finds out their spouse is cheating on them and decides to kill them in a fit of rage isn't going to care about a silencer.

Likewise, gang on gang crime over drug deals doesn't seem to involve a lot of stealthy, hit-man style assassination stuff. Those guys don't need silencers.

And the people who do want one and want to avoid your regulations? Well, they just build their own, no license, background check, or anything else needed.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by fein on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:27PM (#5579939)
It should also be noted that in some European countries, suppressors are required when shooting in a close enough proximity to a neighbor that the loudness could be an inconvenience.

Suppressors are dead easy to make out of household products as is, they just aren't worth more than 2 shots. Likewise, any individual sent as the imaginary "hitman" that everyone seems to believe exists, would probably be aligned with a group with enough finances to either buy legitimate suppressors, or procure them from the black market.

The only people that cannot purchase automatic weapons and restricted modifications (suppressors, grenade launchers, etc) are the poor. The legal roadblocks are overcome (perfectly legally) with money.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by zanny on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:51PM (#5580035)
That isn't the kind of gun violence these emotional responses are trying to stop, though. Situations like Boston and Connecticut are planned incidents. They don't use silencers for the reasons you list because they aren't trying to conceal their crimes, they just want to kill as many people as possible, and silencers hurt accuracy.

People just ignore the slaughter of spouses and mass murder of the destitute on the streets in favor of only focusing on shooting sprees.

The emotional rage murder would be culled by stricter gun laws, but gangs and mass shooters will just go to underground channels to get their armaments if they can't try to get them legally.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by strlen on Monday April 29, 2013 @03:23AM (#5624553)
It's also important to understand that suppressors are not silencers. Most movies depict a suppressed handgun as sounding like an air rifle: that's just not the case unless you're talking about specially built firearms (integral suppressors, no leaks for gas) with sub-sonic rounds. I am going to guess that very few crimes have the monetary pay-off to justify such an investment (and if they do, the criminals can certainly afford to purchase a CNC machine and manufacture a supresor themselves).

On the other hand, a regular 9mm handgun or a .223/.308 rifle with a suppressor will still be very loud: comparable to a car's engine back firing, a tire blow out, or a firecracker. That's definitely a reduction in noise compared to a regular gun shot, but while one such noise might go unnoticed, a rapid succession of such noises certainly will.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by fnordfnordfnord on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:12PM (#5579872)
I mean look at all the silencers people have to get away with murder - oh wait, they don't - because they are illegal and highly regulated.

Murderers rarely use such things

A silencer is cheap and trivial to manufacture from common materials.

I think you overestimate the deterrence of an additional felony charge. "Q. What are you in for? A. Murder... and an unlicensed weapon accessory."

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by spitfire on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:57PM (#5580057)
Often these trivial laws are passed in order to be catch alls. You might get off on a technicality of a murder charge, but they get you for the illegal silencer.

Remember, they got Al Capone on income tax violations.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by fnordfnordfnord on Saturday April 20, 2013 @03:25PM (#5582511)
And you think that's a good thing?
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by rdouble on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:05PM (#5579849)
Suppressors are legal in all but 11 states if you fill out the paperwork.
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by declan on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:14PM (#5579887)
Please don't interject facts into this discussion! This is Hacker News, where we should just say what we THINK might be correct, or should be correct, without having any actual knowledge of the subject. That's what real hackers do, right?

BTW it's worth pointing out that some countries like Finland do not regulate silencers/sound suppressors on the grounds that they reduce noise pollution and benefit public health by reducing the risk of hearing damage: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_politics_in_Finland#Related...

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by rdouble on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:33PM (#5579964)
The post I was replying to is largely correct. Criminals don't have suppressors because there is no secondary market for suppressors due to regulation. That said, I would guess they wouldn't need or use them even if they were available.
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by icelancer on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:53PM (#5580041)
Criminals don't have suppressors because they are a novelty and any gun-owner understands this.
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by vy8vWJlco on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:30PM (#5579950)
I think you're confusing HN with Slashdot. :p (At least, I always hoped the level of discussion was more nitpicking... I mean "detail-oriented.")

Also: "The data indicates that use of silenced firearms in crime is a rare occurence, and is a minor problem" ( http://wcr.sonoma.edu/v08n2/44.clark/clark.pdf )

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by D9u on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:38PM (#5579982)
...without having any actual knowledge of the subject. That's what real hackers do, right?

Not at all. Real "hackers" are intimately knowledgeable regarding the systems with which they work.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by basictheory on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:33PM (#5579962)
and wait 8-10 months for the NFA background check.
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by codewright on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:49PM (#5580030)
Silencers aren't illegal at all.

And really the proper term is sound suppressor, they're far from silent.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by homosaur on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:20PM (#5579912)
maybe in your state.
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by reader5000 on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:24PM (#5579928)
You appear to be angry and marginally psychotic. Willing to bet you have numerous high powered assault rifles. God bless America.
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by mindcrime on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:50PM (#5580032)
You appear to be somebody who slanders random people you know nothing about, makes medical diagnoses you aren't qualified to make, indulges in lazy, stereotype driven thinking, and lacks the interest or ability to contribute anything meaningful to an otherwise interesting discussion. So I guess that makes us even?
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by homosaur on Saturday April 20, 2013 @01:12AM (#5580354)
<---- reddit is that way
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by temphn on Friday April 19, 2013 @10:54PM (#5579811)
Surprising to resist one kind of massive state power and then support another. If the US government really didn't want mentally ill people to get guns then the homeless would be off the streets and in prisons or asylums. Instead there was an attempt to criminalize transactions by law abiding people, purely as an expression of media animus against gun owners and with zero concern for false positive rates.

As for popularity, I'd bet "90%" of people would support virtually anything after being subject to four months of wall to wall propaganda by the corporate media and government. It is amazing to me how erstwhile supporters of minority rights now champion the most literal majoritarianism when convenient.

And how do you see the kind of extraordinary show of force we just saw in Boston and conclude that the citizenry should be even more helpless, more disempowered? Life is a Rorschach test, I guess.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by reader5000 on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:32PM (#5579959)
I'd bet 90% of gun owners would support virtually anything after being subjected to four months of corporate gun industry propaganda. You know, bullshit like how owning a gun "empowers" you.
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by temphn on Saturday April 20, 2013 @12:44AM (#5580266)
How much money does the NRA have? How big is the gun industry? How much money does the mainstream media and the federal government have? Or OFA and Soros, for that matter?

Worth a bit of Googling. Methinks you don't have a good order-of-magnitude estimate of how much money is on each side.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by reader5000 on Saturday April 20, 2013 @01:03AM (#5580324)
The gun industry is $32 billion. Mainstream media and fed government are not on a "side". Soros is $20 billion but a tiny fraction of that is devoted to advocacy. OFA, assuming you mean Obama For America (?), is not a single issue entity. The gun corporations are, and that single issue is maximizing profit.
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by wyager on Saturday April 20, 2013 @12:08AM (#5580107)
Do you think the gun lobby helped to write the second amendment?

I'd also like to point out that the gun industry doesn't really run ads in the same way most industries do. I've never seen a single gun ad outside of a gun magazine.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by reader5000 on Saturday April 20, 2013 @12:46AM (#5580273)
Do I think corporate gun interests influence how the 2a is interpreted? Absolutely.
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by grinich on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:01PM (#5579837)
> I really do not get all the celebration and back-patting, it's disturbing.

This is way less about a real accomplishment, and more about what people need to feel. After the bombings, people felt vulnerable and scared. And for the police, I'm sure also embarrassed and angry. Catching this kid is the vindication they all needed emotionally. I'm just glad they didn't get overzealous and kill him, as most manhunts end.

Cops were sending around a photo of the first suspect after he died, saying that seeing it was "cathartic." Apparently another is circulating of the second captured suspect, with the caption "WE GOT HIM." It's like a locker room after winning a football game.

It's true there was danger and violence here, and the death of innocent good people. But the response today was largely about ego and fear of vulnerability. There were literally thousands of SWAT units in Watertown today, going from door to door, publicly demonstrating America's reaction to terrorist attacks. It was about sending a message to the citizens and police of Boston, as well as the rest of the country.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by zobzu on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:27PM (#5579938)
I'm also a little surprised at the "WE GOT HIM" and the "its the suspect". Pretty obviously everyone behave with this as 'hes guilty', so he's not a suspect anymore.

While he very well may be, everyone is supposed to be innocent til proved otherwise by trial and judgement. That goes for everyone. Murderers, thieves, rapists, politicians and rich dudes alike. Oh, and you and I. Hopefully.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by illuminate on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:56PM (#5580053)
You're confusing law for the court of public opinion. They are two entirely separate (and mostly unrelated) things.
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by zobzu on Saturday April 20, 2013 @05:52AM (#5580911)
pretty sure the police is not public opinion - also happens to pretty much related

Note also that the general public should also know better - there is in fact, no confusion. You're simply disagreeing - part of the people I criticize, in fact, then.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by waps on Saturday April 20, 2013 @12:11AM (#5580124)
There's also another aspect. The security services has now effectively publicly declared that the chance for a repeat has gone down significantly, at least in the short term. Of course that's a good thing.
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by ihsw on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:12PM (#5579876)
I think it's an odd coincidence this happens immediately following my comment six days ago:

> Law enforcement agencies are being lambasted time and again (whether it's valid criticism or not is irrelevant), and they continue to ignore claims of how ineffectual they are. Someone needs to stand up and say "We are here for you and we support you" otherwise it stands to reason that there are dangerous undertones forming.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5544924

It's exactly what that younger gentleman demonstrated -- the police will go above and beyond for you, even to the point of actively impeding normal functions of society.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by cinquemb on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:28PM (#5579940)
But when hear people cheering "USA" in the after math, it makes you think in a couple years we will be having our own Nuremberg Rallies.

Questioning the State™? Thats a no-no.

But then again, i'm just a lowly peasant, what could i possibly know about anything?

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by subsystem on Friday April 19, 2013 @10:38PM (#5579731)
They were actually about to abort the "bruteforce" operation before they got a call that someone had found the suspect in their boat, outside the perimeter. I really hope they evalute the operation properly. A good outcome doesn't necessarily validate the process.
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by emily37 on Friday April 19, 2013 @10:46PM (#5579775)
I thought it was really odd that they told people they could go about their business after completing the Watertown search without finding him. It seemed to me at that point the probability of us being injured had just gone up. However, lifting the stay-indoors request turned out to be crucial, because a man spotted the blood on the boat only after going outside for the first time all day.

On the other hand, if they had simply expanded the search area block by block without lifting the stay-indoors request, then they probably would have found him quickly with less risk to Watertown residents. In any case, I agree that it's important for the governments involved to evaluate what could have been done better.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by cynicalkane on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:16PM (#5579892)
I thought it was really odd that they told people they could go about their business after completing the Watertown search without finding him.

You find it really odd we don't live in a police state?

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by emily37 on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:34PM (#5579967)
I think you're misinterpreting my comment. I found it odd that we were advised to stay indoors all day and then told that we no longer needed to stay indoors at the exact point at which danger seemed to be more likely. My comment wasn't saying anything about my opinion as to whether or not the stay-indoors request was reasonable.

But I think it's also worth noting that the stay-indoors request was a request, as far as I know. Every notification that I received was something along the lines of people being asked to stay indoors with the doors locked, and I know people who chose to go outdoors before the request was lifted. The city shut down because people chose to honor the request out of confidence in the judgement and good intentions of the police. I personally chose to stay indoors because I thought the suspect was probably wandering around on foot in the Watertown/Cambridge area and I thought the inconvenience of staying inside for a day outweighed the risk of running into him.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by Thrymr on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:37PM (#5579976)
The suspect hiding in the boat was found directly because the police finally told people to go about their business.

Alternatively, if they had lifted the shelter-in-place order earlier, the guy would have gone out in his yard and noticed something going on in his boat sooner.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by cjbprime on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:16PM (#5579893)
> On the other hand, if they had simply expanded the search area block by block without lifting the stay-indoors request, then they probably would have found him quickly with less risk to Watertown residents.

On the other other hand, it was getting dark -- the stay-indoors request was lifted an hour from sunset -- and it would have been harder to see the blood without daylight. So maybe they lifted it just in time, or should have lifted it much earlier?

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by weisser on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:36PM (#5579973)
> However, lifting the stay-indoors request turned out to be crucial, because a man spotted the blood on the boat only after going outside for the first time all day.

And I think that was why they might have decided to allow it. Most people would NOT have felt comfortable going outside until he was caught and by letting people go out they had more eyes and a better chance of spotting him. It worked, and quickly.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by CurtMonash on Friday April 19, 2013 @10:46PM (#5579777)
If they had a helicopter that could detect infrared, which indeed sufficed to find him under the boat, why wasn't that already deployed to look into shed, boats, etc. around the neighborhood? (Including outside the main perimeter.)

I doubt the reason was 4th Amendment scruples.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by krapp on Friday April 19, 2013 @10:51PM (#5579800)
Who says it wasn't? Having infrared and having it be easy to find someone who doesn't want to be found with it in an urban environment are different things.
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by fnordfnordfnord on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:02PM (#5579838)
I think you'd need to equip the helicopter with precision grid-flying software/hardware such as is in SAR aircraft and Crop Dusters. FLIR can indeed see "through" some things, but the successful FLIR uses that you see on youtube and TV are usually cases where the pilot has a very small area to search. A comprehensive search of more than a few blocks would need multiple craft and lots of fuel. I agree that the authorities seem to lack awareness of the Bill of Rights.
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by CurtMonash on Saturday April 20, 2013 @12:40AM (#5580255)
I wasn't suggesting an exhaustive search of, say, a 20-100 block area.

I was suggesting a search of a prioritized list -- initially based on visual examination of aerial photographs -- of sheds, boats, and other simple structures in the area.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by ryanhuff on Friday April 19, 2013 @10:36PM (#5579720)
How about celebration for the simple matter that a couple of murderers are off the street, and people can stop hiding in their houses?
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by cdash on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:15PM (#5579891)
Why was it necessary for so many people to be hiding in their houses? I certainly have never seen an entire city shut down and hiding at home because a couple of murders were out there.
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by krapp on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:20PM (#5579911)
Probably, doing so makes it more likely that anyone the cops find outside is the suspect, while lessening the likelihood that a confrontation will lead to civilian casualties.

Also, no one knew how many other bombs there may have been, so public areas still posed an unknown risk.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by lambdaphage on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:22PM (#5579919)
The Miranda issue was puzzling to me. Apparently (http://www.fbi.gov/stats-services/publications/law-enforceme...) the public safety exception to the Miranda warning was created in a ruling that clarified that statements obtained from an un-Mirandized suspected in response to questions asked by police in the heat of the moment (e.g. "Where's the gun?") were admissible. The spirit of the exception was that the threat of suppressed evidence shouldn't prevent police from asking a question that any reasonable person would ask in order to ensure their safety in the heat of the moment.

Clearly, if you can plan not to Mirandize a suspect, then the public safety exception cannot apply in the first place, so calling for the public safety exception merely makes a mockery of the law. The concluding sentences of the FBI's explanation of the public safety exception are worth quoting in full:

"When police officers are confronted by a concern for public safety, Miranda warnings need not be provided prior to asking questions directed at neutralizing an imminent threat, and voluntary statements made in response to such narrowly tailored questions can be admitted at trial. Once the questions turn from those designed to resolve the concern for safety to questions designed solely to elicit incriminating statements, the questioning falls outside the scope of the exception and within the traditional rules of Miranda."

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by homosaur on Saturday April 20, 2013 @01:24AM (#5580388)
You cannot call for public safety exemption when there is no threat to public safety and the police already stated that there was none.

But let's not kid ourselves, Eric Holder and co give zero fucks about the law or our rights. Fast and Furious anyone?

The problem with this exemption, from what I understand (please correct me if wrong) is that any testimony in this questioning WOULD be admissible in court over some nonsense post 9/11 legalese in some crazy ass bill somewhere.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by Jach on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:17PM (#5579895)
Perhaps most people might support more background checks in principle, but it's not really close to what people really care about right now: http://cnsnews.com/news/article/gallup-only-4-americans-thin... Personally I don't support the latest gun legislation because it's not about guns or violence and if it were passed all it would lead to is a round of undeserved self-satisfied back-patting. If people want to get serious on curbing gun violence, maybe they should try their methods in say Chicago first before forcing the whole country to play along. (I know one method that could likely work but it's politically infeasible given the nature of the US's power structure. Are there any methods that can work with the current power structure?)
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by arcatek on Friday April 19, 2013 @10:55PM (#5579816)
To be fair, real, organized terrorists would probably be catch up before the bombing, since they would surely be under the radar of some intelligence agencies.

On the other hand, "lone wolfs" cannot be tracked by agencies, and their actions are hardly predictables.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by Spooky23 on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:01PM (#5579836)
I guess that it is easy to opine from afar when you have no skin in the game. The government has an obligation to protect public safety, and madmen on the loose shooting policemen and tossing bombs out car windows certainly qualifies as a public safety event.

I suppose if Mr. Stallman's home or office were to catch fire, we shouldn't paralyze the immediate area with noisy fire trucks.

The background check issue is a completely separate, legislative one. Democracy is a messy thing -- the democrats killed the bills so they could come back and fight another day.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by Thrymr on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:40PM (#5579990)
Afar? The MIT police officer was killed outside Stallman's building.
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by Spooky23 on Saturday April 20, 2013 @05:34PM (#5582893)
I'm being a little sarcastic, although sometimes I think that Stallman's ivory tower is located in another dimension.
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by tkahn6 on Friday April 19, 2013 @10:50PM (#5579791)
Is it really surprising or disappointing it took 'so long'?

I think your understanding of how easy it is to locate people is influenced by fiction and dramatization.

One man is tiny compared to an entire city. What can you realistically do if that man decides to hide in a covered boat in someone's yard?

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by kanda on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:21PM (#5579914)
Pretty much what they did. Overwhelming force. That's how the justice system is supposed to work.

The problem is that these kids were "organized" after a fashion. They were muslims, discontent, and grabbed up by some radical muslim and told that massacring random americans is the way to heaven. They're very unlikely to be the only ones that believe so.

And what choice is there but to move against whatever persons and/or organizations that radicalized their "interpretation of islam". They pointed out that the muslim prophet was a mass-murdering genocidal raider, which is correct, so it's hard to argue against this point. And of course these 2 boys chose to join their prophet's ways, as opposed to denying them. It's an ingenious way for an ideology to create terror, really. You center the ideology around a figure that's described as "perfect"(/holy/enlightened/...), but in reality that figure is a mass-murdering lying cheating bastard. Then of course the vast majority of people will choose to deny that fact (because 90% of people even in the most radicalized islamic country know perfectly well there's nothing good about massacres, and if "the prophet" committed genocide, that means he and his islam is evil), leading to a society that's workable, even if periodic sudden mass-outbursts of violence are unavoidable if you expect people to live in cognitive dissonance, with the associated risk that such an outburst wins over any government in place, destroying everything .

But any preacher can of course trivially use this to get recruits for terror acts against anyone he pleases (anyone he can realistically paint as an enemy of the ideology, which is to say anyone, if the preacher is any good). Now the vast majority of people will choose to maintain their cognitive dissonance and just add this preacher to the list of things they flat-out deny about the world, so the preacher that has just advocated genocide for 30 minutes can easily share dinner with anyone who just listened (When I first saw someone deny in his mind that a door existed to the point that he had to be restrained because he would keep "walking through it". He was hurting himself to the point that restraint + sedation was the only solution. I left that institution still firmly convinced that such people didn't exist, but after a few nights I seem to have come to terms with it).

However some people will chose to end their dissonance, usually under stress, and crucially, at this point they'll have been in the ideology for years and years, with everybody they know telling them that islam is good and great and can't be criticized. Then this "great insight" comes, that they've known about for decades too : islam works by ambushes and genocide, that's how the prophet did it, that's how muslims should do it. And at that point they will be extremely vulnerable to "suggestions" from said preacher, and of course they'll be looking to imitate what their prophet did, and they'll be looking for exactly the kind of mission that the preacher is likely to give them : ambush and kill innocents who are part of a group that "opposes" islam (and the prophet massacred muslims that he accused of allying with an enemy just the same, so no need to worry about killing a few traitor muslims).

No amount of policies can prevent psychological stress, nor by the way, would you want to do that. Stress may be the way to insanity, but it's also the way to improving yourself. Aside from that, of course you can't "end" psychological stress (though of course you can massively reduce it by providing basic needs services). But you'll never minimize it to the point the supply of terrorists dries up. And of course there's going to be points where the economy of the country is stressed, and there's an explosion in the number of candidate terrorists.

As a bonus, any society with this ideology can of course not allow "free" preachers, or any form of freedom of ideology. That would lead to mass acts of terrorism in short order (what we're about to see in Europe and America). So any society where this ideology takes root either becomes a complete monoculture or destroys the "invading" ideology, at great cost.

I bet this is how a lot of the terror ideologies work, not just islam. This seems like it's roughly the same concept as the stalinism and leninism concepts of communism (and of course the lesser ones too, with Castro, Guevara* and Chavez), or things like the Japanese ideology before WWII, and of course nazism, any such person cultus with anything less than a perfect being like Buddha or Jesus, that no rational being can really criticize any actions of (which means that Christian and Buddhist "terrorists" exist, except they do what Jesus and Buddha did, probably leading to self-sacrifice for a noble cause, because these are ideologies where people's cognitive dissonance has to deny the fact that they themselves are not as moral as their ideology). I bet this is what a "meme" virus looks like, like Hitches professed exist.

Of course negative ideologies (where the ideology is morally worse than most human minds that partake in it) like islam would be fundamentally unstable, and will destroy themselves if they don't have (realistic) enemies, or insufficient access to their enemies. But small pockets will survive even then, ready to start again, in slightly different forms. So preventing terror is the exact same thing as eradicating islam itself, problem is that of course you're never going to be able to do that without attacking individuals.

* Guevara is a perfect example. He's a hero of commusnism, but it is well documented he randomly killed people for fun when they can't defend themselves. And that's not all he's reputed to do either.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by D9u on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:42PM (#5580005)
One could just as easily quote Biblical passages which promote violence as one might from the Qur'an.
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by waps on Saturday April 20, 2013 @12:03AM (#5580081)
The point may be that the personification of some religions/ideologies can reasonably be considered as morally a significantly better person than "average", like Jesus or Buddha, whereas other religions/ideologies, like Islam, have a morally reprehensible personification.

The point seems to be that in neither case does the "average" follower become any better or worse, but the extremists of those religions are significantly different. In every case the extremists become closer to the idealized figures from the ideology, so Christians are prone to self sacrifice, Buddhists are prone to an ascetic, isolated life, and Muslims are prone to violence if this happens.

Not sure about how it causes mono-culture. It seems to me at the beginning of the 20th century, every region on earth was a mono-culture, no matter it's ideology.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by ucee054 on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:54PM (#5580047)
Do you actually believe this crap as stated, or were you going to go back and add "and Judaism and Christianity" to that "Islam is a terror religion" stuff you were spewing?

It's the Old Testament that's the terror religion, whether as practiced by Mohammed or by Moses or by the Crusaders.

And Moslems react when they think their religion is under attack just like Christians do. Have a look at some of the IRA types who were into butchering Irish Protestants. They were "defending" the Catholics in their minds.

It's not "kill the infidels to get into heaven". The religion is merely the language they use to frame the real motivation, which can be defensiveness, reaction, or even sheer prejudice.

And not all the bombers are loonies, by the way, not even the suicidal ones. If the official story so far is correct, the Boston two seem to be good planners with a healthy sense of self-preservation.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by lurker14 on Friday April 19, 2013 @10:36PM (#5579722)
What's the maximum reasonable spend to catch a bomber, for an efficient force? $1M? $100k?

A large part of the expense was due to the successful effort to apprehend him without killing him or bystanders.

Tweets aren't precisely geolocated, so that's not really relevant.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by cjbprime on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:18PM (#5579898)
> What's the maximum reasonable spend to catch a bomber, for an efficient force? $1M? $100k?

The US has a "value of a statistical life"[1] of around $7M, and they had already killed 4 people and injured over a hundred more, so $50M seems like it would be very easily justified.

[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_of_life

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by ck2 on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:24PM (#5579924)
So you are saying the 27 people killed by a bomber in Iraq today were worth less than the 4 killed in Boston?

My point was this was one person (okay, two brothers originally) what would have happened if it was a team of people who were organized and actually secretive and didn't use twitter or live out in the open?

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by cjbprime on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:29PM (#5579945)
> So you are saying the 27 people killed by a bomber in Iraq today were worth less than the 4 killed in Boston?

No, the United States Government is saying that, by using the Value of a Statistical Life that they use. So I'm telling you that (by their own terms) they can justify spending a lot of their money on catching someone who has killed several people and intends to kill more.

I do not agree that it makes sense to value US lives at $7M each and developing world lives at apparently less than $2000 each (the approximate price of saving one according to GiveWell). But that's what the link I cited says is the case here.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by cdash on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:36PM (#5579975)
I would have to include the economical cost of shutting down a city for an entire day in the cost of the operation as well, I am not sure what that would be though.
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by cjbprime on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:40PM (#5579989)
Obviously it depends on the GDP of the city -- in this case, perhaps we could ballpark $100M.

I'm not sure this adequately captures it, though; the bombers are said to have talked in front of their carjacking victim about planning to escape to NYC. Shouldn't we include some expected value term of the cost of shutting down NYC, in case they moved there and had to be hunted there too? Seems like the entire country/world has an interest in seeing them caught here.

Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by cdash on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:49PM (#5580029)
Yea I think you would have to include that, its obviously a very complex situation and next to impossible because it requires a lot of uncertainties if you were to try to base a decision purely on monetary value of a life.
Re:Richard Stallman response to Boston Police efforts by fnordfnordfnord on Friday April 19, 2013 @10:51PM (#5579798)
I am interested in knowing what extra expenses were taken to ensure the safety of bystanders. Please share. I did see a few reports of peoples' homes and property being shot up in a similar style as LAPD a-la Christopher Dorner.