News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fixing the worst law in technology by pessimizer on Monday March 18, 2013 @05:27PM (#5397251)
The death penalty is the maximum statutory penalty for littering?
Re:Fixing the worst law in technology by anigbrowl on Monday March 18, 2013 @05:30PM (#5397273)
No. I said arrested for littering. Until a person is charged, they could conceivably be charged with a much more serious offense. My point is that it would be sensationalist and wildly misleading to focus on that angle, just as it is sensationalist and wildly misleading to focus on the statutory maximum sentence for a particular crime while ignoring the fact that it is almost never applied.
Re:Fixing the worst law in technology by pessimizer on Monday March 18, 2013 @05:47PM (#5397375)
So stating the uncontroversial recorded range of penalties for a particular charge is sensationalist and wildly misleading, and making up a "realistic" number is the proper function of journalism?

Before the charges came down, I would've thought the realistic number was 30 days of probation or maybe 20 hours of community service. Of course, that number would have said more about me than about reality. I prefer my reporters to deliver the facts first, and their interpretations and guesses second.

Re:Fixing the worst law in technology by anigbrowl on Monday March 18, 2013 @05:58PM (#5397444)
They're not stating the recorded range of penalties, they're stating the maximum possible penalty while omitting the rather crucial fact that this is hardly ever administered. They don't have to make anything up, just look at the public record of penalties actually applied.

As I pointed out in another message in this thread, your estimate would be the realistic number, because most petty offenders under the CFAA do get probation.

Re:Fixing the worst law in technology by danso on Monday March 18, 2013 @06:33PM (#5397611)
Yes, but in both scenarios the OP refers to -- Aaron Swartz's and Matthew Keys's -- indictments have already been handed down by a federal grand jury, so it's unlikely the charges will get worse.

Second, you're imposing an unrealistic burden upon reporters. The OP in this case is simply stating the facts: that the charges that Keys faces have a sky-high penalty -- which is not the case for littering, to use our example. For the OP to also say, "but most likely, Keys won't face the full penalty and he may even get a slap on the wrist," the OP has to predict the future or have foreknowledge of these factors:

* How guilty Keys actually is

* The current and near-future caseload of the prosecutor

* How strong the case is

* How likely it is that Keys will be the type to plea bargain

* Whether or not there's the possibility that Keys will turn state's evidence, which would essentially nullify any punishment.

Such a thorough exploration would make for an interesting article, maybe, but that was never the OP's intention. The OP is merely pointing out what a sloppy statue the CFAA is. What happens as a matter of judicial procedure is only a tangent.

Re:Fixing the worst law in technology by anigbrowl on Monday March 18, 2013 @07:13PM (#5397799)
OP's reporting on the statute and its enforcement is inaccurate and IMHO worthless. I managed to turn up statistics on average sentence length under the CFAA within a couple of minutes. It's plain that the guy didn't even do basic research; his article doesn't even list the charges or link to the indictment (http://www.scribd.com/doc/130418853/Matthew-Keys-Indictment)

By contrast, look at the NYT's report on the story: http://www.nytimes.com/2013/03/18/technology/outcry-over-com... This raises all the same issues, but in much greater detail and with meaningful context.