Re:Show HN: Use your phone to present slides on any screen
by alexqgb on Saturday March 23, 2013 @07:01PM
(#5430174)
LOVE this, with one major caveat. I hate, Hate HATE the ads. It's a visceral level of rage that I find remarkable since that's not how I generally respond to in-app ads.
They're just so very very wrong in this context, mainly because they're deliberately distracting. For someone trying to focus on delivering a presentation, this is 100% unacceptable. It would be tolerable (barely) if the ad never changed, but when the damn thing changes every few seconds, it's more than enough to break one's concentration. And that is LETHAL for public speaking.
I know HN guidelines discourage the use of caps for emphasis, and I almost never use them for this reason. But my negative reaction was SO strong that it's worth breaking protocol just to emphasize how awful those intrusions really are.
Aside from that one hideous, terrible, awful, repulsive, glaring deal-killer of a flaw, this app is brilliant. Bottom line: I'd pay $5 for a version without ads. I'd refuse to use it with ads.
Re:Show HN: Use your phone to present slides on any screen
by alexqgb on Sunday March 24, 2013 @12:35AM
(#5431130)
Oh wait, I'm an idiot - of course this isn't your app that's showing the ads, because you don't have one. It's the QR app, which I downloaded just to try your service, and mistakenly thought of as yours. Sorry about that.
Turns out that the app's "More" menu contains a upgrade option that will remove the ads for $0.99. Problem solved.
Re:Show HN: Use your phone to present slides on any screen
by keithpeter on Sunday March 24, 2013 @06:00AM
(#5431595)
Suggestion: pop a note on your landing page about in-app ads in the QR app. If someone posting on HN can get crossed wires about where the ads come from, Joe Random Six Pack Marketer is definitely going to get mixed up.
(I'll eventually have to change my BlackBerry won't I?)
Re:Show HN: Use your phone to present slides on any screen
by gala8y on Saturday March 23, 2013 @02:46PM
(#5429222)
I really like your idea and its pretty self explanatory once you watch the demo. I also like that your demo is somehow hidden - you can't just watch it, you just use the product for the first time and learn it. Don't change it - it's fun and makes for a 'wow' moment.
After some time I started to wonder why I would need a QR... well... QR must be pairing a unique computer/ip/browser (?) with the phone, right? Nice.
I would not bother to add too much explanations on the main page - now its a little mistery and I like that demo is 'hidden' (see above). Also, dont add that both presentation machine and phone must be connected to the internet - it is evident and even if it is not, well, people will figure it out.
Edit: As others mentioned, need for network connection introduces some serious uncertainty. I just get it and would never take a plane (slide 5?) without a copy of my presentation on me.
Have not been presenting for quite a long time, but will surely give it a go when I do.
We recommend Scan for (iPhone) or Google Goggles for (Android).
You might want to fix ()'s: (for iPhone) (for Android)
Thumbnails for slides on the phone must be your next feature, am I right?
Re:Show HN: Use your phone to present slides on any screen
by imissmyjuno on Saturday March 23, 2013 @03:51PM
(#5429490)
>I also like that your demo is somehow hidden
I don't. I opened the page, stared at the massive QR code, tried to get an idea about the product based on the right-hand side list, and closed the page still unsure how the product works exactly.
Re:Show HN: Use your phone to present slides on any screen
by alakin on Saturday March 23, 2013 @02:55PM
(#5429261)
Thanks for the comment! Yup, I'd prefer that the user would actually slide left or right and see the thumb on the phone, but that will probably come once I learn IOS dev.
Side note: If any mobile devs would like to join the team, shoot me an email - anton at Uslide.net
Re:Show HN: Use your phone to present slides on any screen
by rolleiflex on Saturday March 23, 2013 @03:07PM
(#5429309)
Brilliant work. I'm starting to use it, and I'd pay for it.
For me, it replaces:
0) Having to carry my MBP around if the only use is the presentation,
1) Plugging my Macbook Pro in, always carrying a Thunderbolt/vga and Thunderbolt/dvi adapter,
2) Trying to fiddle with almost always flaky cables to get projector working,
3) Setting up a ad-hoc wifi network, connecting my iPhone to that network,
4) But before that, removing the other saved Wifis because somehow both MBP and iPhone tends to ditch that Wifi and connect to the other ones available that has internet access, by default,
5) Open BetterTouchTool Remote on my iPhone,
6) Connect to the MBP from the app,
7) And finally start presenting.
I end up doing a presentation every week, at least. Job well done. I'm your first customer if you sell it.
Re:Show HN: Use your phone to present slides on any screen
by jakozaur on Saturday March 23, 2013 @02:30PM
(#5429136)
Nice MVP, but it's not ready enough to use it.
I would need at least:
- offline mode, even if everything goes down it should work using the remote + I would like to know that we lost connection. Not sure if it's already working.
- authorization using QR
E.g. my best use case for this site: lightening talk session. Able to have multiple presentations linked to each other and be able to rearrange them from different computer.
Re:Show HN: Use your phone to present slides on any screen
by Shenglong on Saturday March 23, 2013 @01:13PM
(#5428864)
I'm still trying to figure out what your product does, and how it works. Questions that come to mind at first glance (although I'm sure I can reason some through, and take guesses... and probably think of more):
- I just download this onto my phone?
- Where would the presentation be stored?
- What do I have to do on the presenting machine?
- What does the remote look like?
- Is the remote going to force my screen not to lock?
- Will my screen be bright and distracting to my audience?
- Why is there no information? Is this malware?
- How do I get rid of the Tip box which is covering text, because I'm using 200% zoom on Retina?
- Why is there a log in? There's no accompanying register.
- What software does this work for?
Also, your logo is really fuzzy, and your HRs don't match up... but that's just me being picky!
Re:Show HN: Use your phone to present slides on any screen
by shadowflit on Sunday March 24, 2013 @06:44AM
(#5431674)
Some thoughts from my typical meetings...
Almost all of the presentations I have seen at work have been shared with people on the phone as well (using terrible sharing tech, I might add). I agree with other posters that having an offline backup solution is important, but given how losing network connectivity already breaks meetings for us, I think having to load up from a USB drive would be an acceptable delay.
A portion of our meetings have demo sections. Either showing off features of some web app from their computer, or VNCing into a server and demo'ing functionality from terminals.
We have to hook up a computer to the projector in a room regardless - there isn't one already there. Having multiple presenters in one meeting would definitely go smoother, though it doesn't happen that often. Startup time would definitely be faster though, as noted our web conference software sucks.
I also like the idea (posted elsewhere) to be able to draw on the slides / point things out.
Re:Show HN: Use your phone to present slides on any screen
by jre on Saturday March 23, 2013 @01:15PM
(#5428868)
This is pretty cool and I like the concept.
The problem I see is that by requiring a working internet connection on your smartphone and the computer you use to present, this add a number of points of failure. I'd feel safer with just a USB key (+ publicly accessible copy on the web) and a PDF.
It would be cool if you'd show the presentation on the phone too and let the presenter use the phone (or tablet) to draw/highlight stuff live.
Re:Show HN: Use your phone to present slides on any screen
by yogKarma on Saturday March 23, 2013 @04:32PM
(#5429658)
Nice work guys. The demo is quite exciting and easy to understand.
I would use it for its cool quotient - I can press next on my phone without anyone noticing - magic!
Though, network connectivity and document confidentiality are major concerns. What do you think?
In both Firefox and Chrome the QR code on the homepage only appears after a refresh or two.
Overall really nicely done, though the two reasons I wouldn't use it personally are 1.) Confidentiality (most decks I would ever want to present I can't upload to some random MVP site) 2.) Branding (I'd want to be able to white label, or self-host).
Re:Show HN: Use your phone to present slides on any screen
by corin_ on Sunday March 24, 2013 @09:28AM
(#5431986)
Probably is, but thought I'd mention it in case the cause isn't something that will have disappeared by the time this version becomes Aurora/standard release.
Re:Show HN: Use your phone to present slides on any screen
by joshmlewis on Saturday March 23, 2013 @01:16PM
(#5428874)
I scanned the QR code and then pressed next/back a few times and then it said connected on the screen. Then I wasn't sure where the demo was even though it said to try it out. I eventually saw the little link at the bottom right hand side and clicked on it. Then it presented the slides but kept going automatically very sporadically and nothing I did stopped or moved anything.
You might want to give a better walkthrough and explanation. :) Really cool though if it is solid. You have to be careful with slide control because this is LIVE and people want things that are absolutely solid and going to work 99.99% of the time. One mishap and you've probably lost that customer if it was in a live setting.
Re:Show HN: Use your phone to present slides on any screen
by joshmlewis on Saturday March 23, 2013 @02:44PM
(#5429211)
No I can't find it offhand. If youd like some design help I'd be interested. I've been looking for another project to design for a side project. Email is in profile!
Re:Show HN: Use your phone to present slides on any screen
by derwildemomo on Saturday March 23, 2013 @08:22PM
(#5430455)
Great idea and nice execution. The demo works great and there's definitely a wow-moment.
It's a bit unfortunate that uploading a keynote-presentation threw an error ( didn't say what the problem was, just that the presentation couldn't be converted ) and uploading a ppt messed up the charts. So, maybe it would be wiser to simply just accept pdf-documents and rely on users to do the conversion – it's a complicated task, versions change all the time and mastering pdf alone is maybe enough work for a mvp. just my two cents.
Re:Show HN: Use your phone to present slides on any screen
by verelo on Saturday March 23, 2013 @02:26PM
(#5429117)
pretty cool, could be very handy for sales presentations but its unusual to be lucky enough to get access to a network of a company you are pitching to.
Re:Show HN: Use your phone to present slides on any screen
by leetrout on Sunday March 24, 2013 @03:14AM
(#5431389)
This looks really cool, fantastic idea!
Unfortunately the site doesn't work with IE on Windows Phone 8. Can't click either of the green buttons seen in this screen shot- http://sdrv.ms/X4gN6 (possible a bootstrap issue).
Hopefully I can snag my wife's droid tomorrow and give it a whirl!
Re:Show HN: Use your phone to present slides on any screen
by imagross on Saturday March 23, 2013 @02:32PM
(#5429153)
One of the things preventing me from using this all the time is that I can't click through the presentation manually on my computer. At least if the internet connection failed, I could have that as a backup plan and continue with any presentations.
Re:Show HN: Use your phone to present slides on any screen
by brettcvz on Saturday March 23, 2013 @10:57PM
(#5430887)
Overall, very slick. I'd recommend also being able to upload a presentation from the phone (by selecting it from gmail, dropbox, etc) so I could do the majority of the setup on my phone and minimal on the presenting computer.
Re:Show HN: Use your phone to present slides on any screen
by CoryG89 on Saturday March 23, 2013 @05:00PM
(#5429747)
This is pretty cool, I like just being able to scan a qr code and start presenting. However, I just finished creating a presentation using Reveal.JS, it would be awesome if I could upload my reveal markup and use that.
Re:Show HN: Use your phone to present slides on any screen
by valgaze on Saturday March 23, 2013 @07:53PM
(#5430369)
Sure, but I really mean the whole process that makes this sort of thing special (using a uniquely generated code, making a QR, having to come up with transmission methods from phone, etc)
Re:Show HN: Use your phone to present slides on any screen
by kekelo on Sunday March 24, 2013 @10:32AM
(#5432138)
I've now tried both and have to say that they are both easy to use. Still I like Presefy (http://presefy.com) more because it's so easy for anyone to remotely view the presentation from my unique presentation url and not a randomly generated url.
Re:Show HN: Use your phone to present slides on any screen
by alakin on Wednesday March 27, 2013 @06:57AM
(#5448678)
Sure - just enable the share feature (top right corner when you log in) and you can just email a link to the broadcast from the remote interface (at the top).
Feel free to contact me - my twitter is in the profile.
Re:Show HN: Use your phone to present slides on any screen
by andyl on Saturday March 23, 2013 @03:14PM
(#5429335)
By the way - I've got a corporate app that has a file-store for presentations. This would be a perfect add-on - is there a way to embed/integrate with your app?
They're just so very very wrong in this context, mainly because they're deliberately distracting. For someone trying to focus on delivering a presentation, this is 100% unacceptable. It would be tolerable (barely) if the ad never changed, but when the damn thing changes every few seconds, it's more than enough to break one's concentration. And that is LETHAL for public speaking.
I know HN guidelines discourage the use of caps for emphasis, and I almost never use them for this reason. But my negative reaction was SO strong that it's worth breaking protocol just to emphasize how awful those intrusions really are.
Aside from that one hideous, terrible, awful, repulsive, glaring deal-killer of a flaw, this app is brilliant. Bottom line: I'd pay $5 for a version without ads. I'd refuse to use it with ads.
Turns out that the app's "More" menu contains a upgrade option that will remove the ads for $0.99. Problem solved.
(I'll eventually have to change my BlackBerry won't I?)
Mine (RL Classic) asked me if I wanted to open the webpage and launched Safari.
After some time I started to wonder why I would need a QR... well... QR must be pairing a unique computer/ip/browser (?) with the phone, right? Nice.
I would not bother to add too much explanations on the main page - now its a little mistery and I like that demo is 'hidden' (see above). Also, dont add that both presentation machine and phone must be connected to the internet - it is evident and even if it is not, well, people will figure it out.
Edit: As others mentioned, need for network connection introduces some serious uncertainty. I just get it and would never take a plane (slide 5?) without a copy of my presentation on me.
Have not been presenting for quite a long time, but will surely give it a go when I do.
We recommend Scan for (iPhone) or Google Goggles for (Android). You might want to fix ()'s: (for iPhone) (for Android)
Thumbnails for slides on the phone must be your next feature, am I right?
I don't. I opened the page, stared at the massive QR code, tried to get an idea about the product based on the right-hand side list, and closed the page still unsure how the product works exactly.
Side note: If any mobile devs would like to join the team, shoot me an email - anton at Uslide.net
For me, it replaces:
0) Having to carry my MBP around if the only use is the presentation,
1) Plugging my Macbook Pro in, always carrying a Thunderbolt/vga and Thunderbolt/dvi adapter,
2) Trying to fiddle with almost always flaky cables to get projector working,
3) Setting up a ad-hoc wifi network, connecting my iPhone to that network,
4) But before that, removing the other saved Wifis because somehow both MBP and iPhone tends to ditch that Wifi and connect to the other ones available that has internet access, by default,
5) Open BetterTouchTool Remote on my iPhone,
6) Connect to the MBP from the app,
7) And finally start presenting.
I end up doing a presentation every week, at least. Job well done. I'm your first customer if you sell it.
I would need at least:
- offline mode, even if everything goes down it should work using the remote + I would like to know that we lost connection. Not sure if it's already working.
- authorization using QR
E.g. my best use case for this site: lightening talk session. Able to have multiple presentations linked to each other and be able to rearrange them from different computer.
- I just download this onto my phone?
- Where would the presentation be stored?
- What do I have to do on the presenting machine?
- What does the remote look like?
- Is the remote going to force my screen not to lock?
- Will my screen be bright and distracting to my audience?
- Why is there no information? Is this malware?
- How do I get rid of the Tip box which is covering text, because I'm using 200% zoom on Retina?
- Why is there a log in? There's no accompanying register.
- What software does this work for?
Also, your logo is really fuzzy, and your HRs don't match up... but that's just me being picky!
-I just download this onto my phone?
"Scan the QR code with your phone. Once you're connected, you can use your phone to present slides on this screen."
-Will my screen be bright and distracting to my audience?
Seriously?
Alakin, ignore most of these questions. I couldn't get the back button to work but apart from that, fine job!
Why should I scan a QR code on his page with no expectation of the results?
Almost all of the presentations I have seen at work have been shared with people on the phone as well (using terrible sharing tech, I might add). I agree with other posters that having an offline backup solution is important, but given how losing network connectivity already breaks meetings for us, I think having to load up from a USB drive would be an acceptable delay.
A portion of our meetings have demo sections. Either showing off features of some web app from their computer, or VNCing into a server and demo'ing functionality from terminals.
We have to hook up a computer to the projector in a room regardless - there isn't one already there. Having multiple presenters in one meeting would definitely go smoother, though it doesn't happen that often. Startup time would definitely be faster though, as noted our web conference software sucks.
I also like the idea (posted elsewhere) to be able to draw on the slides / point things out.
I loved the demo :)
The problem I see is that by requiring a working internet connection on your smartphone and the computer you use to present, this add a number of points of failure. I'd feel safer with just a USB key (+ publicly accessible copy on the web) and a PDF.
It would be cool if you'd show the presentation on the phone too and let the presenter use the phone (or tablet) to draw/highlight stuff live.
In both Firefox and Chrome the QR code on the homepage only appears after a refresh or two.
Overall really nicely done, though the two reasons I wouldn't use it personally are 1.) Confidentiality (most decks I would ever want to present I can't upload to some random MVP site) 2.) Branding (I'd want to be able to white label, or self-host).
You might want to give a better walkthrough and explanation. :) Really cool though if it is solid. You have to be careful with slide control because this is LIVE and people want things that are absolutely solid and going to work 99.99% of the time. One mishap and you've probably lost that customer if it was in a live setting.
It's a bit unfortunate that uploading a keynote-presentation threw an error ( didn't say what the problem was, just that the presentation couldn't be converted ) and uploading a ppt messed up the charts. So, maybe it would be wiser to simply just accept pdf-documents and rely on users to do the conversion – it's a complicated task, versions change all the time and mastering pdf alone is maybe enough work for a mvp. just my two cents.
but you definitely got a user.
You can then add the ability to do live annotations to presentations from the phone/tablet and keep that exclusive to the app.
This whole app is brilliant, I hope it really takes off for you and you make a metric fuck-ton of money out of it. Superb idea.
Unfortunately the site doesn't work with IE on Windows Phone 8. Can't click either of the green buttons seen in this screen shot- http://sdrv.ms/X4gN6 (possible a bootstrap issue).
Hopefully I can snag my wife's droid tomorrow and give it a whirl!
IronMan Clip: http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v...
Is there already a name to shorthand this whole process/idea? "screen pairing"?
Still it was pretty fun to see the slides move when we moved a finger across the phone's screen.
I will give it a spin and see how it differs from http://presefy.com - which I'm currently using.
Why can't you embed a token in the QR code? I use huge pads for passwords and typing them in on my phone is traumatic and awful.
Feel free to contact me - my twitter is in the profile.
I am using Firefox 22 on PC, Firefox browser on phone.
If you dont mind, could you please send me your email address? anton at uslide net