News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by dfc on Friday March 08, 2013 @09:41PM (#5347064)
Morse v. Frederick? Are you trolling? The Morse decision is so narrow that I don't know why you are expecting much traction by bringing it up. I'm curious are you in high school?

Edit:

There is nothing wrong if you are in high school. I was only asking because being a high school student would be a good explanation for why you think the Morse decision was so contentious.

Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by btilly on Friday March 08, 2013 @09:55PM (#5347117)
I brought it up as a free speech decision that demonstrates that this court is not universally on the side of free speech. And yes, I think that the government should not be censoring political speech that takes place off of government property, no matter how much it dislikes the message.

As for your high school accusation, I'm in the top 50 posters on this site. You can easily check that I don't look like a high school student. In fact had I chosen to have children when I got married, they would have now been old enough to have graduated from college.)

Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by dfc on Friday March 08, 2013 @10:03PM (#5347136)
No court is universally on the side of free speech. It was not an accusation of being a high school student. (I'm not even sure what the "accusation" would imply.) The question about high school was to assess why you thought the Morse decision was on the same level as Citizens United.

And I'm not sure what you being in the top 50 has to do with anything.

Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by 1123581321 on Friday March 08, 2013 @11:42PM (#5347352)
By the top 50 remark he meant that you have a large body of material from which to ascertain that he is not a high school student.
Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by rdl on Saturday March 09, 2013 @12:01AM (#5347405)
I wonder who the youngest on http://news.ycombinator.com/leaders (top 100) is. I see a few people I recognize as late-20s, at least, but most in 30s, and plenty in 40s-60s range
Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by lmm on Saturday March 09, 2013 @07:54AM (#5348263)
I doubt they'd admit it. From bitter experience, you can be as respected as you like in a community like this, but the moment you reveal you're 14, everyone will stop listening to you.
Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by Evbn on Saturday March 09, 2013 @10:15PM (#5350557)
Unless you are someone like Aaron Swartz, who was incredibly influential as a teenager.
Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by wtallis on Friday March 08, 2013 @10:04PM (#5347137)
I'm not familiar with the details of Morse v Frederick, but I'm curious to know what makes it a narrow ruling other than the age restriction? It seems at first glance that it gives schools the power to restrict almost any form of protest by students in or near schools.
Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by dfc on Friday March 08, 2013 @10:14PM (#5347156)
What makes it a narrow decision other than the issue of age and interests of a school administrator at a school function? Nothing. That seems to make it pretty narrow. Unlike other commenters in this thread I don't think "Bong Hits 4 Jesus" is political speech at a school function.
Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by wtallis on Friday March 08, 2013 @10:24PM (#5347184)
I don't care whether you consider "Bong Hits 4 Jesus" to be political speech. Did the court? I don't recall hearing that Morse v Frederick only applied to non-political speech.

And other than the age restriction, the only thing you can come up with is that it was restricted to only apply to the government agency that citizens of that age are required to interact with for most of their daily life, and can be reasonably expected to have the most cause to be protesting? That sure as hell doesn't narrow it down much more than the age restriction alone.

Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by rayiner on Friday March 08, 2013 @10:27PM (#5347189)
That's a huge restriction. School is where children are socialized.[1] It's a unique environment in our historical tradition and a unique set of rules are applicable.

[1] You might call it brainwashing, but society has historically valued this function very highly and protected it. Certainly during the founders time.

Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by Evbn on Saturday March 09, 2013 @10:17PM (#5350560)
Did many people even go to school in Founders time? Did we even have public school?
Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by dfc on Friday March 08, 2013 @10:36PM (#5347214)
" I don't recall hearing that Morse v Frederick only applied to non-political speech."

Farther up in the thread you mention that you are unfamiliar with the Morse decision. Has this changed now? If not I recommend scanning the wikipedia article:

"Roberts rejoined that “not even Frederick argues that the banner conveys any sort of political or religious message;” “this is plainly not a case about political debate over the criminalization of drug use or possession.”" [1]

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Morse_v._Frederick

Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by wtallis on Friday March 08, 2013 @10:44PM (#5347238)
I said I was unfamiliar with the details. I certainly remember the general circumstances that were at issue, but I never read the ruling or a detailed analysis of it, so I don't know just how restrictive the wording is, which is what I'm now asking about. Your quotes seem to be very nearly on-topic, but it's not clear to me whether they imply that the school's powers would have been different had the speech been a more traditional and recognizable form of political protest. If Morse v Frederick indeed does not apply to the more coherent forms of protest, then I would certainly consider that to be significantly narrowing.
Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by dfc on Friday March 08, 2013 @10:49PM (#5347252)
I don't know why you are taking my word or anyone else's word for it on HN. If you want to read a quick discussion of the court's ruling just look at 2.1.1-2.1.3 on the wikipedia page:

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Morse_v._Frederick#Opinion_of...

Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by wtallis on Friday March 08, 2013 @11:08PM (#5347286)
You can stop pointing me at the Wikipedia article. I've read it, and it still doesn't answer the question. I'd give more weight to a HN comment that does answer the question than to the wiki article that doesn't, even if the comment is just secondhand recollections that somebody qualified clearly said the ruling doesn't affect the legal status of speech that is clearly political. Did Morse overturn Tinker with the help of anti-drug scaremongering, or was Morse actually a narrow ruling on something not covered by Tinker?

Edit: By searching SCOTUSBlog, it appears that the answer may be that the ruling itself is pretty unclear about how broad or narrow it is, though Kennedy and Alito's concurrence clearly states that it doesn't apply to political speech. I guess we can at least agree that Morse might be a pretty narrow ruling.

Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by dfc on Friday March 08, 2013 @11:36PM (#5347344)
Morse did not overturn Tinker. Tinker was political speech, the court did not think "bong hitz 4 jesus" was political speech.