Imagine that a shared library were upgraded, and it contained a new vulnerability. This vulnerability now automatically exposes any program that uses said said library.
Trade offs :-)
(Compiling Go is fast. Re-rolling a binary isn't a Big Deal.)
> Also, since there is no version management in Go packaging, you better hope that every program uses the API of the latest or fixed version.
Simplicity has a price. But there's no reason why an external tool cannot be made to handle versioning.
Production systems normally only replace shared libraries to fix vulnerabilities. So, that's a non-argument.
On non-production systems, it's far easier to replace one vulnerable library, than tens of vulnerable Go programs. That is, if you know which Go program was using what version of that package again.
Vulnerabilities are usually unforeseen. Which means that upgrading a shared library---for any reason whatsoever---could introduce a new vulnerability to all programs using that library.
> On non-production systems, it's far easier to replace one vulnerable library, than tens of vulnerable Go programs. That is, if you know which Go program was using what version of that package again.
It's easier, but it comes with aforementioned cost. Also, relative difficulty matters here. Maybe you haven't used Go before, but that all seems pretty simple. Particularly given the tools to analyze Go programs built right into the standard library.
Also, FYI, shared Go libraries are on the roadmap. That doesn't really help, but it's certainly better than "we refuse to add it."
I would rather replace all the binaries separately. If one of the new binaries didn't work, I could go back to the old version.
I do agree that the shared library approach uses less network bandwidth, but is that really a big problem these days? Unless you're sysadminning over dialup, chances are you don't really care. The size of binaries has plateaued at a meg or two even as networks have continued to improve.
For general purpose use, this is a huge deficiency in Go.
I also don't really agree with the "fire-fighting" approach to security. Developers are constantly removing security bugs, but they're also constantly adding them. Result: the system is always vulnerable. Why should we copy a failed approach to security, when there are other approaches like sandboxing and process isolation? (By the way, these other approaches are a good idea in C/C++ as well.)
Shared libraries are also on the roadmap for Go so at some point that will be a possibility.
Also, since there is no version management in Go packaging, you better hope that every program uses the API of the latest or fixed version.