News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Examples of beautiful Go? by voidlogic on Thursday March 14, 2013 @10:36AM (#5375199)
"Because of that, I'm having trouble persuading myself that Go is much more expressive than competitors" Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. While one programmer might say beautiful code is expressiveness (ex. performing a one liner quick sort), that is not what most Go developers I know see as beauty. Beautiful Go in my opinion is code that (in increasing importance):

  1. runs fast
  2. uses little memory
  3. is easily made (or is) concurrent / parallel
  4. is transparent (the intuitive run time complexity of operations is apparent, no hidden O(n..) operations, etc)
  5. is easy to maintain
If this code happens to be more verbose than say Java, so be it, it is still beautiful. On an anecdotal note, most large C++, Java and node.js projects I have ported to Go have ended up being fewer LOC in Go.
Re:Examples of beautiful Go? by melling on Thursday March 14, 2013 @11:35AM (#5375590)
How does a Go solution compare to a Perl, Python, or Ruby solution? The latter languages offer quick solutions to problems but they don't often scale to large projects built by large teams.
Re:Examples of beautiful Go? by jweir on Thursday March 14, 2013 @11:43AM (#5375651)
Binary builds are one advantage. Compile your go application and deploy it. No need to also install Ruby, gems etc.

You can cross compile as well. IE compile for Linux from OS X.

http://dave.cheney.net/2012/09/08/an-introduction-to-cross-c...

Re:Examples of beautiful Go? by danieldk on Thursday March 14, 2013 @12:58PM (#5376168)
Imagine that Go were used to write most components on a system. One security vulnerability in one package and you don't replace just one library, you'll have to reroll every binary (or package if you are maintaining a Linux distribution).

Also, since there is no version management in Go packaging, you better hope that every program uses the API of the latest or fixed version.

Re:Examples of beautiful Go? by burntsushi on Thursday March 14, 2013 @02:24PM (#5376749)
> Imagine that Go were used to write most components on a system. One security vulnerability in one package and you don't replace just one library, you'll have to reroll every binary (or package if you are maintaining a Linux distribution).

Imagine that a shared library were upgraded, and it contained a new vulnerability. This vulnerability now automatically exposes any program that uses said said library.

Trade offs :-)

(Compiling Go is fast. Re-rolling a binary isn't a Big Deal.)

> Also, since there is no version management in Go packaging, you better hope that every program uses the API of the latest or fixed version.

Simplicity has a price. But there's no reason why an external tool cannot be made to handle versioning.

Re:Examples of beautiful Go? by danieldk on Thursday March 14, 2013 @03:35PM (#5377149)
Imagine that a shared library were upgraded, and it contained a new vulnerability. This vulnerability now automatically exposes any program that uses said said library.

Production systems normally only replace shared libraries to fix vulnerabilities. So, that's a non-argument.

On non-production systems, it's far easier to replace one vulnerable library, than tens of vulnerable Go programs. That is, if you know which Go program was using what version of that package again.

Re:Examples of beautiful Go? by burntsushi on Friday March 15, 2013 @12:58AM (#5379286)
> Production systems normally only replace shared libraries to fix vulnerabilities. So, that's a non-argument.

Vulnerabilities are usually unforeseen. Which means that upgrading a shared library---for any reason whatsoever---could introduce a new vulnerability to all programs using that library.

> On non-production systems, it's far easier to replace one vulnerable library, than tens of vulnerable Go programs. That is, if you know which Go program was using what version of that package again.

It's easier, but it comes with aforementioned cost. Also, relative difficulty matters here. Maybe you haven't used Go before, but that all seems pretty simple. Particularly given the tools to analyze Go programs built right into the standard library.

Also, FYI, shared Go libraries are on the roadmap. That doesn't really help, but it's certainly better than "we refuse to add it."

Re:Examples of beautiful Go? by dscrd on Friday March 15, 2013 @12:51AM (#5379274)
"far easier" only because there's a huge infrastructure in the package manager that has been built over several years. And it does not always work, even though these days it most often does.
Re:Examples of beautiful Go? by cmccabe on Friday March 15, 2013 @02:14AM (#5379430)
Do you feel comfortable ripping out a shared library used by many different binaries on a production system and replacing it with a new one? I would be pretty scared to do that.

I would rather replace all the binaries separately. If one of the new binaries didn't work, I could go back to the old version.

I do agree that the shared library approach uses less network bandwidth, but is that really a big problem these days? Unless you're sysadminning over dialup, chances are you don't really care. The size of binaries has plateaued at a meg or two even as networks have continued to improve.

Re:Examples of beautiful Go? by danieldk on Friday March 15, 2013 @02:23AM (#5379444)
Sure, I know when the ABI changes and when not. For security fixes it's pretty safe to do. In fact, Debian Stable et al. do it all the time.
Re:Examples of beautiful Go? by TheCoelacanth on Thursday March 14, 2013 @02:33PM (#5376795)
This isn't a big problem for Google because they are mostly focused on a tightly controlled server environment where they control everything and created most of the software themselves.

For general purpose use, this is a huge deficiency in Go.

Re:Examples of beautiful Go? by cmccabe on Friday March 15, 2013 @02:07AM (#5379414)
Honestly, I expect there to be far fewer security vulnerabilities in Go than in C/C++ code, simply because it's a managed language. I'm sure there will be some at some point, but it should be at least an order of magnitude less.

I also don't really agree with the "fire-fighting" approach to security. Developers are constantly removing security bugs, but they're also constantly adding them. Result: the system is always vulnerable. Why should we copy a failed approach to security, when there are other approaches like sandboxing and process isolation? (By the way, these other approaches are a good idea in C/C++ as well.)

Shared libraries are also on the roadmap for Go so at some point that will be a possibility.

Re:Examples of beautiful Go? by icebraining on Thursday March 14, 2013 @11:59AM (#5375765)
That's not necessarily an advantage. E.g. PyInstaller can create stand-alone executables from Python packages.

That said, it's certainly much cleaner to just build static binary executables like Go does.

Re:Examples of beautiful Go? by voidlogic on Thursday March 14, 2013 @11:52AM (#5375712)
Pretty much like you would expect, the Go code is a bit longer but much more efficient at runtime; similar to what you see at the benchmark game: http://benchmarksgame.alioth.debian.org/u64q/benchmark.php?t... Note: That graph is using go 1.0.3 not Go tip which is even faster.

I do believe the Go code is more maintainable and I like the fact it is statically typed.

Re:Examples of beautiful Go? by aleyan on Thursday March 14, 2013 @03:41PM (#5377194)
Go is quite a bit faster and memory efficient than Python3? No unexpected. Curious how it stacks up with PyPy.

Looking at the Benchmark Game Go vs Java7[0], why is Java 2x to 8x faster than Go for many benchmarks? Is the jvm that optimized these days or are those Java7 programs super tweaked for performance?

[0] http://benchmarksgame.alioth.debian.org/u64q/benchmark.php?t...

Re:Examples of beautiful Go? by Ziomislaw on Thursday March 14, 2013 @04:11PM (#5377400)
jvm is really fast, it can usually compete with C++ code in terms of speed (if you ignore the startup time ;p )
Re:Examples of beautiful Go? by voidlogic on Thursday March 14, 2013 @04:42PM (#5377560)
The JVM is really fast- but to be fair note the JVMs memory usage in that comparison. Also version of Go used in that comparison is Go 1.0.3 and Go 1.1 RC (which is much faster and has better garbage collection) is going to be out next month.

Go is a very young language so while very fast compared to an interpreted language like Ruby, Python, etc by virtue of being compiled, it going to take some time be be on par (in terms of execution speed) with a Java, a JIT language that has had 18 years to mature.

It says a lot for Go that its execution time is on par with C#: http://benchmarksgame.alioth.debian.org/u64q/benchmark.php?t...

Re:Examples of beautiful Go? by pekk on Thursday March 14, 2013 @11:46AM (#5375677)
This kind of free-floating opinion, unsupported by evidence or even details, is worse than useless. It's a waste of time masquerading as content.

What is the basis for your claim? That it's impossible to build large projects without static typing, or what?

Re:Examples of beautiful Go? by pjmlp on Thursday March 14, 2013 @02:34PM (#5376805)
Based on my experience yes.

I work in enterprise projects done in multi-site context context, usually with teams that encompass more than 30 developers with multiple levels of experience.

Depending on the customer, sometimes it is very hard to force developers to write unit tests. If the customer does not care about them, the product manager will not enforce them.

Additionally given the lack of experiences of the junior developers, always chosen because they are cheaper to the customer, unit tests tend to be badly written.

So with static typing one has at least a guarantee that the product compiles and might eventually even run.

With dynamic typing and lack of tests, you can spend days getting the product back into a runnable state.