By that standard I could say 'X has been arrested for littering - he could face the death penalty!!' Well, it's possible - until X has been charged with something specific, who am I to say he won't get hit with a capital murder charge or somesuch?
I don't agree with you about the how the OP is using the rule of lenity. He specifically says the executive needs to change its enforcement on that basis, whereas changing the law is something that would be done by Congress. If he can't say what he means then he has no business reporting on legal topics.
If may be misleading, but strictly speaking it's factually accurate. That is the maximum penalty -- and as long as it is, people who don't like it are going to report it.
If you want them to stop, amend the law so that minor offenses don't fall under the same section as major offenses. For a law to carry felony penalties, it should require something in the nature of profit motive and nontrivial actual harm. Then some fool who vandalizes a website for fun can be convicted of a misdemeanor and pay a fine or go to jail for a couple months while we still get to throw the book at people who make fraudulent credit card charges or engage in industrial espionage, and you won't see any more stories about how the former class of people could be jailed until death for the computer equivalent of disregarding a sign that says "don't walk on the grass."
As a matter of fact, the mean sentence under the CFAA (as of 2008 EDIT: typo. This is as of 2000.) is only 6.8 months. Minor offenders tend to get probation, and the heaviest sentences fall on those who interfere with the administration of justice or commit industrial espionage - and they face an average sentence of 17.3 months.[1]
1. http://proc.isecon.org/2000/128/ISECON.2000.Nwokoma.pdf
It's a bit pointless demanding reform of the law without any context for how it is actually working in the real world.
I imagine people convicted of manslaughter also don't typically serve anything like the statutory maximum. But we calibrate our expectations and sense of proportionality based on the maximum because that's the number that gets published and compared to penalties for other offenses, and actual sentences are often set in proportion to the maximum, so changing the maximum has the practical consequence of changing the result in typical cases.
>As a matter of fact, the mean sentence under the CFAA (as of 2008) is only 6.8 months.
If you get convicted of a felony and sentenced to probation, you still get a felony record. I don't think we should be making felons out of people who have done something that deserves to be punished only with probation. The maximum penalty is extremely relevant because that's what makes it a felony, even if it bears little resemblance to what happens in the typical case.
>It's a bit pointless demanding reform of the law without any context for how it is actually working in the real world.
By the real world you mean the court system, but what about the real real world? The maximum is what you read in the statute when you're trying to decide whether to break an unclear law for a good reason. It probably has more influence on the behavior of people in the real world than the unpublicized actual outcomes do.
Well, this is the problem - it's often the only number that gets published, because it makes for a better story than qualifying that sensational number with the rather less exciting reality of sentences administered.
You can't go complaining about the length of the maximum sentence and then waving aside the much lower sentences that are actually handed out as if they didn't matter.
I don't think we should be making felons out of people who have done something that deserves to be punished only with probation.
We're not, generally. Not every offense prosecuted under CFAA is a felony; in many cases defendants are charged with a misdemeanor instead. This was mentioned int he link I gave you earlier, and it's treated in much more detail here: http://www.justice.gov/criminal/cybercrime/docs/ccmanual.pdf
This is why I'm grumbling about the inaccuracy in reporting. You see the big maximum sentence as if it were the only thing that mattered, and you develop a really inaccurate idea of the law as a result.
I think it's more of an issue that the truth is complicated and a journalist can't cover a story in the detail you might like without losing too many readers to "TL;DR" or spending more hours to research it than the editor has assigned for the story. The typical sentences handed down are by far not the only important thing left out of articles like this. The things missing from these articles could span volumes of books. And each one of them needs to be put into context. If you discuss the typical sentences handed down then they ought to be compared to the sentences handed down for other similar offenses, or to the offenses that have similar typical sentences, and a thorough treatment would go down the rabbit hole into plea bargaining and sentencing guidelines and the whole works. But given limited resources and limited column inches, instead we end up with heuristics like using the maximum penalty as a proxy for the severity with which the law treats the behavior.
Whenever there is a popular push to change the law, most people aren't going to understand all the details. People don't have time to learn everything about everything. At some point the layman will have to defer to someone trustworthy (like the EFF or the ACLU) to do the legwork and then adopt their position on the strength of their reputation. They need to get down into the weeds and make sure they understand what's going on, but they aren't the ones getting their information from popular media, they're the ones reading the statutes and the case law and engaging in discussions with scholars and legislators etc. Articles in The New Yorker aren't meant for those people, they're meant for the man in the street who needs to be made aware that something is going on and the people who have done their homework are saying it's a problem and we should do something about it. That way a critical mass of people willing to support doing something about it can be achieved, even if it isn't possible for all of those people to each be individually aware of every nuance of the issue. If someone wants to know more then the information is available. Anyone so inclined can look it up. But most people won't; I don't see any obvious way around that. And an article that skims over some of the details for the sake of brevity and approachability is a lot more likely to be read by those people, so that at least they know that something is happening and maybe some subset of the currently-oblivious can be inspired to learn more.
>Not every offense prosecuted under CFAA is a felony; in many cases defendants are charged with a misdemeanor instead.
I'm not sure how that changes anything. That some cases are prosecuted as misdemeanors or in an otherwise unproblematic fashion doesn't mean we can't do better in the cases that aren't. And if many of the cases prosecuted as misdemeanors could under the law have been prosecuted as felonies but for the grace of the prosecutor, that still points to a problem in the law.
Listing only the maximum is a good thing because phrasing the range of penalties as you suggest is a variant of the "Door in the Face" technique. In absolute terms, 5 years may seem incomprehensibly ridiculous for what amounts to digital graffiti, but when readers are skimming through an article they'll see "5 out of 25" and think, "How generous of the prosecutors to knock off 80% of the sentence!" This is not the desired outcome.
Is it not factually accurate? Could local law enforcement not arrest you for doing it and subject you to a trial or try to coerce you into a plea bargain, if they didn't mind the response from the public or the courts?
Moreover, would you not oppose an effort to remove such a law from the books? How do you imagine anyone would lobby for that to happen without discussing it?
In Minnesota, oral sex is punishable by up to a year in jail and a $3,000 fine.
Factually accurate:
In Minnesota, by law, oral sex is punishable by up to a year in jail and a $3,000 fine. However, that law is never enforced and your chances of getting prosecuted are 0.
Factually accurate does not mean you can cherry pick your facts and pretend you are telling the whole truth just because each individual fact is accurate.
It is, however, frequently used to intimidate people into giving up their rights. There is a reason that more people go to prison each year than could possibly be sentenced by a jury of their peers, and the maximum penalties allowed by the law is one of them. Let's put it this way: the four men in Norfolk who pled guilty to a rape and murder they were entirely innocent of did not do so because they were insane; they were simply terrified of the possibility that they might be executed (and the exhaustion of many hours of berating by the police did not help).
The tactic works because of human psychology. Being in an interrogation room is terrifying, and people have a natural instinct to try to get out as soon as possible. The police interrogators are trained to extract confessions and play on those instincts and the general fear their subjects experience. The problem is not the press, it is the interrogation and plea bargaining process itself.
My whole point is that such data are missing from this article, despite their relevance.
The tactic works because of human psychology. Being in an interrogation room is terrifying, and people have a natural instinct to try to get out as soon as possible.
I've been in one. I found it annoying rather than terrifying, but that's obviously not the case for many other people. For all its flaws, sitting people down and asking them uncomfortable questions is one of the better techniques we have for solving crimes, and I find it vastly preferable to the use of things like truth serums or lie detectors.
Before the charges came down, I would've thought the realistic number was 30 days of probation or maybe 20 hours of community service. Of course, that number would have said more about me than about reality. I prefer my reporters to deliver the facts first, and their interpretations and guesses second.
As I pointed out in another message in this thread, your estimate would be the realistic number, because most petty offenders under the CFAA do get probation.
Second, you're imposing an unrealistic burden upon reporters. The OP in this case is simply stating the facts: that the charges that Keys faces have a sky-high penalty -- which is not the case for littering, to use our example. For the OP to also say, "but most likely, Keys won't face the full penalty and he may even get a slap on the wrist," the OP has to predict the future or have foreknowledge of these factors:
* How guilty Keys actually is
* The current and near-future caseload of the prosecutor
* How strong the case is
* How likely it is that Keys will be the type to plea bargain
* Whether or not there's the possibility that Keys will turn state's evidence, which would essentially nullify any punishment.
Such a thorough exploration would make for an interesting article, maybe, but that was never the OP's intention. The OP is merely pointing out what a sloppy statue the CFAA is. What happens as a matter of judicial procedure is only a tangent.
By contrast, look at the NYT's report on the story: http://www.nytimes.com/2013/03/18/technology/outcry-over-com... This raises all the same issues, but in much greater detail and with meaningful context.
> Really? The prosecutor is seeking the maximum statutory penalty for this? Somehow I doubt that.
The penalties listed are what's defined in the statutes. Keep in mind that the case at hand was just revealed. The prosecutors won't be saying what penalties they seek until the bargaining and sentencing phase.
> 2. BY A COURT. The rule of lenity is something that is supposed to guide the behavior of judges.
You're correct that this is a guideline for judges. But the OP is apparently referring to "the rule of lenity" in how 13 federal judges so far have rejected the DOJ's interpretation of the CFAA. To the OP, this is proof that the law is so vague that it needs to be changed, or else "the rule of lenity" will constantly be invoked.