News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What happens when the Secret Service uses a NSL on you by tikhonj on Thursday March 21, 2013 @03:47PM (#5418345)
That's a bit of a red herring because virtually everyone (including the courts) agrees there should be some limits to free speech: copyright, trademarks, fraud, consumer protection, libel/slander, obscenity and more that I'm forgetting.

So the real question (whether NSLs should be allowed) is quite a bit more nuanced.

I don't think they should, but not really on the basis of free speech.

Re:What happens when the Secret Service uses a NSL on you by crusso on Thursday March 21, 2013 @03:52PM (#5418377)
While there are limits in the first amendment, its primary purpose is to allow individual citizens to speak out against the tyranny of government.

So while you can quibble over yelling "fire" in a theater, silencing speech against prosecution from the government is diametrically opposed to the intent of the first amendment.

Re:What happens when the Secret Service uses a NSL on you by AnIrishDuck on Thursday March 21, 2013 @04:12PM (#5418556)
> you can quibble over yelling "fire" in a theater

FYI, even this argument has been rejected for decades. Now, your speech must be likely to cause "imminent lawless action". [1]

1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brandenburg_v._Ohio

Re:What happens when the Secret Service uses a NSL on you by gamblor956 on Thursday March 21, 2013 @05:35PM (#5419238)
No, you're misunderstanding Brandenburg.

Yelling fire in a crowded theater is not about causing lawless action; the people fleeing in panic are behaving lawfully. The act of yelling "fire" is outlawed because that panic can result in grave bodily harm to others, and is a foreseeable result of doing so.

Brandenburg deals with inflammatory speech (usually hate speech but also includes seditious speech), which must rise to the level of incitement to be criminal, specifically meaning that you must incite others to actually hurt a third party or to actually take seditious actions against the government. Otherwise, the inflammatory speech is justy the expression of personal opinion, which is directly protected by the 1st Amendment.

Re:What happens when the Secret Service uses a NSL on you by yew on Thursday March 21, 2013 @06:17PM (#5419582)
The 'fire in a crowded theatre' standard was a metaphor for opposing the draft originating in Schenck v United States.

Neither Schenck nor Brandenburg (which is considered to relate to Schenck) relate to actually yelling the word 'fire' more than indirectly.

Re:What happens when the Secret Service uses a NSL on you by AnIrishDuck on Thursday March 21, 2013 @08:28PM (#5420481)
I was (poorly) raging against the "fire in a crowded theater" metaphor, which gets trotted out too often [1].

I'm mildly interested in the actual hypothetical; out of curiosity can you cite caselaw that backs your claim (The act of yelling "fire" is outlawed because that panic can result in grave bodily harm to others, and is a foreseeable result of doing so)?

1. http://www.popehat.com/2012/09/19/three-generations-of-a-hac...

Re:What happens when the Secret Service uses a NSL on you by misnome on Thursday March 21, 2013 @04:03PM (#5418457)
> While there are limits in the first amendment, its primary purpose is to allow individual citizens to speak out against the tyranny of government.

Then, I think someone forgot to tell the government that.

Re:What happens when the Secret Service uses a NSL on you by carbocation on Thursday March 21, 2013 @04:10PM (#5418533)
Not sure if you're kidding, cynical, or serious.

The entire framework of the US government's core documents and the non-legal documents written by the founders around the same time completely support the notion that these documents have purposes, chief among which is the defense of citizens from the government itself.

Re:What happens when the Secret Service uses a NSL on you by nightpool on Thursday March 21, 2013 @07:52PM (#5420266)
Not the original poster, but I think his comment was meant to be interpreted as "Somebody should remind our current government of its original vision"
Re:What happens when the Secret Service uses a NSL on you by foobarqux on Thursday March 21, 2013 @08:17PM (#5420422)
Re:What happens when the Secret Service uses a NSL on you by flyinRyan on Friday March 22, 2013 @06:27AM (#5422146)
So, ironically, the "fire in a theater" phrase actually indicates the government can simply ignore their own laws any time they feel like it, as they did when the phrase was uttered.
Re:What happens when the Secret Service uses a NSL on you by bsimpson on Thursday March 21, 2013 @04:01PM (#5418436)
Article I Section VIII enumerates the powers of the federal government, and includes an intellectual property provision, as well as an interstate commerce one.
Re:What happens when the Secret Service uses a NSL on you by dreamdu5t on Thursday March 21, 2013 @04:31PM (#5418733)
... which have been completely shit on by the criminals sitting on the Supreme Court.

Interstate commerce has been applied to non-commercial private activities on personal property in numerous ways, for 70+ years.

Please see Raich v. Gonzales and Wickard v. Filburn.

Re:What happens when the Secret Service uses a NSL on you by bsimpson on Thursday March 21, 2013 @04:44PM (#5418834)
Interstate commerce is abused by all branches of the federal government, but the point is that laws regarding fraud or copyright don't abate our 1st Amendment rights to free speech.
Re:What happens when the Secret Service uses a NSL on you by gamblor956 on Thursday March 21, 2013 @05:41PM (#5419281)
One of the hallmarks of technology, and especially the internet, is that almost no actions an individual takes can be regarded as truly private anymore. Nowadays, doing anything in some way has an effect on interstate commerce in a way not contemplated by the Founding Fathers.

Raich and Wickard are not unreasonable extensions of federal power--they simply reflect the fact that technology has changed the nature of commerce since the Constitution was drafted.

Re:What happens when the Secret Service uses a NSL on you by kbolino on Thursday March 21, 2013 @06:42PM (#5419774)
Except that the power of Congress to "regulate Commerce ... among the several States" does not mean that Congress has the power to regulate an individual's commercial activity. It means that Congress has the power to forbid a state from interfering in commerce taking place across state lines.

The problem with Raich and Wickard (et al.) is not that they extend federal power, but rather that they invent it of whole cloth.

Re:What happens when the Secret Service uses a NSL on you by gamblor956 on Thursday March 21, 2013 @08:20PM (#5420439)
"among the States," not "of the States" or "by the States." This means that Congress has the power to regulate Commerce occuring "amongst" several states. This includes but is not limited to regulating the States' power to regulate commerce within their own borders.

Raich and Wickard do not invent federal power; they simply extend it to the modern era (or rather, into their future and our present day, since technology took a few decades to catch up).

Re:What happens when the Secret Service uses a NSL on you by dreamdu5t on Thursday March 21, 2013 @09:03PM (#5420640)
Using that interpretation the Federal government has no meaningful limits on its power, if "regulate Commerce... among the several States" includes every physical thing in the US.

Let me ask you this: What activity isn't covered in your interpretation of the commerce clause?

Re:What happens when the Secret Service uses a NSL on you by ubernostrum on Friday March 22, 2013 @04:16AM (#5421871)
The exact scope of the Commerce Clause is actually one of the classic questions of US constitutional law. Court interpretations have gone back and forth over the years; currently, things are a bit muddy because members of the Supreme Court have a tendency to expand or restrict the clause to suit their own ideologies (i.e., Scalia believes that a federal ban on marijuana can apply even to marijuana which never crosses a state line, because he doesn't like marijuana; he has a very different and arguably conflicting opinion on gun regulations, though, because he likes guns).
Re:What happens when the Secret Service uses a NSL on you by eurleif on Thursday March 21, 2013 @06:18PM (#5419597)
The argument in Wickard is that growing wheat on your farm is interstate commerce because if you grow your own wheat, you won't buy someone else's wheat, which affects the interstate market for wheat. How does that depend on technological progress? Seems like it would apply as long as wheat were sold across state lines at all.
Re:What happens when the Secret Service uses a NSL on you by gamblor956 on Thursday March 21, 2013 @08:29PM (#5420486)
Interstate effect is meaningless if technology cannot support the transfer of goods across the necessary distances. In the 1900s, this technology was mostly physical, related to the transport and storage of goods.

Today, technology across all sectors has improved to the point where you can now order heirloom todays and get same day delivery (in some markets). When these SCOTUS cases were decided, that same process would have taken months.

Re:What happens when the Secret Service uses a NSL on you by eurleif on Thursday March 21, 2013 @08:56PM (#5420615)
Interstate markets always existed, despite being less convenient and less popular. If you chose to buy from a local vendor, you were implicitly choosing not to buy from an interstate vendor, which means you were having the indirect effect on interstate commerce that Wickard v. Filburn relies on.
Re:What happens when the Secret Service uses a NSL on you by dreamdu5t on Thursday March 21, 2013 @06:40PM (#5419743)
Technology has nothing to do with it. Activity that does not involve trade is not commercial. Trade that does not cross state lines is not inter-state. Non-commercial (no selling, no trading) private activity that never leaves your property is not interstate commerce. The sky is still blue even if the Supreme Court says it is yellow.
Re:What happens when the Secret Service uses a NSL on you by gamblor956 on Thursday March 21, 2013 @08:24PM (#5420463)
Commercial activity does not require trade. Otherwise, professional services such as accounting or law would not be commercial activities since no "trade" actually occurs. Commercial activity simply requires an intent to achieve a net economic benefit position (i.e., profit) through an activity.

Moreover, trade that does not cross state lines can be interstate. For example--you make good Widget that you sell nationwide. I decide in State X that I want to make and sell Widget as well. (Patent, etc. are not a concern in this hypothetical). My sale in State X of widget necessarily affects your interstate sale of the same widget: every widget that I sell in State X is one less that you might sell, which means one more widget is available in other states, altering the normal supply/demand considerations. (I'm not just pulling this out of my ass, this is the actual logic set forth in the SCOTUS cases.)

Re:What happens when the Secret Service uses a NSL on you by dreamdu5t on Thursday March 21, 2013 @08:42PM (#5420548)
> professional services such as accounting or law

You have to trade something in return for those services. Almost always that something is money.

If a lawyer represents me for nothing in return - then no trade took place, it would be a gift.

Re:What happens when the Secret Service uses a NSL on you by ryguytilidie on Thursday March 21, 2013 @04:45PM (#5418848)
If they agree there should be some limits they should make an amendment to the constitution versus just pretending like the constitution doesn't exist.
Re:What happens when the Secret Service uses a NSL on you by wyager on Thursday March 21, 2013 @05:46PM (#5419319)
"because virtually everyone (including the courts) agrees there should be some limits to free speech"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argumentum_ad_populum

"Virtually everyone" is not qualified to make a constitution, and if by "the courts" you mean the SCOTUS, then the courts have a history of doing a lot of stupid things based on personal bias.