The stats on Detroit emergency responders are utterly embarrassing. You pretty much can't count on police, fire or EMT even if you had a gunshot wound in a burning house and the shooter was still there.
So I'm guessing the issue in Detroit is less about technique and more about no access to trained responders.
*And to be clear, I'm not blaming the emergency responders in Detroit for the problem. The city is huge and spread out so it takes a long time to get to the scene, there's no funding for additional outposts or training, and the jobs are dangerous making them unattractive to people with other options, and there's a higher than average amount of serious crime and emergencies.
Statistic is true, but to say it is because of those things would requite some further analysis. Given confounding factors I don't think you can make that claim.
Seattle has an obesity rate of 22.5%, compared with 35.7% nationwide, and 33.1% in Detroit. Obesity is a major risk factor for cardiac arrest.
Seattle is also extremely white for a large American city, 67.1%, versus a place like Detroit which is 82.7% African American. Black American's have significantly higher incidences of hypertension and cardiac disease than White Americans, both for reasons that seem to have some unrealiable relations to genetic heritage but more significantly due to social stressors related to racism and overrepresentation of poverty.
Speaking of economics, Seattle has a median household income of $45k, while Detroit has a median household income of $26k. Cardiac Arrest risk factors are greatly exacerbated in the United States by poverty.
I don't deny the importance of instituting up-to-date protocols for Emergency health personnel, broad equipment supply, and widespread lay education. But to give them all the credit is to ignore Seattle's many advantages, and Detroit's many other sufferings.
Perhaps a trained medical professional will correct me, but I've worked closely with the technology for years and I don't believe this is accurate. An AED can indeed bring someone back to consciousness if the shock is successful. If it isn't successful, then it wouldn't affect the efficacy of CPR one way or the other.
The rest of your comment seems spot on.
An AED disrupts the fibrillation of the heart - often an outcome of a heart attack. Fibrillation is basically different parts of the heart firing randomly, with the effect that not much blood gets pumped. A defib (from AED or otherwise) is like a hard reboot of the heart, to try to reset the heart so it all contracts together again.
Consciousness is more to due with a neuro-state, which is affected by blood flow so its a symptom of the heart problem rather than the problem itself.
Also, as someone else mentioned, heart stopping /= death anymore, it is determined by brain activity [2]
[1] http://intensivecare.hsnet.nsw.gov.au/cardiac-arrest [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death#Diagnosis [3] http://depts.washington.edu/chru/May-20-A-Wicks-2_JC.pdf
If the cardiac arrest is the result of another mechanism, defibrillation is ineffective.
But to your specific question: If a patient is in cardiac arrest but not in VF, then this means his heart has completely stopped. Forcing defibrillation won't likely improve the situation, but nor can it make it much worse.
That's only for bystanders for the reason you cite (reluctance to give aid). Rescue breaths are helpful and those of us who have to respond for our employer still give them. I carry around a barrier mask all the time now.
Source: I have the HCP level CPR cert.
That spiral in the middle is the one way valve.
I was recently witness to exactly this situation. The father of a friend of mine, an otherwise healthy man in his late 50s, collapsed when his heart stopped due to what was later diagnosed as some heart rhythm problem (I'm not sure exactly the cause). A friend of the family performed CPR until the ambulance arrived (which took a while, this being a rural location).
Less than a week later he was back on his feet.
I'm not a medical professional, so I can't say for sure that he would have survived without CPR; but I don't doubt it was key to his survival.
The survival rates are:
CPR by a bystander: 4%
Cardiocerebral Resuscitation (i.e., chest compressions only without artificial respiration): 6%
No bystander CPR: 2%
So attempting CPR results on average in doubling the survival rate as opposed to just waiting for an ambulance, and chest compressions only are 50% better than chest compressions plus mouth-to-mouth.
EDIT: By sheer coincidence I found my stat about CPR while commenting on another thread. http://www.zocalopublicsquare.org/2011/11/30/how-doctors-die...
Ambulance + plain old CPR, however, is much more effective than Ambulance + yelling "ITS GOING TO BE OK!" or playing Angry Birds or whatever. I don't remember the stats on effectiveness of performing CPR while waiting for the ambulance vs. not, but they were persuasive.
The hell of it was, it did work. The guy kept waking up from it while they were doing it, being very grumpy that people were pressing on his chest, and the moment they stopped he'd go unconscious again. Continued through the normal CPR and the ambulance's CPR apparently.
Unfortunately in the end he didn't make it (heart just would not restart fully).
Plus, as others have said, it's also beneficial for the bystanders to be doing something beneficial. In my own situation, I didn't know for sure that CPR wouldn't have helped until the autopsy came back. That's a pretty big time frame to sit around and wonder if you could have done anything or not. If you're just a random person on the street, you may never get that information to ease your mind.
I heard this years ago, and both times that I took CPR certification classes since then, we did mouth-to-mouth anyway. I guess different courses are different.
https://www.cprundead.ca/guinness-event
and they specifically said that mouth-to-mouth is no longer a part of it. It's all about the chest compressions.
I recall seeing that it is almost as effective as the "legacy" CPR rescue breaths.
It's honestly super easy to remember, and I'll feel comfortable performing it if I find myself in that situation.
--Seattle has the highest survival rate for heart stop events in the world at 56%. That's because of pioneering advances in EMT training, broad availability of AEDs, high percentage of people trained, etc.
--When I asked for a point of comparison, he said Detroit was 4%.
--AEDs don't actually bring you back to consciousness. They just make CPR more effective. (much more!)
--Bad CPR is much better than no CPR. So much so that high end AEDs will actually teach you CPR with voice prompts, since it's better than sitting there. Some 911 operators will coach you through it as well. Even if your CPR is rusty, it's worth trying.
--Modern CPR (for adults) no longer includes rescue breaths. Mouth-to-mouth was too much of a turnoff, and chest compressions alone are very effective given the response times of ambulances.
--And most importantly - $40 and two hours can save a life! You can set yourself up here: http://www.heart.org/HEARTORG/CPRAndECC/CPR_UCM_001118_SubHo...