News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New lithium-ion battery design – 2,000x more powerful, re... by icegreentea on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @02:11PM (#5566027)
Well... it's tricky. If you assume that current electric cars have the performance of that A123 battery from the graph, and then pick something in the middle of the spread of the colourful dots, you get a roughly 1 order decrease in energy density, and a 1 order increase in power density. So, taking the Model S as an example, you have a 300 mile range, and a charge time of like 45 minutes at a super charger.

So... now you end up with like a 30-60 mile range range, and can charge up fully in like 3-5 minutes. So we've brought charge times into the realm of filly up gas, but you're doing it waaay more often.

If this is a useful advancement or not depends completely on what type of infrastructure we want to envision. I would certainly love a world where this was possible/feasible, but it's certainly not a grand slam.

Re:New lithium-ion battery design – 2,000x more powerful, re... by VLM on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @04:45PM (#5567090)
Minor nitpick is charge time at a supercharger would remain 45 minutes. You'd need some kind of miracle superduper charger to deliver that kind of current. A cable that can handle that kind of current would be kind of unimaginable for the average civilian. It would resemble a telephone pole. Not the wires on the pole, but the pole itself.

A stereotypical thermodynamics class assignment was something along the lines of assume your 10 gallon gas tank is filled in a minute at the gas pump through a little half inch gas nozzle. Now calculate the thermal energy of that nozzle assuming perfect combustion in megawatts. Then given that the gas nozzle is about half an inch, look up what diameter copper wire would be required to transfer that kind of energy if it was electricity. The answer was pretty stunning.

Re:New lithium-ion battery design – 2,000x more powerful, re... by talmand on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @05:18PM (#5567326)
For those of us that didn't study thermodynamics, what is the answer that's so stunning?
Re:New lithium-ion battery design – 2,000x more powerful, re... by Lagged2Death on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @07:02PM (#5567895)
10 gal = 37.85L

37.85L x 36MJ/L = 1,362 MJ in the tank.

1,362 MJ / 60s = 22MJ/s from the hose.

J/s is Watts, so that's 22 megawatts. A cable that carried 200A at 110KV would do it. I think 000 gauge would handle 200A, it's just under 11mm in diameter.

Re:New lithium-ion battery design – 2,000x more powerful, re... by EEGuy on Thursday April 18, 2013 @12:30AM (#5568895)
Agreed, stunning it is that so common and reasonably safe a thing as a self-serve gas pump is a 22 MW chemical energy delivery system!

Some reflections:

* Perhaps an EV might be 10x as efficient with its input energy as a gasoline powered car. Perhaps 220 KW would do.

* Perhaps a robotically mobile, rather than a counterweighted, manually lifted and connected cable is in order. The present day robotic car wash design where the car stays still while the motile, rotating washing machinery moves around it comes to mind.

* Electrical connectors give me more trouble than wires and cables. A replaceable, quick-disconnect connector capable of 20KA seems more of a design challenge than the cables that would go with it.

* High voltage insulation and wiring is "easier" than high current conductance (low resistance) wiring, for example: Common engineering practice with 30-volt solar panels is to wire them in series so that the total string voltage is 300 to 600 VDC at 8 Amps, rather than in parallel so that the current would be 80 to 160 Amps at 30 Volts. Air is a lousy and unsafe insulator, but there are good liquid insulators which could easily, temporarily fill a two-pole, ground-surround high-voltage connector (displacing the air) before it's allowed to be electrically energized and ramped up to a high voltage. Precise ground fault current detection could make it safe from fault currents (i.e. shocks & shorts) in the milliamp range even as the cable carries hundreds or thousands of Amps. But any HV supply requires up-conversion at the station and down-conversion in the EV; whilst these can be 95% efficient, the effect of each conversion inefficiency is multiplicative, and they add weight.

* Then there's the charging station itself. If it has eight charging stations at, say 250 KW each, that's 2 MW draw from the utility (or an underground group of batteries recharged at a lower rate from utility power?) when all stations are charging cars. Not trivial; just the 500 KVA (call it 500 KW for discussion purposes) utility distribution transformer outside building where I work is the size of four refrigerators, not including its switchgear, all of which is enclosed by a 20 foot tall fence surrounding about 200 sq feet. Multiply that by four in volume to get 2 MW supply required from the utility.

Re:New lithium-ion battery design – 2,000x more powerful, re... by lutorm on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @08:18PM (#5568228)
But 110kV into the car is totally out of the question. At a more reasonable battery voltage of 1kV, you'd need 20kA. That'd be a fat cable indeed.
Re:New lithium-ion battery design – 2,000x more powerful, re... by Lagged2Death on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @10:22PM (#5568606)
But 110kV into the car is totally out of the question.

It would be pretty unreasonable. But burning gas at 100% efficiency is actually impossible, so it's sort of a silly scenario anyway.

...you'd need 20kA. That'd be a fat cable indeed.

Maybe not as fat as you'd think; this guy figures 50KA here, and you wouldn't want to work with an extension cord like that every day, but it's not like you'd need a crane to lift it, either:

http://youtu.be/uXEPy6Za6cI

Re:New lithium-ion battery design – 2,000x more powerful, re... by lutusp on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @05:33PM (#5567415)
The OP didn't give enough information to produce a specific answer. For a higher voltage and lower current (same power), the wire could be thinner with the same outcome. The reason electricity utilities string million-volt lines between cities is to minimize the heating losses in the conductors, not to impress the civilians.

It's the same reason electric car designs favor putting a lot of cells in series -- a high-voltage electric motor gets more of the power delivered by the batteries, less of it is wasted in the connecting wires. Also, in the car's charging circuit, the high voltage choice maximizes power transfer for a given connecting wire size.

Re:New lithium-ion battery design – 2,000x more powerful, re... by mbell on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @06:00PM (#5567597)
You still need to convert this high supply voltage to a lower voltage to match the cell voltage for charging. The currents involved mean this converter is still likely to dissipate a lot of heat, even if it is extremely efficient.
Re:New lithium-ion battery design – 2,000x more powerful, re... by lutusp on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @06:57PM (#5567873)
> You still need to convert this high supply voltage to a lower voltage to match the cell voltage for charging.

No, instead you charge the cells in series. That delivers the same power while avoiding the problem of having to produce overly high currents.

> The currents involved mean this converter is still likely to dissipate a lot of heat, even if it is extremely efficient.

Yes, but there are ways to minimize this loss factor. Obviously a fast-charging scheme for a car is going to involve a lot of current, but the system designers do all they can to minimize that current. The primary way they do that is by both charging and discharging the cells arranged as much in series as is practical.

In the Tesla design, there are 11 modules connected in series and delivering 375 volts nominal (and requiring 375 volts to produce an optimal charging current). So there's no issue of changing individual cells at their normal cell voltage, instead the system charges modules consisting of 621 cells in an optimized series-parallel scheme:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesla_Roadster#Battery_system

Quote: "Tesla Motors refers to the Roadster's battery pack as the Energy Storage System or ESS. The ESS contains 6,831 lithium ion cells arranged into 11 "sheets" connected in series; each sheet contains 9 "bricks" connected in series; each "brick" contains 69 cells connected in parallel (11S 9S 69P)"

Re:New lithium-ion battery design – 2,000x more powerful, re... by mbell on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @09:23PM (#5568421)
By 'cell' I meant the overall pack, not the individual unit within the pack.

From your link: "A full recharge of the battery system requires 3½ hours using the High Power Connector which supplies 70 amp, 240 volt electricity"

Multiply that current by 10-100 to 'charge it faster' and you have a huge problem with thermal dissipation, not to mention using truly massive cables.

Re:New lithium-ion battery design – 2,000x more powerful, re... by lutusp on Thursday April 18, 2013 @04:21AM (#5569460)
> Multiply that current by 10-100 to 'charge it faster' ...

No, that can't be done without damaging the batteries. A fast charge in this context means multiplying the default charging current by roughly three, not 10, and certainly not 100.

Re:New lithium-ion battery design – 2,000x more powerful, re... by cmccabe on Thursday April 18, 2013 @02:16AM (#5569149)
Once you start getting into the thousands of volts, it becomes very dangerous. That stuff will arc through the air and kill you. There is a reason why we use a hundred or two volts in consumer appliances.
Re:New lithium-ion battery design – 2,000x more powerful, re... by userulluipeste on Thursday April 18, 2013 @06:47AM (#5569818)
Not necessarily. If the connection would be unmanaged, as having the power available for drainage all the time, then you're right! ...but we have computers and all kind of complex systems now. The cable may be "empty" of that high voltage current until the cable is safely plugged in and ready. After plugging, before unleashing energy, the car's system and the power source's system may first communicate and verify their sensors if everything's ready to go, like isolation and other things. The high voltage risk and its management it's an engineering solvable problem.
Re:New lithium-ion battery design – 2,000x more powerful, re... by cmccabe on Thursday April 18, 2013 @10:49PM (#5574455)
You have the wrong idea of how voltage works. High voltage electricity can and will kill you before the ground fault interruptor (or whatever) can kick in. It takes time to break a high voltage circuit, (on the order of milliseconds), and during that time, you will die. If the current is across your heart it's especially lethal.

If the voltage is high enough, there is no way to break the circuit anyway. The electricity will just arc across the (ionized) air, even if the computer physically disconnect it. Assuming the computer itself isn't killed by the spark, which is pretty likely. This is why linemen on high voltage lines don't even try to electrically insulate themselves when they're working with it live. Ask wikipedia:

For high-voltage and extra-high-voltage transmission lines, specially trained personnel use "live line" techniques to allow hands-on contact with energized equipment. In this case the worker is electrically connected to the high-voltage line but thoroughly insulated from the earth so that he is at the same electrical potential as that of the line. Since training for such operations is lengthy, and still presents a danger to personnel, only very important transmission lines are subject to maintenance while live. Outside these properly engineered situations, insulation from earth does not guarantee that no current flows to earth—as grounding or arcing to ground can occur in unexpected ways, and high-frequency currents can burn even an ungrounded person. Touching a transmitting antenna is dangerous for this reason, and a high-frequency Tesla Coil can sustain a spark with only one endpoint).

Re:New lithium-ion battery design – 2,000x more powerful, re... by userulluipeste on Friday April 19, 2013 @10:55AM (#5576956)
You understood wrong my statement. Assume that you have two independent connecting channels in the same connecting tube. One is a live low-voltage channel for communication protocol and the other one is high-power (but dead in idle) pumping channel. When you plug the tube you automatically connect both channels. After that, having the info-line established, having assured that the couple has been locked & safe (i.e. insulated), both systems might then agree on opening the second high-power channel. It won't matter if it will take more than a few milliseconds to open or cut the power with the tube being in a safe coupling state. By "safe coupling state" I mean that not even the contact with the possible ionized air is allowed, the line being covered/insulated all the way. You just design the systems to not allow power to drain from the source unless it's safe. I also think that it's already time to design all the systems like that, not only the high-power car-recharging ones. This would make a difference in lives saved.
Re:New lithium-ion battery design – 2,000x more powerful, re... by cmccabe on Friday April 19, 2013 @02:51PM (#5578113)
Google "ground fault interruptor." What are you are talking about already exists. And it doesn't solve the problem.
Re:New lithium-ion battery design – 2,000x more powerful, re... by VLM on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @08:06AM (#5594554)
Whoa am I posting late sorry.

There's a simpler way to do the analysis which doesn't require heat of combustion of typical gasoline analysis and flowrates and such. Assume it takes a KW for a horsepower (perfectly accurate for 1 sig fig) and it takes a couple horsepower (kilowatts) to go down the highway on a long road trip. To at least one sig fig this is correct. Also it takes about 3 times the chemical gasoline energy to generate electricity because IC engines are not terribly efficient. We'll call it 10 KW gas equivalent to drive on the interstate at a constant-ish high speed.

Now what fraction of the time of a road trip do you spend pumping gas vs driving? Well it can't take more than 4 minutes to fill a 10 or so gallon gas tank, and on cross country trips I can get a good 8 hours or so outta one tank, so to one sig fig I spend WAY less than 1/100th the time pumping gas vs driving.

So multiply 10 KW by 100 times the flow rate (conservation of energy and all that)

Another way to look at it, is think of the flow rate, lets say 5 gallons per minute. The kind of engine required to burn a couple gallons per minute resembles my uncle's hospital UPS backup engines, certainly in the megawatt class. This is also in the thousand horsepower (aka megawatt) class airplane engine and race car category.

Re:New lithium-ion battery design – 2,000x more powerful, re... by jguimont on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @02:21PM (#5566076)
Could electric car battery use a dual type battery pack to optimize charging and range?
Re:New lithium-ion battery design – 2,000x more powerful, re... by bradleyland on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @03:12PM (#5566420)
You could do that, but energy density is the key metric here.

Energy density determines the size of the battery required to store a specific amount of energy. There's only so much space in the car, and you also have to factor in that any battery that will be moved by its own power loses efficiency with lower energy density. You've got a huge battery to move, and physics dictate that accelerating this battery is going to use more energy.

So, let's say you split this hybrid battery 50/50, your quick charge-discharge battery quickly becomes too small to deliver meaningful range, and you've given up space that could be used for the traditional battery.

Re:New lithium-ion battery design – 2,000x more powerful, re... by chongli on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @03:25PM (#5566507)
The Tesla Model S already uses 7000 individual battery cells. This is how it's able to charge as quickly as it does with the supercharger. The main limitation of household charging is lack of power.
Re:New lithium-ion battery design – 2,000x more powerful, re... by reportingsjr on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @10:58PM (#5568699)
That isn't necessarily true. Them using small batteries to make a larger battery is what allows them to make their car sized batteries cheaper, since the smaller sized batteries are already mass produced for things like laptops. For charging time it depends on how those batteries are connected.
Re:New lithium-ion battery design – 2,000x more powerful, re... by colanderman on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @02:14PM (#5566041)
Don't you mean a charge in 24-30 seconds? Otherwise your example is just that of a 10x smaller A123 battery.
Re:New lithium-ion battery design – 2,000x more powerful, re... by meepmorp on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @02:46PM (#5566240)
45 min is 2700 seconds, so 10x faster charging is 270 seconds or 4 1/2 minutes.
Re:New lithium-ion battery design – 2,000x more powerful, re... by flakmonkey on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @03:57PM (#5566724)
The rate that the battery charges is independent from the capacity of the battery. Assuming the new tech is 10x less energy dense and has a 10x faster charge rate, if you compare one of these new batteries with capacity equal to that of the Model S battery, the new battery will charge 10x faster but occupy 10x the volume, since it is less energy dense. A new battery of this kind that occupied the same volume as a Model S would contain 10x less energy than the Model S battery, but it would charge to full capacity 100x faster than the Model S.
Re:New lithium-ion battery design – 2,000x more powerful, re... by cdash on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @03:57PM (#5566727)
There should be two multipliers though right? If it charges 10x faster and you are charging to a 10x less total energy it should charge 100x faster right?
Re:New lithium-ion battery design – 2,000x more powerful, re... by rdtsc on Thursday April 18, 2013 @12:10AM (#5568850)
Imagine shorting this capacitor.