So the real question (whether NSLs should be allowed) is quite a bit more nuanced.
I don't think they should, but not really on the basis of free speech.
So while you can quibble over yelling "fire" in a theater, silencing speech against prosecution from the government is diametrically opposed to the intent of the first amendment.
FYI, even this argument has been rejected for decades. Now, your speech must be likely to cause "imminent lawless action". [1]
Yelling fire in a crowded theater is not about causing lawless action; the people fleeing in panic are behaving lawfully. The act of yelling "fire" is outlawed because that panic can result in grave bodily harm to others, and is a foreseeable result of doing so.
Brandenburg deals with inflammatory speech (usually hate speech but also includes seditious speech), which must rise to the level of incitement to be criminal, specifically meaning that you must incite others to actually hurt a third party or to actually take seditious actions against the government. Otherwise, the inflammatory speech is justy the expression of personal opinion, which is directly protected by the 1st Amendment.
Neither Schenck nor Brandenburg (which is considered to relate to Schenck) relate to actually yelling the word 'fire' more than indirectly.
I'm mildly interested in the actual hypothetical; out of curiosity can you cite caselaw that backs your claim (The act of yelling "fire" is outlawed because that panic can result in grave bodily harm to others, and is a foreseeable result of doing so)?
1. http://www.popehat.com/2012/09/19/three-generations-of-a-hac...
Then, I think someone forgot to tell the government that.
The entire framework of the US government's core documents and the non-legal documents written by the founders around the same time completely support the notion that these documents have purposes, chief among which is the defense of citizens from the government itself.
Interstate commerce has been applied to non-commercial private activities on personal property in numerous ways, for 70+ years.
Please see Raich v. Gonzales and Wickard v. Filburn.
Raich and Wickard are not unreasonable extensions of federal power--they simply reflect the fact that technology has changed the nature of commerce since the Constitution was drafted.
The problem with Raich and Wickard (et al.) is not that they extend federal power, but rather that they invent it of whole cloth.
Raich and Wickard do not invent federal power; they simply extend it to the modern era (or rather, into their future and our present day, since technology took a few decades to catch up).
Let me ask you this: What activity isn't covered in your interpretation of the commerce clause?
Today, technology across all sectors has improved to the point where you can now order heirloom todays and get same day delivery (in some markets). When these SCOTUS cases were decided, that same process would have taken months.
Moreover, trade that does not cross state lines can be interstate. For example--you make good Widget that you sell nationwide. I decide in State X that I want to make and sell Widget as well. (Patent, etc. are not a concern in this hypothetical). My sale in State X of widget necessarily affects your interstate sale of the same widget: every widget that I sell in State X is one less that you might sell, which means one more widget is available in other states, altering the normal supply/demand considerations. (I'm not just pulling this out of my ass, this is the actual logic set forth in the SCOTUS cases.)
You have to trade something in return for those services. Almost always that something is money.
If a lawyer represents me for nothing in return - then no trade took place, it would be a gift.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argumentum_ad_populum
"Virtually everyone" is not qualified to make a constitution, and if by "the courts" you mean the SCOTUS, then the courts have a history of doing a lot of stupid things based on personal bias.
It's one thing for lawmakers to get tripped up on finer points of Constitutional law with which the Supreme Court disagrees with. It's quite another to just play this "catch me if you can" game trying to push the limits of what is possible while ignoring the Bill of Rights.
A lot more about the fourth ammendment -- unreasonable searches and seizures, the right to be "secure in your papers and effects" -- the one that says they need a warrant and ordinarily need to let you know the warrant was served). Don't it?
The constitution is not a suicide pact. That is, the system cannot interpret the various provisions of the constitution in such a way that would destroy the country. The Declaration of Independence is a statement of philosophy. The constitution is a rather vague and self-contradictory description of structure. Different thing entirely.
Having said that, what has happened is that 240 years has given all the players in government a chance to find edge cases where they can have their way at the expense of others.
What we're seeing now is a state of perpetual war. This was never envisioned when the country was founded. So we're way off the script.
Isn't it? It seems like it was intended to be a set of fully strict provisions, and if they didn't work, everyone had to agree on changing it.
Such as when it falls into a perpetual state of war. Like they complained about England doing. I think it was well envisioned and it's well on script. However, the Founders believed the separation of powers between branches would create adequate checks and balances to prevent it from happening. I think they failed to envision the case where said branches would collude and ignore the rules to protect each other's power quid pro quo, and most people would not notice and not be bothered.
> 1. A government may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm. > 2. A government must obey the laws given to it by human beings (through their representatives), except where such laws would conflict with the First Law. > 3. A government must protect its own existence as long as such protection does not conflict with the First or Second Laws.
If so, they forgot an important addendum. -- but they can be forgiven, AI research was in its infancy back then, after all. :^)
>A government that keeps growing[1] more complex will inevitably reach Rampancy[2]. It is recommended you implement more than a few kill-switches for when (not if) this happens... Relying on a system to regulate/moderate itself is asking for disappointment.
And of course:
> 0. A government may not harm humanity, or, by inaction, allow humanity to come to harm.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parkinson%27s_law [2] http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/AIIsACrapshoot
We have a tendency to anthropomorphize things. Corporations, Congress, religions, anything that is a group of people can be thought of as a unique, distinct entity of its own. But really, they aren't. Congress isn't one thing, it's 535 people who each have their own brains, their own decision structures. It may be a convenient model to treat them as a single entity at times, but as with all models, it is only an approximation and fails in corner cases.
I pushed a lot of people to remember this when governing our hackerspace. The space was not a thing without the people in it. A lot of people were talking about "the needs of the space" and "where the space was going", talking like there was a creature called The Space who had her own wishes and desires and we needed to be considerate of them. Once we broke that lunacy down, we saw that nobody actually wanted the things people said The Space wanted, it was just assumed these were things everyone wanted, so they went along to not violate the sanctity of The Space.
The Constitution falls into anthropomorphizing Congress. It says, "Congress shall make no law", not "The people in Congress shall make no law." It's the old kid's joke of, "who broke the cookie jar? Nobody! Wow, this Nobody guy sure does break a lot of stuff." If Congress did it, than no individual did it. If Congress is held accountable for something, then no individual can be held accountable.
It's just too easy to test the legal envelope without any repercussions. Don't like the limits on your power that the Constitution has in place? Pass the law you want anyway and see if anyone notices. Fake-it-till-you-make-it. The Constitution means whatever fantasy Congress and the President says it means, redefined words and all. In order for The People to be secure, the people need to have their personal security violated. In order for Freedom to live on, freedom must be curtailed. It's not until the Supreme Court has someone shove it in their face too hard for them to ignore it that anyone even starts to look at the provisions of these bills. And then the same guys who passed the first one just try again, often with nearly identical wording to the last time, until everyone is just too damned tired to keep fighting.
Let's create an Amendment to hold congresscritters accountable--say, with jail time--for passing laws that violate the Constitution. The Constitution is law with most of its provisions lacking codified punishments. I think only Treason is defined with an explicit punishment in the Constitution. If the Supreme Court decides a law gets struck down because it is unconstitutional, then all the names on the list of sponsors for the bill go to jail. The Amendment could be that all new Amendments must have a codified punishment and all previous Amendments need to have punishments amended to them.
Stop Cowboy Government.
"Test-driven" means we decide what it should do, then we write the corresponding code.
A "test-driven" nation would decide first what the government ought to do, then proceed by writing the corresponding laws.
The system you describe is the exact opposite: let's write some code / law and then see what happens. You have a Cowboy Congress.
You might amend your last sentence to read "Start Test Driven Government" instead.
At the least, our use and interpretation of the Constitution has explicitly discounted individual rights in favor of the collective state since approximately Lincoln. Against 150 years of tradition, what the Founders intended (up to and including the arming of the populace as a deterrent against tyranny) is largely irrelevant.
Note: My point is not at all about gun control, it's just the first example of inconsistency that I had in mind. Not starting any debate here.
There, I said it.
is it cowardly? well, yeah. but can you really blame anyone else for not wanting to mess up what they have? I mean, let's be realistic.
How do you know? It seems to me like the people who wrote the constitution (and authored/ratified the Bill of Rights) were willing to risk everything to achieve the freedoms enumerated in the constitution and its subsequent amendments. While I'm probably projecting my own opinions onto them to some extent, it seems to me that the founders of the United States would rather see the nation fall apart than become what they set out to destroy.
Poppycock.
The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.